Popular in Social Sciences

Banks and Policy Organisations

Macroeconomic modelling of CBDC: a critical review

European Central Bank Ulrich Bindseil

Social Identities and Divisions

A new explanation of antisemitism: Jew hatred as a civilisational phenomenon

Boston University Liah Greenfeld

Banks and Policy Organisations

Financing Private Credit

Federal Reserve Bank of New York Nina Boyarchenko

Economics

Failing Banks

Massachusetts Institute of Technology Emil Verner

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

American Politics

Keeping the Republic

Boston College Marc Landy

British Politics

Entrepreneurial thinking: the politics and practice of policy impact

University of Sheffield Matthew Flinders

Toni Morrison: Imagining Freedom

View more insights in Social Sciences - Political Science - Politics and Gender

View more figures from University of Virginia

View the page of Lawrie Balfour

Read the Study

Next in Political Science

Exploring Impacts and Implications of US-China Relations on US Public Opinion toward Chinese and Asian Americans

Pei-Te Lien | University of California Santa Barbara

Is There Really a Dictator’s Dilemma? Information and Repression in Autocracy

Scott Gehlbach | University of Chicago

How does Toni Morrison reimagine freedom beyond racial and societal norms, challenging us to rethink liberty through her powerful use of language and storytelling?

Image courtesy of interviewee. November 30, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video reflects on the legacy of Toni Morrison, a renowned author and Nobel Prize winner, particularly highlighting her contributions to understanding freedom, race, and language. Morrison, who passed away in 2019, is described as a revolutionary political thinker whose works addressed critical issues on race, slavery, and the meaning of freedom in the U.S.

The writer emphasizes how Morrison’s literature, especially the novel "Beloved," explores the complexities of freedom through the experiences of enslaved individuals, focusing on individual and collective struggles for emancipation. The analysis points out three key features in her works: the portrayal of enslaved women's perspectives, the importance of solidarity under duress, and critiques of the assumptions surrounding white freedom.

Morrison also emphasizes "word work" as a practice of freedom in her Nobel lecture, advocating for a conscious and careful use of language to secure human differences and address the violence done to language itself. Her stories challenge readers to rethink the implications of race and freedom, ultimately asserting that the act of storytelling can forge connection and community in the face of racial terror.

This video concludes by highlighting the contemporary relevance of Morrison’s warnings against censorship and the importance of protecting writers amidst increasing political repression, especially targeting marginalized voices. Through her body of work, Morrison invites readers to participate in the ongoing quest for understanding freedom and navigating the complexities of race in America.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video regarding Toni Morrison's contributions and significance:

1. **Morrison as a Revolutionary Political Thinker**: The video emphasizes that Toni Morrison, while renowned as a Nobel Prize-winning literary artist, is also celebrated as a revolutionary political thinker whose insights into freedom, race, and societal structures have profoundly influenced political theory.

2. **Exploration of Freedom**: Morrison's work, particularly in her novel "Beloved," offers a deep exploration of freedom, illustrating how it is intertwined with race and collective experiences rather than solely individual values. The narrative highlights the struggles of enslaved individuals who understand the true meaning of freedom through their harsh realities.

3. **Language as Agency**: Morrison’s views on language as a form of empowerment (referred to as "word work") highlight its potential to create meaning and shape human experience. However, she also critiques the violence done to language and emphasizes the responsibility of wielding language with care, particularly in addressing issues of race and freedom.

4. **Ethics of Responsibility**: Morrison shifts the notion of responsibility away from blaming marginalized individuals for their circumstances to recognizing the inherent responsibility towards those who have been historically oppressed. She critiques how society often overlooks the struggles and agency of these individuals, especially in the convideo of motherhood and community care.

5. **Threats to Freedom of Expression**: The video acknowledges Morrison's concern over censorship and political repression faced by writers, particularly those from marginalized communities. Her final work warns against the dangers of authoritarianism, emphasizing that the freedom of writers is closely tied to the broader freedom of society. Morrison advocates for the importance of storytelling in fostering ethical debates and community understanding.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes extracted from the video regarding Toni Morrison's contributions and her theoretical insights on language, freedom, and responsibility:

1. **Morrison as a Revolutionary Thinker**: "Morrison has been a guide and essential guide to my own work as a political theorist since I was a graduate student."

2. **Exploration of Freedom**: "One of her greatest and maybe least appreciated contributions is her profound exploration of the meaning of freedom."

3. **Freedom in American Political Discourse**: "Freedom is one of the most inspiring and overused and trivialized words in our political lexicon."

4. **Morrison's Perspective on Freedom**: "She is one of the most acute interpreters of... what it means to live in a nation of people who decided that their worldview would combine agendas for individual freedom with mechanisms for devastating racial oppression."

5. **Freedom in "Beloved"**: "Beloved... makes vivid how women, men, and children living under conditions of extreme duress have struggled to emancipate themselves and to emancipate each other."

6. **Word Work**: "Word work is sublime because it is generative... In Morrison's view, language... is the wellspring of our creativity."

7. **Role of Storytelling**: "Storytelling is where the serious ethical debates are happening. It can move readers to see the world anew."

8. **Responsibility**: "Morrison inverts this idea... she wants to assume responsibility for people no one's ever assumed responsibility for."

9. **Conversations on Home**: "What does it mean... to be at home in my state, the state of Virginia, if you are a black woman, who was enslaved and is now somewhat emancipated?"

10. **Language and Racism**: "It's not possible simply to wish or will racism or sexism away, because they're embedded in the language that she uses."

11. **Collective vs. Individual Freedom**: "She counters the idea that freedom is an individual value and shows how individual freedom is always bound up with the collective."

12. **Warning to Writers**: "Morrison opened her last published book... to warn against the threat of regimes that censor, harass or exile writers."

13. **The Consequences of Censorship**: "It's not just the writers themselves, but everyone's freedom that's at stake."

Each of these quotes encapsulates important themes in Morrison's work and illustrates her influence on the understanding of race, freedom, language, and responsibility in contemporary society.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP=LOCAL:00:00:00.000,MPEGTS:90000

1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.165
Antonio Morrison died in 2019.

2
00:00:02.465 --> 00:00:05.725
Angela Davis and Farrah Jasmine Griffin published an op-ed

3
00:00:05.725 --> 00:00:08.045
in the New York Times in which they hailed her

4
00:00:08.105 --> 00:00:10.245
as a revolutionary political thinker.

5
00:00:10.865 --> 00:00:12.645
Um, now she's better known, of course,

6
00:00:12.745 --> 00:00:14.965
as a Nobel Prize winner, as a literary artist.

7
00:00:15.305 --> 00:00:17.525
Um, but this formulation,

8
00:00:17.845 --> 00:00:19.845
Morrison is a revolutionary political thinker,

9
00:00:19.845 --> 00:00:21.125
struck me as exactly right.

10
00:00:21.745 --> 00:00:23.685
Um, Morrison has been a guide

11
00:00:23.705 --> 00:00:25.205
and essential guide to my own work

12
00:00:25.205 --> 00:00:28.045
as a political theorist since I was a graduate student,

13
00:00:28.425 --> 00:00:30.685
and especially for thinking about the relationship

14
00:00:30.685 --> 00:00:32.165
of language and politics.

15
00:00:32.785 --> 00:00:35.805
Um, political theory in the 1990s when I first started

16
00:00:36.165 --> 00:00:39.645
graduate school was stunningly silent on the questions

17
00:00:39.785 --> 00:00:42.605
of race and racism and on slavery, colonialism

18
00:00:42.605 --> 00:00:46.045
and their legacies Morrison's writings filled that void.

19
00:00:47.105 --> 00:00:49.325
One of her greatest and maybe least appreciated

20
00:00:49.685 --> 00:00:51.165
contributions is her profound

21
00:00:51.165 --> 00:00:52.685
exploration of the meaning of freedom.

22
00:00:53.425 --> 00:00:58.045
And I first came to understand this, in the classroom.

23
00:00:58.705 --> 00:01:01.845
Um, that is to say that, as I was working

24
00:01:01.915 --> 00:01:05.685
with undergraduates, I found,

25
00:01:05.795 --> 00:01:08.485
that I kept returning to the notion of freedom.

26
00:01:09.165 --> 00:01:10.885
I should say that this matters in the US

27
00:01:10.985 --> 00:01:14.565
and Morrison is particularly helpful in this regard,

28
00:01:14.565 --> 00:01:17.965
because freedom is one of the most inspiring and overused

29
00:01:17.965 --> 00:01:20.965
and trivi trivialized words in our political lexicon.

30
00:01:21.585 --> 00:01:23.365
Um, but at this political moment,

31
00:01:23.465 --> 00:01:26.565
and I think we saw this with the most recent election,

32
00:01:27.245 --> 00:01:29.845
Americans don't use this word to mean the same thing.

33
00:01:29.865 --> 00:01:31.365
The meanings are pulling apart.

34
00:01:31.985 --> 00:01:35.765
And part of the reason for this, I think, is that,

35
00:01:35.905 --> 00:01:38.885
the US is shaped by our origins,

36
00:01:39.065 --> 00:01:42.845
as a democratic society founded both in, the value

37
00:01:42.865 --> 00:01:44.885
of liberty and the right to enslave.

38
00:01:45.225 --> 00:01:49.565
And this is really where Morrison's work, zeroes in,

39
00:01:50.225 --> 00:01:54.805
that she, she is one of the most acute, interpreters

40
00:01:54.805 --> 00:01:57.845
of what she called the question of what, what it means

41
00:01:57.905 --> 00:02:00.565
to live in a nation of people who decided

42
00:02:00.595 --> 00:02:03.205
that their worldview would combine agendas

43
00:02:03.205 --> 00:02:05.405
for individual freedom with mechanisms

44
00:02:05.405 --> 00:02:07.165
for devastating racial oppression.

45
00:02:07.825 --> 00:02:09.565
And we see that in all of her work,

46
00:02:09.705 --> 00:02:12.405
but especially in her 1987 novel, beloved,

47
00:02:12.415 --> 00:02:17.245
which I frequently inspire in the, inspire,

48
00:02:17.885 --> 00:02:19.405
a sign in the classroom.

49
00:02:19.505 --> 00:02:21.365
No, wait. Do that, do that, do that one sentence. Okay.

50
00:02:21.435 --> 00:02:22.565
Good thing. Okay.

51
00:02:23.745 --> 00:02:26.365
Um, we see this in all of her work,

52
00:02:26.385 --> 00:02:31.005
and especially in her 1987 novel, beloved, which I,

53
00:02:31.405 --> 00:02:33.005
frequently assign in the classroom.

54
00:02:33.485 --> 00:02:35.925
I think a, a critical text,

55
00:02:36.465 --> 00:02:39.365
for understanding the meanings of freedom, both in the US

56
00:02:39.465 --> 00:02:40.965
but also more generally,

57
00:02:40.965 --> 00:02:43.965
because it's not simply about freedom,

58
00:02:44.595 --> 00:02:46.605
from the front matter that is from the epigraph

59
00:02:46.605 --> 00:02:49.045
and the dedication to the very last page,

60
00:02:49.675 --> 00:02:51.965
beloved makes vivid how women, men,

61
00:02:51.985 --> 00:02:53.685
and children living under conditions

62
00:02:53.685 --> 00:02:56.965
of extreme duress have struggled to emancipate themselves

63
00:02:57.185 --> 00:02:58.525
and to emancipate each other.

64
00:02:59.305 --> 00:03:01.845
Um, these are people who know what freedom means,

65
00:03:01.845 --> 00:03:03.605
because they can't take it for granted.

