Popular in Sociology

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

Culture and Society

Carceral Entrapments: Views from the Prison/Street Interface in India

Indian Institute of Technology Delhi Mahuya Bandyopadhya

Culture and Society

Pre-problem families: predictive analytics and the future as the present

University of Southampton Rosalind Edwards

Ethnicity and Racism

Were Muslim Barbarians Really Knocking On the Gates of Ontario?

University of Ottawa Natasha Bakht

Culture and Society

Poor People’s Survival Strategies

The University of Texas at Austin Javier Auyero

Ethnicity and Racism

Sociology of Whiteness

Arizona State University Monica McDermott

Ethnicity and Racism

Narratives of Harm and the case for detention abolition

Queen's University Sharry Aiken

Familial Moralities: Moral (Re)source of Commitment in the Immigrant Rights Movement in El Paso, Texas

View more insights in Social Sciences - Sociology - Social Identities and Divisions

View more figures from University of South Florida

View the page of Alejandro Márquez

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Social movement scholars acknowledge the importance of morality in joining and shaping social movements. There is less knowledge about the content of morality that keeps social movement participants committed, once in. Moral commitments, Alejandro Márquez argues, emerge from the work conducted within social movements.

Image courtesy of interviewee. August 9, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

Faculti AI is thinking...

< >

Summary
Related Studies
Faculti AI
Key Points
Key Quotes
Translate
Transcript

Export as PDF

This video is a transcript of a conversation between a researcher, Alejandro, and an interviewer discussing Alejandro’s research on the immigrant rights movement, particularly in the context of solidarity and morality. Alejandro shares insights from his participant observation in two organizations in El Paso, Texas—one a legal aid office and the other a migrant shelter—that both engage with migrants and asylum seekers.

Key points include:

1. **Context of Research**: Alejandro focused on how solidarity is practiced through care work, aiming to understand its moral dimensions within social movements.

2. **Findings on Care Work**: He discovered that care work in these organizations is predominantly about providing support to migrants, which can be emotionally taxing due to the interpersonal nature of the work and the challenging political environment during the Trump administration.

3. **Familial Morality**: The researchers found that a strong theme of familial morality emerged in both organizations, influencing their commitment to helping migrants. Staff members often reflect on their own or their families' migration histories, creating personal connections to their work.

4. **Variations in Experience**: While the legal aid office staff engaged more intellectually and reflected on their migration stories, the shelter staff focused on everyday domestic tasks, leading to a different type of familial attachment to the migrants they assist.

5. **Burnout and Commitment**: Alejandro observed that many who participate in this work experience burnout, raising questions about how they maintain their commitment despite the difficulties.

6. **Implications for Future Research**: Alejandro expressed interest in exploring how migrants perceive their interactions with both movement organizations and the state, as well as how similar movements function in other contexts, such as Mexico.

Overall, the research highlights the complex interplay of moral commitments and personal histories in the immigrant rights movement, demonstrating how these factors shape social movement engagement and organizational dynamics.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are 5 key points from the video:

1. **Research Focus on Solidarity**: The speaker investigates the immigrant rights movement, particularly how solidarity is practiced daily among individuals supporting migrants and asylum seekers. The interest stems from observing support manifested through demonstrations, art, and, crucially, care work.

2. **Care Work and Its Challenges**: The study reveals that solidarity in these organizations primarily takes the form of care work, which includes providing support and services to migrants. However, this care work is identified as emotionally and convideoually challenging, especially due to the socio-political climate during the Trump administration, which created a difficult environment for immigration support work.

3. **Emotional and Moral Dimensions of Commitment**: The speaker explores the moral and emotional aspects that motivate individuals to remain committed despite burnout and the arduous nature of care work. This commitment is often linked to familial themes, where caregivers draw on personal or family histories of migration as a source of motivation and empathy.

4. **Organizational Differences and Impact on Engagement**: The research compares two organizations: a legal aid office composed mostly of local Mexican American women and a shelter staffed by mostly non-local volunteers. The nature of care and the backgrounds of staff members are shown to significantly influence the expression of familial morality and community attachment within each organization.

5. **Future Research Directions**: The speaker expresses interest in exploring the perspectives of migrants and asylum seekers regarding their interactions with care organizations and the emotional ties that develop. Additionally, there is a desire to investigate how similar movements function in different countries and convideos, particularly in Mexico, to understand the dynamics of caregiver-migrant relationships across varying cultural landscapes.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes from the video, which focuses on the immigrant rights movement, solidarity, and care work:

1. **On the Start of Research:**
- "I research on the immigrant rights movement, started with my interest in solidarity."

2. **On the Nature of Solidarity:**
- "I wanted to see how solidarity is practiced on the everyday… demonstrations of support online. You might also see, artistic… support, right?"

3. **On Findings in El Paso:**
- "What I found is that, um, solidarity is mostly practiced through care work."

4. **On the Definition of Care Work:**
- "Care work is any kind of interpersonal assistance or work… to develop the capabilities of the care receivers."

5. **On the Challenge of Care Work:**
- "I realized that this is very difficult work because of the interpersonal nature of it… they were operating in a very difficult convideo."

6. **On Emotional and Moral Components of Commitment:**
- "I realized that there was this emotional and moral component to the work that they were doing."

7. **On Familial Themes:**
- "In these organizations, it has a very clear familial theme."

8. **On Moral Shock:**
- "Moral shock is… this kind of reaction… to experiencing or witnessing an event… that is just in total contradiction to their own worldview."

9. **On the Importance of Morality in Social Movements:**
- "What I’m trying to show is that morality is also something that is, um, shaped in the movement itself."

10. **On the Role of Care Workers:**
- "I observed that… the care work practiced in the immigrant rights movement creates these emotional spaces… for people to feel comfortable sharing their problems."

11. **On Personal Experience and Privilege:**
- "I migrated to the US when I was 10 years old… how privileged I was and how I migrated to the country."

12. **On Future Research Interests:**
- "I'd like to continue exploring these different interactions with migrants… how they feel about all these movement organizations… what do they make of it?"

These quotes encapsulate the themes of the video, including solidarity, care work, moral engagement, personal experience, and the dynamics within the immigrant rights movement.

Export as PDF
Here are some articles that are similar in theme and content to the video you about Alejandro’s research on the immigrant rights movement:

1. **"Solidarity Across Borders: The Role of Care Work in Refugee Support Organizations"**
This article dives into the experiences of individuals working in NGOs that provide assistance to refugees. It highlights the emotional challenges of care work and the personal histories that often motivate staff in the field.

2. **"Familial Narratives and Moral Engagement in Social Movements"**
This piece explores how personal and family migration histories play a crucial role in shaping the moral frameworks of activists involved in immigrant rights movements, contributing to a deeper understanding of their commitment to the cause.

3. **"Burnout Among Social Justice Workers: Strategies for Sustaining Commitment in Challenging Times"**
This article investigates the phenomenon of burnout among workers in social justice organizations, specifically in the immigrant rights sector, and discusses strategies that individuals employ to sustain their engagement and motivation.

4. **"The Emotional Labor of Caring: Insights from Migrant Shelters"**
Focusing on the experiences of staff in migrant shelters, this research examines the emotional toll of care work and how the daily responsibilities influence staff's relationships with the migrants they assist.

5. **"Political Convideos and the Dynamics of Solidarity in Immigrant Advocacy"**
This article analyzes how changing political climates, particularly during the Trump administration, affected the practices of solidarity and support within organizations that advocate for immigrant rights.

6. **"Migrant Perspectives: Understanding the Interactions with Rights Organizations"**
This research offers insight into how migrants perceive their relationships with NGOs and governmental bodies, particularly focusing on the sentiments of trust and mistrust that shape these interactions.

7. **"Intersections of Care Work and Activism: Lessons from Community Organizations"**
This article highlights various community organizations that engage in care work for migrant populations, reflecting on how personal narratives and communal support contribute to their activism.

8. **"Transnational Ties and Solidarity: Examining the Immigrant Rights Movement in Mexico and the U.S."**
This comparative study looks at how immigrant rights movements in different convideos (the U.S. and Mexico) handle solidarity and care work, with an emphasis on cultural and historical influences.

These articles address similar themes of solidarity, care work, emotional challenges, moral commitments, and the experiences of both activists and migrants within the convideo of immigrant rights movements.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.125 --> 00:02.605
I research on the immigrant rights movement, started

00:02.675 --> 00:04.805
with my interest in solidarity.

00:05.625 --> 00:08.885
Um, I was interested in how people

00:10.125 --> 00:11.965
demonstrated support for people

00:12.105 --> 00:15.965
who might be in a difficult situation like migrants or,

00:16.465 --> 00:20.525
or maybe people who are a victim of, other type

00:20.525 --> 00:22.245
of state violence, for example.

00:22.505 --> 00:26.565
So I wanted to see how solidarity is,

00:26.565 --> 00:27.765
practiced on the everyday.

00:28.005 --> 00:31.285
'cause I seen, you know, demonstrations of support online.

00:31.985 --> 00:34.965
Um, you might also see, artistic,

00:35.465 --> 00:37.805
you know, support, right?

00:37.885 --> 00:39.005
Like, songs

00:39.825 --> 00:43.125
or films right, that, are kind of supporting

00:43.125 --> 00:45.165
or showing solidarity with a particular group.

00:45.825 --> 00:48.885
Um, but I wanted to see it on, on, on, on a day-to-Day, what

00:48.885 --> 00:50.165
that kind of looked like.

00:51.095 --> 00:54.315
So I started, doing,

00:55.105 --> 00:59.275
participant observation in two social movement organizations

00:59.415 --> 01:02.555
on the US Mexico border, particularly in the city

01:02.575 --> 01:03.675
of, of El Paso.

01:04.615 --> 01:06.915
And what I found is that,

01:07.565 --> 01:10.875
solidarity is mostly practiced, through care work.

01:11.535 --> 01:13.915
Um, the members of these,

01:14.275 --> 01:16.995
movement organizations are providing some sort of support

01:17.615 --> 01:20.755
or services to migrants and asylum seekers.

01:21.415 --> 01:24.275
Um, so yeah, that, that, that's one

01:24.275 --> 01:25.595
of the first things I found.

01:25.975 --> 01:28.435
Um, but then I also found that this kind

01:28.435 --> 01:30.395
of care work is, is very difficult.

01:30.935 --> 01:33.515
And I'll just note that care work, just to kind

01:33.635 --> 01:38.035
of provide a definition, is any kind of interpersonal,

01:39.015 --> 01:40.395
assistance

01:40.415 --> 01:43.155
or work, that you do in order to

01:44.185 --> 01:46.875
develop the capabilities of the care receivers, right?

01:46.935 --> 01:50.315
So, very, you know, common examples of care,

01:50.865 --> 01:54.555
care work are like, nursing or teaching, right?

01:54.915 --> 01:58.875
Teachers, doctors, social workers, in some instances,

01:58.945 --> 02:00.235
even even lawyers, right?

02:00.335 --> 02:03.465
So, doing this work,

02:03.945 --> 02:05.345
participating in these activities, I realized

02:05.345 --> 02:07.585
that this is very difficult work,

02:07.775 --> 02:10.185
because of the interpersonal nature of it.

02:11.015 --> 02:13.505
Also, because they were operating in a very

02:13.695 --> 02:15.105
difficult context.

02:16.135 --> 02:18.265
They, this was during the middle

02:18.265 --> 02:19.345
of the Trump administration.

02:19.605 --> 02:21.105
So the way a lot

02:21.105 --> 02:23.585
of immigration laws being were being applied,

02:24.095 --> 02:26.825
were being implemented, was, changing.

02:27.445 --> 02:30.625
And there were also new policies that were coming down from,

02:30.625 --> 02:31.625
from the administration

02:31.625 --> 02:33.305
that were making this work very difficult.

02:33.405 --> 02:35.465
So, so I saw that a lot

02:35.465 --> 02:38.865
of people in these organizations were burnout, burnt out.

02:39.245 --> 02:41.585
Um, it was kind of like an endemic thing.

02:42.165 --> 02:43.905
So then my interest became like, well,

02:43.925 --> 02:45.105
how do these people keep going?

02:45.285 --> 02:49.465
How do they keep their commitment, to this kind of,

02:49.465 --> 02:51.825
difficult, of work?

02:52.085 --> 02:56.185
So, eventually I realized that there was this emotional

02:56.285 --> 02:58.385
and moral component to, to,

02:58.405 --> 02:59.645
to the work that they were doing.

03:00.305 --> 03:04.285
Um, so my aim of this paper was to kind of explore, try

03:04.285 --> 03:07.285
to understand the moral dimension of commitment.

03:07.945 --> 03:11.405
Um, and I found that in these organization,

03:11.625 --> 03:16.045
it organizations, it has a very clear familial theme.

03:16.865 --> 03:20.005
Um, and what my, what I mean by that is that the kind

03:20.005 --> 03:24.085
of stories or narratives that caregivers,

03:24.715 --> 03:27.925
kind of reflect on to kind of explain their commitment have

03:27.925 --> 03:31.485
to do with, with the idea of family, either their own

03:32.045 --> 03:34.885
families or, or new families,

03:34.915 --> 03:37.365
that they might see themselves,

03:37.885 --> 03:39.525
forming in, in, in this context.

03:39.865 --> 03:41.845
The literature on morality

03:41.845 --> 03:44.605
and social movements is, I think, very interesting

03:44.605 --> 03:46.245
because it kind of explains

03:46.245 --> 03:48.725
or tries to show how morality leads

03:48.785 --> 03:50.605
to certain kinds of behavior.

03:51.465 --> 03:56.285
So one of the most, popular, I guess, ideas,

03:57.025 --> 03:59.725
in this literature is, mortal shock.

04:00.305 --> 04:04.085
Um, according to James Jasper, moral shock is, kind

04:04.085 --> 04:08.965
of, this kind of reaction, to experiencing

04:09.185 --> 04:10.645
or witnessing an event

04:10.745 --> 04:12.765
or reading about it, looking,

04:13.065 --> 04:14.365
you know, watching it on the news.

04:14.675 --> 04:18.365
Something that just kind of, is in total contradiction

04:18.425 --> 04:21.005
to their own worldview, that is just,

04:21.065 --> 04:22.725
it just doesn't fit, or it,

04:22.945 --> 04:25.365
or they feel like it shouldn't be the case, right?

04:25.365 --> 04:27.605
So this kind of outrage or anger

04:27.745 --> 04:32.645
or maybe sadness kind of leads them to, get engaged to,

04:32.645 --> 04:34.245
to start participating in a movement

04:34.425 --> 04:36.125
or to form their own group.

04:36.825 --> 04:40.805
Um, this literature also points to perhaps, member,

04:40.805 --> 04:43.005
individuals who are outside the movement,

04:43.495 --> 04:46.965
maybe celebrities or some sort of other, you know,

04:47.035 --> 04:49.325
respected individual kind of promoting

04:49.385 --> 04:50.645
or endorsing a movement.

04:50.645 --> 04:53.925
So that also kind of provides some sort of moral,

04:55.205 --> 04:57.645
encouragement for people to just get involved.

04:58.505 --> 05:00.925
Um, another way in which morality kind

05:00.925 --> 05:02.605
of matters in social movements is just

05:02.745 --> 05:05.365
how it shapes the practices within a movement.

05:05.425 --> 05:09.205
So, for example, we see this, we saw this very recently

05:09.205 --> 05:12.885
with the encampments in, university campuses,

05:12.945 --> 05:14.165
across the United States,

05:14.185 --> 05:17.805
and in many parts of the world, these encampments,

05:18.355 --> 05:21.645
sometimes involve a lot of reflection and discussion, right?

05:21.825 --> 05:23.525
Uh, talking about the pain

05:23.525 --> 05:26.205
and suffering of, of other individuals who might be victims

05:26.465 --> 05:27.565
of state violence.

05:28.505 --> 05:33.205
So, here we kind of see morality, kind of,

05:33.475 --> 05:37.125
guiding those, those practices, for movements

05:37.125 --> 05:39.125
that are kind of religiously oriented.

05:39.665 --> 05:42.165
Uh, sometimes they incorporate rituals

05:42.705 --> 05:45.285
or maybe in reflections they talk about,

05:46.025 --> 05:47.325
biblical themes.

05:47.905 --> 05:50.205
So again, you know, another way in which,

05:50.405 --> 05:55.125
morality might kind of get people, motivated

05:55.225 --> 05:59.825
or, or, kind of, keeps them engaged.

06:00.685 --> 06:03.385
Um, and another, interesting way,

06:03.815 --> 06:06.665
that we see morality shaping movement activity is just,

06:06.665 --> 06:10.575
kind of, providing sort, sort

06:10.575 --> 06:12.655
of principle about individual behavior.

06:13.395 --> 06:16.855
Uh, the environmental movement, for example,

06:17.195 --> 06:19.415
is very good at kind of, promoting this kind

06:19.415 --> 06:20.775
of consumer culture, right?

06:20.775 --> 06:22.975
That we shouldn't consume as much meat,

06:23.035 --> 06:24.615
or we should buy electric cars

06:24.835 --> 06:27.655
or, stop using straws, that kind of thing.

06:27.755 --> 06:30.375
So that might happen within the movement,

06:30.375 --> 06:33.575
or even outside, even for people who are not like,

06:34.495 --> 06:36.375
participating in the movement day in and day out.

06:37.285 --> 06:40.705
Um, and even basic principles like the golden rule,

06:41.125 --> 06:42.265
you know, it's, that has been

06:42.265 --> 06:43.585
espoused by the feminist movement.

06:43.805 --> 06:46.345
Um, so again, you know, those are just a few,

06:46.485 --> 06:49.465
few ways in which morality is getting, behavior.

06:49.925 --> 06:52.665
In my case, what I'm trying to show is that morality

06:53.685 --> 06:57.625
is also something that is, shaped

06:58.585 --> 07:00.525
in the movement itself, right?

07:00.745 --> 07:05.205
In the, in the everyday actions of the movement, that itself

07:06.065 --> 07:09.085
can, trigger some sort of,

07:09.335 --> 07:11.285
moral reflection about why

07:11.845 --> 07:14.005
participants are doing what they're doing, right?

07:14.025 --> 07:15.725
Why, why they should stay committed.

07:16.225 --> 07:18.765
And this is particularly relevant in the case of, of the,

07:18.765 --> 07:20.045
of the Immigrant Rights Movement, just

07:20.045 --> 07:23.765
because, the work, is so, so difficult.

07:24.545 --> 07:27.325
Um, so I, I observed that,

07:28.225 --> 07:31.275
and the care work practiced in the immigrant rights

07:31.515 --> 07:35.915
movement, creates these emotional spaces, these kind

07:35.915 --> 07:37.235
of intimate spaces.

07:38.055 --> 07:40.435
Um, and we would expect this from, from care work

07:40.435 --> 07:42.035
because care workers kind of have

07:42.035 --> 07:45.555
to create these safe spaces for people to feel,

07:45.785 --> 07:48.955
comfortable sharing their, the problems or their issues.

07:49.355 --> 07:51.915
I conducted participant observation in two movement

07:51.915 --> 07:53.875
organizations in El Paso, Texas.

07:53.985 --> 07:56.115
This is right on the, on the US Mexico border.

07:57.095 --> 07:58.715
And these organizations are part

07:58.715 --> 08:00.715
of this broader immigrant rights movement

08:00.715 --> 08:05.115
that we see in the us and, and it even spans across borders.

08:06.015 --> 08:09.635
And what the movement, the broad movement is trying

08:09.635 --> 08:12.795
to do is mostly just protect the rights of migrants

08:12.795 --> 08:16.675
and asylum seekers, and also expand their rights in

08:16.675 --> 08:17.835
particular areas.

08:18.855 --> 08:21.995
Um, so in my study, I, I look at two organizations.

08:22.455 --> 08:26.435
The first one is a legal aid office that I call compromiso.

08:27.375 --> 08:28.755
And this,

08:28.755 --> 08:32.475
organization provides accessible low cost services

08:32.615 --> 08:35.035
to migrants in the El Paso region.

08:36.055 --> 08:39.715
Um, and these services can be anything from asylum,

08:39.775 --> 08:41.955
asylum, you know, representation.

08:42.975 --> 08:47.555
Um, it could be adjustment of status, also,

08:47.655 --> 08:50.875
for example, helping, the dreamers get the, the,

08:50.885 --> 08:52.995
their daca, status.

08:53.215 --> 08:56.135
So a broad array of, of services.

08:56.835 --> 08:59.655
And I was a, a, a volunteer

08:59.655 --> 09:02.415
and eventually became like a staff member there,

09:02.715 --> 09:03.975
for about six months.

09:04.755 --> 09:07.975
And then I was also participating at a migrant shelter

09:08.195 --> 09:09.775
for about seven months.

09:10.515 --> 09:12.695
And that shelter provides,

09:13.255 --> 09:16.095
historically just had just helped, migrants

09:16.095 --> 09:17.495
who had just crossed the border, kind

09:17.495 --> 09:20.135
of just give them a space for them to, to rest

09:20.635 --> 09:22.775
and perhaps think of what they could do next.

09:23.515 --> 09:26.375
Um, but since about around 2014,

09:26.955 --> 09:29.175
the shelter started taking a lot of asylum seekers

09:29.175 --> 09:31.615
who had already been processed by immigration.

09:32.555 --> 09:36.335
Um, these are people who came to the US Mexico border,

09:36.335 --> 09:40.295
claimed asylum, and they were processed, they were detained

09:40.395 --> 09:44.375
for a couple of days, and then they were released, to,

09:45.355 --> 09:46.655
to go with their family members

09:46.715 --> 09:48.615
or to friends that they might have in the us.

09:49.595 --> 09:51.625
Um, mainly

09:51.625 --> 09:55.565
because the, the, the, the US government doesn't have spaces

09:55.785 --> 09:58.565
to hold, so many people, especially

09:58.565 --> 09:59.645
to hold family units.

10:00.425 --> 10:02.125
Um, so they're released

10:02.185 --> 10:05.645
and the shelter kind of provide support, helping them,

10:06.185 --> 10:10.685
kind of, organize their,

10:10.685 --> 10:12.125
their travel arrangements.

10:12.265 --> 10:15.165
Uh, so they might stay there for one day or, or three days.

10:16.105 --> 10:20.005
Um, so yeah, I, I also lived in the shelter along

10:20.005 --> 10:21.965
with the other volunteers,

10:22.385 --> 10:25.445
and I did, you know, at the shelter, I would, you know,

10:25.635 --> 10:27.165
have do shifts there.

10:27.565 --> 10:29.845
I would, there's all these sorts of tasks

10:30.025 --> 10:32.525
and assignments that all the staff have in order

10:32.525 --> 10:35.805
to keep the shelter running at the legal aid office,

10:36.085 --> 10:38.685
I was a, like a, a paralegal, so I would help

10:38.835 --> 10:40.565
with the research for asylum cases.

10:41.645 --> 10:44.285
I would also help with translations, just anything

10:44.285 --> 10:47.665
that they needed me, with.

10:47.765 --> 10:50.385
Um, something to point out about these organizations is

10:50.385 --> 10:52.905
that they, they're not very well resourced.

10:53.525 --> 10:56.865
Um, El Paso is not a particularly wealthy city.

10:57.045 --> 10:59.665
And these organizations also, yeah,

10:59.815 --> 11:01.065
they did not have enough staff,

11:01.205 --> 11:03.345
so they rely heavily on volunteers.

11:04.205 --> 11:07.185
Um, when I was at the legal aid office, there was,

11:07.575 --> 11:09.585
only one attorney on staff.

11:09.685 --> 11:12.505
So, so that, demanded, again, a lot of work.

11:12.525 --> 11:14.785
And this is part of the reason why, everyone was

11:14.785 --> 11:15.945
so, burnt out.

11:16.805 --> 11:18.665
Um, and something else I wanna say about the,

11:18.665 --> 11:20.865
the organizations is how they're, they're composed.

11:21.365 --> 11:25.105
So the, the legal aid office, was composed of mostly,

11:25.765 --> 11:28.225
Mexican American women,

11:28.285 --> 11:31.185
or people who have lived in El Paso for, for a while.

11:31.765 --> 11:33.585
And in the case of the shelter, most

11:33.585 --> 11:37.825
of those staff members were, not non-local.

11:37.825 --> 11:39.305
They were from other parts of the us.

11:39.925 --> 11:43.225
Uh, they also tended to be women, middle class,

11:43.685 --> 11:45.025
and, and also white.

11:45.605 --> 11:49.345
So these are, very, kind of distinct,

11:49.345 --> 11:51.985
compositions that, that also shape the culture

11:52.045 --> 11:53.065
of each organization.

11:53.405 --> 11:56.045
I did participant observation, which involves observation

11:56.105 --> 11:59.605
and writing these, these notes, every day if possible.

11:59.905 --> 12:02.605
And I also conducted interviews with members

12:02.745 --> 12:06.245
of each organization as well as with, members

12:06.305 --> 12:07.725
of other organizations in the city

12:07.725 --> 12:09.205
that were conducting similar work.

12:10.155 --> 12:14.055
Um, so yeah, that, that's mostly what I did.

12:14.055 --> 12:17.255
And I also did a little bit of, archival research on,

12:17.275 --> 12:21.015
on the history of mutual organization, as well as, just,

12:21.115 --> 12:24.155
the context of, of immigration

12:24.535 --> 12:27.235
and, in El Paso, the ways that,

12:28.595 --> 12:29.935
the different waves and,

12:29.935 --> 12:32.455
and the different ways that organizations in El Paso have

12:32.455 --> 12:35.615
helped migrants and asylum seekers, throughout history.

12:35.935 --> 12:39.055
I find this, this familial morality in both organizations.

12:39.795 --> 12:43.015
And, what it, what's particularly interesting is

12:43.015 --> 12:44.775
that the way that the familial morality

12:45.495 --> 12:47.855
manifests in each organization is different.

12:48.635 --> 12:51.815
At Compromiso, the legal aid office, I find that

12:52.575 --> 12:55.935
familial morality has to do with,

12:56.065 --> 13:00.215
reflection about staff members,

13:00.675 --> 13:01.895
own history of migration

13:01.915 --> 13:03.895
or their family's history of migration.

13:04.755 --> 13:07.695
So the kind of work that is done in the,

13:07.975 --> 13:10.415
in the legal aid office is in a sense,

13:10.415 --> 13:11.695
kind of intellectual, right?

13:11.715 --> 13:14.855
You interview, asylum seekers of migrants,

13:14.875 --> 13:18.055
you ask them about their life histories,

13:18.445 --> 13:21.415
what they did in their home countries, why they decided

13:21.475 --> 13:22.775
to, to leave their country.

13:23.715 --> 13:25.615
Uh, they tell you a little bit about their journey

13:25.715 --> 13:26.935
to the us, right?

13:26.995 --> 13:30.455
So it involves a kind of very, comprehensive

13:31.245 --> 13:32.295
idea of their life, right?

13:32.295 --> 13:34.935
And also a lot of, they provide a lot of information about,

13:35.395 --> 13:36.695
their persecution, right?

13:36.695 --> 13:39.415
About violence that they might encounter,

13:39.515 --> 13:40.855
or that they might have been a victim of.

13:40.955 --> 13:44.255
So, so this kind of,

13:44.885 --> 13:49.815
knowledge about migrants, in a sense triggers their,

13:50.515 --> 13:53.735
reflections about their own families, right?

13:53.735 --> 13:55.855
About how they might have migrated

13:55.855 --> 13:57.655
or how their families might have migrated.

13:58.395 --> 14:02.215
Um, and that kind of, I guess conversation

14:02.325 --> 14:05.455
that they keep having with themselves about,

14:06.465 --> 14:08.175
about migration, kind of,

14:08.175 --> 14:10.935
keeps them interested in the work and keeps them engaged,

14:10.955 --> 14:15.535
and it gives them, sort of meaning, in the case

14:15.535 --> 14:18.975
of the shelter, they're not doing this kind

14:18.975 --> 14:20.055
of intellectual labor, right?

14:20.055 --> 14:23.095
They're living in a, basically a huge house

14:23.095 --> 14:24.175
with other migrants.

14:24.875 --> 14:27.135
Um, and most of the conversations,

14:27.195 --> 14:29.135
or most of the interactions have to deal

14:29.135 --> 14:31.495
with very domestic things, right?

14:31.555 --> 14:35.775
So like preparing meals, playing with children, getting

14:35.835 --> 14:38.815
to know, about, you know, migrants

14:38.815 --> 14:43.615
or asylum seekers, home countries, yeah,

14:44.435 --> 14:47.295
the shelter has a, a, a clothing bank.

14:47.395 --> 14:49.695
So, you know, finding clothes for, for everyone.

14:49.755 --> 14:52.005
So, you know, these interactions kind

14:52.005 --> 14:56.865
of promote a different, kind of reflections

14:57.045 --> 15:00.265
or, or, or attachments to the kind of work

15:00.265 --> 15:01.505
and to migrants themselves.

15:02.245 --> 15:03.705
Uh, so in the sense when,

15:03.705 --> 15:06.345
when they start talking about why they do this kind of work

15:06.365 --> 15:10.105
or why they stay, it has to do a lot about this kind of

15:10.625 --> 15:12.105
familial obligation, right?

15:12.105 --> 15:15.705
They, they talk about their, their attachments as the kind

15:15.705 --> 15:16.745
of attachment that you would have

15:16.745 --> 15:18.265
to your own family members, right?

15:18.365 --> 15:20.785
To, to, to, to your husband

15:21.045 --> 15:22.905
or to, to, to, to your mother, right?

15:22.905 --> 15:25.105
Like, how can you leave your child, right?

15:25.105 --> 15:26.505
That they, they would say things like that,

15:26.525 --> 15:29.545
or How could you ignore so and so, right?

15:29.605 --> 15:33.905
You, you have to, keep, you know, providing for them or,

15:33.965 --> 15:35.825
or assisting them in some way.

15:36.325 --> 15:38.305
And even when they, when they leave, I think in the,

15:38.305 --> 15:41.105
in the article I talk about the, the, the director

15:41.105 --> 15:43.585
of the shelter thinking about how, you know,

15:43.685 --> 15:47.385
making this comparison to how when children leave

15:47.685 --> 15:49.985
for college or, you know, they leave the house, right?

15:50.525 --> 15:53.185
Um, is that same kind of, feeling, right?

15:53.185 --> 15:55.305
That you just kind of have to let them go and,

15:55.325 --> 15:56.705
and make their own life.

15:57.445 --> 16:01.065
So, so yeah, those are the two, two main differences.

16:01.725 --> 16:03.225
And as I've kind of already alluded

16:03.225 --> 16:06.265
to the main reasons why is one, the kind of work

16:06.375 --> 16:07.985
that they're doing, right, the kind of work

16:07.985 --> 16:10.625
that each organization is very different,

16:11.205 --> 16:12.385
and also the background

16:12.565 --> 16:16.385
of the caregivers themselves in the legal aid office,

16:17.285 --> 16:18.345
the, the paralegals

16:18.345 --> 16:21.745
and the attorney, you know, have this history of,

16:21.765 --> 16:23.185
of migration in the shelter.

16:24.245 --> 16:28.665
Um, the mostly non-local caregivers don't have that history

16:28.665 --> 16:30.265
of migration, or it's not very recent.

16:31.125 --> 16:35.105
Um, so they cannot relate to migrants in that sense, right?

16:35.205 --> 16:38.185
The way that, it happens in, in the, in the shelter.

16:38.965 --> 16:43.115
Um, so ultimately what I argue is that,

16:43.785 --> 16:47.885
what this implies is that what migrant, what,

16:47.885 --> 16:51.685
social movements do day in and day out in, in the every day,

16:52.025 --> 16:55.005
and who is doing that work,

16:55.625 --> 16:58.325
shapes the moral dimension of commitment.

16:58.985 --> 17:01.045
Um, and this kind

17:01.045 --> 17:04.045
of gets a little bit bit away from the idea that it,

17:04.425 --> 17:06.045
you know, that it's just ideology.

17:06.045 --> 17:09.925
That ideology is why, why people join the movement,

17:09.985 --> 17:11.845
and that's why people kind of stay, right?

17:11.845 --> 17:14.965
That what I'm trying to say is that there's kind of a, a,

17:14.965 --> 17:18.005
there's a, a set of ideas or, or,

17:18.145 --> 17:23.125
or moral sense that is developed within the movement itself,

17:23.145 --> 17:25.965
within the, the activities of the movement.

17:26.585 --> 17:29.205
Um, so that might represent a change, right?

17:29.205 --> 17:32.005
The reasons why they might have joined the movement

17:32.305 --> 17:33.565
change with time, right?

17:33.585 --> 17:38.165
And, and they become a bit more, specific in this case.

17:38.825 --> 17:40.525
Um, yeah.

17:40.905 --> 17:43.925
And, and I'll also just point out that this idea that

17:43.925 --> 17:46.925
that family is an important kind of frame

17:47.105 --> 17:49.325
for the immigrant rights movement is, is not new.

17:49.445 --> 17:51.445
A lot of other scholars have pointed this out.

17:52.145 --> 17:56.415
Um, but, what, what I, what I try

17:56.415 --> 17:59.815
to emphasize here is that the way that family,

18:01.415 --> 18:04.015
manifests right in, in, in, in the way

18:04.015 --> 18:06.855
that people talk about their engagement,

18:07.915 --> 18:09.545
might be different based on, on

18:09.545 --> 18:11.385
what they're doing in the movement and,

18:11.405 --> 18:12.945
and how they're interacting with,

18:13.095 --> 18:14.625
with migrants and asylum seekers.

18:14.825 --> 18:16.065
I am myself a migrant.

18:16.585 --> 18:19.905
I, I migrated to the US when I was 10 years old.

18:20.885 --> 18:24.625
So, certainly, it certainly, for example,

18:24.765 --> 18:28.225
at the legal aid office, I, it, it certainly made me realize

18:28.325 --> 18:31.545
how privileged I was and how I migrated to the country.

18:32.365 --> 18:34.145
Um, and,

18:34.165 --> 18:36.945
and of course, you know, I also maintained kind

18:36.945 --> 18:38.425
of like a, let's call it like an,

18:38.645 --> 18:40.345
an academic distance to it, right?

18:40.365 --> 18:45.235
So, so I could, I could also kind

18:45.355 --> 18:49.595
of, analyzed all these different stories

18:49.815 --> 18:52.755
and different cases that I came across within, you know,

18:52.755 --> 18:55.115
the broader literature of, of migration

18:55.255 --> 18:57.995
and how the immigration system has changed through time.

18:58.095 --> 19:02.315
So, so yeah, I, I also experienced that at the, at the,

19:02.695 --> 19:05.435
at the legal aid office and at the shelter also, definitely,

19:05.735 --> 19:09.795
the sense of, even solidarity

19:09.795 --> 19:11.035
with other staff members.

19:11.855 --> 19:16.475
Um, the, the kind of experiences that you're exposed to,

19:16.775 --> 19:20.715
create a very interesting, connection with, with other,

19:20.975 --> 19:24.205
staff members, so much so that a lot

19:24.205 --> 19:26.445
of them keep coming back, to the shelter.

19:26.695 --> 19:30.325
Maybe they can't, volunteer for as long as they did

19:30.325 --> 19:32.885
that first time, which is usually about a year.

19:33.625 --> 19:37.405
Um, but they certainly, you know, have very fond memories

19:37.405 --> 19:38.885
of their time in, in the shelter,

19:39.265 --> 19:42.925
and they, they, a lot of them also,

19:43.355 --> 19:46.885
stay engaged in, in immigration issues, you know, even

19:46.975 --> 19:48.965
after, their time there.

19:49.585 --> 19:51.245
Um, and yeah, and,

19:51.265 --> 19:53.485
and you also, develop very,

19:53.485 --> 19:55.205
close sometimes close relationships

19:55.205 --> 19:57.565
with individual migrants and asylum seekers.

19:57.625 --> 19:59.245
You, you care for them,

19:59.705 --> 20:02.485
and a lot of them, you know, you, you,

20:02.625 --> 20:04.325
you also feel concerned, right?

20:04.325 --> 20:05.845
When they decide to leave the shelter.

20:06.465 --> 20:08.165
Um, you're also concerned about that.

20:08.165 --> 20:11.365
You're worried about what's gonna happen to them,

20:11.705 --> 20:13.405
how their case will turn out.

20:14.105 --> 20:18.645
Um, so yeah, it's, it's quite, an experience,

20:18.945 --> 20:22.365
that, that you, you know, that stays with you.

20:23.145 --> 20:27.365
Um, and that, I believe probably continues to,

20:28.065 --> 20:32.925
to shape how, how these individuals, stay engaged with,

20:33.035 --> 20:34.605
with politics generally,

20:34.605 --> 20:38.845
but also, with the cause of migrants and asylum seekers.

20:38.985 --> 20:43.885
Hey, I'm interested in, I guess in, in terms of,

20:43.885 --> 20:48.715
future research, I would like to just, like

20:48.715 --> 20:52.035
to continue this, exploring these different,

20:53.595 --> 20:56.515
I guess, interactions with, with migrants.

20:56.555 --> 20:59.555
I think it'd be interesting to know, the way

20:59.555 --> 21:02.755
that migrants and asylum seekers feel about all these,

21:02.755 --> 21:05.555
interactions with, with caregivers in the United States.

21:06.215 --> 21:10.665
Um, I think there's some research on, on

21:10.685 --> 21:12.865
how they feel about, you know, the way that the state

21:12.885 --> 21:14.505
and state agencies treat them.

21:15.085 --> 21:16.785
But it'd be interesting to see also how,

21:16.885 --> 21:19.025
how they feel about all these movement organizations,

21:19.275 --> 21:21.425
these churches and other religious institutions.

21:22.165 --> 21:24.065
Um, what do they make of it?

21:24.765 --> 21:29.425
Um, so that is something that, that I am interested in.

21:30.505 --> 21:35.125
Uh, generally, it'd be interesting also

21:35.185 --> 21:39.925
to keep, just exploring how this movement,

21:40.265 --> 21:44.445
in other countries perhaps, how it's, it develops

21:44.445 --> 21:46.445
and the kind of connections that people make.

21:47.025 --> 21:50.125
Uh, for example, I'm interested in, in similar context in,

21:50.125 --> 21:54.885
in Mexico, to see if the, the different,

21:55.245 --> 22:00.115
I guess, context shapes the types of attachments

22:00.115 --> 22:03.315
that people make, with migrants and asylum seekers.

22:03.935 --> 22:07.755
Um, so that, that could also, I think that that's also very,

22:07.825 --> 22:10.315
very interesting that, and I would like to keep exploring,

22:10.385 --> 22:11.075
exploring that.

Faculti AI can make mistakes