Popular in Professional

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

Education

The Role of Education in Reducing Racial Inequality

University of Southern California Pedro A. Noguera

Law

Diversity and Social Mobility in the UK legal profession

Law Society I. Stephanie Boyce

Internet Law

The Law of AI for Good

University of San Diego Orly Lobel

Pharmacy

Cytotoxic Activity and Anti-Migratory Effect of Berberine-Phytantriol Liquid Crystalline on Non-Small-Cell Lung Cancer

University of Technology Sydney Kamal Dua

Human Rights Law

Transforming Restorative Justice for Transitional Settings

University of Nottingham Kerry Clamp

Education

Conceptualizing and Enabling Transformative Learning Through Relational Onto-Epistemology

View more insights in Professional - Education - Educational Psychology

View more figures from University of Sydney

View the page of Beatriz Carrillo Garcia

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Beatriz Carrillo Garcia puts forward Theory U as a framework for developing a more holistic and embodied understanding and approach to the practice and conceptualization of transformative learning.

Image courtesy of interviewee. August 7, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

Faculti AI is thinking...

< >

Summary
Related Studies
Faculti AI
Key Points
Key Quotes
Translate
Transcript

Export as PDF

This video is a detailed discussion about **Theory U**, an interdisciplinary framework developed by Otto Scharmer that focuses on transformative learning and systemic change. The speaker outlines the theory's context, highlighting its use in education to foster transformative learning experiences through awareness-based methods. The key divides that Theory U addresses include ecological, social, and spiritual divides, which impact individuals’ and societies’ ability to create desired change.

The theory emphasizes a transformation journey from ego to ego awareness, where individuals gain a deeper understanding of their mental patterns and connect with a higher purpose. It integrates concepts from various fields, including systems thinking and leadership studies, and encourages educators to adopt a holistic approach to learning.

Furthermore, the speaker discusses the **U-Lab**, a MOOC associated with Theory U that facilitates experiential learning through activities like mindfulness and reflexive journaling. It also highlights the importance of listening—transformative listening practices among participants foster trust and safety, allowing for deeper discussions and co-creation of insights.

The findings suggest that cognitive shifts alone are insufficient for transformative learning; emotional, relational, and spiritual dimensions are critical. The speaker calls for more research into integrating embodied practices in education and emphasizes that acknowledgment of individual learner experiences can lead to broader acceptance of transformative methodologies.

The overarching conclusion indicates that while Theory U and its practices hold potential for significant impact in education, particularly in higher education, there is still work to do in mainstreaming these ideas and their applications.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.105 --> 00:03.725
In my research and also in my teaching, I engage

00:03.725 --> 00:06.405
with Theory U as both a theoretical

00:07.145 --> 00:10.005
and a methodological framework to do two things.

00:10.745 --> 00:13.085
One is to, to foster transformative

00:13.525 --> 00:14.685
learning in the classroom.

00:15.515 --> 00:19.295
And in my research, I use it as a conceptual frame

00:19.475 --> 00:21.535
to develop new understandings

00:21.595 --> 00:23.975
of transformative learning as a process.

00:25.035 --> 00:29.175
So Theory U is an interdisciplinary framework

00:29.175 --> 00:32.415
that draws on various, bodies of knowledge,

00:32.415 --> 00:36.015
various fields, including systems thinking,

00:36.705 --> 00:39.055
leadership studies, phenomenology,

00:40.115 --> 00:43.615
and action research, among other, other influences.

00:43.675 --> 00:48.495
So, broadly speaking, the theory seeks to develop,

00:49.075 --> 00:51.855
new theories of change and of learning.

00:52.515 --> 00:57.135
So, Sharma who developed Theory U, defines it

00:57.135 --> 01:01.015
as an awareness based method for changing systems.

01:02.075 --> 01:05.055
And so he argues that there are three sort

01:05.055 --> 01:08.375
of core device in our current world,

01:08.555 --> 01:12.095
and ecological divide, which is, you know, the,

01:12.675 --> 01:14.655
the continued, view

01:14.655 --> 01:17.335
that we are separate from the natural world,

01:17.435 --> 01:19.495
and that we control the world, so to speak.

01:20.155 --> 01:21.815
Uh, a social divide, which

01:22.375 --> 01:24.535
manifest in the growing inequalities

01:24.535 --> 01:28.855
that we experience across and within societies,

01:28.915 --> 01:31.975
but also a spiritual divide by which he means, you know,

01:31.975 --> 01:36.945
the disconnection with, with our inner self,

01:37.205 --> 01:39.825
and with a sense of a sense of purpose.

01:40.005 --> 01:44.105
So we kind of lost, lost meaning in life kind of thing,

01:44.105 --> 01:47.665
which often manifests in, in the current mental health

01:48.665 --> 01:51.625
epidemic that, that we experience.

01:52.525 --> 01:56.585
So he argues that we are collectively producing results

01:56.585 --> 01:58.665
that nobody wants,

01:58.725 --> 02:00.945
and yet we dunno how to change that, right?

02:01.605 --> 02:05.545
So to tackle those divide theory, you puts for a process,

02:05.985 --> 02:09.785
a kind of a journey of transformation of the self, sort of,

02:09.805 --> 02:12.305
of the individual, but also of the collective.

02:12.305 --> 02:13.785
And it says, you know, the two are very

02:13.785 --> 02:15.065
closely interrelated.

02:15.805 --> 02:20.185
Uh, so the transformation of the individual, is related

02:20.245 --> 02:22.465
to the transformation of the system.

02:23.365 --> 02:27.145
Um, and in terms of the transformation of the self

02:27.205 --> 02:30.705
or the individual, this is gained through greater awareness

02:31.685 --> 02:35.465
of our mental patterns and our ways of being.

02:36.235 --> 02:39.745
Which, you know, this awareness allows the individual

02:39.925 --> 02:43.385
to connect with a, with so to speak, a higher purpose.

02:43.495 --> 02:46.345
What am I really, what's my work? What do I really wanna do?

02:47.005 --> 02:49.745
Uh, and but also from a different perspective,

02:49.775 --> 02:52.225
from the perspective, not just of what do I want

02:52.225 --> 02:55.025
as an individual, but what is the, also the system needs.

02:55.685 --> 03:00.285
Uh, and Sharma calls this shift, you know, a shift from ego

03:00.705 --> 03:04.685
to ego awareness, or a perspective from the whole.

03:05.585 --> 03:10.365
Um, this transformation from ego toco awareness,

03:10.585 --> 03:14.205
is based on the development of, a new

03:15.285 --> 03:19.005
rationality, a waste of relating to each other

03:19.835 --> 03:23.845
that is, underpinned also by a, a new worldview

03:24.585 --> 03:26.685
and a different, a different way of being.

03:26.745 --> 03:30.005
And, I, I can elaborate more on how, how

03:30.005 --> 03:31.165
that happens later on.

03:31.305 --> 03:35.125
Uh, so this is what I refer to in my work as a, as a new

03:36.015 --> 03:39.965
relational on Epistemology theory Review is actually a

03:39.965 --> 03:41.765
relatively new framework.

03:42.025 --> 03:46.325
Uh, Sharma first, published his book,

03:46.805 --> 03:50.485
a Theory Review in 2009, which followed from the work,

03:50.705 --> 03:54.565
and publications he did with his colleagues at MIT,

03:55.525 --> 03:56.765
Sloan School of Management.

03:56.825 --> 03:58.765
So they, the people he worked

03:58.765 --> 04:01.165
with actually come from organizational learning,

04:01.225 --> 04:05.765
people like Peters, Betty Flowers, Joseph Ky

04:05.785 --> 04:08.965
for example, who were researching organizational change

04:09.505 --> 04:12.205
and the leadership styles that supported

04:12.205 --> 04:13.765
that organizational change.

04:13.825 --> 04:15.805
That's kind of like the, the background

04:15.865 --> 04:16.925
of the, of the theory.

04:17.465 --> 04:21.365
Uh, and it was in that joint work of Sharma with,

04:21.395 --> 04:24.165
with those other colleagues that they developed the concept

04:24.465 --> 04:28.565
of presencing, which was, a holistic view

04:28.825 --> 04:33.085
and awareness, in leadership within, within leadership.

04:33.105 --> 04:34.605
And that becomes sort of a core,

04:35.165 --> 04:37.445
a core concept in, in Theory U.

04:38.425 --> 04:43.005
So, I, I think, you know, up until quite recently,

04:43.015 --> 04:46.925
there was really very little published, around Theory U

04:47.665 --> 04:52.125
Uh, there was very, a, a modest output of, of research.

04:52.385 --> 04:56.485
Um, 'cause initially the theory, as I said, you know,

04:56.485 --> 05:00.005
was used primarily to discuss, leadership and,

05:00.145 --> 05:01.965
and management styles.

05:02.745 --> 05:05.885
Uh, but from there, it also began to be considered

05:05.885 --> 05:09.325
and used by researchers in, in adult education studies,

05:09.945 --> 05:11.525
mainly those, who were,

05:11.825 --> 05:14.205
who were researching transformative learning,

05:14.295 --> 05:18.605
which in itself is a, it is a relatively new, new area

05:18.825 --> 05:20.045
as well in education.

05:20.225 --> 05:23.335
So, I guess as a, you know, as a framework

05:23.335 --> 05:28.095
of transformative, transformative change theory, you seem

05:28.095 --> 05:31.495
to be a natural feat for educators who were seeking

05:31.595 --> 05:34.815
to foster transformative learning in their classroom.

05:35.035 --> 05:39.915
Um, and this engagement of Theory u with Theory U

05:39.925 --> 05:43.955
among educators, came about, mainly from the

05:44.915 --> 05:49.755
participation in the UA, the Ulab MOOC that,

05:49.775 --> 05:54.315
Sharma also launched, that was launched in 2015.

05:54.535 --> 05:56.755
And this is actually how I came to

05:56.775 --> 06:00.885
Theory UI enrolled, in the Ulab, which is,

06:01.245 --> 06:05.245
provided by MIT, the EDX platform.

06:05.425 --> 06:08.685
Uh, I did, the Ulab in 2016.

06:08.825 --> 06:12.245
And after participating in the course, I just thought,

06:12.345 --> 06:15.205
you know, this could be a real game changer for

06:15.325 --> 06:17.325
how we teach, how students learn.

06:18.105 --> 06:21.045
Uh, but also, you know, we we're, as educators,

06:21.065 --> 06:25.125
we are really, interested in how our, our teaching

06:25.145 --> 06:28.165
and the learning experience can bring about

06:28.275 --> 06:29.525
broader social change.

06:29.705 --> 06:33.375
So that's kind of how I came into theory.

06:33.595 --> 06:37.335
So earlier I talked about theory uses, journey

06:37.355 --> 06:40.255
of transformation from ego to equal awareness.

06:41.155 --> 06:45.215
And that journey requires, again, a greater awareness

06:45.435 --> 06:49.175
of self, of our worldview, of our behaviors,

06:49.475 --> 06:52.455
and the way we interact with, with others.

06:53.315 --> 06:55.695
Uh, and so the, the theory speaks to that.

06:55.715 --> 07:00.495
And then in ulab, this embodied process, is guided

07:00.495 --> 07:05.015
through a series of experiential learning activities,

07:05.085 --> 07:09.455
drawing on a variety of awareness based practices such as,

07:09.515 --> 07:13.695
you know, mindfulness, different ways of listening,

07:14.775 --> 07:18.335
reflexive journaling, also body movement.

07:18.395 --> 07:22.575
So it's, it's quite varied, the kinds of, of tools

07:22.635 --> 07:24.895
and methodologies that, that are used,

07:24.895 --> 07:27.335
because there's, there's a sense that the body, it's, it's,

07:27.335 --> 07:29.695
it is as much an, an embodied processes, a

07:29.855 --> 07:31.455
as a cognitive process.

07:32.235 --> 07:35.305
Uh, so as part of that,

07:35.405 --> 07:36.945
or as part of the theory,

07:37.135 --> 07:40.065
listening is probably the most important tool

07:40.845 --> 07:42.625
for enabling transformation.

07:42.765 --> 07:46.745
So the way, sham put said is that changing

07:46.885 --> 07:49.945
how you listen means that you also change

07:50.085 --> 07:52.265
how you experience relationships

07:52.765 --> 07:54.345
and how you experience the world.

07:54.725 --> 07:57.025
And he says, if you can change that, if you can change

07:57.045 --> 07:59.025
how you experience relationships in the world,

07:59.055 --> 08:02.105
then you can change anything, right, or everything.

08:02.565 --> 08:07.065
Uh, so that's kind of like, it, it urges people

08:07.085 --> 08:09.825
to pay attention to how they listen

08:09.965 --> 08:13.185
and how that then relates to how they engage with others.

08:13.805 --> 08:16.625
So, very early on in the Ulab course,

08:16.745 --> 08:20.665
participants learn about the different ways of listening

08:20.725 --> 08:25.465
and conversing, and about how to negotiate,

08:25.765 --> 08:30.345
you know, our internal voices of, of judgment, of ci,

08:30.485 --> 08:33.625
of cynicism or fear, you know, like when we talk to people,

08:34.245 --> 08:36.825
one of those is sort of in the, in the background.

08:36.925 --> 08:41.225
And, and by sort of being more aware of how we listen,

08:41.245 --> 08:43.625
we can sort of manage, manage that.

08:44.565 --> 08:47.745
So participants are sort of learning

08:47.965 --> 08:51.265
to engage in sort of more empathetic ways

08:51.265 --> 08:53.535
of listening and listening.

08:53.535 --> 08:56.605
That is, you know, as, as it's put in the, in the theory

08:56.675 --> 09:00.845
that is guided by an open mind, an open heart,

09:01.025 --> 09:05.125
but also an open will to generate new knowledge

09:05.185 --> 09:09.125
or new perspectives, rather than only listening to kind

09:09.125 --> 09:11.325
of support your own, your own beliefs

09:11.425 --> 09:14.005
or whatever you already hold, you know,

09:14.005 --> 09:15.045
release, you already hold.

09:15.305 --> 09:18.255
Um, and I guess in a group setting,

09:19.655 --> 09:23.825
fostering such a generative dialogue, you know, we're,

09:23.825 --> 09:26.185
we're listening again, with an open mind, open heart,

09:26.765 --> 09:30.865
and open will necessitates, you know, a sense of a sense

09:30.865 --> 09:32.345
of safety and,

09:32.645 --> 09:37.165
and a degree of trust among participants for them

09:37.225 --> 09:40.525
to be able to participate again, without fear of judgment

09:40.745 --> 09:42.605
or even of retaliation.

09:43.385 --> 09:47.035
Uh, and so you, you've, you've gotta, you know,

09:47.035 --> 09:48.675
listening is a skill you build, right?

09:49.335 --> 09:52.355
And you have to build it in a, in a safe, in a safe space.

09:52.415 --> 09:56.875
So at the hub sessions that we held as part of the ulab,

09:57.175 --> 09:59.835
all participants agreed, you know, we came in

09:59.835 --> 10:02.315
and we all had to kind of like, make an agreement

10:02.385 --> 10:05.955
that we would listen and interact again with an open mind,

10:05.955 --> 10:08.475
open heart, and open will.

10:08.735 --> 10:09.955
Uh, so trust

10:10.055 --> 10:12.315
and safety, you start to develop it over time

10:12.315 --> 10:13.515
through these principles.

10:14.255 --> 10:17.955
And, and that allows people to be, to be more vulnerable,

10:18.335 --> 10:19.715
in what they share.

10:19.775 --> 10:22.555
So they're starting to, to be more open to sharing things

10:22.555 --> 10:25.675
that they may not share, elsewhere

10:25.735 --> 10:27.675
or in other contexts, knowing

10:27.675 --> 10:31.515
that their remarks will not be met with either judgment

10:31.815 --> 10:32.955
or cynicism.

10:33.655 --> 10:35.395
So these more open and

10:35.535 --> 10:39.115
and empathetic interactions created the space

10:39.115 --> 10:42.755
where individuals and the group could co-create new insights

10:43.495 --> 10:45.355
and, and perspectives,

10:45.585 --> 10:48.435
into whatever issue we were discussing at the time,

10:48.455 --> 10:50.915
or whatever challenge somebody had brought

10:50.915 --> 10:52.955
to the group in order to force the,

10:53.375 --> 10:55.635
to foster transformative learning experiences.

10:56.435 --> 10:58.515
A cognitive shift is not enough

10:58.775 --> 11:01.035
to bring about transformation in the individual.

11:01.665 --> 11:04.715
Instead, what we found is that you need something, a,

11:04.795 --> 11:09.315
a more integrity framework such as that, that I argue, Teri,

11:09.315 --> 11:12.955
you and new lab offer, to allow not only

11:13.055 --> 11:15.855
for a change in perception,

11:16.115 --> 11:20.255
but one which also engages in more emotional, relational,

11:20.355 --> 11:24.215
or spiritual dimensions of the learners personal

11:24.215 --> 11:25.735
or even professional development.

11:25.875 --> 11:28.695
Uh, so, you know, the, I guess, you know, many

11:28.695 --> 11:31.055
of the participants talked about how, you know,

11:31.055 --> 11:33.015
they might have been at the time going

11:33.015 --> 11:36.415
through a personal sort of crisis or a personal issue,

11:36.955 --> 11:39.935
but they were also concerned about sort of more societal

11:40.115 --> 11:42.295
or world issues, and they, they didn't know

11:42.295 --> 11:44.055
how the two were interrelated,

11:44.155 --> 11:46.335
but actually through that, you, they find

11:46.335 --> 11:47.695
that they are interrelated,

11:47.755 --> 11:50.215
and they, they, they give some tools to how to, how

11:50.215 --> 11:52.175
to deal, how to deal with that.

11:52.515 --> 11:55.045
Um, so I guess theory, you

11:55.325 --> 11:57.965
provided both the epidemiological

11:58.265 --> 12:02.005
or the theoretical framework to underpin that transformation

12:02.065 --> 12:05.165
so that it doesn't feel like it is just about, you know,

12:05.395 --> 12:08.205
emotion and we're all kind of good to each other and so on.

12:08.805 --> 12:11.245
Actually, there is, you know, there's a theory,

12:11.785 --> 12:15.325
behind this, a systems view,

12:15.325 --> 12:17.605
awareness based per perspective of change,

12:17.605 --> 12:19.085
which is also helpful for people.

12:19.305 --> 12:21.605
Um, and so, and,

12:21.625 --> 12:25.445
and then on the, on the other hand, you have ulab

12:25.445 --> 12:27.725
that gives you kind of that scaffolding and,

12:27.725 --> 12:29.045
and the exercises

12:29.045 --> 12:33.445
and the tools to bring those new awareness, in,

12:33.585 --> 12:35.725
in the way in which we relate to, to others.

12:35.865 --> 12:38.085
So I guess deep

12:38.265 --> 12:41.205
or empathetic listening as mentioned earlier,

12:41.625 --> 12:42.725
is, was, was key.

12:42.745 --> 12:45.285
And this is something that participants mentioned once I,

12:45.395 --> 12:49.285
once I became aware of how I listened and I changed that,

12:49.545 --> 12:53.405
and I changed how interacted that, that really became,

12:53.565 --> 12:55.685
a pathway for transformation.

12:56.385 --> 13:01.165
Uh, the other thing is again, that that skill needs

13:01.225 --> 13:05.285
to first be, be built in a safe space.

13:05.425 --> 13:08.885
You can't throw people out and go, you know, be empathetic

13:09.025 --> 13:11.805
and in, in, in the world where you need to build

13:11.805 --> 13:13.965
that skill first and, and,

13:13.985 --> 13:15.725
and build the awareness so

13:15.725 --> 13:19.725
that then people can bring it out into other interactions

13:19.995 --> 13:22.405
outside of that, of that, of that initial group.

13:23.025 --> 13:27.795
Uh, so, they, they need to hone that that's,

13:27.795 --> 13:31.275
that that skill in the safe, in the safe space,

13:31.535 --> 13:33.195
and safe spaces

13:33.615 --> 13:37.635
and the, the trust that underpins them can be, again,

13:37.635 --> 13:41.275
further cultivated through mindfulness,

13:41.305 --> 13:43.755
through journaling exercises.

13:43.895 --> 13:47.755
So, for example, every day, participants needed

13:47.815 --> 13:49.875
to journal about their listening.

13:50.025 --> 13:53.475
They needed to do some reflection about how they listened

13:53.475 --> 13:57.435
to others in any, any interaction that they had

13:57.735 --> 14:00.115
during the day, and how did that affect

14:00.215 --> 14:01.715
how they related to the other person.

14:01.855 --> 14:05.195
So when you're doing that on a, you know, on a daily basis,

14:05.455 --> 14:07.515
it really kind of forces you to start.

14:07.805 --> 14:09.195
Every time you listen to somebody,

14:09.195 --> 14:10.475
you're thinking, okay, hang on.

14:10.575 --> 14:13.555
How am I listening? You're become aware rather than letting,

14:13.775 --> 14:15.835
as I say, you know, the voices take, take over.

14:16.935 --> 14:21.165
Um, so what is established is, is really a practice

14:21.595 --> 14:26.325
through iteration that enhances self-awareness, new ways

14:26.325 --> 14:29.365
of being, and new ways of thinking, which is, you know,

14:29.525 --> 14:31.965
a transformative learning process that we will,

14:32.165 --> 14:35.405
I would argue is a transformative, learning process,

14:35.455 --> 14:38.645
which will become, you know, a stepping stone for,

14:39.025 --> 14:40.685
for further transformation.

14:41.155 --> 14:45.095
It's an emerging, research field.

14:45.435 --> 14:48.975
Uh, and so there's, there's a lot to still to be done

14:49.115 --> 14:50.995
to, to better

14:51.235 --> 14:54.365
Conceptualize, the, the process

14:54.665 --> 14:56.365
of building self-awareness

14:56.545 --> 15:01.025
and building sort of, different ways of, of being.

15:01.325 --> 15:03.745
And there's, you know, there's, there's probably also

15:04.375 --> 15:07.865
more research needed in terms of how we connect that to

15:09.365 --> 15:12.625
mod embodied ways of, of, of changing.

15:13.645 --> 15:18.545
Uh, so that would probably be, you know, areas for,

15:19.365 --> 15:21.545
for further research to make it more mainstream.

15:21.745 --> 15:24.505
'cause I think, you know, particularly in, in,

15:24.885 --> 15:27.185
in the field of higher education, I think a lot

15:27.185 --> 15:28.945
of the methodologies that I mentioned before,

15:29.205 --> 15:30.425
and the tools that I mentioned

15:30.425 --> 15:33.705
before, are not, are not really,

15:34.005 --> 15:35.545
or have not really been embraced.

15:35.725 --> 15:40.125
I'm not seen as, you know, tools that, you know,

15:40.205 --> 15:44.085
I perhaps, you know, you in the individual,

15:45.485 --> 15:48.405
educator can implement, but they, they're still not

15:48.505 --> 15:51.765
as recognized as other, other pedagogies or their,

15:51.785 --> 15:55.765
or their impact has not been, as, as as recognized.

15:55.765 --> 15:57.925
You know, particularly when we start to talk about,

15:57.945 --> 16:00.085
you know, more effective

16:00.085 --> 16:04.685
or more spiritual, aspects of, of,

16:04.935 --> 16:09.485
individual change that a lot of academics go, hang on.

16:10.345 --> 16:12.845
That's, that's, that's not my, my area.

16:13.145 --> 16:16.205
And if, you know, if we are able to kind of,

16:17.165 --> 16:20.765
bringing people to this understanding that those aspects

16:20.865 --> 16:22.325
of the individual learner

16:22.325 --> 16:25.885
of the individual students are just an important to reach

16:26.545 --> 16:31.285
and to bring about new knowledge, then there might,

16:31.285 --> 16:35.285
there might be, you know, more, more widely used within,

16:35.285 --> 16:37.965
particularly within, higher education.

16:38.165 --> 16:38.365
I think.

Faculti AI can make mistakes