66
00:03:04.365 --> 00:03:08.285
Morrison, transforms freedom in the novel,

67
00:03:08.315 --> 00:03:11.245
from a definition or a concept into a living thing.

68
00:03:11.715 --> 00:03:14.125
It's a profound longing, a fragile achievement,

69
00:03:14.145 --> 00:03:18.165
and an aspiration that one can touch, taste,

70
00:03:18.395 --> 00:03:20.925
feel here, as well as know.

71
00:03:21.545 --> 00:03:24.005
Um, and very quickly, there are three features of the novel

72
00:03:24.005 --> 00:03:25.525
that I think really illustrate this.

73
00:03:26.145 --> 00:03:28.685
Um, first, the novel as a story.

74
00:03:29.025 --> 00:03:31.525
Um, reorients readers away from abstract

75
00:03:31.545 --> 00:03:33.525
and typically masculine understandings

76
00:03:33.525 --> 00:03:34.565
of what freedom means.

77
00:03:35.305 --> 00:03:39.405
Um, she focuses on the vantage of enslaved women, for whom,

78
00:03:39.545 --> 00:03:42.645
such basic human acts as choosing whom to love

79
00:03:43.065 --> 00:03:45.725
or caring for their children, was outlawed.

80
00:03:46.265 --> 00:03:47.805
Um, second, she attends

81
00:03:47.805 --> 00:03:50.685
to the ways in which people forge solidarity

82
00:03:51.255 --> 00:03:52.605
under extreme duress.

83
00:03:52.605 --> 00:03:56.365
So whether it's on, the plantation on the chain gang,

84
00:03:56.385 --> 00:04:00.365
and the flight from slavery, or in the brutal world,

85
00:04:00.695 --> 00:04:05.605
after, the Civil War, she counters, the idea

86
00:04:05.605 --> 00:04:07.365
that freedom is an individual value

87
00:04:07.465 --> 00:04:09.405
and shows how the individual freedom is

88
00:04:09.405 --> 00:04:10.765
always bound up with the collective.

89
00:04:11.345 --> 00:04:15.965
And third, and finally, the vivid portraits that she paints

90
00:04:15.965 --> 00:04:19.205
of white Americans of enslavers who think they can rise

91
00:04:19.375 --> 00:04:22.165
above, the institution on which they depend

92
00:04:22.545 --> 00:04:25.045
of abolitionists, who harbor racist ideas,

93
00:04:25.225 --> 00:04:27.445
and even of children who are trained into the habits

94
00:04:27.505 --> 00:04:30.685
of mastery from a very early age,

95
00:04:30.925 --> 00:04:34.485
cautions against mistaking white freedom,

96
00:04:34.545 --> 00:04:35.685
for freedom itself.

97
00:04:35.905 --> 00:04:40.085
And I think this is one of the ways in which she offers a,

98
00:04:40.225 --> 00:04:44.605
her narratives as a counter, a counterweight

99
00:04:44.945 --> 00:04:47.005
to the emphasis on freedom as white freedom

100
00:04:47.075 --> 00:04:48.765
that has defined political theory.

101
00:04:49.265 --> 00:04:52.765
In the book, I focus on what Morrison calls word work

102
00:04:53.065 --> 00:04:54.485
as a practice of freedom.

103
00:04:54.985 --> 00:04:57.045
And she introduces the phrase,

104
00:04:57.345 --> 00:05:00.205
in her 1997 Nobel lecture on literature,

105
00:05:00.205 --> 00:05:03.005
and I should say, as an aside, it's available

106
00:05:03.005 --> 00:05:04.765
through the Nobel Prize website.

107
00:05:04.825 --> 00:05:07.165
And I, I recommend that anyone,

108
00:05:07.355 --> 00:05:10.885
with any interest in language in Morrison,

109
00:05:11.225 --> 00:05:14.885
or just interest in spending a beautiful 40 minutes listen

110
00:05:14.885 --> 00:05:16.885
to the audio of, of her lecture.

111
00:05:17.825 --> 00:05:19.485
Um, in that lecture, she says,

112
00:05:19.485 --> 00:05:21.925
and here I'm quoting that word, work is sublime

113
00:05:22.035 --> 00:05:23.405
because it is generative.

114
00:05:23.545 --> 00:05:25.765
It makes meaning that secures our difference,

115
00:05:26.065 --> 00:05:27.325
our human difference,

116
00:05:27.785 --> 00:05:32.045
the way in which we are not like no other life language,

117
00:05:32.065 --> 00:05:34.725
in other words, in Morrison's view, is a kind of agency.

118
00:05:34.755 --> 00:05:37.805
It's the wellspring of, of our creativity,

119
00:05:37.865 --> 00:05:39.325
in fact, of our, of our being.

120
00:05:40.275 --> 00:05:43.015
At the same time, Morrison also addresses the violence

121
00:05:43.045 --> 00:05:46.775
that is done to language, whether by heads of state,

122
00:05:46.955 --> 00:05:49.935
by corporate leaders, by academics, by patriots,

123
00:05:49.935 --> 00:05:52.615
and by many others, and by language,

124
00:05:52.955 --> 00:05:55.935
the ways in which the use of words can silence or kill.

125
00:05:56.475 --> 00:05:59.925
Um, and so the Nobel Lecture offers eloquent testimony

126
00:06:00.065 --> 00:06:01.965
to the generative power of board work,

127
00:06:02.145 --> 00:06:05.885
and at the same time, to the urgency of wielding that power

128
00:06:05.995 --> 00:06:09.725
with care for the lives, that it destroys or enables.

129
00:06:09.925 --> 00:06:12.285
I think even though she pursues this idea

130
00:06:12.285 --> 00:06:17.205
that language can be liberating in Oliver, work,

131
00:06:17.855 --> 00:06:20.565
she's especially interested in how the, the novel

132
00:06:20.825 --> 00:06:24.565
or narrative fiction can be crucial in changing the way

133
00:06:24.565 --> 00:06:26.205
readers think about the relationship

134
00:06:26.205 --> 00:06:27.445
between race and freedom.

135
00:06:28.265 --> 00:06:31.045
In fact, she says that, storytelling is

136
00:06:31.045 --> 00:06:33.405
where the serious ethical debates are happening.

137
00:06:34.265 --> 00:06:38.205
Um, and it is a way of forging community in the face of race

138
00:06:38.225 --> 00:06:40.925
or racial terror, or estrangement.

139
00:06:41.265 --> 00:06:43.405
It can move readers to see the world anew,

140
00:06:43.865 --> 00:06:46.845
and it treats the lives of the enslaved, the dispossessed,

141
00:06:46.905 --> 00:06:49.805
the hunted, as worthy of everyone's concern.

142
00:06:50.265 --> 00:06:53.685
Um, and we can see this, I think,

143
00:06:53.905 --> 00:06:55.525
in the way she explores two words.

144
00:06:55.825 --> 00:06:58.045
Uh, I mean, there are many, many examples,

145
00:06:58.065 --> 00:06:59.885
but I was thinking about two in particular.

146
00:07:00.465 --> 00:07:02.965
The first is the word responsibility, which is a word

147
00:07:02.965 --> 00:07:06.125
that occurs across both her novels,

148
00:07:06.505 --> 00:07:08.365
and her, her nonfiction writings.

149
00:07:08.425 --> 00:07:10.405
And in fact, across her interviews, it's a word

150
00:07:10.405 --> 00:07:12.485
that she spend a lot of time thinking about.

151
00:07:13.265 --> 00:07:15.925
And I think we often, talk about freedom

152
00:07:15.985 --> 00:07:19.085
and responsibility as being linked in the sense that,

153
00:07:19.145 --> 00:07:21.485
you know, for those of us who have children, we tell them

154
00:07:21.485 --> 00:07:24.045
to make good choices as a condition of their,

155
00:07:24.585 --> 00:07:25.845
of their freedom.

156
00:07:26.505 --> 00:07:30.885
Uh, it means being, both having an opportunity to choose

157
00:07:30.885 --> 00:07:33.845
what to do or to be, and a capacity to do it rightly,

158
00:07:34.225 --> 00:07:36.525
and Morrison doesn't disagree,

159
00:07:36.525 --> 00:07:37.565
but where the language

160
00:07:37.585 --> 00:07:40.725
of personal responsibility has often been used as a kind

161
00:07:40.725 --> 00:07:43.725
of a cudgel, as a way of blaming people who are vulnerable

162
00:07:43.745 --> 00:07:44.805
for their situations.

163
00:07:45.725 --> 00:07:49.405
Morrison inverts this idea, indeed, she says,

164
00:07:49.425 --> 00:07:52.085
as a novelist, she wants to assume responsibility

165
00:07:52.185 --> 00:07:55.405
for people no one's ever assumed responsibility for.

166
00:07:56.185 --> 00:07:59.205
Um, and so what she does is she looks at the lives

167
00:07:59.305 --> 00:08:02.645
of people, whose situations are most precarious,

168
00:08:03.185 --> 00:08:06.845
and asks, how it is that they,

169
00:08:06.875 --> 00:08:09.085
they act accountably to themselves

170
00:08:09.145 --> 00:08:12.285
and to each other, often in ways that are disregarded by,

171
00:08:12.585 --> 00:08:14.485
historians and commentators.

172
00:08:15.345 --> 00:08:20.325
So in Beloved, for instance, you know, being responsible

173
00:08:20.325 --> 00:08:23.005
for one's children was actually illegal if you were

174
00:08:23.005 --> 00:08:24.205
an enslaved person.

175
00:08:25.145 --> 00:08:28.965
Um, and the burden, this burden fell hardest on mothers,

176
00:08:29.665 --> 00:08:31.205
in ways that I think,

177
00:08:31.515 --> 00:08:33.925
have their legacies in the contemporary world.

178
00:08:34.025 --> 00:08:36.805
We see the ways in which, motherhood, especially

179
00:08:37.415 --> 00:08:40.405
among poor women and women of color, is often criminalized.

180
00:08:41.065 --> 00:08:45.085
Um, and so the novel follows the remarkable acts

181
00:08:45.085 --> 00:08:49.365
of creativity and plotting that were required so that,

182
00:08:49.365 --> 00:08:51.765
especially Seth, who's one of the central characters,

183
00:08:51.765 --> 00:08:54.925
an enslaved mother, enables her children

184
00:08:55.065 --> 00:08:58.405
to escape from slavery, struggles to feed

185
00:08:58.425 --> 00:09:00.205
and to nurture them and to give them a future.

186
00:09:00.505 --> 00:09:02.405
And at the same time, she shows how many

187
00:09:02.405 --> 00:09:03.405
of the white characters

188
00:09:03.625 --> 00:09:06.845
who believed they were the responsible ones, just

189
00:09:06.985 --> 00:09:10.085
as policymakers today, often figure themselves as,

190
00:09:10.305 --> 00:09:14.445
as responsible as their chastising, vulnerable people,

191
00:09:15.185 --> 00:09:17.285
and presume that the freedom

192
00:09:17.305 --> 00:09:19.645
of the enslaved is rightly in their hands, even

193
00:09:19.665 --> 00:09:23.125
as they take no responsibility for the injustice of slavery.

194
00:09:23.865 --> 00:09:25.125
So that's one example.

195
00:09:25.315 --> 00:09:26.605
Another is the way in which

196
00:09:26.965 --> 00:09:28.485
Morrison approaches the word home.

197
00:09:29.145 --> 00:09:33.775
Um, her novels, often focus on people

198
00:09:33.835 --> 00:09:36.135
who are on the move, and,

199
00:09:36.235 --> 00:09:38.295
and regularly on the move against their will.

200
00:09:38.295 --> 00:09:39.535
These are enslaved people.

201
00:09:39.585 --> 00:09:42.615
These are fugitives, migrants, refugees,

202
00:09:42.835 --> 00:09:46.335
the dispossessed from the 17th century to the 21st.

203
00:09:46.475 --> 00:09:49.215
So there's this some amazing kind of scope,

204
00:09:49.505 --> 00:09:51.175
historical scope in her writing.

205
00:09:51.915 --> 00:09:56.635
Um, at the same time, she is,

206
00:09:57.535 --> 00:10:01.755
she, like many feminist thinkers is acutely conscious

207
00:10:01.935 --> 00:10:06.515
how, violence often takes place inside the home,

208
00:10:06.515 --> 00:10:08.195
both in the sense of domestic spaces

209
00:10:08.455 --> 00:10:10.115
and in the sense of a homeland.

210
00:10:10.135 --> 00:10:12.395
In fact, she's interested in the lives of people

211
00:10:12.415 --> 00:10:15.835
who are in her words, not at home in their homeland.

212
00:10:16.415 --> 00:10:18.195
Um, so what does it mean, for instance,

213
00:10:18.255 --> 00:10:21.395
to be at home in my my state, the state of Virginia,

214
00:10:21.975 --> 00:10:25.475
if you are a black woman, who was enslaved

215
00:10:25.575 --> 00:10:28.275
and is now some somewhat emancipated,

216
00:10:28.495 --> 00:10:30.195
but living with the, the violence

217
00:10:30.375 --> 00:10:33.315
and the, the ever present threat of dispossession,

218
00:10:33.445 --> 00:10:38.235
especially if you attempt to act politically, in,

219
00:10:38.975 --> 00:10:43.715
and how does this notion of home operate

220
00:10:44.255 --> 00:10:47.075
at a time when anti-black terror was preventing the

221
00:10:47.075 --> 00:10:50.155
establishment of, multiracial democracy?

222
00:10:50.625 --> 00:10:54.075
When Morrison talks about home, I think she is trying

223
00:10:54.075 --> 00:10:55.515
to think about how, in her words,

224
00:10:55.535 --> 00:10:57.275
to be both free and situated.

225
00:10:57.705 --> 00:10:59.675
It's something that people deeply desire,

226
00:10:59.695 --> 00:11:01.355
and it's also something that can kill them.

227
00:11:01.425 --> 00:11:04.435
Fiction for her becomes a site where she can explore

228
00:11:05.045 --> 00:11:07.235
these different meanings, how they fit together,

229
00:11:07.495 --> 00:11:08.755
and how they are intention

230
00:11:08.855 --> 00:11:11.235
or even in mortal contradiction with each other.

231
00:11:11.995 --> 00:11:14.795
Morrison often notes that American English,

232
00:11:14.895 --> 00:11:16.875
the language in which he writes and thinks

233
00:11:16.875 --> 00:11:19.435
and dreams is also, the master's tongue.

234
00:11:19.435 --> 00:11:21.755
That is, it's the language of racial slavery,

235
00:11:21.855 --> 00:11:23.155
of indigenous dispossession.

236
00:11:23.535 --> 00:11:27.675
And it's not possible simply to wish, or to will racism

237
00:11:27.975 --> 00:11:29.915
or sexism away,

238
00:11:29.915 --> 00:11:33.035
because they're embedded in the language that she uses.

239
00:11:33.735 --> 00:11:36.635
Um, so on the one hand, she,

240
00:11:37.465 --> 00:11:40.355
resists the idea, refuses the idea that we can simply

241
00:11:40.875 --> 00:11:42.195
transcend racial categories.

242
00:11:42.215 --> 00:11:45.915
So the idea of, of colorblindness that we can,

243
00:11:46.385 --> 00:11:48.835
just pretend that race doesn't matter

244
00:11:48.975 --> 00:11:50.395
and go on about our business.

245
00:11:51.175 --> 00:11:54.485
Um, and on the other hand, she, she wants to think about

246
00:11:54.625 --> 00:11:58.205
how it is that ra that language can be reshaped,

247
00:11:58.225 --> 00:12:01.485
can be bent, or in her words, manipulated, so

248
00:12:01.485 --> 00:12:04.525
that racial categories retain their historical specificity.

249
00:12:04.555 --> 00:12:07.485
That is, they're still rooted in the experiences of people

250
00:12:07.485 --> 00:12:12.005
who have been raised, but not their capacity to murder.

251
00:12:12.665 --> 00:12:16.245
Um, and so she tries to generate a different kind

252
00:12:16.245 --> 00:12:19.125
of American English that's capacious enough,

253
00:12:19.125 --> 00:12:23.765
to articulate the complexity of US history, to re

254
00:12:23.825 --> 00:12:27.845
to transform a tool of unfreedom into a medium emancipation.

255
00:12:27.945 --> 00:12:29.885
And I think she does this in two ways.

256
00:12:30.455 --> 00:12:32.285
First, she emphasizes that the beauty

257
00:12:32.305 --> 00:12:35.045
and complexity of of black linguistic forms

258
00:12:35.185 --> 00:12:38.165
and cultural traditions, infuse

259
00:12:38.165 --> 00:12:42.865
and structure her art so that she uses,

260
00:12:43.305 --> 00:12:45.985
specific, elements from black history,

261
00:12:46.335 --> 00:12:50.505
phrases in idioms that are, distinct creations

262
00:12:50.725 --> 00:12:53.585
of African American culture, orality

263
00:12:53.725 --> 00:12:56.585
and emphasis on improvisation, on call response,

264
00:12:57.005 --> 00:13:00.425
and on collective values as a way of trying

265
00:13:00.445 --> 00:13:04.065
to create a language as her, as she puts it, that is worthy

266
00:13:04.565 --> 00:13:05.745
of black culture.

267
00:13:06.605 --> 00:13:10.185
At the same time, she also subverts racial categories in

268
00:13:10.185 --> 00:13:12.065
these really ingenious ways by playing

269
00:13:12.065 --> 00:13:13.345
with reader's expectations.

