Popular in Arts and Humanities

Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

McGill University Michael Fronda

Arts and Humanities

Lincoln and the Jews

Brandeis University Jonathan Sarna

Arts and Humanities

Amputations and Convalescence

University of Western Australia Emily Brink

Art

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

University of Birmingham David Hemsoll

Art

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

University of San Diego Chelsea Behle Fralick

Arts and Humanities

Early Modern Natural Law Theories

University of Copenhagen Knud Haakonssen

Forbidden

View more insights in Arts and Humanities - Books - History

View more figures from University of Wisconsin Madison

View the page of Jordan D. Rosenblum

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Jordan D. Rosenblum historicizes the emergence of the pig as a key symbol of Jewish identity

Image courtesy of interviewee. August 28, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

Faculti AI is thinking...

< >

Summary
Related Studies
Faculti AI
Key Points
Key Quotes
Translate
Transcript

Export as PDF

This video is a transcript of an interview with Jordan, who discusses the motivations behind his book on the cultural significance of pigs, particularly in Jewish and non-Jewish identity. The conversation begins with an introduction to the context and the date, August 23rd, around 3 PM in London.

Jordan explains that his interest in the topic started nearly 20 years ago when he was researching food laws in ancient texts, specifically focusing on how pigs were discussed by ancient rabbis and Romans in relation to identity. He accumulated various anecdotes and facts over the years, highlighting how discussions around pigs often generated curiosity and engagement in his talks.

The interview further explores how pigs have been used as a metaphor over time, especially as a symbol of humiliation in Jewish contexts. Jordan argues that while pigs are rarely mentioned in the Hebrew Bible, their significance grew during the Second Temple period, particularly through stories of martyrdom. He explains how the pig became emblematic of Jewish identity and Jewish dietary laws, while also being a tool for external mockery in medieval Christian contexts.

Jordan emphasizes that the symbolic value of pigs continues to evolve and remains relevant today. He discusses contemporary implications, such as the cultural reaction to “impossible pork” products, which raise questions about identity and the routine eating habits of different cultures. He concludes by expressing hopes that readers will appreciate the depth of the narrative around pigs and consider the broader implications of food choices and identity narratives in their lives.

The conversation also hints at the potential for future research on pigs and food studies more generally, suggesting a need for both micro and macro studies of food's symbolic meanings in different cultures. Jordan invites further exploration and scholarship on the topic, encouraging others to join the dialogue about the cultural weight of food and identity.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video:

1. **Historical Exploration**: The speaker discusses their academic journey, which began nearly 20 years ago while researching food laws in ancient times, focusing particularly on the cultural and identity-related significance of pigs in Jewish and non-Jewish convideos.

2. **Cultural Symbolism of Pigs**: The video highlights how the pig has been used historically to signify Jewish identity, particularly during periods of persecution, such as during the second temple period and in medieval times. The choice to eat or not eat pig has been layered with meanings over centuries.

3. **Ongoing Research and Interest**: The speaker describes their passion for the subject, mentioning that their research naturally expanded as they kept discovering more references and narratives about pigs, leading to the creation of multiple works on the topic.

4. **Relation to Broader Cultural Themes**: The discussion touches on how food and dietary choices reflect and communicate identity, values, and beliefs across different cultures and religions, emphasizing the importance of understanding the underlying meanings tied to these choices.

5. **Contemporary Implications**: The video draws connections between historical attitudes toward pigs and modern discussions around food alternatives, such as plant-based meats, suggesting that cultural baggage heavily influences contemporary dietary choices and their meanings in society today.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes from the video:

1. **Origin of Interest**:
- “This started back almost 20 years ago when I was working on my dissertation... I kept finding facts and I would think it was interesting and throw it into a talk and throw it into a file.”

2. **Cultural Significance of Pigs**:
- “...the more I worked on it, the more I was interested in it.”
- “If you look at the Hebrew Bible, pigs appear very rarely... but starting in the second temple period, starting around the time of the Maccabees, there start to be pigs in stories of Jewish martyrdom.”

3. **Identity and Meaning**:
- “To eat the pig as a Jew means a variety of things. To not eat the pig means a variety of things.”

4. **Historical Convideo**:
- “...over 2000 years, it gets layered with more meaning.”

5. **Personal Anecdote**:
- “...my family make fun of me because I love my mechanical pencils. So I love having books and I not just underline, I make my own index.”

6. **Cultural Layers and Modern Implications**:
- “...it continues to mean something. A Jew who eats pig can't just be a person who's eating pig. It has to be read by it...there's still a desire to prove, are you doing that to transgress?”

7. **Discussion on Impossible Pork**:
- “And both their, their kosher agency... refused to give it to impossible pork... it’s not technically wrong, but it feels wrong.”

8. **Conclusion and Broader Message**:
- “What I want them to take away from it is it has been, and I would argue, will continue to be used to tell stories of Jewish and non-Jewish identity.”
- “So what I would want them to take away from it is number one, this fascinating story, but then to think about how that applies to their other things that they recognize in life.”

These quotes exemplify the evolution of the speaker's interest in the cultural, religious, and historical layers of the significance of pigs in Jewish and broader society over time. The speaker reflects on personal experiences while also addressing larger themes related to identity and meaning in food choices.

Export as PDF
Here are some articles that share similar themes and topics with the transcript about Jordan's interview on the cultural significance of pigs in relation to identity:

1. **"The Symbolism of Food in Jewish Identity"** - This article explores how various foods have symbolized aspects of Jewish culture and identity, delving into the historical and religious significance of dietary laws.

2. **"Pigs and Piety: The Cultural Convideo of Dietary Laws in Judaism"** - An analysis of how dietary restrictions, particularly regarding pigs, reflect broader cultural and religious identities within the Jewish community.

3. **"Pigs in Mythology: A Study of Symbolism and Identity"** - This paper discusses the role of pigs in various cultural mythologies and what these stories convey about social values and identity constructs.

4. **"Food as Identity: Cultural Significance and Modern Implications"** - An exploration of how food choices shape identities in contemporary society, including discussions about plant-based alternatives and their reception in different cultural convideos.

5. **"Jewish Dietary Laws and Their Impact on Jewish Identity Through History"** - This article reviews the transformative role of Jewish dietary laws, including the cultural implications of eating and not eating certain foods throughout history.

6. **"The Evolution of Dietary Symbolism: From Ancient Texts to Modern Reading"** - A comprehensive study on how food symbolism has changed over time and the ongoing relevance of these symbols in today’s cultural discussions.

7. **"Cultural Identity and Food: The Intersection of Diet and Tradition"** - This piece explores how traditional food practices contribute to cultural identity, with case studies drawn from various ethnic groups including Jewish communities.

8. **"The Impact of Food Choices on Identity: A Socio-Cultural Perspective"** - An examination of how modern food trends like veganism and lab-grown meat pose new questions about identity and tradition.

9. **"Sacred Foods and Secular Society: The Changing Face of Dietary Rituals"** - This article investigates how secularization affects traditional food practices and the ritualistic meanings attached to them in modern society.

These articles collectively dive into the intersection of food, culture, and identity, similar to what Jordan discusses in his interview on the cultural significance of pigs.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.075 --> 00:02.805
This started back almost 20 years ago when I

00:02.805 --> 00:03.925
was working on my dissertation.

00:04.665 --> 00:09.165
And, I was working on food laws in the

00:09.435 --> 00:11.645
ancient world, and the ancient rabbis

00:12.185 --> 00:13.605
and pig kept popping up.

00:14.185 --> 00:18.795
And, I wrote my first article on this subject.

00:19.135 --> 00:23.345
Uh, it was even the subject of my, job talk

00:23.345 --> 00:24.585
for the job that I currently hold.

00:25.005 --> 00:28.665
Um, and 'cause I was looking at how the ancient Jews

00:28.805 --> 00:32.305
and ancient rabbis talked about pig and Jewish

00:32.365 --> 00:33.385
and non-Jewish identity,

00:33.445 --> 00:36.065
and then found that Romans were talking about

00:36.065 --> 00:37.705
Jewish identity through the Pig two.

00:37.705 --> 00:40.065
And so it was interesting to look at insiders

00:40.065 --> 00:43.515
and outsiders talking about identity in different ways,

00:43.615 --> 00:45.675
but through the same mechanism.

00:46.655 --> 00:48.355
And I pig kept popping up.

00:48.395 --> 00:50.435
I kept finding facts and I would think it was interesting

00:50.435 --> 00:52.395
and throw it into a talk and throw it into a file.

00:52.655 --> 00:54.915
And I would give talks and people would wanna know, well,

00:55.095 --> 00:56.555
why don't Jews eat pigs?

00:56.555 --> 00:57.795
Or let, or they would come up

00:57.795 --> 00:59.715
and share their story of their, their,

00:59.815 --> 01:01.675
the ways they would or wouldn't eat pig.

01:02.295 --> 01:04.385
And I kept saying,

01:04.385 --> 01:05.865
this is the next thing I'm gonna work on.

01:06.695 --> 01:10.155
And after a certain point, I, the file was overflowing.

01:10.695 --> 01:12.635
Um, well, I guess that's a, that's a metaphor

01:12.635 --> 01:14.355
that maybe would work for someone my age,

01:14.375 --> 01:16.635
but younger people wouldn't necessarily understood the,

01:16.855 --> 01:19.235
the word document had lots of sources in it,

01:19.775 --> 01:21.915
and I started to put it together

01:21.975 --> 01:23.635
and I just kept finding it and finding it.

01:23.635 --> 01:26.355
And also, I hit a point where I had to be okay with the fact

01:26.355 --> 01:28.835
that I was gonna find, that I was gonna continue to find

01:29.385 --> 01:30.675
sources after I,

01:30.915 --> 01:32.075
'cause if I waited to find every source,

01:32.115 --> 01:33.435
I would never finish the book.

01:33.435 --> 01:35.235
And in fact, and I now have a file

01:35.335 --> 01:39.355
of things I've found since I sent the book to the publisher,

01:39.355 --> 01:42.035
and they told me I am not allowed to touch a word.

01:42.495 --> 01:45.075
Um, but so the motivation was, it just kept coming up.

01:45.455 --> 01:48.195
And it was so fascinating. It was such rich material.

01:49.015 --> 01:50.555
And the more I worked on it,

01:50.555 --> 01:51.635
the more I was interested in it.

01:51.635 --> 01:52.755
This is my fourth book.

01:52.855 --> 01:55.955
And actually, the first three I was kind of sick of

01:56.175 --> 01:57.235
by the time I was done with it.

01:57.315 --> 01:58.955
I like didn't want to talk about it anymore.

01:59.535 --> 02:02.595
But you can ask my family, I'm still overly excited

02:02.615 --> 02:04.595
to talk about what I call like my pigs.

02:04.615 --> 02:07.675
You know, there's so much, so the, so it's,

02:07.935 --> 02:10.675
the motivation was it was just kept popping up

02:11.615 --> 02:13.315
and there was so much information.

02:13.655 --> 02:15.595
So that, that's what inspired me

02:15.595 --> 02:19.795
or continues to, I, I, I, again, I keep collecting

02:20.465 --> 02:23.155
pigs sources for future talks

02:23.295 --> 02:25.955
or, for, you know, if there's ever another addition

02:25.955 --> 02:27.515
or something, I could squeeze in more pigs.

02:27.615 --> 02:31.715
If you look at the Hebrew Bible, pigs appear very rarely,

02:32.215 --> 02:34.955
you know, you're told in, in, Leviticus

02:34.955 --> 02:36.115
and Deuteronomy don't eat them,

02:36.115 --> 02:37.715
but you're also told not to eat the camel.

02:38.295 --> 02:41.635
Um, and pigs, pigs appear only a handful of times.

02:41.775 --> 02:43.835
So many other, not categorically,

02:43.835 --> 02:45.555
not kosher animals appear in the Hebrew Bible.

02:46.135 --> 02:48.195
Um, what, what I argue is

02:48.195 --> 02:50.235
that starting in the second temple period, starting

02:50.235 --> 02:53.875
around the time of the, the Maccabees, where, there,

02:54.445 --> 02:58.275
there start to be pigs in stories of Jewish martyrdom,

02:58.275 --> 03:02.285
stories of Jews being told you, you either eat the pig

03:02.705 --> 03:04.805
and submit to foreign rule or you'll be killed.

03:05.265 --> 03:07.205
And in those stories, they could equally say you could eat

03:07.205 --> 03:10.885
the camel, you could eat the eagle, you could eat,

03:11.565 --> 03:12.725
a variety of other non-kosher animals.

03:12.725 --> 03:13.965
But it's the pig. And I think it's the pig

03:14.085 --> 03:17.285
'cause that's the most commonly available non-kosher animal.

03:17.285 --> 03:19.205
But it, it starts to make it mean more.

03:19.545 --> 03:22.805
And in fact, you know, when you, when you write a book,

03:22.805 --> 03:25.525
you write the same ideas over and over

03:25.525 --> 03:27.085
and over again as you're rewriting the chapter.

03:27.385 --> 03:28.805
And then as you're writing a book review,

03:28.805 --> 03:30.685
and as you're writing, a book, proposal,

03:30.785 --> 03:32.245
and as you're giving talks related to it,

03:32.545 --> 03:34.725
and there was one kind of throwaway line I wrote one time

03:34.725 --> 03:35.885
that like made me stop,

03:36.065 --> 03:38.725
and now I keep coming back to, which was I realized

03:38.725 --> 03:42.045
that in the most ancient sources about, the Maccabees,

03:42.045 --> 03:45.005
which are about this, the what is now the modern Jewish

03:45.005 --> 03:47.045
holiday of Hanukkah, you learn

03:47.145 --> 03:49.205
so much more about the pig than you do about oil.

03:49.205 --> 03:50.965
People today talk about, the miracle of oil.

03:51.305 --> 03:52.565
It lasted eight days.

03:52.715 --> 03:53.725
This kosher oil

03:53.895 --> 03:56.485
after the Maccabees were, were victorious.

03:56.705 --> 03:58.285
But that story doesn't come until

03:58.935 --> 04:00.385
several hundred years after.

04:00.495 --> 04:02.625
It's the first recorded event of that story.

04:02.725 --> 04:04.545
But if you read the earliest book of Maccabees,

04:04.755 --> 04:06.225
there are are page after page

04:06.225 --> 04:09.345
after page about Jews being forced to either

04:10.045 --> 04:12.065
eat the pig or be killed.

04:12.685 --> 04:16.235
And so starting, and then both Jews

04:16.255 --> 04:19.235
and the, the Jews particularly start to notice that

04:19.555 --> 04:20.795
'cause the Jewish sources talking about it.

04:20.795 --> 04:23.115
But then also non-Jew sources start to notice, Hey,

04:23.925 --> 04:25.175
Jews don't eat the pig.

04:25.195 --> 04:28.415
Now, that's not always true. Some Jews do, but Jews

04:28.475 --> 04:31.775
and non-Jews sources start talking about it more and more.

04:31.775 --> 04:33.055
And as they talk about it more,

04:33.285 --> 04:34.655
they invest it with more meaning.

04:34.755 --> 04:36.775
And then what I say is, over 2000 years,

04:37.635 --> 04:38.895
it gets layered with more meaning.

04:39.945 --> 04:43.965
And so to eat the pig as a Jew means a variety of things.

04:45.175 --> 04:47.595
To not eat the pig means a variety of things.

04:48.055 --> 04:49.675
For a Jew or a non-Jew to eat

04:49.695 --> 04:51.395
or not eat the pig means a variety of things.

04:51.455 --> 04:54.155
And so each successive generation

04:54.155 --> 04:55.395
layers another meaning on it.

04:55.855 --> 04:58.355
And so the, the longer you go, the more it means.

04:58.415 --> 05:01.435
So now the pig means so much more than the camel.

05:01.735 --> 05:04.915
And in fact, I, in the opening of the book, I point out,

05:04.935 --> 05:07.395
I have a, a soon to be 10-year-old son.

05:07.695 --> 05:10.395
And when I was, he was a a baby,

05:10.575 --> 05:12.315
my mom got him these wooden blocks

05:12.745 --> 05:14.355
that had Hebrew letters on them and,

05:14.355 --> 05:15.955
and animals with their Hebrew names on it.

05:16.295 --> 05:18.115
Um, and my wife grew up in Italy.

05:18.115 --> 05:20.235
So then I bought some Italian blocks too,

05:20.495 --> 05:22.235
and I was comparing them from the same company,

05:22.535 --> 05:25.695
and I found that they both had the eagle,

05:26.195 --> 05:27.415
and several other animals.

05:27.475 --> 05:31.545
But the Hebrew blocks didn't have the pig,

05:32.565 --> 05:34.225
the, but the Italian blocks did.

05:34.645 --> 05:36.625
Um, but so I then compared all of them

05:36.625 --> 05:37.785
to see what did they replace it with?

05:38.085 --> 05:39.545
And the Hebrew blocks placed the,

05:39.825 --> 05:41.025
replaced the pig with the camel.

05:41.285 --> 05:42.785
But if you look at the biblical verses,

05:42.785 --> 05:44.065
the camel is prohibited, right?

05:44.065 --> 05:47.305
Literally right next to the pig in the Hebrew Bible, right?

05:47.565 --> 05:49.255
So they were

05:50.365 --> 05:52.455
replacing one biblically forbidden animal with another.

05:52.475 --> 05:55.215
But the pig just the cultural symbolism.

05:55.555 --> 05:57.485
And sort of my point is, if you just had the Hebrew Bible,

05:57.485 --> 05:58.605
that would make no sense.

05:59.465 --> 06:02.925
But it's, it's the, these thousands of years of,

06:03.425 --> 06:06.925
of complications, that's the story that I tell in this book

06:07.355 --> 06:09.965
that explain these blocks my family make fun of me

06:09.965 --> 06:11.685
because I, I love my mechanical pencils.

06:11.685 --> 06:13.445
So I, I love having books

06:13.545 --> 06:15.885
and I not just underline, I make my own index.

06:16.305 --> 06:18.725
So if you look at the back of my book, and,

06:18.865 --> 06:21.245
and so the first thing I did when I finally said, okay,

06:21.245 --> 06:22.605
I wanna do this, is I looked at the back

06:22.605 --> 06:25.365
of pretty much every book I've read for the past 20 years

06:25.825 --> 06:27.165
and look to find my pig.

06:27.965 --> 06:30.265
And, and you find it and all sorts of,

06:30.285 --> 06:32.905
and then you give toxin, people tell you, you know,

06:33.135 --> 06:34.745
have you did this?

06:34.805 --> 06:36.345
Or you talk about it in class.

06:36.725 --> 06:40.705
Um, there's one, one have a, there's a story,

06:40.805 --> 06:45.305
in Voltaire Canid that talks, that tells of,

06:45.485 --> 06:48.785
people who are suspected of being, con

06:48.925 --> 06:51.385
of muranos, which we'll get to that in a minute

06:51.565 --> 06:52.785
of this pig history.

06:53.205 --> 06:54.625
Um, and,

06:54.625 --> 06:57.865
because they take the, the, the bake, the, the ham,

06:58.245 --> 06:59.785
the bacon outta their chicken, right?

07:00.165 --> 07:01.945
Um, and a student in class,

07:02.065 --> 07:04.105
I was just mentioning this pi, something about pigs.

07:04.105 --> 07:05.425
And a student was like, we just

07:05.425 --> 07:07.185
read Voltaire in my other class.

07:07.245 --> 07:08.305
And there's this story, right?

07:08.325 --> 07:11.265
So if you talk about it, people tell you things.

07:11.325 --> 07:13.865
So I've been collecting pig facts through the years,

07:14.365 --> 07:17.145
and then the, what I try, what I did was start trying

07:17.145 --> 07:19.345
to figure out how to put it together and where it was.

07:19.345 --> 07:21.585
And then once you start looking,

07:22.925 --> 07:26.465
and then it's just reading all sorts of different things.

07:26.545 --> 07:28.545
I read things way beyond my comfort zone.

07:29.245 --> 07:31.145
And then one thing leads to another.

07:31.405 --> 07:34.245
Um, you know, you find one book

07:34.705 --> 07:36.165
and then you look at the footnotes,

07:36.465 --> 07:38.565
and then you follow the footnotes and they suggest that.

07:38.565 --> 07:41.805
And then you go to the library and you look, it's hard

07:41.805 --> 07:43.045
to get students these days to go

07:43.045 --> 07:44.045
to an actual physical library.

07:44.225 --> 07:45.365
You can do a lot on Google books,

07:45.365 --> 07:47.245
but I love to go to the library

07:47.385 --> 07:50.005
and look at the book to the right and the left of it,

07:50.005 --> 07:51.365
and open it up, right?

07:51.545 --> 07:54.165
And it's the chance finding the things,

07:54.185 --> 07:55.405
and then it's just random.

07:55.665 --> 07:57.045
You're reading a random book.

07:57.585 --> 08:01.565
And so, they just, they're everywhere.

08:01.565 --> 08:05.715
And once you start looking for it, it's everywhere.

08:06.495 --> 08:10.905
And so, it was 20 years of chance

08:11.165 --> 08:12.545
and purposeful findings

08:13.045 --> 08:14.625
and then trying to bring them together.

08:14.625 --> 08:16.945
And then once you start bringing together, story starts

08:16.945 --> 08:18.465
to come out of it and you start

08:18.465 --> 08:20.825
to see when certain trends appear,

08:21.045 --> 08:22.705
and then you go looking for more of those.

08:23.725 --> 08:27.735
So that was, sort of purposeful

08:27.735 --> 08:28.975
and accidental findings.

08:29.235 --> 08:30.935
You can start and say in the, in the second,

08:31.155 --> 08:33.455
in the second temple period when I talked about that eat pig

08:33.595 --> 08:37.615
or be, be, martyred.

08:37.955 --> 08:41.095
But I really see that story emerging in medieval times

08:41.095 --> 08:45.215
and beyond, where you see,

08:45.295 --> 08:48.295
Christians using it to mock Jews,

08:48.355 --> 08:51.055
but also to mock Christians

08:51.075 --> 08:53.415
who weren't being Christian enough.

08:53.415 --> 08:54.815
Right? We have, there,

08:55.045 --> 08:56.445
Nuremberg has written about anti Judaism

08:56.445 --> 09:00.765
and the, the idea of, there, going back

09:00.765 --> 09:02.885
to John Christo, an early church father

09:03.065 --> 09:04.525
who talked about judaizing Christians

09:04.525 --> 09:06.525
and what he meant are bad Christians, Christians

09:06.525 --> 09:08.525
who were acting like Jews, right?

09:08.625 --> 09:11.245
And, and so pig became a symbol of that now.

09:11.245 --> 09:14.005
So it was used to mock Jews in ways of, there was,

09:14.785 --> 09:17.685
in the 12 and 13 hundreds, there were, vows

09:17.685 --> 09:19.765
that Jews had to make if you're gonna go into.

09:19.785 --> 09:22.445
So, oaths, you had to take, if you're gonna go into

09:23.025 --> 09:24.565
be, give evidence in a trial,

09:24.865 --> 09:27.125
and they had to stand on a sow's skin

09:27.345 --> 09:29.085
and hold a Toro skull, right?

09:29.145 --> 09:32.245
Um, and the sow skin was clearly meant to mock Jews.

09:32.905 --> 09:35.285
Um, and the way you could tell it was originally a,

09:35.485 --> 09:38.075
a goat skin, and they changed it, right?

09:38.175 --> 09:42.195
And, you have, different ways.

09:42.455 --> 09:46.315
So the, they had, you look at again, well,

09:46.315 --> 09:48.635
we could look at Murano, the term for Murano means pig.

09:48.815 --> 09:51.915
And the idea that was a Jew who had converted to Christ

09:52.135 --> 09:54.715
who had Catholicism, but you suspected

09:54.715 --> 09:56.715
that they were secretly acting like a pig.

09:57.105 --> 09:58.635
They were secretly acting like a Jew.

09:58.635 --> 10:03.355
And that's layers of mockery to say, you're a Jew, really,

10:03.695 --> 10:05.915
and Jews don't eat pigs, but so you're a pig.

10:05.915 --> 10:08.355
And so one of the biggest accusations against suspected

10:08.545 --> 10:12.405
muranos was that they didn't eat pig.

10:13.275 --> 10:15.415
Um, and there were, there are testimonies of Jesus,

10:15.755 --> 10:20.215
you know, Converso, who said, no, no,

10:20.255 --> 10:21.295
I just don't like pig.

10:21.295 --> 10:23.415
Like, look at all these other non-kosher animals.

10:23.535 --> 10:25.815
I eat, but I just don't like it. Right?

10:25.995 --> 10:29.855
And, the, and maybe it's true, maybe it's not.

10:30.235 --> 10:33.055
You had the, the famous example in Germany of the Densa,

10:33.055 --> 10:35.215
which was, it started as,

10:35.675 --> 10:38.895
and this goes back to early Christianity, looking

10:39.075 --> 10:40.815
and ancient Judaism too.

10:40.955 --> 10:43.655
The idea of animals as embodying virtues and vices.

10:44.035 --> 10:46.495
So if you go back to the second temple period, there was a,

10:46.575 --> 10:49.175
a j named Philo who talked about how,

10:49.515 --> 10:50.975
why is pig not allowed?

10:50.975 --> 10:54.175
And he said, well, 'cause it's, you look at animals,

10:54.355 --> 10:57.455
the allowable animals that are domesticated quad eds.

10:57.455 --> 11:00.015
So like, why are cow allowed in pig not, he said,

11:00.085 --> 11:01.455
well, 'cause what are their characteristics?

11:01.455 --> 11:03.335
They have to chew the cud and have split hooves.

11:03.675 --> 11:07.495
And he said, chew the cud is when you,

11:07.605 --> 11:10.175
what they do is they chew information, they bring it down,

11:10.195 --> 11:12.335
and they literally regurgitate the knowledge.

11:12.515 --> 11:14.295
And so they say, this is how you should be as a thinker.

11:14.395 --> 11:18.175
You should take in information, digest it, bring it back up,

11:18.855 --> 11:21.285
think about it again, digest it, bring it back up,

11:21.295 --> 11:23.005
think about it, digest it, bring it back up.

11:23.425 --> 11:26.645
And he said that, so by eating animals that chew the cud,

11:26.645 --> 11:27.765
that's literally what they do.

11:28.025 --> 11:29.845
But that's a lesson in education.

11:30.355 --> 11:32.805
When you, you should listen to this interview

11:33.265 --> 11:37.005
and go think about it and then listen to it again, right?

11:37.185 --> 11:38.805
The, and then think about it again.

11:39.025 --> 11:41.325
Um, and they said the split hooves is about, there's two,

11:41.325 --> 11:43.765
there's virtue and there's vice in life.

11:44.025 --> 11:46.685
And by eating that you remember which path you should go.

11:47.395 --> 11:51.085
Well, the, at first in this was all over Europe, the idea

11:51.085 --> 11:52.965
of animals as virtues and vices in churches.

11:53.465 --> 11:56.005
But in Germany in particular, they start to take the pig,

11:56.005 --> 11:57.365
which embodied greed.

11:59.105 --> 12:01.985
'cause it's piggy, you know, it's, it's piggish and,

12:02.965 --> 12:05.865
and say, well, that embodies greed equals Jews.

12:06.175 --> 12:08.905
Jews are greedy, Jews are pigs. Jews hate pigs.

12:09.005 --> 12:10.745
And it starts to become a, a joke

12:10.765 --> 12:15.585
and then a vulgar joke by having Jews eat a pig excrement

12:15.585 --> 12:16.825
and drink pig urine.

12:17.445 --> 12:19.705
And it becomes vul more and more vulgar.

12:19.925 --> 12:22.825
And a certain point becomes so vulgar that they say, yeah,

12:22.825 --> 12:25.065
we can't even have this in churches anymore, right?

12:25.065 --> 12:27.905
Because it just devolves into a, a vulgar joke.

12:27.925 --> 12:30.465
But for several centuries, it was a vulgar joke

12:30.465 --> 12:32.425
that was perfectly acceptable to have in churches.

12:33.485 --> 12:36.185
Um, so pig is used to dehumanize Jews,

12:37.085 --> 12:38.985
but it's also used to,

12:39.935 --> 12:42.185
because of that to mock Christians

12:42.205 --> 12:44.625
who aren't good enough Christians.

12:46.885 --> 12:48.065
And that continues on.

12:48.065 --> 12:49.945
And there's a long history of,

12:50.345 --> 12:52.465
I mean the Nazis used that as part of that.

12:52.665 --> 12:55.305
I, in the book, I give one example of it and I said,

12:55.705 --> 12:56.785
'cause that's the other,

12:57.565 --> 13:00.265
the hard part I started in the medieval chapter was going

13:00.265 --> 13:04.375
through all of the awful antisemitic tropes of that.

13:04.375 --> 13:06.935
And that's kinda, it exacts a toll on a writer.

13:06.935 --> 13:08.255
And so when I got to the Nazis,

13:08.255 --> 13:09.495
I'm like, I'm gonna give you one example.

13:10.535 --> 13:11.535
I don't need to go through it.

13:11.755 --> 13:15.575
You, the reader and me the author do not need to do, he,

13:15.605 --> 13:18.495
I'll I'll give you one quote from I think Himler I used,

13:18.595 --> 13:21.255
and then there's plenty of others, you know?

13:21.355 --> 13:22.655
So I hit a poor, I hit a,

13:22.655 --> 13:23.735
that was when I hit my breaking point.

13:23.765 --> 13:25.575
Well, let's look at impossible pork and work backwards.

13:25.575 --> 13:27.695
What I'd say is that it continues to mean something.

13:28.215 --> 13:30.295
A Jew who eats pig

13:31.335 --> 13:33.325
can't just be a person who's eating pig.

13:33.625 --> 13:36.485
It has to be read by it.

13:36.585 --> 13:39.175
Um, either themselves

13:39.355 --> 13:41.615
or others will read like, well, why are you eating?

13:41.615 --> 13:43.215
What does it mean? Like, there, there's a,

13:43.215 --> 13:44.895
there's still a desire to prove, are you doing

13:44.895 --> 13:45.935
that to transgress?

13:45.995 --> 13:47.455
And one of the, so I'm gonna get

13:47.455 --> 13:49.215
to the impossible pig in a second to say, one of the things

13:49.215 --> 13:50.895
that I really highlight is I think there's a problem

13:50.895 --> 13:54.375
that some people say, a Jew pig is a bad Jew,

13:54.995 --> 13:57.135
or they're heretical in some way.

13:57.135 --> 13:59.935
And I'm like, well, we have this long history I can talk

13:59.935 --> 14:02.095
about too, of Jews who chose to eat pig

14:02.355 --> 14:04.015
to transgress Jewish identity,

14:04.035 --> 14:06.495
but in a way that we reinforces Jewish identity, right?

14:06.495 --> 14:08.135
Because they're, by doing that,

14:08.135 --> 14:10.135
they're making a statement about their Jewish identity.

14:10.195 --> 14:12.735
And my broader point is just pig is used

14:12.795 --> 14:14.095
to talk about Jewish identity.

14:14.515 --> 14:16.215
And I, I think it continues to be.

14:16.515 --> 14:18.055
So let's look at impossible pork.

14:18.355 --> 14:19.495
So for those who don't know, this,

14:19.495 --> 14:23.135
obviously an impossible meats company, makes lots

14:23.135 --> 14:26.155
of fake meat products

14:26.625 --> 14:29.075
that have no animal products in them whatsoever.

14:29.465 --> 14:32.995
They make fake impossible sausage, impossible, beef

14:33.685 --> 14:35.715
impossible, all sorts of things.

14:35.855 --> 14:38.635
All of those things, are, he,

14:38.635 --> 14:39.715
they have a kosher certification

14:39.715 --> 14:42.355
and halal, they have Islamic, certifications.

14:42.745 --> 14:44.555
They then came up with impossible pork.

14:45.055 --> 14:48.315
And both their, their kosher agency, the ou,

14:48.315 --> 14:50.835
which has been in business since 1923, it started

14:50.835 --> 14:52.285
with Heinz vegetarian baked beans

14:52.305 --> 14:53.645
and now continues to today.

14:53.645 --> 14:55.285
So it just celebrated its hundredth anniversary

14:55.285 --> 14:56.325
of kosher certification.

14:56.865 --> 14:58.885
And halal certification refused to give it

14:58.885 --> 14:59.925
to impossible pork.

15:01.095 --> 15:02.515
And i I, and this,

15:02.615 --> 15:05.195
and they said, look, it's, it's all the same ingredients

15:05.295 --> 15:07.195
as impossible sausage that's continues to be

15:08.035 --> 15:09.875
possible pork sausage, right?

15:09.875 --> 15:12.515
Like it's modeling that, but it's impossible pork.

15:12.655 --> 15:16.675
And the, they, the head of that agency admitted like,

15:16.675 --> 15:18.835
look, it's just, it feels wrong.

15:19.555 --> 15:21.375
And people have different explanations for this.

15:21.995 --> 15:25.375
And so you should always take sky's explanation

15:25.375 --> 15:28.495
with a grain of salt in that we all have, you know, if

15:29.215 --> 15:31.055
I have my, my reason for it,

15:31.095 --> 15:32.335
'cause I've been doing this historical sweep,

15:32.335 --> 15:33.495
there are other people who,

15:33.495 --> 15:34.615
they're interested in technologists

15:34.615 --> 15:35.815
that have a technological answer

15:35.835 --> 15:37.015
or people have the other things.

15:37.035 --> 15:39.375
So for me, for my historical sweep, what I see this is,

15:41.295 --> 15:43.595
it makes sense and doesn't make sense, right?

15:43.655 --> 15:44.715
It doesn't make sense

15:44.715 --> 15:46.195
because all the ingredients are kosher.

15:47.105 --> 15:48.645
You do all these other products.

15:49.465 --> 15:53.555
But when you look at over 2000 years of this baggage for it

15:53.855 --> 15:57.235
to claim that that's kosher just feels wrong.

15:57.825 --> 16:00.115
It's not technically wrong, but it feels wrong

16:00.655 --> 16:02.675
and that is part of it, right?

16:02.855 --> 16:07.595
Um, but, and you could imagine someone choosing to eat that

16:07.855 --> 16:11.355
as a statement of arguing against certain

16:12.425 --> 16:13.585
rabbinic interpretations.

16:13.925 --> 16:17.425
You could choose, see someone not eating it, in favor

16:17.425 --> 16:18.505
of rabbinic interpretations,

16:18.505 --> 16:21.465
or not eating it in favor of cultural trends.

16:21.965 --> 16:24.225
The same way a lot of people, you know,

16:24.225 --> 16:25.705
I collect stories 'cause people come up

16:25.705 --> 16:26.745
and tell me I've, the amount

16:26.745 --> 16:28.345
of times I've heard someone say, I'll eat bacon,

16:28.365 --> 16:29.625
but I can't eat a pork chop.

16:30.135 --> 16:33.465
Just a big piece of meat. And there's a long story for that.

16:33.605 --> 16:36.505
Now you look at the fake meat products going back

16:36.505 --> 16:38.545
to the twenties and thirties, there was beef fry.

16:38.545 --> 16:42.065
There's a long history of fake meat products

16:42.065 --> 16:43.705
that have been certified as kosher.

16:44.605 --> 16:49.215
But the problem with impossible pork is it was the name

16:49.475 --> 16:52.775
and the taste and the quality are so close.

16:53.595 --> 16:56.335
And I could find you going back to the Talmud sources

16:56.405 --> 16:57.855
that tell you, no, no, it's totally fine.

16:59.025 --> 17:00.205
But that's not the point here.

17:00.305 --> 17:01.925
The the point that I was trying to bring out, it's here.

17:01.925 --> 17:03.645
It's, it's not about the legality.

17:03.675 --> 17:06.405
There's this baggage, this weight.

17:06.465 --> 17:09.845
So that's why I say it, me, it continues to mean even more

17:09.845 --> 17:13.535
because legally there's no reason not to.

17:14.155 --> 17:17.655
But it's that extra cultural layer of meaning that,

17:17.765 --> 17:20.575
that I find fascinating that I think only makes sense

17:21.235 --> 17:23.695
if you look at this 3000 year sweep.

17:23.935 --> 17:27.695
I hope they take from it, the, the story

17:27.795 --> 17:30.455
of the pig and why it comes to mean something

17:30.455 --> 17:32.255
and why it matters, right?

17:32.395 --> 17:35.535
Um, and I hope they, particularly, I hope they take from it

17:35.555 --> 17:38.215
to not, there's a lot of judgment like, I can't,

17:38.275 --> 17:39.815
people understand their perspective,

17:39.815 --> 17:41.295
but don't understand someone else's.

17:41.725 --> 17:43.935
Like, why, why would anyone eat the pig?

17:44.015 --> 17:46.775
I would never, or why wouldn't someone eat the pig?

17:46.775 --> 17:47.975
That's, it's ridiculous.

17:48.555 --> 17:53.085
Or, why does the, the pig comes

17:53.085 --> 17:54.245
to mean so many different things.

17:54.245 --> 17:57.165
And what I want them to take away from it is it has been,

17:57.165 --> 18:01.165
and I would argue, will continue to be used to tell

18:01.915 --> 18:04.085
stories of Jewish and non-Jewish identity.

18:04.905 --> 18:07.485
And instead of judging that one way

18:07.605 --> 18:08.965
or the other, I would want them

18:09.585 --> 18:11.525
to step back and say, well, why?

18:11.525 --> 18:12.925
What does it mean? What does it mean?

18:13.365 --> 18:15.085
I often want people also to step back

18:15.085 --> 18:16.725
and think about everything they eat food.

18:17.835 --> 18:19.575
So I'm interested in food in general

18:19.795 --> 18:22.135
and the ways that religious communities

18:22.315 --> 18:25.295
and people even zooming out past religion,

18:25.915 --> 18:29.175
use the way they eat to tell their story and their identity.

18:29.845 --> 18:33.475
Right? I'm a vegetarian, I'm a vegan, I,

18:33.615 --> 18:35.935
all I eat is meat, right?

18:36.115 --> 18:39.695
Um, and what that, what that communicates about them,

18:39.755 --> 18:42.855
and it communicates values and meanings and,

18:44.155 --> 18:45.295
and so what I would want them

18:45.295 --> 18:48.615
to take away from it is number one, this fascinating story,

18:48.635 --> 18:50.615
but then to think about how that applies to

18:51.225 --> 18:53.815
their other things that they recognize in life.

18:54.515 --> 18:58.625
Um, and so I get that that would be,

18:58.665 --> 18:59.985
I think the main thing I want people to take away from,

18:59.985 --> 19:02.545
because it's a, and I would hopefully want them

19:02.545 --> 19:03.945
to take away that the pig is pretty cool.

19:04.385 --> 19:06.345
I touched throughout on Islam,

19:06.405 --> 19:08.625
but, I, I couldn't tell everything

19:08.625 --> 19:11.785
and I would love, I think there would be a very different,

19:11.805 --> 19:14.345
but in some ways similar story of Islam in the pig.

19:14.925 --> 19:17.175
Um, I think that

19:18.975 --> 19:20.695
I would, so there's a few areas.

19:20.835 --> 19:23.735
One is, there's more work to be done.

19:24.555 --> 19:28.455
Um, I'm still continuing on the ways that food rules,

19:28.515 --> 19:30.535
and relations to food and animals.

19:31.195 --> 19:32.975
Um, and there's two sort of, there's food studies

19:32.995 --> 19:34.855
and there's animal studies which connect

19:34.855 --> 19:36.175
and don't connect,

19:36.205 --> 19:38.655
tell stories about Judaism and other religions.

19:38.835 --> 19:41.775
And so I'd want people to, to tell these stories.

19:42.435 --> 19:45.375
Um, I think there's more work to be done,

19:45.835 --> 19:47.375
on the way on comparative.

19:47.405 --> 19:49.535
What, what does it mean for different traditions

19:49.535 --> 19:50.655
in different times and places?

19:51.355 --> 19:54.375
Um, it's also early on in my career, I used to judge people

19:54.475 --> 19:57.375
who did like these sweeping stories, right?

19:57.395 --> 19:58.815
And so I, I was on my first,

19:58.915 --> 20:01.775
my dissertation in my first book is on very narrow,

20:01.955 --> 20:04.295
you know, first through third century CE stories.

20:04.795 --> 20:07.215
Um, and I would've very much judged me today

20:07.215 --> 20:08.775
for writing this 3000 year scope.

20:09.395 --> 20:14.295
But, having done that, I also think that we need both.

20:14.315 --> 20:16.535
We need those micro studies and those macro studies,

20:16.715 --> 20:19.695
and then we need to have a little forgiveness for the people

20:19.835 --> 20:23.015
who are stretching beyond their boundaries, right?

20:23.515 --> 20:25.375
Um, and a little forgiveness for those

20:25.375 --> 20:26.815
who are staying within their boundaries.

20:27.395 --> 20:29.815
So, I think that, one of the things

20:29.815 --> 20:32.175
that came from this is I really benefited from people

20:32.275 --> 20:33.895
who did, who stayed in their boundaries.

20:33.895 --> 20:38.175
Someone who wrote about pigs in this time in, in Italy,

20:38.275 --> 20:41.415
or this time in England, or this time in Egypt.

20:41.955 --> 20:44.535
Um, and I needed all of that to stitch it together.

20:45.035 --> 20:46.935
So what I would say is, people

20:46.965 --> 20:49.205
Could take it in both directions, sort of the accordion.

20:49.205 --> 20:50.965
They could zoom out or they could zoom

20:50.965 --> 20:52.045
in and they can say, you know what?

20:52.045 --> 20:54.685
You got this piece wrong when you're talking about

20:55.235 --> 20:57.365
17th century England, right?

20:57.425 --> 21:00.845
And then they can do a, a micro history for that to fill in,

21:00.865 --> 21:01.925
and that would be wonderful.

21:02.425 --> 21:05.525
Um, or they can say there's something else if

21:05.565 --> 21:06.605
you zoom out a little bit more.

21:07.225 --> 21:08.725
So I think there's a lot of room.

21:08.865 --> 21:11.445
I'm not, everyone's welcome to study the pig.

21:11.685 --> 21:13.325
I would love more people to hang out with me.

21:13.425 --> 21:14.725
I'm not gonna hog the spotlight.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Miami University Anne Whitesell

Books

Deviant Matter: Ferment, Intoxicants, Jelly, Rot

University at Buffalo Kyla Wazana Tompkins

Faculti

Popular in Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

Lincoln and the Jews

Post-Kantian perfectionism

Amputations and Convalescence

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

Early Modern Natural Law Theories

Forbidden

Leave a Reply Cancel reply