Defining “Patient-Centered Medicine”

Key Question Being Explored in This Insight:

What is the proper relation between a scientific understanding of disease and the subjective phenomenon of being sick? Charles L. Bardes, M.D. discusses “Patient-centered medicine” concept.

View the page of: Charles L. Bardes

Institution: Cornell University

Explore more insights in:

Medicine Professional Public Health

Media Literacy Toolkit

Faculti's Media Literacy Toolkit helps viewers critically engage with academic insights by analyzing the research context, identifying perspectives, and encouraging thoughtful evaluation.

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

What assumptions does the research make?
Are there alternative perspectives not explored?
What are the limitations of the research method?

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

This research comes from Cornell University . Reflect on how the institution's academic focus and research partnerships may shape the questions being explored.

Further Reading ▼

Read the Study

What is the proper relation between a scientific understanding of disease and the subjective phenomenon of being sick? Charles L. Bardes, M.D. discusses “Patient-centered medicine” concept.

Image courtesy of interviewee. February 20, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the concept of patient-centered medicine, which emphasizes prioritizing the needs and concerns of patients over a disease-centered or doctor-centered approach. Originating in the 1960s, this approach critiques traditional medical practices that may treat patients as mere components of a disease management system. The speaker outlines the historical duality in medicine: the delivery of medical technologies and the care of individuals' subjective experiences of illness.

This video video critiques the current healthcare purchasing model in the U.S., which complicates consumer choice due to various filters like doctors and insurers, potentially obscuring costs. It also highlights that healthcare decisions can be driven by intense emotions, especially when the stakes are high, such as with a sick child.

While advocating for greater attention to patients' experiences, the speaker suggests that neither patients nor doctors can be viewed as the sole center of care. Instead, a more interconnected model is proposed, likening the relationship to a binary star system or the double helix structure of DNA, emphasizing the mutual dependence of patients and healthcare providers. This video video concludes by referencing the caduceus symbol, traditionally depicting two serpents, to illustrate the interwoven relationships in healthcare.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.000 --> 00:02.125
Well, patient centered medicine is an idea

00:02.875 --> 00:06.205
that we should redirect our foremost attention towards the

00:06.205 --> 00:07.685
needs and concerns of the patient.

00:08.625 --> 00:11.685
The term first appeared in the 1960s in the field

00:11.685 --> 00:14.925
of psychiatry and rapidly gained traction throughout

00:15.165 --> 00:18.685
medicine society, and it basically implies a contrast

00:18.835 --> 00:20.805
with whatever is not patient centered,

00:20.945 --> 00:23.045
and that could be conceived as disease centered

00:23.105 --> 00:24.685
or doctor centered, but

00:24.685 --> 00:25.965
something different from the patient.

00:26.145 --> 00:28.965
As the center. Throughout its long history,

00:29.325 --> 00:31.125
medicine has always invoked two principles,

00:31.185 --> 00:33.325
and one is the delivery of certain technologies,

00:34.085 --> 00:35.845
whatever the technology of the day may be.

00:36.905 --> 00:39.845
Uh, but the other is something more like the care of souls.

00:40.345 --> 00:41.885
And the first, the delivery

00:41.905 --> 00:44.605
of technologies focuses on the mechanics

00:44.985 --> 00:46.445
of disordered physiology.

00:47.185 --> 00:48.405
But the second,

00:48.595 --> 00:51.645
more on the subjective experience of being ill.

00:52.485 --> 00:54.065
So the idea here is that

00:54.065 --> 00:56.105
by focusing attention on the patient,

00:56.605 --> 00:59.345
patient-centered medicine, both implicitly

00:59.405 --> 01:02.465
and explicitly, critiques a version of medicine

01:02.465 --> 01:05.065
that focuses on the disease rather than on

01:05.205 --> 01:06.425
the person with the disease.

01:07.405 --> 01:11.445
So that, in a system

01:11.445 --> 01:12.685
that is not patient-centered,

01:13.385 --> 01:16.085
the patient can sometimes feel like a cog in a

01:16.085 --> 01:17.285
disease treating machine.

01:17.585 --> 01:19.205
And in this sense, it parallels

01:19.225 --> 01:21.885
to some degree 19th century awareness of

01:21.885 --> 01:25.765
how the industrial assembly line can transform a person into

01:25.805 --> 01:29.085
a thing, which is a concept that the Germans call fingal,

01:29.745 --> 01:32.285
or for that matter, a 21st century,

01:32.285 --> 01:34.805
worker pushing pixels on a computer screen,

01:35.355 --> 01:37.045
less human, more mechanistic.

01:38.095 --> 01:40.755
And by the way, doctors can feel this way too sometimes,

01:40.755 --> 01:41.955
just as if they were servants

01:41.955 --> 01:43.475
to the electronic medical record.

01:43.815 --> 01:46.955
Now, in a consumer society, individuals consider

01:46.955 --> 01:48.715
what they want and they choose to purchase it

01:49.095 --> 01:50.915
or not based on its cost

01:50.915 --> 01:53.395
and how it compares with their other priorities.

01:53.975 --> 01:56.595
But healthcare, purchasing strains this model in important

01:56.665 --> 01:58.795
ways, especially in the, in the United States.

01:59.495 --> 02:01.555
Uh, there are filters between the patients

02:01.655 --> 02:03.595
and their ability to obtain what they want.

02:03.935 --> 02:07.955
Uh, the filter could be a doctor or an insurer,

02:07.955 --> 02:08.955
or the NHS.

02:09.935 --> 02:12.315
Uh, the cost is often invisible both

02:12.335 --> 02:13.755
to the patients and to the doctors.

02:15.115 --> 02:17.755
A third point is that consumers often think about costs

02:17.935 --> 02:19.515
to themselves as individuals,

02:19.575 --> 02:22.915
but healthcare often involves cost to society as a whole.

02:23.335 --> 02:25.515
Now, this is not unique to medical purchasing,

02:25.515 --> 02:27.515
and I imagine that the Britains,

02:27.515 --> 02:28.995
do this better than the Americans.

02:29.975 --> 02:33.115
But, if you're thinking only about the cost to yourself,

02:33.115 --> 02:35.915
you're unaware of the cost to society as a whole.

02:37.445 --> 02:40.545
And consumer desire, is often driven

02:40.645 --> 02:42.545
by advertising, by buzz, by hearsay.

02:42.805 --> 02:44.585
Now, this is also not unique to medicine, of course,

02:44.885 --> 02:48.305
but healthcare decisions can be, extremely emotional,

02:48.765 --> 02:50.185
often uniquely so,

02:50.565 --> 02:53.745
and I realize that other purchases can be, emotional,

02:54.205 --> 02:56.465
but to the parent of a sick child, the benefit

02:56.525 --> 02:58.665
of a cure is nearly infinite,

02:59.065 --> 03:01.645
Or even the prospect of a cure is nearly infinite.

03:01.905 --> 03:04.165
But the cost often becomes an abstraction.

03:04.505 --> 03:07.645
So what is the meaning, in US dollars of a cure

03:07.645 --> 03:10.805
that costs a hundred thousand dollars or a million dollars

03:11.065 --> 03:13.485
or $10 million, or a hundred million dollars?

03:13.865 --> 03:18.285
And these become just abstract numbers, that,

03:18.465 --> 03:19.685
are very hard to conceive.

03:19.875 --> 03:22.645
Well, when you think about, the metaphor of the patient

03:22.825 --> 03:25.965
as a center, you think about other analogies,

03:26.025 --> 03:27.685
of centeredness, for example.

03:28.265 --> 03:32.165
Uh, do we live in a tmeic universe where the

03:33.455 --> 03:34.995
sun rotates around the earth

03:35.175 --> 03:36.715
or a Copernican universe

03:36.715 --> 03:38.315
where the earth rotates around the sun?

03:38.895 --> 03:41.845
Uh, those are the sorts of things

03:41.845 --> 03:43.645
that we think about in terms of a center.

03:45.845 --> 03:50.265
Uh, but the flaw in the idea of the patient of center,

03:50.445 --> 03:52.305
by the way, I mean, I, I do advocate the idea

03:52.305 --> 03:53.785
that the patient,

03:53.785 --> 03:56.225
that more attention should be directed towards the

03:56.225 --> 03:59.705
subjective experiences of the patient,

04:00.325 --> 04:02.785
and their, and what they're experiencing.

04:04.005 --> 04:06.665
But, they're not entirely the center

04:06.975 --> 04:08.545
because neither the doctor

04:08.765 --> 04:11.385
nor the patient can be the unique center.

04:11.885 --> 04:14.705
Uh, they have to co-exist in a therapeutic and social

04:15.005 --> 04:19.025
and economic relationship, that is highly interwoven.

04:21.035 --> 04:23.255
So when we think about, metaphors,

04:23.275 --> 04:25.655
we might think instead about a binary star system

04:25.655 --> 04:28.495
where the two stars orbit around each other,

04:29.035 --> 04:32.255
or the double helix of DNA in which the two strands

04:32.795 --> 04:33.855
and circle each other.

04:34.715 --> 04:37.455
Or if you go back to ancient medicine to the caduceus,

04:37.455 --> 04:40.815
and I realize that the most ancient caduceus is a single

04:41.255 --> 04:44.335
serpent wrapped around a staff, but there's a later image,

04:44.335 --> 04:45.815
and this is the one you see more often

04:45.875 --> 04:48.375
of two serpents wrapped around a staff,

04:48.835 --> 04:49.855
and they intertwine forever.

Understanding Patient-Centered Medicine

00:00:00 - Well, patient centered medicine is an idea that we should redirect our foremost attention towards the needs and concerns of the patient. The term first appeared in the 1960s in the field of psychiatry and rapidly gained traction throughout medicine society, and it basically implies a contrast with whatever is not patient centered, and that could be conceived as disease centered or doctor centered, but something different from the patient. As the center. Throughout its long history, medicine has always invoked two principles, and one is the delivery of certain technologies,
00:00:36 - but the other is something more like the care of souls. And the first, the delivery of technologies focuses on the mechanics of disordered physiology. But the second, more on the subjective experience of being ill. So the idea here is that by focusing attention on the patient, patient-centered medicine, both implicitly and explicitly, critiques a version of medicine that focuses on the disease rather than on
00:01:07 - So that, in a system that is not patient-centered, the patient can sometimes feel like a cog in a disease treating machine. And in this sense, it parallels to some degree 19th century awareness of how the industrial assembly line can transform a person into a thing, which is a concept that the Germans call fingal, or for that matter, a 21st century, worker pushing pixels on a computer screen,
00:01:38 - And by the way, doctors can feel this way too sometimes, just as if they were servants to the electronic medical record. Now, in a consumer society, individuals consider what they want and they choose to purchase it or not based on its cost and how it compares with their other priorities. But healthcare, purchasing strains this model in important ways, especially in the, in the United States. there are filters between the patients and their ability to obtain what they want. the filter could be a doctor or an insurer,
00:02:09 - the cost is often invisible both to the patients and to the doctors. A third point is that consumers often think about costs to themselves as individuals, but healthcare often involves cost to society as a whole. Now, this is not unique to medical purchasing, and I imagine that the Britains, do this better than the Americans. But, if you're thinking only about the cost to yourself, you're unaware of the cost to society as a whole. And consumer desire, is often driven
00:02:42 - Now, this is also not unique to medicine, of course, but healthcare decisions can be, extremely emotional, often uniquely so, and I realize that other purchases can be, emotional, but to the parent of a sick child, the benefit of a cure is nearly infinite, Or even the prospect of a cure is nearly infinite. But the cost often becomes an abstraction. So what is the meaning, in US dollars of a cure that costs a hundred thousand dollars or a million dollars

Centering Patients: Metaphors and Relationships

00:03:13 - And these become just abstract numbers, that, are very hard to conceive. Well, when you think about, the metaphor of the patient as a center, you think about other analogies, of centeredness, for example. do we live in a tmeic universe where the sun rotates around the earth or a Copernican universe where the earth rotates around the sun? those are the sorts of things
00:03:45 - but the flaw in the idea of the patient of center, by the way, I mean, I, I do advocate the idea that the patient, that more attention should be directed towards the subjective experiences of the patient, and their, and what they're experiencing. But, they're not entirely the center because neither the doctor nor the patient can be the unique center.
00:04:15 - and economic relationship, that is highly interwoven. So when we think about, metaphors, we might think instead about a binary star system where the two stars orbit around each other, or the double helix of DNA in which the two strands and circle each other. Or if you go back to ancient medicine to the caduceus, and I realize that the most ancient caduceus is a single serpent wrapped around a staff, but there's a later image,
00:04:48 - of two serpents wrapped around a staff, and they intertwine forever.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis

Data

Originals

Explainers

Podcasts

Faculti

New on Faculti

Idea Explorer

Definition

News Context

Critical Questions and Answers

Research Summaries

Defining “Patient-Centered Medicine”

Media Literacy Toolkit

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

Further Reading ▼