270
00:13:13.765 --> 00:13:17.265
So her 1997 novel Paradise opens with a line,

271
00:13:17.265 --> 00:13:18.825
they shoot the white girl first,

272
00:13:19.365 --> 00:13:22.425
and then the novel goes on, to tell you who the they is

273
00:13:23.005 --> 00:13:25.385
or they are, but she refuses

274
00:13:25.385 --> 00:13:27.705
to divulge which character is the white girl.

275
00:13:28.165 --> 00:13:30.465
And the point here is not to highlight race,

276
00:13:30.885 --> 00:13:33.745
but to get it out of the way as she puts it, to, to play

277
00:13:33.745 --> 00:13:35.425
with our expectations to say,

278
00:13:35.895 --> 00:13:38.505
what do we lose if we actually don't know the racial

279
00:13:38.595 --> 00:13:39.905
identities of the characters?

280
00:13:39.925 --> 00:13:42.145
For sure. And I think the point of both

281
00:13:42.145 --> 00:13:44.585
of these strategies is to create

282
00:13:44.625 --> 00:13:48.105
what she calls a shareable world, a way of communicating,

283
00:13:48.485 --> 00:13:51.225
with people that is not,

284
00:13:51.295 --> 00:13:53.305
doesn't impose a new order on them,

285
00:13:53.365 --> 00:13:55.745
but invites them to rethink,

286
00:13:55.845 --> 00:13:57.825
to re-see the world that they live in.

287
00:13:57.845 --> 00:14:00.825
And I think it's crucial that she sees fiction writing.

288
00:14:00.935 --> 00:14:02.665
It's not a form of policymaking,

289
00:14:02.965 --> 00:14:04.705
but it is a collaborative enterprise,

290
00:14:05.325 --> 00:14:09.065
and she tries to find ways to bring the reader in,

291
00:14:09.165 --> 00:14:12.065
to enable them in effect, to complete the story.

292
00:14:12.285 --> 00:14:14.545
One thing that I think was extraordinarily prescient was

293
00:14:14.545 --> 00:14:18.825
that Morrison opened her last published book in 2019,

294
00:14:19.065 --> 00:14:22.705
a book, a collection of nonfiction, with an essay

295
00:14:22.705 --> 00:14:24.225
that was entitled Peril.

296
00:14:24.885 --> 00:14:28.385
Um, this was a speech that she had delivered in 2009,

297
00:14:28.405 --> 00:14:30.185
but she came back to it 10 years later

298
00:14:30.725 --> 00:14:33.425
to warn against the threat of regimes that censor,

299
00:14:33.645 --> 00:14:35.105
harass or exile writers.

300
00:14:35.805 --> 00:14:37.945
Um, and she appeals to her fellow writers

301
00:14:38.045 --> 00:14:40.705
to protect each other against the authoritarian

302
00:14:40.705 --> 00:14:43.105
encroachments and to persist in doing the work

303
00:14:43.105 --> 00:14:45.865
that she sees is distinctly the work of writers.

304
00:14:45.925 --> 00:14:48.225
And here, I would say both fiction writers and,

305
00:14:48.565 --> 00:14:50.545
and, writers working

306
00:14:50.725 --> 00:14:53.205
In, in nonfiction genres as well,

307
00:14:53.705 --> 00:14:57.165
to use their imaginative gifts to translate trauma, cruelty,

308
00:14:57.305 --> 00:15:00.805
and exploitation into, what I referred, referred

309
00:15:00.805 --> 00:15:02.485
to a minute ago as a shareable world.

310
00:15:03.145 --> 00:15:06.605
Um, and I think these words resonate especially forcefully

311
00:15:06.655 --> 00:15:11.445
today, when writers, particularly women non-white queer

312
00:15:11.465 --> 00:15:13.445
and other minoritized writers are,

313
00:15:13.545 --> 00:15:16.045
and their publications have become targets of

314
00:15:16.635 --> 00:15:18.485
political repression around the world.

315
00:15:18.865 --> 00:15:21.805
Um, just as, journalists are silenced

316
00:15:21.825 --> 00:15:22.845
and subjected to violence

317
00:15:22.905 --> 00:15:26.205
or record, no numbers globally in the us,

318
00:15:26.205 --> 00:15:28.165
where they haven't been threatened personally.

319
00:15:28.665 --> 00:15:31.525
Um, their books are being banned in schools and libraries.

320
00:15:31.845 --> 00:15:34.805
Morrison's first novel, the Bluest Eye is always on the top

321
00:15:34.865 --> 00:15:37.485
10 list of books that are banned in the us

322
00:15:38.185 --> 00:15:40.645
And writers like Morrison who attempt to grapple

323
00:15:40.645 --> 00:15:43.685
with slavery and its legacies are often depicted

324
00:15:43.685 --> 00:15:45.045
as woke or even racist.

325
00:15:45.625 --> 00:15:47.925
Um, while teaching the history of race

326
00:15:47.925 --> 00:15:50.445
and racism has been legally restricted.

327
00:15:50.545 --> 00:15:53.725
And Morrison focuses on the peril facing writers.

328
00:15:53.865 --> 00:15:55.205
She puts readers on notice

329
00:15:55.595 --> 00:15:57.405
that it's not just the writers themselves,

330
00:15:57.585 --> 00:16:00.085
but everyone's freedom that's at stake.

331
00:16:00.585 --> 00:16:02.805
Um, the work of words matter, she says,

332
00:16:02.805 --> 00:16:04.765
because all next are on the line.

333
00:16:05.585 --> 00:16:08.325
Um, and I think fortunately, she not only leaves readers

334
00:16:08.325 --> 00:16:10.605
with a warning, she leaves us with 11 novels

335
00:16:10.665 --> 00:16:12.845
and countless essays and addresses

336
00:16:13.065 --> 00:16:17.245
and other kinds of, of writing that's a testament

337
00:16:17.265 --> 00:16:19.165
to the generative power of language.

338
00:16:19.445 --> 00:16:21.365
I think her work, all of it, enlist readers

339
00:16:21.425 --> 00:16:25.125
as participants in carrying forward her unfinished project

340
00:16:25.225 --> 00:16:26.085
of imagining freedom.

Title: "The Legacy of Toni Morrison: Revolutionary Thinker and Linguist"

00:00:00 - Antonio Morrison died in 2019. Angela Davis and Farrah Jasmine Griffin published an op-ed in the New York Times in which they hailed her as a revolutionary political thinker. now she's better known, of course, as a Nobel Prize winner, as a literary artist. but this formulation, Morrison is a revolutionary political thinker, struck me as exactly right. Morrison has been a guide and essential guide to my own work as a political theorist since I was a graduate student, and especially for thinking about the relationship of language and politics.
00:00:36 - graduate school was stunningly silent on the questions of race and racism and on slavery, colonialism and their legacies Morrison's writings filled that void. One of her greatest and maybe least appreciated contributions is her profound exploration of the meaning of freedom. And I first came to understand this, in the classroom. that is to say that, as I was working with undergraduates, I found,
00:01:09 - I should say that this matters in the US and Morrison is particularly helpful in this regard, because freedom is one of the most inspiring and overused and trivi trivialized words in our political lexicon. but at this political moment, and I think we saw this with the most recent election, Americans don't use this word to mean the same thing. The meanings are pulling apart. And part of the reason for this, I think, is that,

"Exploring Freedom and Oppression in Toni Morrison's Work"

00:01:39 - as a democratic society founded both in, the value of liberty and the right to enslave. And this is really where Morrison's work, zeroes in, that she, she is one of the most acute, interpreters of what she called the question of what, what it means to live in a nation of people who decided that their worldview would combine agendas for individual freedom with mechanisms for devastating racial oppression.
00:02:09 - but especially in her 1987 novel, beloved, which I frequently inspire in the, inspire, a sign in the classroom. No, wait. Do that, do that, do that one sentence. Okay. Good thing. Okay. we see this in all of her work, and especially in her 1987 novel, beloved, which I, frequently assign in the classroom. I think a, a critical text, for understanding the meanings of freedom, both in the US
00:02:40 - because it's not simply about freedom, from the front matter that is from the epigraph and the dedication to the very last page, beloved makes vivid how women, men, and children living under conditions of extreme duress have struggled to emancipate themselves and to emancipate each other. these are people who know what freedom means, because they can't take it for granted. Morrison, transforms freedom in the novel, from a definition or a concept into a living thing.

"Redefining Freedom: The Collective Struggle Through Morrison's Lens"

00:03:14 - and an aspiration that one can touch, taste, feel here, as well as know. and very quickly, there are three features of the novel that I think really illustrate this. first, the novel as a story. reorients readers away from abstract and typically masculine understandings of what freedom means. she focuses on the vantage of enslaved women, for whom, such basic human acts as choosing whom to love
00:03:46 - second, she attends to the ways in which people forge solidarity under extreme duress. So whether it's on, the plantation on the chain gang, and the flight from slavery, or in the brutal world, after, the Civil War, she counters, the idea that freedom is an individual value and shows how the individual freedom is always bound up with the collective. And third, and finally, the vivid portraits that she paints
00:04:19 - above, the institution on which they depend of abolitionists, who harbor racist ideas, and even of children who are trained into the habits of mastery from a very early age, cautions against mistaking white freedom, for freedom itself. And I think this is one of the ways in which she offers a, her narratives as a counter, a counterweight to the emphasis on freedom as white freedom

"Exploring 'Word Work': Toni Morrison's Concept of Language as Agency and Power"

00:04:49 - In the book, I focus on what Morrison calls word work as a practice of freedom. And she introduces the phrase, in her 1997 Nobel lecture on literature, and I should say, as an aside, it's available through the Nobel Prize website. And I, I recommend that anyone, with any interest in language in Morrison, or just interest in spending a beautiful 40 minutes listen to the audio of, of her lecture.
00:05:19 - and here I'm quoting that word, work is sublime because it is generative. It makes meaning that secures our difference, our human difference, the way in which we are not like no other life language, in other words, in Morrison's view, is a kind of agency. It's the wellspring of, of our creativity, in fact, of our, of our being. At the same time, Morrison also addresses the violence that is done to language, whether by heads of state, by corporate leaders, by academics, by patriots,
00:05:52 - the ways in which the use of words can silence or kill. and so the Nobel Lecture offers eloquent testimony to the generative power of board work, and at the same time, to the urgency of wielding that power with care for the lives, that it destroys or enables. I think even though she pursues this idea that language can be liberating in Oliver, work, she's especially interested in how the, the novel

"Storytelling as a Framework for Ethical Responsibility and Community in Morrison's Work"

00:06:24 - readers think about the relationship between race and freedom. In fact, she says that, storytelling is where the serious ethical debates are happening. and it is a way of forging community in the face of race or racial terror, or estrangement. It can move readers to see the world anew, and it treats the lives of the enslaved, the dispossessed, the hunted, as worthy of everyone's concern. and we can see this, I think,
00:06:55 - I mean, there are many, many examples, but I was thinking about two in particular. The first is the word responsibility, which is a word that occurs across both her novels, and her, her nonfiction writings. And in fact, across her interviews, it's a word that she spend a lot of time thinking about. And I think we often, talk about freedom and responsibility as being linked in the sense that, you know, for those of us who have children, we tell them to make good choices as a condition of their,
00:07:26 - it means being, both having an opportunity to choose what to do or to be, and a capacity to do it rightly, and Morrison doesn't disagree, but where the language of personal responsibility has often been used as a kind of a cudgel, as a way of blaming people who are vulnerable for their situations. Morrison inverts this idea, indeed, she says, as a novelist, she wants to assume responsibility for people no one's ever assumed responsibility for.

"Exploring Responsibility and Motherhood in Toni Morrison's 'Beloved'"

00:07:59 - of people, whose situations are most precarious, and asks, how it is that they, they act accountably to themselves and to each other, often in ways that are disregarded by, historians and commentators. So in Beloved, for instance, you know, being responsible for one's children was actually illegal if you were an enslaved person. and the burden, this burden fell hardest on mothers,
00:08:31 - have their legacies in the contemporary world. We see the ways in which, motherhood, especially among poor women and women of color, is often criminalized. and so the novel follows the remarkable acts of creativity and plotting that were required so that, especially Seth, who's one of the central characters, an enslaved mother, enables her children to escape from slavery, struggles to feed and to nurture them and to give them a future.
00:09:02 - of the white characters who believed they were the responsible ones, just as policymakers today, often figure themselves as, as responsible as their chastising, vulnerable people, and presume that the freedom of the enslaved is rightly in their hands, even as they take no responsibility for the injustice of slavery. So that's one example. Another is the way in which Morrison approaches the word home. her novels, often focus on people

"Exploring the Complexities of Home, Freedom, and Violence in Toni Morrison's Work"

00:09:36 - and regularly on the move against their will. These are enslaved people. These are fugitives, migrants, refugees, the dispossessed from the 17th century to the 21st. So there's this some amazing kind of scope, historical scope in her writing. at the same time, she is, she, like many feminist thinkers is acutely conscious how, violence often takes place inside the home,
00:10:08 - and in the sense of a homeland. In fact, she's interested in the lives of people who are in her words, not at home in their homeland. so what does it mean, for instance, to be at home in my my state, the state of Virginia, if you are a black woman, who was enslaved and is now some somewhat emancipated, but living with the, the violence and the, the ever present threat of dispossession, especially if you attempt to act politically, in,
00:10:44 - at a time when anti-black terror was preventing the establishment of, multiracial democracy? When Morrison talks about home, I think she is trying to think about how, in her words, to be both free and situated. It's something that people deeply desire, and it's also something that can kill them. Fiction for her becomes a site where she can explore these different meanings, how they fit together, and how they are intention or even in mortal contradiction with each other.

"Language as a Site of Power and Resistance in Morrison's Work"

00:11:14 - the language in which he writes and thinks and dreams is also, the master's tongue. That is, it's the language of racial slavery, of indigenous dispossession. And it's not possible simply to wish, or to will racism or sexism away, because they're embedded in the language that she uses. so on the one hand, she, resists the idea, refuses the idea that we can simply transcend racial categories.
00:11:46 - just pretend that race doesn't matter and go on about our business. and on the other hand, she, she wants to think about how it is that ra that language can be reshaped, can be bent, or in her words, manipulated, so that racial categories retain their historical specificity. That is, they're still rooted in the experiences of people who have been raised, but not their capacity to murder.
00:12:16 - of American English that's capacious enough, to articulate the complexity of US history, to re to transform a tool of unfreedom into a medium emancipation. And I think she does this in two ways. First, she emphasizes that the beauty and complexity of of black linguistic forms and cultural traditions, infuse and structure her art so that she uses,

"Reimagining Race and Language: The Innovative Narrative Techniques of Toni Morrison"

00:12:46 - phrases in idioms that are, distinct creations of African American culture, orality and emphasis on improvisation, on call response, and on collective values as a way of trying to create a language as her, as she puts it, that is worthy of black culture. At the same time, she also subverts racial categories in these really ingenious ways by playing with reader's expectations.
00:13:17 - they shoot the white girl first, and then the novel goes on, to tell you who the they is or they are, but she refuses to divulge which character is the white girl. And the point here is not to highlight race, but to get it out of the way as she puts it, to, to play with our expectations to say, what do we lose if we actually don't know the racial identities of the characters? For sure. And I think the point of both of these strategies is to create
00:13:48 - with people that is not, doesn't impose a new order on them, but invites them to rethink, to re-see the world that they live in. And I think it's crucial that she sees fiction writing. It's not a form of policymaking, but it is a collaborative enterprise, and she tries to find ways to bring the reader in, to enable them in effect, to complete the story. One thing that I think was extraordinarily prescient was that Morrison opened her last published book in 2019,

"Defending the Power of Words: Morrison's Call to Protect Writers Against Censorship"

00:14:22 - that was entitled Peril. this was a speech that she had delivered in 2009, but she came back to it 10 years later to warn against the threat of regimes that censor, harass or exile writers. and she appeals to her fellow writers to protect each other against the authoritarian encroachments and to persist in doing the work that she sees is distinctly the work of writers. And here, I would say both fiction writers and, and, writers working
00:14:53 - to use their imaginative gifts to translate trauma, cruelty, and exploitation into, what I referred, referred to a minute ago as a shareable world. and I think these words resonate especially forcefully today, when writers, particularly women non-white queer and other minoritized writers are, and their publications have become targets of political repression around the world. just as, journalists are silenced
00:15:22 - or record, no numbers globally in the us, where they haven't been threatened personally. their books are being banned in schools and libraries. Morrison's first novel, the Bluest Eye is always on the top 10 list of books that are banned in the us And writers like Morrison who attempt to grapple with slavery and its legacies are often depicted as woke or even racist. while teaching the history of race and racism has been legally restricted. And Morrison focuses on the peril facing writers.

"Language as Liberation: The Lasting Legacy of Toni Morrison"

00:15:55 - that it's not just the writers themselves, but everyone's freedom that's at stake. the work of words matter, she says, because all next are on the line. and I think fortunately, she not only leaves readers with a warning, she leaves us with 11 novels and countless essays and addresses and other kinds of, of writing that's a testament to the generative power of language. I think her work, all of it, enlist readers as participants in carrying forward her unfinished project
00:16:25 -

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis