Popular in Sociology

Social Identities and Divisions

A new explanation of antisemitism: Jew hatred as a civilisational phenomenon

Boston University Liah Greenfeld

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

Culture and Society

Carceral Entrapments: Views from the Prison/Street Interface in India

Indian Institute of Technology Delhi Mahuya Bandyopadhya

Culture and Society

Pre-problem families: predictive analytics and the future as the present

University of Southampton Rosalind Edwards

Ethnicity and Racism

Were Muslim Barbarians Really Knocking On the Gates of Ontario?

University of Ottawa Natasha Bakht

Culture and Society

Poor People’s Survival Strategies

The University of Texas at Austin Javier Auyero

Ethnicity and Racism

Sociology of Whiteness

Arizona State University Monica McDermott

Social Practices and Cultural Contexts

View more insights in Social Sciences - Sociology - Social Identities and Divisions

View more figures from Boston University

View the page of Nancy Ammerman

Read the Study

Next in Social Identities and Divisions

Monetary Sanctions as a Pound of Flesh

Alexes Mary-Yvonne Harris | University of Washington

The Architecture of Status Hierarchies

Fabien Accominotti | University of Wisconsin Madison

Spirituality is a part of religious practice, encompassing embodiment, materiality, emotion, aesthetics, morality, and narrative. Nancy Ammerman highlights the internal dynamics of these dimensions.

Image courtesy of interviewee. January 15, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

The speaker discusses the limitations of traditional sociological studies of religion, which often rely on surveys that quantify beliefs and affiliations. They argue that this approach fails to capture the true essence of spirituality and its presence in people's lives. By conducting fieldwork and engaging with individuals, one can identify deeper themes related to spirituality, which varies significantly across different cultures and contexts.

Spirituality is described as a multifaceted concept that can exist both within organized religion and outside it, often intertwined with people's daily practices and moral frameworks. The speaker emphasizes that spirituality is not merely an abstract idea but is grounded in tangible activities and experiences, highlighting the importance of the physical and communal aspects of spiritual practices.

Furthermore, the speaker challenges the notion that spirituality and religiosity are mutually exclusive, noting that many people view themselves as both spiritual and religious. They suggest that participation in spiritual or religious gatherings is crucial for moral and civic development, arguing that those who lack such experiences may struggle to navigate the world effectively. Ultimately, the speaker calls for a broader understanding of spirituality and a recognition of its significance in everyday life, advocating for more engagement with people's personal spiritual narratives.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.245 --> 00:03.225
In my field in sociology, a lot

00:03.285 --> 00:06.505
of the way people have understood religion has been

00:06.535 --> 00:08.105
primarily through surveys

00:08.245 --> 00:12.385
and through, counting up how many people believe this

00:12.405 --> 00:14.785
or that, how many people belong to this or that.

00:15.165 --> 00:16.225
And it just seemed to me

00:16.225 --> 00:19.225
that we were really truncating our understanding

00:19.565 --> 00:21.305
of the presence of religion

00:21.365 --> 00:23.545
and society by doing it that way.

00:23.725 --> 00:25.745
And that if we got out into the field

00:25.805 --> 00:27.225
and followed some people around

00:27.325 --> 00:29.745
and asked them to tell some stories about their lives,

00:29.775 --> 00:33.105
that we might discover that there's more going on than,

00:33.455 --> 00:35.625
than just what they check off on a survey.

00:36.075 --> 00:38.545
First of all, I think it's important to understand

00:38.575 --> 00:40.705
that spirituality means a lot

00:40.705 --> 00:42.785
of different things in different contexts,

00:42.845 --> 00:44.185
in different places in the world.

00:44.885 --> 00:47.425
So, it, there's no one thing

00:47.425 --> 00:51.065
that constitutes spirituality, as such.

00:51.485 --> 00:54.705
So we really have to ask what do the people we're talking to

00:55.355 --> 00:58.025
understand, to be spirituality?

00:59.335 --> 01:03.145
What I then have done in working with that material,

01:03.735 --> 01:06.545
with those stories is to, look

01:06.565 --> 01:07.945
for the kind of common themes.

01:08.085 --> 01:12.305
And the common themes tend to be around in experiencing

01:12.485 --> 01:16.105
or believing there to be something beyond the everyday,

01:16.105 --> 01:18.865
something beyond what we can see and, and touch,

01:19.205 --> 01:21.545
and that there's some presence

01:21.645 --> 01:26.105
or reality in the larger world that, is important,

01:26.525 --> 01:30.065
and that can be, a part of people's lives.

01:30.745 --> 01:35.225
Morality is, the way we orient,

01:35.645 --> 01:40.505
the decisions we make about how we, how we move

01:40.505 --> 01:42.905
through the world, what we believe to be right and wrong.

01:43.465 --> 01:47.145
Spirituality, is a much more neutral sort of,

01:47.145 --> 01:48.385
phenomenon, if you will.

01:48.925 --> 01:53.105
Uh, it can be oriented toward things that are harmful.

01:53.405 --> 01:56.745
It can be oriented toward things that are helpful

01:56.925 --> 02:00.025
and encouraging and comforting and empowering.

02:00.565 --> 02:04.985
Uh, but, it is, it's a much more, yes,

02:05.095 --> 02:09.145
amorphous and somewhat neutral kind of, understanding

02:09.205 --> 02:11.785
of what's out there, in the world.

02:12.285 --> 02:15.265
One of the things that's interesting about spirituality is

02:15.335 --> 02:18.305
that while we talk about it as something that's kind

02:18.305 --> 02:21.745
of amorphous and out there, it always has connections

02:22.205 --> 02:24.825
to things that are actually in, that we can observe

02:24.825 --> 02:25.825
that are in this world.

02:26.485 --> 02:30.345
Uh, so when people are engaged in spiritual practices,

02:30.575 --> 02:33.945
they almost always are doing things with their bodies.

02:34.575 --> 02:36.865
They're, in physical places.

02:37.695 --> 02:40.665
They have candles or they have altars

02:40.885 --> 02:44.585
or they wear jewelry, all sorts of things

02:44.695 --> 02:48.265
that either remind them of that spiritual presence

02:48.765 --> 02:51.065
or invoke that spiritual presence.

02:51.885 --> 02:53.825
Uh, so the materiality

02:53.845 --> 02:57.145
and the embodiment is very much a part of what it means

02:57.765 --> 03:00.845
to have a spiritual dimension in one's life.

03:01.225 --> 03:02.725
One of the things that's a problem

03:03.665 --> 03:06.925
in thinking about spirituality is to think about it

03:06.985 --> 03:11.285
as something that is this amorphous, otherworldly thing.

03:12.225 --> 03:16.805
And when we start to think about, really trying

03:16.805 --> 03:17.845
to understand it

03:18.225 --> 03:20.085
and understanding it as something

03:20.085 --> 03:24.205
that happens in this world, then we begin

03:24.205 --> 03:27.925
to see these multiple dimensions of what's going on

03:27.925 --> 03:29.005
with spirituality.

03:29.665 --> 03:34.085
And spirituality is simply one aspect

03:34.305 --> 03:37.365
of the practices that people are engaged in.

03:37.905 --> 03:41.565
The, the materiality, the embodiment, the aesthetics,

03:42.025 --> 03:43.205
the moral dimensions.

03:43.255 --> 03:47.925
Those are things that are very much present in the midst

03:48.185 --> 03:51.045
of the things that people are doing that they see

03:51.065 --> 03:52.685
as their spiritual lives.

03:53.225 --> 03:57.205
The core argument I'm trying to make is that, this

03:57.765 --> 04:01.885
spirituality is something that can exist both in

04:02.685 --> 04:04.845
religious contexts that we recognize

04:04.985 --> 04:07.085
as organized religious places,

04:07.625 --> 04:11.805
but also exists in many other, places in, in the world

04:11.805 --> 04:13.165
and in people's lives.

04:13.545 --> 04:16.365
And that it exists in very different ways,

04:16.705 --> 04:19.925
in different kinds of contexts around the world, that

04:19.925 --> 04:22.765
what we think of in the US

04:23.025 --> 04:27.805
or in Europe as spirituality is often divorced from

04:28.405 --> 04:30.725
religious traditions and religious institutions.

04:31.025 --> 04:34.805
People have thought about this as something that's an either

04:34.945 --> 04:36.605
or, you're either spiritual

04:36.705 --> 04:38.685
or you're religious, but not both.

04:38.825 --> 04:40.005
But the reality is

04:40.435 --> 04:43.285
that most religious people think they're spiritual.

04:43.905 --> 04:46.885
And many of the people who are spiritual say

04:46.885 --> 04:48.805
that they're spiritual, but not religious.

04:48.985 --> 04:51.925
Not so much because they're really different from religious

04:51.925 --> 04:54.445
people, but because they don't like the way

04:55.165 --> 04:56.565
religion has been organized

04:56.625 --> 04:59.005
and the kinds of things that religion has stood

04:59.025 --> 05:00.645
for in their experience.

05:00.835 --> 05:02.845
Certainly theologians would argue,

05:03.345 --> 05:04.965
and many anthropologists would argue

05:04.965 --> 05:08.245
that human beings simply have a kind of spiritual

05:08.995 --> 05:11.365
dimension in their lives that, that we,

05:11.785 --> 05:13.325
that's part of the human condition.

05:13.865 --> 05:17.485
Now, you know, lots of people would also argue that no,

05:17.605 --> 05:20.285
I can be just an ordinary secular person and,

05:20.425 --> 05:24.165
and I don't recognize anything, extraordinary in the,

05:24.265 --> 05:27.885
in the world, but that's actually a pretty small,

05:28.165 --> 05:31.725
proportion of the population that will make that assertion

05:31.725 --> 05:33.485
that there's just really nothing else.

05:33.625 --> 05:37.085
But what we see, I actually worry more about people

05:37.185 --> 05:40.125
who don't seek out some kind of spiritual

05:40.145 --> 05:41.645
or religious gathering

05:42.025 --> 05:45.965
or assembly to be a part of, than I worry about people

05:46.025 --> 05:49.685
who don't have some sort of active spiritual experience

05:49.785 --> 05:50.925
or spiritual life.

05:51.735 --> 05:54.605
Those, those gatherings turn out

05:54.605 --> 05:56.405
to be extraordinarily important

05:57.225 --> 05:59.845
For how we are formed as moral people

06:00.025 --> 06:02.005
and how we're formed as citizens.

06:02.745 --> 06:06.565
And, without those, we have pretty good evidence.

06:07.065 --> 06:11.765
Uh, people really struggle, to find a kind

06:11.765 --> 06:16.245
of moral centered, find a kind of way of engaging the world

06:16.305 --> 06:18.925
and their societies in productive ways.

06:19.465 --> 06:22.925
It is important to actually ask people what they're doing

06:23.625 --> 06:27.325
and ask people where they intersect with something

06:27.325 --> 06:28.725
beyond themselves in their lives.

06:29.465 --> 06:33.345
Uh, we've, we've really gotten into a situation

06:33.345 --> 06:37.905
where we have, such a limited understanding

06:38.525 --> 06:41.465
of what spirituality is, what religion is,

06:42.125 --> 06:44.225
and the people that are

06:44.325 --> 06:47.105
around us every day probably could enlighten us a lot.

Rethinking Spirituality and Religion in Sociology

00:00:00 - In my field in sociology, a lot of the way people have understood religion has been primarily through surveys and through, counting up how many people believe this or that, how many people belong to this or that. And it just seemed to me that we were really truncating our understanding of the presence of religion and society by doing it that way. And that if we got out into the field and followed some people around and asked them to tell some stories about their lives, that we might discover that there's more going on than,
00:00:36 - First of all, I think it's important to understand that spirituality means a lot of different things in different contexts, in different places in the world. So, it, there's no one thing that constitutes spirituality, as such. So we really have to ask what do the people we're talking to understand, to be spirituality? What I then have done in working with that material,
00:01:06 - for the kind of common themes. And the common themes tend to be around in experiencing or believing there to be something beyond the everyday, something beyond what we can see and, and touch, and that there's some presence or reality in the larger world that, is important, and that can be, a part of people's lives. Morality is, the way we orient,
00:01:40 - through the world, what we believe to be right and wrong. Spirituality, is a much more neutral sort of, phenomenon, if you will. it can be oriented toward things that are harmful. It can be oriented toward things that are helpful and encouraging and comforting and empowering. but, it is, it's a much more, yes, amorphous and somewhat neutral kind of, understanding
00:02:12 - One of the things that's interesting about spirituality is that while we talk about it as something that's kind of amorphous and out there, it always has connections to things that are actually in, that we can observe that are in this world. so when people are engaged in spiritual practices, they almost always are doing things with their bodies. They're, in physical places. They have candles or they have altars
00:02:44 - that either remind them of that spiritual presence or invoke that spiritual presence. so the materiality and the embodiment is very much a part of what it means to have a spiritual dimension in one's life. One of the things that's a problem in thinking about spirituality is to think about it as something that is this amorphous, otherworldly thing.

Exploring the Dimensions of Spirituality in Society

00:03:16 - to understand it and understanding it as something that happens in this world, then we begin to see these multiple dimensions of what's going on with spirituality. And spirituality is simply one aspect of the practices that people are engaged in. The, the materiality, the embodiment, the aesthetics, the moral dimensions.
00:03:48 - of the things that people are doing that they see as their spiritual lives. The core argument I'm trying to make is that, this spirituality is something that can exist both in religious contexts that we recognize as organized religious places, but also exists in many other, places in, in the world and in people's lives.
00:04:16 - in different kinds of contexts around the world, that what we think of in the US or in Europe as spirituality is often divorced from religious traditions and religious institutions. People have thought about this as something that's an either or, you're either spiritual or you're religious, but not both. But the reality is that most religious people think they're spiritual.
00:04:46 - that they're spiritual, but not religious. Not so much because they're really different from religious people, but because they don't like the way religion has been organized and the kinds of things that religion has stood for in their experience. Certainly theologians would argue, and many anthropologists would argue that human beings simply have a kind of spiritual dimension in their lives that, that we, that's part of the human condition. Now, you know, lots of people would also argue that no,
00:05:20 - and I don't recognize anything, extraordinary in the, in the world, but that's actually a pretty small, proportion of the population that will make that assertion that there's just really nothing else. But what we see, I actually worry more about people who don't seek out some kind of spiritual or religious gathering or assembly to be a part of, than I worry about people who don't have some sort of active spiritual experience
00:05:51 - Those, those gatherings turn out to be extraordinarily important For how we are formed as moral people and how we're formed as citizens. And, without those, we have pretty good evidence. people really struggle, to find a kind of moral centered, find a kind of way of engaging the world and their societies in productive ways. It is important to actually ask people what they're doing

Expanding Our Understanding of Spirituality

00:06:44 - beyond themselves in their lives. we've, we've really gotten into a situation where we have, such a limited understanding of what spirituality is, what religion is, and the people that are around us every day probably could enlighten us a lot.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis