Popular in Professional

Architecture

Connecting Cities and Nature

University of Virginia Timothy Beatley

Human Rights Law

Human Rights and Corruption: Problems and Potential of Individualising a Systemic Problem

Max Planck Institute Anne Peters

Finance

Chinese Exchange Rate Policy: Lessons for Global Investors

University of California San Diego Michael Melvin

Law

A statistical approach to law school citation rankings

University of Virginia Joshua Fischman

Education

Firm Performance Pay as Insurance against Promotion Risk

Stockholm School of Economics Alvin Chen

Constitutional Law

What is constitutional ideology?

University of Oxford Nick Barber

Teaching Democracy and Capitalism

View more insights in Professional - Business - Corporate Finance - Finance - Management

View more figures from University of Virginia

View the page of Robert Bruner

Read the Study

Next in Business

Mapping “Varieties of Workplace Bullying”

Premilla D’Cruz | Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad

Painting a Clear Picture while Seeing the Big Picture

Andrew M. Carton | University of Pennsylvania

Why should we educate about democracy and capitalism? This essay discusses the intricacies and necessity of teaching these pivotal systems, emphasizing the use of engaging strategies like case studies to enhance understanding and stimulate informed decision-making in real-world contexts.

Image courtesy of interviewee. November 14, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video discusses the importance of teaching democracy and capitalism within the context of the current political climate in the United States, particularly as the country approaches a presidential election. It highlights that many students lack adequate knowledge of these complex systems, often shaped by social media influences, and suggests a need for a student-centered learning approach.

The author advocates for active learning strategies, such as case studies, where students engage with real-world problems and data, allowing them to develop their reasoning and decision-making skills. It emphasizes the necessity of motivating students with relevant issues rather than abstract textbook concepts.

Two types of case studies are described: decision-based, where students take on the role of decision-makers, and analytical cases, where students analyze data to draw conclusions. The teaching method used at the University of Virginia's Darden Business School involves preparing students for interactive discussions based on real data and decision-making contexts.

Finally, the text stresses the need to teach core knowledge about democracy and capitalism, develop analytical and synthesis skills, and foster judgment among students. By effectively engaging students in the learning process, it aims to create a deeper understanding and lasting impact regarding these essential subjects. The author argues that teaching these concepts is critical for students' preparedness in a democratic republic and market economy, as they relate to global welfare and reduce poverty significantly.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video:

1. **Teaching Democracy and Capitalism**: The video emphasizes the importance of teaching democracy and capitalism as vital components of personal agency and functioning within a democratic republic and market economy. It highlights that many students enter learning environments with limited knowledge of these concepts, necessitating effective instruction.

2. **Student-Centered Learning Approach**: The author advocates for a student-centered learning approach, which begins with the students’ existing knowledge and frames discussions around questions and problems they can relate to. This method is designed to engage students actively and meaningfully in learning.

3. **Active Learning Methods**: The video discusses the significance of active learning through case studies, which provide real-world problems for students to analyze and solve. Examples include decision-based and analytical case studies that require students to engage deeply with the material and draw their own conclusions.

4. **Impactful Lessons and Retention**: The author highlights the effectiveness of teaching methods that promote "sticky learning"—knowledge that stays with students long after they complete their studies. This is achieved by immersing students in discussions and challenges that encourage them to think critically and apply what they’ve learned.

5. **Core Knowledge, Skills, and Wisdom**: The teaching agenda includes three critical components: core knowledge of democracy and capitalism, skills for analysis and synthesis, and the development of wisdom. The author argues that wisdom, which involves moral reasoning and judgment, should be cultivated alongside knowledge and skills to prepare students for real-world decision-making.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes extracted from the video that encapsulate important themes and ideas:

1. **Motivation to Teach Democracy and Capitalism**:
- “It's important to teach democracy and capitalism because they're vital personal agency and life in a democratic republic, a market economy.”

2. **Student Engagement**:
- “My motto is, you learn best at which you teach yourself.”
- “The approach begins where the student is. It's called student-centered learning.”

3. **Learning Process**:
- “Often talking, as teachers everywhere know, you really don't know something until you can help to explain it to someone else.”

4. **Case Studies as Teaching Tools**:
- “In my article, I discuss case studies that are loaded with relevant data.”
- “There are actually many kinds, but the two kinds that are readily available to instructors and learners... decision based case studies... analytical cases.”

5. **Importance of Realistic Problem-Solving**:
- “It's very important for the instructor to frame, for the students at hand, and to provide an interesting problem... that would prompt the student to puzzle and wrestle with the problem.”

6. **Impact of Education**:
- “I've had students come to me many years after graduating... to say that the lessons learned... made an indelible impression.”

7. **Relation Between Democracy and Capitalism**:
- “Democracy and capitalism do tend to progress together... one tends to encourage the other.”

8. **Teaching Objectives**:
- “It's important to teach three aspects: core knowledge, skills of analysis, and building wisdom.”

9. **Reflection on Learning and Judgment**:
- “Everyone builds judgment through trial and error. The famous quip of Walter Riston... experience comes from bad judgment.”

These quotes reflect the central concern of the video regarding the significance of teaching democracy and capitalism, the methods and motivations for engaging students effectively, and the broader impact of these educational efforts.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP=LOCAL:00:00:00.000,MPEGTS:90000

1
00:00:00.025 --> 00:00:04.745
Is motivated by this, by the, the context of,

2
00:00:04.875 --> 00:00:06.905
sharp disagreement in the political

3
00:00:06.905 --> 00:00:08.345
environment in the United States.

4
00:00:08.645 --> 00:00:12.745
Uh, as we head into the presidential election next week, it,

5
00:00:12.845 --> 00:00:14.225
it reaches a peak,

6
00:00:14.365 --> 00:00:17.745
but this has been, bubbling away for years

7
00:00:18.605 --> 00:00:22.995
and is unlikely to simmer down anytime soon.

8
00:00:23.145 --> 00:00:26.235
It's important to teach democracy and capitalism

9
00:00:26.625 --> 00:00:30.915
because, they're, they're vital

10
00:00:31.575 --> 00:00:35.195
to the ability of students, to be prepared for

11
00:00:35.795 --> 00:00:39.475
personal agency and, life in

12
00:00:40.115 --> 00:00:42.795
a democratic republic, a a market economy.

13
00:00:43.215 --> 00:00:46.255
And, I find that many students,

14
00:00:46.255 --> 00:00:50.735
particularly undergraduates, don't, come into the

15
00:00:52.425 --> 00:00:55.025
learning experience very well informed about either topic.

16
00:00:55.685 --> 00:00:58.945
The topics are complicated,

17
00:00:59.045 --> 00:01:02.945
and, students tend to bring to those topics, attitudes

18
00:01:03.165 --> 00:01:07.965
and information shaped by social media, by word of mouth,

19
00:01:08.095 --> 00:01:12.245
among other students, and by, perhaps outright,

20
00:01:12.245 --> 00:01:16.285
information we're all aware of, of attempts by,

21
00:01:17.195 --> 00:01:20.775
other parties to influence elections

22
00:01:21.075 --> 00:01:23.975
and drive public opinion in various ways.

23
00:01:24.075 --> 00:01:27.815
So, so I think it's important to help students make meaning

24
00:01:27.875 --> 00:01:29.775
for themselves and the way they make meaning.

25
00:01:29.955 --> 00:01:34.695
Now, responding to your question is, to,

26
00:01:35.075 --> 00:01:36.215
to teach themselves.

27
00:01:36.395 --> 00:01:37.895
Um, my, my motto is,

28
00:01:37.915 --> 00:01:41.015
you learn best at which you teach yourself.

29
00:01:41.075 --> 00:01:45.575
And so that it's very important to serve up to students,

30
00:01:46.055 --> 00:01:50.895
problems and, decision settings in which they must,

31
00:01:51.245 --> 00:01:54.015
resolve the issue in front of them

32
00:01:54.395 --> 00:01:56.295
and be prepared to talk about it.

33
00:01:56.625 --> 00:01:59.055
Often talking as, as,

34
00:01:59.375 --> 00:02:01.735
teachers everywhere know you really don't know something

35
00:02:01.785 --> 00:02:05.255
until you can help to explain it to someone else.

36
00:02:05.715 --> 00:02:08.015
And therefore, a discussion based

37
00:02:08.335 --> 00:02:09.935
approach is vitally important.

38
00:02:10.795 --> 00:02:15.095
Um, our approach begins where the student is.

39
00:02:15.405 --> 00:02:17.535
It's called student-centered learning.

40
00:02:17.835 --> 00:02:20.535
You, you frame a set of questions

41
00:02:20.635 --> 00:02:23.615
and a discussion problem at the level at which

42
00:02:24.535 --> 00:02:25.775
students come into the classroom.

43
00:02:25.805 --> 00:02:28.375
They may be, they may be undergraduates, they may be

44
00:02:29.195 --> 00:02:33.655
PhD candidates, they may be, people,

45
00:02:33.995 --> 00:02:35.215
simply looking

46
00:02:35.435 --> 00:02:38.295
for a little more information in a non-credit,

47
00:02:38.845 --> 00:02:39.865
environment.

48
00:02:40.135 --> 00:02:43.545
It's important to, to serve up to those students

49
00:02:44.605 --> 00:02:49.445
problems and situations that they can grasp within, say,

50
00:02:49.605 --> 00:02:51.805
a 90 minute class session,

51
00:02:52.385 --> 00:02:54.125
having done the reading in advance,

52
00:02:54.945 --> 00:02:58.245
and, discuss the analysis of the problem,

53
00:02:58.795 --> 00:03:02.125
Problem and, possible resolutions.

54
00:03:02.975 --> 00:03:06.915
Um, there, it it's very important, of course,

55
00:03:06.975 --> 00:03:11.795
to motivate students, not with abstract textbook kinds

56
00:03:11.795 --> 00:03:15.355
of problems, but with, real problems sustained by

57
00:03:16.075 --> 00:03:17.355
relevant data for that purpose.

58
00:03:17.815 --> 00:03:22.755
In my article, I discuss case studies that are,

59
00:03:23.585 --> 00:03:25.435
that, that portray real problems

60
00:03:25.495 --> 00:03:27.875
and that are loaded with re relevant data.

61
00:03:28.055 --> 00:03:30.075
To begin a low engagement,

62
00:03:30.675 --> 00:03:32.515
activity would be passive learning,

63
00:03:32.515 --> 00:03:35.595
which would be sitting in a lecture hall, taking notes,

64
00:03:36.185 --> 00:03:39.595
listening to a lecturer,

65
00:03:40.465 --> 00:03:43.235
expound on whatever the topic the day is.

66
00:03:43.855 --> 00:03:47.475
Uh, passive learning tends to result in,

67
00:03:47.605 --> 00:03:51.945
rapid accumulation of knowledge and, rapid loss.

68
00:03:52.525 --> 00:03:56.795
So students, students can memory memorize names, dates,

69
00:03:56.885 --> 00:04:01.195
facts of, of a setting or a problem, and very shortly

70
00:04:01.285 --> 00:04:05.905
after an examination on those, will for yeah, them.

71
00:04:06.285 --> 00:04:09.905
Uh, what's important is to teach students a means

72
00:04:09.965 --> 00:04:14.505
of reasoning through a, a problem reasoning through a,

73
00:04:15.145 --> 00:04:16.985
a, a a kind of analysis.

74
00:04:17.855 --> 00:04:22.035
And for that purpose, we wanna frame,

75
00:04:22.135 --> 00:04:25.275
the problem in realistic terms, in, in terms suitable

76
00:04:25.455 --> 00:04:27.595
for the level of the student, that day,

77
00:04:27.775 --> 00:04:30.595
and ly motivating to the student,

78
00:04:30.825 --> 00:04:32.955
that would prompt the student to puzzle

79
00:04:33.255 --> 00:04:34.515
and wrestle with the problem.

80
00:04:35.425 --> 00:04:38.165
Um, as everyone's grandmother teaches us

81
00:04:38.235 --> 00:04:40.965
that nothing good comes without a struggle of some kind.

82
00:04:41.065 --> 00:04:42.685
So it is in learning,

83
00:04:43.225 --> 00:04:47.365
and it's very important for the instructor to frame,

84
00:04:47.645 --> 00:04:50.125
a learning challenge that's suitable

85
00:04:50.265 --> 00:04:51.405
for the students at hand,

86
00:04:52.265 --> 00:04:56.045
and to provide an, an interesting problem, perhaps,

87
00:04:56.445 --> 00:04:59.365
relevant to the setting that students find them in,

88
00:04:59.915 --> 00:05:01.125
find themselves in there.

89
00:05:01.125 --> 00:05:02.485
And then, in my article,

90
00:05:02.685 --> 00:05:04.245
I described two kinds of case studies.

91
00:05:04.255 --> 00:05:05.645
There are actually many kinds,

92
00:05:05.745 --> 00:05:10.245
but the, the two kinds that are readily available to

93
00:05:10.835 --> 00:05:15.245
instructors and, learners of all kinds would be,

94
00:05:15.485 --> 00:05:20.445
decision based case studies that, serve up

95
00:05:21.475 --> 00:05:25.835
a great deal of data on a, a problem setting,

96
00:05:26.375 --> 00:05:30.755
and frame a, a decision for the students,

97
00:05:31.265 --> 00:05:33.955
putting the students in the shoes of a decision maker

98
00:05:34.575 --> 00:05:35.875
and asking the student

99
00:05:35.975 --> 00:05:38.435
to bring forward a recommendation, make a choice.

100
00:05:38.575 --> 00:05:43.035
An example would be, a case study set on,

101
00:05:43.415 --> 00:05:47.195
in, in the 1870s with,

102
00:05:47.655 --> 00:05:51.615
the consequence of the Civil War, which had, in which the,

103
00:05:51.795 --> 00:05:55.735
the government of the north, the, the, the union government,

104
00:05:55.835 --> 00:05:59.245
so to speak, had issued, greenbacks.

105
00:05:59.415 --> 00:06:03.645
These were IOUs by the federal government promising

106
00:06:03.665 --> 00:06:06.565
to pay the holder in gold at some date in the future.

107
00:06:07.455 --> 00:06:10.835
Uh, the date, left open and unspecified,

108
00:06:10.855 --> 00:06:13.715
and the greenbacks often traded at a

109
00:06:13.715 --> 00:06:15.595
serious discount to gold.

110
00:06:17.035 --> 00:06:19.495
And the question, that was brought up

111
00:06:19.515 --> 00:06:23.395
to the highest court in the United States, is this,

112
00:06:23.695 --> 00:06:27.455
is this legal should, should not the government,

113
00:06:27.645 --> 00:06:31.935
immediately settle all of its debts in gold, as opposed

114
00:06:31.935 --> 00:06:35.885
to allow these certificates of, promise

115
00:06:36.585 --> 00:06:39.525
to pay, to circulate in the economy.

116
00:06:40.925 --> 00:06:43.375
This is the beginning, of course, of the green

117
00:06:43.965 --> 00:06:46.855
colored currency that has been enforced in the

118
00:06:46.855 --> 00:06:48.095
United States ever since.

119
00:06:48.195 --> 00:06:52.985
But at, at the day, it's quite a controversial problem,

120
00:06:54.015 --> 00:06:57.525
is, is fiat money, money

121
00:06:58.065 --> 00:06:59.085
is the deep question.

122
00:06:59.785 --> 00:07:03.925
And students come to that case needing to decide

123
00:07:04.555 --> 00:07:08.245
what the Supreme Court of the United States should decide.

124
00:07:08.905 --> 00:07:11.365
And it's a, it's a very stimulating problem.

125
00:07:12.305 --> 00:07:16.925
It is a problem framed by the extreme urgency

126
00:07:16.925 --> 00:07:19.685
of the crisis, of the Civil War, the,

127
00:07:20.065 --> 00:07:23.205
the very deep indebtedness of the,

128
00:07:23.975 --> 00:07:26.715
of the federal government, of the country,

129
00:07:27.015 --> 00:07:30.585
and the likelihood that it would take years to

130
00:07:31.105 --> 00:07:34.625
repay the debt and to, to emerge back to a,

131
00:07:34.865 --> 00:07:36.905
a gold standard in the United States.

132
00:07:37.165 --> 00:07:38.785
So that's a decision based case.

133
00:07:39.315 --> 00:07:43.225
There are, analytical cases where the, the challenge

134
00:07:43.285 --> 00:07:47.595
of the student is to, to, to take a sample of data

135
00:07:48.135 --> 00:07:52.595
and, describe, whether,

136
00:07:53.735 --> 00:07:57.755
the, the observations in the data, conform, let us say

137
00:07:58.795 --> 00:08:02.415
to the model of a, democracy or an autocracy

138
00:08:03.035 --> 00:08:05.695
or conform to the model of a market-based

139
00:08:06.585 --> 00:08:09.065
IE capitalist economy, as opposed

140
00:08:09.445 --> 00:08:11.905
to a centrally planned economy.

141
00:08:13.255 --> 00:08:17.635
So students, are not simply told what are

142
00:08:18.625 --> 00:08:22.435
democracies and autocracies, capitalist systems

143
00:08:22.735 --> 00:08:25.425
and, centrally planned systems.

144
00:08:25.535 --> 00:08:27.585
They, they have to get into the data

145
00:08:27.885 --> 00:08:30.455
and, decide for themselves.

146
00:08:30.555 --> 00:08:35.055
And in so doing, it creates a very deep impression,

147
00:08:35.475 --> 00:08:38.095
that, that actually, sticks.

148
00:08:38.375 --> 00:08:40.855
I call it, as I said, sticky learning.

149
00:08:41.155 --> 00:08:44.815
So all of my career, I've, I've, been an instructor

150
00:08:45.525 --> 00:08:48.455
here at the University of Virginia's Darden Business School,

151
00:08:48.585 --> 00:08:50.655
where we teach by the ACE method.

152
00:08:51.235 --> 00:08:55.565
And students, are certainly encouraged to consult,

153
00:08:55.965 --> 00:08:58.285
textbooks and online sources of information.

154
00:08:59.085 --> 00:09:02.625
But every day, students are asked to come to class prepared

155
00:09:02.625 --> 00:09:06.445
to discuss three decision settings

156
00:09:06.465 --> 00:09:10.365
or analytical challenges in, in open discussion.

157
00:09:10.365 --> 00:09:12.405
And it's, it's quite impactful.

158
00:09:12.715 --> 00:09:15.165
I've had students come to me many, many years

159
00:09:16.015 --> 00:09:20.005
after graduating from our program to say that,

160
00:09:20.465 --> 00:09:23.645
the lessons learned in the program,

161
00:09:24.235 --> 00:09:25.845
made an indelible impression.

162
00:09:25.915 --> 00:09:30.885
They range from, market systems

163
00:09:31.425 --> 00:09:36.065
in, in which, governments place great faith in,

164
00:09:36.285 --> 00:09:39.585
in markets to, to do what needs to be done, to set prices.

165
00:09:40.175 --> 00:09:41.985
They, they intervene rather less.

166
00:09:42.135 --> 00:09:45.345
They, they have a rather lighter regulatory touch.

167
00:09:46.045 --> 00:09:49.385
And, and, systems such as those

168
00:09:49.415 --> 00:09:54.215
that exist in the United States, the uk, Australia,

169
00:09:54.355 --> 00:09:58.175
New Zealand, Canada, the Anglo,

170
00:09:58.895 --> 00:10:02.215
American system as it's sometimes called would, would be

171
00:10:03.005 --> 00:10:07.655
exemplars at that extreme, at, at a midpoint.

172
00:10:07.915 --> 00:10:11.535
You might have, systems such as

173
00:10:12.305 --> 00:10:17.255
exist on the continent, Germany, France, Japan,

174
00:10:17.635 --> 00:10:19.175
and then you have systems

175
00:10:19.285 --> 00:10:22.095
that are much more centrally ordered.

176
00:10:22.205 --> 00:10:26.455
Certainly China's and Vietnams would be examples of those.

177
00:10:26.915 --> 00:10:30.695
Uh, and at the very, very far extreme,

178
00:10:31.455 --> 00:10:35.415
Venezuela, North Korea, Cuba,

179
00:10:36.305 --> 00:10:40.675
where the government sets prices, rations,

180
00:10:41.245 --> 00:10:42.675
goods and services, et cetera.

181
00:10:43.495 --> 00:10:47.875
Uh, so we have exercises that students

182
00:10:48.895 --> 00:10:53.635
to categorize countries, they, they're not named

183
00:10:53.815 --> 00:10:58.585
so that any student with foreknowledge doesn't immediately

184
00:10:59.235 --> 00:11:00.425
categorize the student.

185
00:11:00.565 --> 00:11:04.875
But, on the basis of the data, please,

186
00:11:05.065 --> 00:11:08.915
tell us in which category these countries might belong.

187
00:11:09.225 --> 00:11:13.635
It's a very stimulating exercise, especially, by the end

188
00:11:13.635 --> 00:11:17.995
of the class session when, the great reveal occurs

189
00:11:18.215 --> 00:11:21.915
and students are shown the, the identities of the countries.

190
00:11:22.065 --> 00:11:26.195
That would be an example of an analytic, case problem.

191
00:11:27.165 --> 00:11:30.705
And, and the decision based case problems are,

192
00:11:31.325 --> 00:11:32.505
legion.

193
00:11:32.725 --> 00:11:37.035
Uh, the Darden Business School, publishes these cases,

194
00:11:37.085 --> 00:11:38.795
makes 'em available publicly.

195
00:11:38.795 --> 00:11:42.315
Harvard Business School does, university of Western Ontario

196
00:11:42.415 --> 00:11:47.035
and others teaching democracy and capitalism is hard.

197
00:11:47.875 --> 00:11:51.135
Uh, both systems are quite complicated

198
00:11:51.845 --> 00:11:53.805
when you get into them in any detail.

199
00:11:54.505 --> 00:11:57.925
Uh, as I said, students bring little familiarity generally,

200
00:11:58.225 --> 00:12:00.605
and, and there is a great deal

201
00:12:00.605 --> 00:12:03.485
of misinformation out there to be overcome.

202
00:12:04.265 --> 00:12:08.795
Um, yet the systems, both systems are

203
00:12:09.335 --> 00:12:13.515
highly material to the life experience of students,

204
00:12:13.895 --> 00:12:15.475
not only in developed economies,

205
00:12:15.495 --> 00:12:17.155
but in developing economies.

206
00:12:17.915 --> 00:12:22.055
Um, more than 60% of the world's,

207
00:12:22.055 --> 00:12:26.745
gross domestic product is accounted for by,

208
00:12:27.425 --> 00:12:28.985
countries with market economies.

209
00:12:30.005 --> 00:12:32.545
You cannot avoid,

210
00:12:33.025 --> 00:12:36.745
engaging capitalist economies in some way, shape

211
00:12:36.745 --> 00:12:38.545
or form, even if you live in a,

212
00:12:39.165 --> 00:12:41.525
a highly centrally planned economy, where

213
00:12:42.145 --> 00:12:45.275
generally speaking, authorities do allow market exchange,

214
00:12:45.415 --> 00:12:48.675
but in gray market and black market fashion.

215
00:12:49.415 --> 00:12:53.635
So, citizens all over the world will deal with

216
00:12:54.255 --> 00:12:56.755
the, the experience of voluntary

217
00:12:56.815 --> 00:13:00.275
and indeed some, sometimes involuntary market exchange.

218
00:13:01.225 --> 00:13:04.485
Um, it's certainly important to teach democracy

219
00:13:04.665 --> 00:13:06.245
and capitalism,

220
00:13:06.245 --> 00:13:09.085
because of, their association with

221
00:13:09.885 --> 00:13:12.045
dramatic growth in human welfare.

222
00:13:12.785 --> 00:13:15.805
The standard statistic afforded by the World Bank is

223
00:13:15.835 --> 00:13:18.805
that in 1991,

224
00:13:19.465 --> 00:13:21.645
2 billion people lived in extreme poverty.

225
00:13:22.495 --> 00:13:27.005
Uh, by, 2019,

226
00:13:27.515 --> 00:13:32.045
that number had fallen to 698 million,

227
00:13:32.395 --> 00:13:36.645
despite a dramatic growth in world population over those,

228
00:13:37.385 --> 00:13:38.685
30 years.

229
00:13:39.685 --> 00:13:42.425
Uh, and largely that

230
00:13:43.015 --> 00:13:46.945
decline in extreme poverty is due to the growth

231
00:13:46.945 --> 00:13:51.025
of international trade, transfer of technology,

232
00:13:51.055 --> 00:13:55.465
capital investment across borders, the relaxation of,

233
00:13:55.605 --> 00:13:59.345
government regulations and central planning and,

234
00:13:59.485 --> 00:14:01.585
and, force, terms of exchange.

235
00:14:02.285 --> 00:14:05.665
So it's due to the spread of capitalist systems.

236
00:14:05.865 --> 00:14:09.145
I would argue as well, that it's due to the liberalization

237
00:14:09.405 --> 00:14:11.265
of governments around the world.

238
00:14:11.325 --> 00:14:12.425
The growth of democracy.

239
00:14:13.385 --> 00:14:17.075
Democracy and capitalism do tend to progress together,

240
00:14:17.375 --> 00:14:19.195
not evenly, not in lockstep,

241
00:14:19.415 --> 00:14:23.475
but one tends to encourage the,

242
00:14:23.815 --> 00:14:25.355
the expansion of the other.

243
00:14:26.025 --> 00:14:27.795
Certainly, there are arguments

244
00:14:27.905 --> 00:14:32.315
that the two systems carry great moral legitimacy.

245
00:14:33.025 --> 00:14:36.715
This, can foster a very stimulating debate,

246
00:14:36.715 --> 00:14:38.995
sometimes passionate debate among students.

247
00:14:39.735 --> 00:14:44.475
But, it's important for students to understand the,

248
00:14:44.575 --> 00:14:46.995
the foundations of those arguments

249
00:14:47.055 --> 00:14:49.355
and what the extent to which they may apply

250
00:14:49.975 --> 00:14:52.105
in their own lives and in their own countries.

251
00:14:52.175 --> 00:14:54.945
It's very important to, to teach three aspects

252
00:14:54.965 --> 00:14:56.585
of democracy and capitalism.

253
00:14:56.645 --> 00:14:58.585
The first is core knowledge.

254
00:14:59.205 --> 00:15:01.625
Uh, and, and of course, this would be on the agenda

255
00:15:01.685 --> 00:15:03.065
of virtually any instructor,

256
00:15:04.045 --> 00:15:06.905
but it's, knowledge about the origins of the systems,

257
00:15:07.445 --> 00:15:12.305
how they work, the dimensions of the, the systems

258
00:15:12.835 --> 00:15:16.305
today, the different forms the systems could take.

259
00:15:17.045 --> 00:15:21.895
Um, the second dimension would be skills, skills

260
00:15:22.115 --> 00:15:25.095
of analysis, skills of synthesis,

261
00:15:25.875 --> 00:15:30.265
and, skills of, of, of,

262
00:15:30.735 --> 00:15:31.985
distinction, if you will.

263
00:15:32.285 --> 00:15:34.585
Uh, being able

264
00:15:34.585 --> 00:15:37.895
to identify varying forms and the like.

265
00:15:38.515 --> 00:15:43.375
Uh, skills can be advanced by, problems

266
00:15:43.515 --> 00:15:45.695
and exercises, either highly structured

267
00:15:45.715 --> 00:15:47.415
or rather unstructured.

268
00:15:47.515 --> 00:15:52.415
But, going from knowledge to skills, knowledge building

269
00:15:52.515 --> 00:15:54.055
to skill building is a big leap.

270
00:15:55.015 --> 00:15:59.445
And even bigger leap addresses the third attribute,

271
00:16:00.025 --> 00:16:04.605
and that is, building judgment, building a sense of,

272
00:16:05.495 --> 00:16:07.805
priorities in the mind of the student.

273
00:16:08.465 --> 00:16:11.005
And, we might call this building wisdom.

274
00:16:11.625 --> 00:16:14.565
Uh, many instructors, shy away from this.

275
00:16:14.635 --> 00:16:17.285
They, they feel that, building knowledge,

276
00:16:17.525 --> 00:16:19.165
building skills are quite sufficient.

277
00:16:19.305 --> 00:16:22.515
Uh, you know, everyone builds judgment

278
00:16:22.515 --> 00:16:23.795
through trial and error.

279
00:16:23.895 --> 00:16:27.475
The, the, the famous, quip of, Walter Riston,

280
00:16:27.475 --> 00:16:30.875
the former CEO of Citigroup, was,

281
00:16:32.275 --> 00:16:35.055
good judgment comes from experience,

282
00:16:35.895 --> 00:16:38.515
and experience comes from bad judgment.

283
00:16:39.255 --> 00:16:41.195
So if you, if you, if you try

284
00:16:41.295 --> 00:16:44.075
and fail, you learn, you try again,

285
00:16:44.095 --> 00:16:45.635
you get a little better, you try again.

286
00:16:45.695 --> 00:16:47.475
But you can, you can frame

287
00:16:47.475 --> 00:16:49.955
that much more effectively in a classroom setting,

288
00:16:49.955 --> 00:16:54.195
making it safe for students to justify

289
00:16:54.845 --> 00:16:57.195
their recommendations on moral grounds

290
00:16:57.335 --> 00:16:59.715
and hear the potential objections

291
00:16:59.815 --> 00:17:01.435
of other students in class.

292
00:17:02.385 --> 00:17:04.925
And, and potentially revise

293
00:17:05.455 --> 00:17:10.285
their recommendations based on, moral,

294
00:17:10.515 --> 00:17:15.425
outrage or moral, support, but knowledge, skills,

295
00:17:15.765 --> 00:17:19.665
and judgment amount to the know what, know

296
00:17:19.805 --> 00:17:21.745
how, and know why.

297
00:17:22.165 --> 00:17:26.005
And that constitutes deep learning.

Teaching Democracy and Capitalism in a Divided Political Climate

00:00:00 - Is motivated by this, by the, the context of, sharp disagreement in the political environment in the United States. as we head into the presidential election next week, it, it reaches a peak, but this has been, bubbling away for years and is unlikely to simmer down anytime soon. It's important to teach democracy and capitalism because, they're, they're vital

00:00:35 - personal agency and, life in a democratic republic, a a market economy. And, I find that many students, particularly undergraduates, don't, come into the learning experience very well informed about either topic. The topics are complicated, and, students tend to bring to those topics, attitudes

00:01:08 - among other students, and by, perhaps outright, information we're all aware of, of attempts by, other parties to influence elections and drive public opinion in various ways. So, so I think it's important to help students make meaning for themselves and the way they make meaning. Now, responding to your question is, to,

Empowering Learning through Problem-Solving

00:01:36 - my, my motto is, you learn best at which you teach yourself. And so that it's very important to serve up to students, problems and, decision settings in which they must, resolve the issue in front of them and be prepared to talk about it. Often talking as, as, teachers everywhere know you really don't know something until you can help to explain it to someone else.

00:02:08 - approach is vitally important. our approach begins where the student is. It's called student-centered learning. You, you frame a set of questions and a discussion problem at the level at which students come into the classroom. They may be, they may be undergraduates, they may be PhD candidates, they may be, people, simply looking for a little more information in a non-credit,

00:02:40 - It's important to, to serve up to those students problems and situations that they can grasp within, say, a 90 minute class session, having done the reading in advance, and, discuss the analysis of the problem, Problem and, possible resolutions. there, it it's very important, of course, to motivate students, not with abstract textbook kinds

Engaging Students Through Real-World Case Studies

00:03:16 - relevant data for that purpose. In my article, I discuss case studies that are, that, that portray real problems and that are loaded with re relevant data. To begin a low engagement, activity would be passive learning, which would be sitting in a lecture hall, taking notes, listening to a lecturer, expound on whatever the topic the day is.

00:03:47 - rapid accumulation of knowledge and, rapid loss. So students, students can memory memorize names, dates, facts of, of a setting or a problem, and very shortly after an examination on those, will for yeah, them. what's important is to teach students a means of reasoning through a, a problem reasoning through a,

00:04:17 - And for that purpose, we wanna frame, the problem in realistic terms, in, in terms suitable for the level of the student, that day, and ly motivating to the student, that would prompt the student to puzzle and wrestle with the problem. as everyone's grandmother teaches us that nothing good comes without a struggle of some kind. So it is in learning, and it's very important for the instructor to frame,

Engaging Students with Decision-Based Case Studies

00:04:50 - for the students at hand, and to provide an, an interesting problem, perhaps, relevant to the setting that students find them in, find themselves in there. And then, in my article, I described two kinds of case studies. There are actually many kinds, but the, the two kinds that are readily available to instructors and, learners of all kinds would be, decision based case studies that, serve up

00:05:26 - and frame a, a decision for the students, putting the students in the shoes of a decision maker and asking the student to bring forward a recommendation, make a choice. An example would be, a case study set on, in, in the 1870s with, the consequence of the Civil War, which had, in which the,

00:05:55 - so to speak, had issued, greenbacks. These were IOUs by the federal government promising to pay the holder in gold at some date in the future. the date, left open and unspecified, and the greenbacks often traded at a serious discount to gold. And the question, that was brought up to the highest court in the United States, is this,

Debating Currency: The Gold Standard and Supreme Court Decision-Making

00:06:27 - immediately settle all of its debts in gold, as opposed to allow these certificates of, promise to pay, to circulate in the economy. This is the beginning, of course, of the green colored currency that has been enforced in the United States ever since. But at, at the day, it's quite a controversial problem,

00:06:58 - is the deep question. And students come to that case needing to decide what the Supreme Court of the United States should decide. And it's a, it's a very stimulating problem. It is a problem framed by the extreme urgency of the crisis, of the Civil War, the, the very deep indebtedness of the, of the federal government, of the country,

00:07:31 - repay the debt and to, to emerge back to a, a gold standard in the United States. So that's a decision based case. There are, analytical cases where the, the challenge of the student is to, to, to take a sample of data and, describe, whether, the, the observations in the data, conform, let us say

Engaging Students in Capitalism and Democracy: The Power of Sticky Learning

00:08:03 - or conform to the model of a market-based IE capitalist economy, as opposed to a centrally planned economy. So students, are not simply told what are democracies and autocracies, capitalist systems and, centrally planned systems. They, they have to get into the data and, decide for themselves.

00:08:35 - that, that actually, sticks. I call it, as I said, sticky learning. So all of my career, I've, I've, been an instructor here at the University of Virginia's Darden Business School, where we teach by the ACE method. And students, are certainly encouraged to consult, textbooks and online sources of information. But every day, students are asked to come to class prepared

00:09:06 - or analytical challenges in, in open discussion. And it's, it's quite impactful. I've had students come to me many, many years after graduating from our program to say that, the lessons learned in the program, made an indelible impression. They range from, market systems in, in which, governments place great faith in,

Regulatory Approaches Across Political Economies

00:09:40 - They, they intervene rather less. They, they have a rather lighter regulatory touch. And, and, systems such as those that exist in the United States, the uk, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the Anglo, American system as it's sometimes called would, would be exemplars at that extreme, at, at a midpoint.

00:10:12 - exist on the continent, Germany, France, Japan, and then you have systems that are much more centrally ordered. Certainly China's and Vietnams would be examples of those. and at the very, very far extreme, Venezuela, North Korea, Cuba, where the government sets prices, rations,

00:10:43 - so we have exercises that students to categorize countries, they, they're not named so that any student with foreknowledge doesn't immediately categorize the student. But, on the basis of the data, please, tell us in which category these countries might belong. It's a very stimulating exercise, especially, by the end

Teaching Democracy and Capitalism: Challenges and Case Studies

00:11:18 - and students are shown the, the identities of the countries. That would be an example of an analytic, case problem. And, and the decision based case problems are, legion. the Darden Business School, publishes these cases, makes 'em available publicly. Harvard Business School does, university of Western Ontario and others teaching democracy and capitalism is hard.

00:11:51 - when you get into them in any detail. as I said, students bring little familiarity generally, and, and there is a great deal of misinformation out there to be overcome. yet the systems, both systems are highly material to the life experience of students, not only in developed economies, but in developing economies.

00:12:22 - gross domestic product is accounted for by, countries with market economies. You cannot avoid, engaging capitalist economies in some way, shape or form, even if you live in a, a highly centrally planned economy, where generally speaking, authorities do allow market exchange, but in gray market and black market fashion.

Teaching Democracy and Capitalism: Impacts on Human Welfare

00:12:54 - the, the experience of voluntary and indeed some, sometimes involuntary market exchange. it's certainly important to teach democracy and capitalism, because of, their association with dramatic growth in human welfare. The standard statistic afforded by the World Bank is that in 1991,

00:13:22 - by, 2019, that number had fallen to 698 million, despite a dramatic growth in world population over those, 30 years. and largely that decline in extreme poverty is due to the growth of international trade, transfer of technology,

00:13:55 - government regulations and central planning and, and, force, terms of exchange. So it's due to the spread of capitalist systems. I would argue as well, that it's due to the liberalization of governments around the world. The growth of democracy. Democracy and capitalism do tend to progress together, not evenly, not in lockstep, but one tends to encourage the,

Teaching Democracy and Capitalism: Knowledge, Skills, and Moral Legitimacy

00:14:26 - Certainly, there are arguments that the two systems carry great moral legitimacy. This, can foster a very stimulating debate, sometimes passionate debate among students. But, it's important for students to understand the, the foundations of those arguments and what the extent to which they may apply in their own lives and in their own countries. It's very important to, to teach three aspects

00:14:56 - The first is core knowledge. and, and of course, this would be on the agenda of virtually any instructor, but it's, knowledge about the origins of the systems, how they work, the dimensions of the, the systems today, the different forms the systems could take. the second dimension would be skills, skills of analysis, skills of synthesis,

00:15:30 - distinction, if you will. being able to identify varying forms and the like. skills can be advanced by, problems and exercises, either highly structured or rather unstructured. But, going from knowledge to skills, knowledge building to skill building is a big leap. And even bigger leap addresses the third attribute,

Fostering Wisdom in Student Learning

00:16:05 - priorities in the mind of the student. And, we might call this building wisdom. many instructors, shy away from this. They, they feel that, building knowledge, building skills are quite sufficient. you know, everyone builds judgment through trial and error. The, the, the famous, quip of, Walter Riston, the former CEO of Citigroup, was,

00:16:35 - and experience comes from bad judgment. So if you, if you, if you try and fail, you learn, you try again, you get a little better, you try again. But you can, you can frame that much more effectively in a classroom setting, making it safe for students to justify their recommendations on moral grounds and hear the potential objections of other students in class.

00:17:22 - their recommendations based on, moral, outrage or moral, support, but knowledge, skills, and judgment amount to the know what, know how, and know why. And that constitutes deep learning.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis