ValuJet Flight 592: Crisis communication theory blended and extended

Key Question Being Explored in This Insight:

Donald Fishman discusses the integration of three crisis communication approaches as it analyzes the crash of ValuJet Flight 592

View the page of: Donald Fishman

Institution: Boston College

Explore more insights in:

Journalism and Media Professional

Media Literacy Toolkit

Faculti's Media Literacy Toolkit helps viewers critically engage with academic insights by analyzing the research context, identifying perspectives, and encouraging thoughtful evaluation.

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

What assumptions does the research make?
Are there alternative perspectives not explored?
What are the limitations of the research method?

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

This research comes from Boston College . Reflect on how the institution's academic focus and research partnerships may shape the questions being explored.

Further Reading ▼

Read the Study

Donald Fishman discusses the integration of three crisis communication approaches as it analyzes the crash of ValuJet Flight 592

Image courtesy of interviewee. June 11, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video discusses the Value Jet Flight 592 disaster, which occurred in 1996, highlighting its significance within crisis communication. Value Jet was a discount airline that emerged as part of a new segment promoted by the FAA, which aimed to make air travel more affordable. However, the flight from Miami to Atlanta faced an electrical disturbance, resulting in a tragic crash over the Florida Everglades, leading to the deaths of all 110 people on board. The fire burned so intensely that remnants of the aircraft were virtually non-existent, complicating recovery efforts, such as locating the black box.

The author utilizes this crisis as a case study to explore theories of crisis communication, emphasizing the three necessary criteria for a crisis: sudden occurrence, a threat to important values, and a short response time. Additionally, the text outlines four stages of a crisis according to Stephen Fink's stage theory: prodromal (warning signs), acute (the actual crisis event), chronic (investigation and reform), and crisis resolution.

The discussion also incorporates strategy theory, particularly William Benoit’s strategies for managing reputation during a crisis, like denial, minimizing offensiveness, and corrective action. Furthermore, the narrative touches on the concept of focusing events—sudden occurrences that capture public attention and often lead to changes in perception or policy. The collapse of Value Jet serves as an emblematic case of poor safety oversight, illustrating how conflicting priorities within regulatory agencies can lead to tragic outcomes.

Ultimately, the text argues for a comprehensive understanding of crisis situations by combining insights from various theories, stressing the importance of preparedness and proactive crisis management, especially within organizations. The author advocates for the establishment of crisis communication managers and emergency preparedness plans to mitigate the impacts of future crises.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.055 --> 00:04.205
Value Jett Flight 92 took off in 1996.

00:05.505 --> 00:08.115
What was interesting about Value Jett is

00:08.115 --> 00:10.435
that it was a discount airline.

00:10.935 --> 00:15.515
Uh, the FAA wanted to promote this whole new segment of

00:16.295 --> 00:19.275
air communica airline communication.

00:19.575 --> 00:23.875
And so Value Jet happened to be one of the poster children

00:24.215 --> 00:27.395
for this new line of airlines.

00:27.745 --> 00:30.315
Southwest was probably the most prominent one

00:30.315 --> 00:33.475
that has survived in that, unfortunately,

00:34.255 --> 00:35.915
having taken off in Miami

00:36.455 --> 00:38.075
and heading toward Atlanta,

00:39.215 --> 00:41.915
it had an electrical disturbance right away,

00:42.415 --> 00:46.675
and 110 people died over the Florida Everglades.

00:47.015 --> 00:50.835
The fire was so strong that you didn't have seats,

00:50.895 --> 00:53.435
you didn't have metal, you had virtually nothing on

00:53.435 --> 00:54.555
the Everglades.

00:54.555 --> 00:57.195
And looking for the black box was hard.

00:57.775 --> 01:02.485
And so the question became, how did this crisis occur?

01:03.105 --> 01:04.765
Who was responsible for it?

01:05.065 --> 01:07.205
And how do we explain it in this context?

01:07.825 --> 01:12.005
And so I used the Value Jet Airline crash

01:12.465 --> 01:16.765
as a vehicle for bringing together several theories

01:16.865 --> 01:19.445
and several elements of crisis communication.

01:20.035 --> 01:22.325
That was the context in which it occurred.

01:22.685 --> 01:25.125
A lot of people use the word crisis in sort

01:25.125 --> 01:26.525
of everyday language.

01:26.625 --> 01:30.125
And so newspapers love to talk about, crisis,

01:30.865 --> 01:35.605
and that we had a more specific notion of what a crisis is.

01:36.145 --> 01:38.685
Um, in order to have a crisis, you have

01:38.685 --> 01:39.845
to meet three criteria.

01:40.305 --> 01:42.565
One criteria is something occurs sudden.

01:43.145 --> 01:45.805
So a lot of problems occur

01:45.805 --> 01:48.365
because they're simmering, they simmer for a long time,

01:48.425 --> 01:50.405
and then they finally blow over.

01:50.505 --> 01:54.765
And that, for crisis to occur, something happens to have

01:55.495 --> 01:58.765
occur sudden, much like with the challenger disaster,

01:58.895 --> 02:03.715
where we had so many, shuttles that flew,

02:04.015 --> 02:06.835
routinely in that, but then you had a crash.

02:06.975 --> 02:10.475
So it has to be something that number one is sudden.

02:10.475 --> 02:13.275
Number two, it has to be a threat to important value.

02:13.575 --> 02:17.155
So you're on your way to work today, you have a flat tire,

02:18.095 --> 02:20.075
you pull off to the side.

02:20.095 --> 02:25.065
Is that a crisis? Well, it may be to you a traumatic event,

02:25.605 --> 02:29.105
but actually you pull out your phone, you call aaa

02:29.165 --> 02:31.225
or you call one of the, services.

02:31.445 --> 02:34.825
And that, it's just a distraction or a nuisance.

02:36.065 --> 02:38.185
A threat to important values has

02:38.185 --> 02:39.625
to really hit important values.

02:40.135 --> 02:42.745
I'll give you an example of a threat to important values.

02:43.405 --> 02:47.945
The University of Minnesota, had a basketball team

02:47.945 --> 02:50.785
that made the men's basketball bracket

02:51.085 --> 02:53.985
for the NCA tournament on the eve

02:53.985 --> 02:57.505
of their playing in the game, it was revealed that

02:58.425 --> 02:59.475
somebody had written papers

03:00.015 --> 03:02.715
for 15 basketball players on the team.

03:04.065 --> 03:06.575
Well, is this a crisis?

03:07.115 --> 03:10.015
Uh, there's nothing more important than academic life

03:10.045 --> 03:11.455
than academic integrity.

03:12.275 --> 03:15.215
And in fact, the team was pulled from the tournament.

03:15.875 --> 03:18.815
Uh, the basketball coach was eventually fired.

03:19.235 --> 03:21.455
The athletic director for women was fired,

03:21.555 --> 03:23.015
the athletic director for men

03:23.015 --> 03:25.975
and the vice president for, student affairs.

03:26.155 --> 03:30.015
And so, a crisis has to be a threat to important values.

03:30.275 --> 03:32.615
And the third element is that,

03:32.615 --> 03:34.255
there's a short response time.

03:34.715 --> 03:35.735
You don't have forever.

03:36.365 --> 03:40.415
With an airline crash, you usually have to get

03:41.095 --> 03:42.335
a message to the public,

03:42.435 --> 03:45.935
and it could be a standby message within four hours.

03:46.035 --> 03:47.815
And the message may say something like this,

03:48.275 --> 03:50.015
we haven't recovered the black box.

03:50.545 --> 03:51.935
We're not sure what happened,

03:52.115 --> 03:53.655
but we're looking for the black box.

03:53.795 --> 03:55.895
And as soon as we have any

03:55.895 --> 03:57.575
information, we'll relay it to you.

03:58.075 --> 04:00.855
And the reason you do this in the airline industry is

04:00.855 --> 04:04.295
that 20% of the public is scared of flying anyways.

04:04.595 --> 04:07.375
You've got another 30% that have anxieties.

04:07.395 --> 04:10.935
And so you have to calm a public that this was an atypical

04:11.235 --> 04:12.335
or an anomaly.

04:12.955 --> 04:15.695
Uh, but you don't wanna let a lot of time go

04:15.755 --> 04:17.575
by an academic life.

04:17.575 --> 04:21.015
When somebody attacks an article you've written,

04:21.075 --> 04:23.015
the response may be six months

04:23.075 --> 04:27.015
or a year later, that doesn't happen in a crisis situation.

04:27.315 --> 04:28.815
The response has to be immediate.

04:29.275 --> 04:32.655
So for a crisis to occur, we have three elements, surprise,

04:32.835 --> 04:36.255
threat to important value and a short response time.

04:36.635 --> 04:40.495
And those three constitute what we think of as a crisis.

04:40.915 --> 04:44.215
And there are crisis situations which have to be responded

04:44.215 --> 04:45.535
to for a long time.

04:45.735 --> 04:48.615
I used to go to a, we had crisis conferences.

04:48.715 --> 04:50.415
And the crisis conferences started

04:50.465 --> 04:54.215
after the Exxon Bel Ds, where you had academics.

04:54.215 --> 04:56.975
You had people who were government regulators,

04:57.195 --> 04:58.935
you had people from corporations.

04:59.315 --> 05:00.615
And we tell war stories.

05:00.995 --> 05:03.295
And the war stories would often be interesting.

05:03.605 --> 05:05.775
They often involve lots of people in that,

05:06.235 --> 05:10.215
but you didn't get a sense of how you could proceed.

05:10.515 --> 05:13.255
And so the academics started getting together,

05:13.475 --> 05:17.055
and we started talking about how do we explain these things?

05:17.195 --> 05:19.415
We could have 2000 war stories,

05:19.755 --> 05:22.135
but you haven't developed any principles.

05:22.585 --> 05:26.635
Eventually, out of these conferences, we developed several

05:27.515 --> 05:29.675
approaches to how to study a crisis.

05:30.255 --> 05:32.635
One approach, we'll call a stage,

05:32.735 --> 05:34.515
theory and stage theory.

05:34.515 --> 05:35.795
And there are several theorists.

05:35.935 --> 05:38.035
The one I like best is Stephen Fink.

05:38.455 --> 05:41.675
Uh, stage theory is really a natural history,

05:41.945 --> 05:43.195
evolution of a crisis.

05:43.695 --> 05:45.915
And natural history means something has a

05:45.915 --> 05:47.115
beginning, middle, and end.

05:47.455 --> 05:50.955
In the case of Stephen Fink, he's really got four stages

05:51.265 --> 05:52.875
that each crisis goes through.

05:53.735 --> 05:56.075
The first stage is something called the prodromal,

05:56.375 --> 05:59.485
or it's a Greek word, meaning running ahead.

05:59.905 --> 06:02.885
And he says that there are warning signs

06:02.915 --> 06:04.445
that run ahead of a crisis.

06:04.905 --> 06:06.845
In the case of the Challenger disaster,

06:07.465 --> 06:10.285
the o-rings had not sealed 19 times before.

06:11.365 --> 06:12.625
So there were warning signs

06:12.925 --> 06:15.825
and astute manager would've noticed there's a problem

06:15.855 --> 06:18.185
with the O rings, thicks the problem

06:18.205 --> 06:19.785
before it actually took off.

06:20.405 --> 06:23.625
The second stage fin is the acute stage.

06:23.925 --> 06:27.225
And the acute stage is where something happens.

06:27.725 --> 06:30.265
In the case of value, jet flight 5 92,

06:30.845 --> 06:33.025
the acute stage was the

06:33.535 --> 06:35.825
explosion over the Florida Everglades.

06:36.245 --> 06:39.025
The acute stage is often the shortest part of a crisis.

06:39.605 --> 06:42.305
In the case of values that it lasted about 10 days

06:42.405 --> 06:44.905
as they went on a scavenger hunt, looking for the bodies,

06:44.905 --> 06:46.265
looking for the black box.

06:46.965 --> 06:49.465
The third stage is the a chronic stage.

06:49.805 --> 06:51.025
And the chronic stage is

06:51.025 --> 06:52.945
where you investigate what happened.

06:53.445 --> 06:57.265
You make changes along the way. You implement reforms.

06:57.475 --> 07:00.065
Oftentimes you fire managers and that,

07:00.645 --> 07:03.105
and this is the longest of the four stages.

07:03.885 --> 07:05.625
And then the crisis resolution.

07:05.845 --> 07:08.625
And the definition of a crisis resolution for f is

07:08.695 --> 07:11.545
that the company has made whole again.

07:12.005 --> 07:13.825
And so the company has made whole,

07:14.045 --> 07:16.825
and you start looking for new prodromes along the way.

07:17.245 --> 07:21.345
So the four stages for Fink were, the prodromal,

07:21.365 --> 07:24.145
the acute, the chronic, and the crisis resolution.

07:24.605 --> 07:27.985
That's a natural history. There were other stage theorists.

07:28.125 --> 07:31.025
The stage theory is a really useful way

07:31.025 --> 07:32.265
of thinking about a crisis.

07:33.145 --> 07:36.225
A second approach, a very different orientation,

07:37.005 --> 07:38.305
is strategy theory.

07:38.885 --> 07:42.425
And the strategy theory that I like best is William Benoit.

07:42.885 --> 07:47.785
And strategy, theory is centered on reputation and image.

07:48.885 --> 07:51.825
Uh, much like economics is designed,

07:52.045 --> 07:54.505
to talk about profit maximizing activity.

07:55.365 --> 07:57.465
In communication, we're concerned with

07:58.235 --> 08:00.545
reputation maximizing activity.

08:00.965 --> 08:02.265
And so either an individual

08:02.565 --> 08:06.025
or an organization has a reputation that they wanna protect.

08:06.725 --> 08:08.505
And Benoit says that

08:10.115 --> 08:13.795
a crisis occurs when there's an attack on your reputation.

08:14.195 --> 08:15.635
Somebody has said something offensive

08:16.375 --> 08:18.035
and that it hits you directly.

08:18.535 --> 08:22.155
And for him, there are five strategies in which you can

08:24.145 --> 08:28.705
minimize or, reduce, excuse me,

08:28.705 --> 08:32.225
the attack, one of the strategies is called just denial.

08:32.885 --> 08:35.705
Uh, whatever you said is not true. Uh, it's false.

08:36.025 --> 08:38.945
I didn't do it. And so, a variation

08:38.945 --> 08:41.025
of denial is, scapegoating.

08:41.215 --> 08:43.745
Yeah, it was done, but was done by somebody else.

08:44.205 --> 08:48.025
Uh, it wasn't me. And so denial is one strategy.

08:48.285 --> 08:52.225
Second strategy is reducing the offensiveness where you try

08:52.225 --> 08:54.825
to reduce the offensiveness of it.

08:55.385 --> 08:57.645
Uh, and here you can use minimization.

08:57.985 --> 08:59.565
You can use displacement.

08:59.895 --> 09:03.405
There are various things that you can use in order to,

09:03.625 --> 09:05.645
reduce the offensiveness of it.

09:06.695 --> 09:09.015
A third is invasion of responsibility.

09:09.475 --> 09:13.375
Uh, where you try to show that you had a good intentions

09:13.595 --> 09:15.215
or an accident occurred,

09:15.755 --> 09:19.395
or his most interesting,

09:19.505 --> 09:21.235
variation is the feasibility.

09:21.415 --> 09:23.315
Things just got out of control.

09:23.775 --> 09:28.355
Uh, and the Exxon Ved, the weather was calm for three days

09:28.415 --> 09:29.715
and then the weather was bad,

09:29.935 --> 09:32.715
and you couldn't bring in an easy rescue crew.

09:33.055 --> 09:36.675
And so, that became part of

09:38.725 --> 09:40.725
re evasion of responsibility.

09:41.305 --> 09:45.685
Uh, the nice fourth category is a corrective action.

09:45.865 --> 09:49.445
And here's where people make cor corrections or reforms.

09:50.025 --> 09:52.965
You implement measures so that it won't happen again.

09:53.585 --> 09:57.365
And his stiff category is apologies or mortification.

09:57.875 --> 09:59.325
Here you express regret.

09:59.825 --> 10:02.445
You express, problems along the way.

10:02.825 --> 10:07.325
Uh, the problem with expressing regret though, is that

10:07.985 --> 10:10.685
as other people point it out, there's a trade off.

10:11.515 --> 10:15.415
Uh, if I say I'm sorry, I really didn't mean to do it,

10:15.675 --> 10:17.695
it opens me up to legal liability.

10:18.155 --> 10:19.295
And so a lot

10:19.295 --> 10:22.255
of companies use what's called the equivocal apology.

10:22.795 --> 10:24.695
Uh, I'm really sorry.

10:24.795 --> 10:26.455
The problem occurred, but you never

10:26.475 --> 10:27.855
say I caused the problem.

10:28.435 --> 10:30.215
You always have something that

10:30.755 --> 10:32.815
is very ambivalent along the way.

10:33.515 --> 10:36.695
So that was the third, a fourth of,

10:36.715 --> 10:38.015
benoy strategies.

10:38.635 --> 10:42.695
Uh, his last strategy is, ification.

10:42.875 --> 10:46.975
So you've got five strategies that he has as part of

10:48.615 --> 10:49.915
how to handle a crisis.

10:50.615 --> 10:54.395
And the last major orientation I look at at,

10:54.395 --> 10:56.635
especially in this article, is focusing event.

10:57.155 --> 11:00.895
A focusing event is a sudden event

11:01.205 --> 11:02.775
that captures public attention.

11:03.275 --> 11:05.975
And that event sort of crystallizes lots

11:05.975 --> 11:07.295
of issues along the way.

11:08.115 --> 11:11.795
Uh, probably the best example

11:11.815 --> 11:14.115
of a focus event is something like Columbine.

11:14.615 --> 11:17.275
We had had school shootings before Columbine.

11:17.685 --> 11:20.355
Often they occurred in urban areas,

11:20.755 --> 11:22.835
drive-by shootings or in rural areas.

11:23.695 --> 11:26.865
What was so devastating about Columbine,

11:27.645 --> 11:30.385
it occurred in an upper middle class town,

11:30.495 --> 11:31.665
Littleton, Colorado.

11:32.485 --> 11:37.215
Uh, it occurred in an area where people moved to,

11:37.675 --> 11:40.055
to get away from the ills of urban society.

11:40.435 --> 11:44.735
And so it became an event that crystallized public opinion.

11:45.145 --> 11:48.745
There were five cover stories on Time Magazine,

11:48.875 --> 11:52.385
about school shootings, about, what happens.

11:53.625 --> 11:57.885
Uh, it, led to a lot of attention along the way.

11:58.685 --> 12:02.085
Berkland, who's the chief theorist of focusing event, says

12:02.085 --> 12:06.605
that a focusing event will lead to a legislative enactment.

12:06.605 --> 12:08.245
People will pass legislation

12:08.245 --> 12:09.925
to prevent this from happening again.

12:10.745 --> 12:13.525
My approach is that a focus event often leads

12:13.545 --> 12:14.845
to a rhetorical symbol.

12:15.305 --> 12:19.885
So Columbine did not have a legislative enactment.

12:20.385 --> 12:23.005
Uh, television people argue that,

12:23.305 --> 12:26.325
and computer people argued that, the First Amendment

12:26.955 --> 12:28.365
stopped the government from

12:29.455 --> 12:32.105
issuing a new regulations gun.

12:32.105 --> 12:33.985
People said the Second Amendment stopped

12:33.985 --> 12:35.145
people from doing this.

12:35.805 --> 12:38.825
And so there was never any major legislation.

12:39.245 --> 12:40.945
But Columbine has become a symbol.

12:41.085 --> 12:42.825
And anytime we've had a school shooting,

12:43.245 --> 12:47.625
and since Columbine in 1990, nine, we have had

12:48.415 --> 12:51.065
several school shootings along the way.

12:51.285 --> 12:54.665
And everybody brings up Columbine as the template

12:54.725 --> 12:56.145
for here's what happens.

12:56.365 --> 13:01.025
So a focusing events is a way of looking at how the public

13:01.945 --> 13:03.705
actually focuses on something.

13:04.175 --> 13:07.065
It's an agenda setting part of the media,

13:07.645 --> 13:11.665
how the agenda is set by the media in order for

13:12.645 --> 13:15.705
public opinion to crystallize on one topic.

13:16.325 --> 13:18.225
So there's three different approaches

13:18.225 --> 13:21.905
that I look at in this article, stage theory, strategy,

13:21.925 --> 13:24.225
theory and focusing event.

13:24.605 --> 13:25.825
And all three have it.

13:26.285 --> 13:30.025
My argument is that the best way to understand the crisis is

13:30.025 --> 13:32.545
to take elements from all three approaches

13:32.965 --> 13:35.505
to actually get a more comprehensive view

13:35.605 --> 13:36.785
of what a crisis is

13:36.785 --> 13:37.785
Like. Why is

13:37.785 --> 13:39.105
value jet lasting?

13:39.255 --> 13:41.465
It's 25 years since I wrote the article.

13:41.895 --> 13:44.025
What was special about value jet

13:44.555 --> 13:47.465
value jet was a discount airline.

13:47.965 --> 13:50.585
The FAA was put into a dual role.

13:51.045 --> 13:54.265
On the one hand, it wanted to promote this discount segment

13:54.805 --> 13:56.145
of the airline industry.

13:56.745 --> 13:58.825
Discount airlines were affordable.

13:59.015 --> 14:00.945
They offered easy access to people.

14:01.485 --> 14:04.465
The seaport Small, they have no frills,

14:04.525 --> 14:05.705
no extra food in that.

14:05.925 --> 14:09.785
But part of the FAA wanted to promote this as a way

14:09.785 --> 14:11.465
of people moving.

14:12.005 --> 14:14.745
On the other hand, the fa a's mandate is

14:14.745 --> 14:16.185
to provide for public safety.

14:16.885 --> 14:20.705
And so, you had conflicting goals we wanna both promote

14:21.125 --> 14:23.505
as well as measure public safety.

14:23.845 --> 14:26.985
So there was something special about the value jet case.

14:27.445 --> 14:30.465
You had a federal agency that was caught in

14:30.855 --> 14:32.905
with dual purposes and acted

14:32.995 --> 14:34.985
Badly Because they should have

14:36.085 --> 14:37.975
monitored value jet ahead of time.

14:38.075 --> 14:39.215
And indeed, they claimed

14:39.645 --> 14:43.455
that they had monitored 5,000 value jet

14:43.455 --> 14:44.655
flights ahead of time.

14:45.685 --> 14:46.705
So What happened?

14:46.855 --> 14:51.485
Well, there had been warning signs that value jet was

14:52.445 --> 14:54.405
a problematic airline value.

14:54.545 --> 14:57.805
Jet often bought planes from other companies

14:58.105 --> 14:59.645
and then reconditioned them.

14:59.905 --> 15:03.295
But these planes were predisposed

15:03.295 --> 15:04.895
to have accidents and value.

15:04.995 --> 15:08.295
Jet had a higher rate of accident than what was normal

15:08.915 --> 15:10.575
in the airline industry.

15:11.155 --> 15:13.775
And the FAA sort of let it slide.

15:14.195 --> 15:17.735
So in the prodromal where you could've actually intervened,

15:18.195 --> 15:22.135
the FAA just let it go, in the acute,

15:22.795 --> 15:24.135
it was a terrible tragedy.

15:24.435 --> 15:27.655
You could not find any remnants of the bodies at all.

15:28.395 --> 15:31.735
Uh, people combed the Flora Everglades, they were able

15:31.735 --> 15:34.535
to find, the black box eventually,

15:34.675 --> 15:36.455
but it was a difficult thing.

15:36.765 --> 15:40.495
What turns out is the Arrow values

15:40.565 --> 15:43.615
that Flight 5 92 was carrying some oxygen tanks.

15:43.795 --> 15:46.415
And those oxygen tanks exploded

15:46.755 --> 15:49.735
and the way that didn't leave any remnants

15:49.735 --> 15:50.775
of the plane at all.

15:50.955 --> 15:54.895
And so there was a question, do you allow these airplanes

15:54.955 --> 15:59.015
to actually carry these oxygen tanks in this kind

15:59.015 --> 16:01.575
of a manner, especially if it was an older, plane.

16:01.835 --> 16:04.415
And so the acute raised some questions.

16:04.675 --> 16:09.375
The chronic is people started investigating a value jet,

16:10.235 --> 16:13.735
and value jet had cut corners, had not done the kind

16:13.735 --> 16:14.935
of maintenance it needed.

16:15.635 --> 16:18.495
It was able to postpone maintenance in order

16:18.555 --> 16:20.135
to keep the prices down.

16:20.275 --> 16:21.295
And so,

16:21.485 --> 16:24.415
what was interesting about its pricing structure is

16:24.615 --> 16:27.095
that it achieved those economies,

16:27.235 --> 16:29.575
but only by neglecting the kinds of things

16:29.575 --> 16:30.655
that should have been done.

16:31.195 --> 16:34.255
And so there was a question about whether values Jett would

16:34.255 --> 16:35.295
be able to exist.

16:35.555 --> 16:39.335
And indeed, values Jet had to change its name.

16:39.835 --> 16:42.335
The public was so alarmed by this.

16:42.635 --> 16:45.575
Now, there were other discount airlines.

16:45.805 --> 16:48.855
Many of them went by the wayside.

16:49.275 --> 16:52.015
Uh, we had something called People's Express in the

16:52.295 --> 16:53.495
nineties that came out of Newark.

16:54.045 --> 16:57.295
Southwest Airline was the best of the discount,

16:57.515 --> 16:58.935
but,

16:59.105 --> 17:02.535
value Jet could not survive in its current way.

17:03.195 --> 17:08.015
You saw value jet fighting back using many of OID strategies

17:08.205 --> 17:11.015
that, it was a good airline,

17:11.085 --> 17:14.335
that it bolstered it record of how it served people

17:14.475 --> 17:17.135
and that, so it followed a pattern in that.

17:17.475 --> 17:19.495
But this became a focusing a bit.

17:19.795 --> 17:21.935
And the reason it did is

17:21.935 --> 17:26.295
that you had con contradictory goals by a federal agency

17:26.685 --> 17:29.695
that was designed to supervise this, company.

17:30.315 --> 17:33.855
And that just defaulted on what its responsibility is.

17:33.875 --> 17:37.815
And so value Jet becomes the poster child for

17:39.295 --> 17:42.305
this is bad government and bad industry.

17:42.815 --> 17:44.065
What I did in the work,

17:44.205 --> 17:46.865
and actually I was trying to find a good vehicle

17:47.285 --> 17:48.425
for looking at theory.

17:49.065 --> 17:51.485
Uh, if you're gonna work in a field like crisis

17:51.925 --> 17:54.405
communication, war stories aren't enough.

17:54.665 --> 17:58.965
Uh, I have a database with had,

17:58.975 --> 18:01.645
which has 2000 crisis events.

18:02.065 --> 18:03.685
We have crisis events all the time.

18:04.345 --> 18:07.565
Uh, the other day, the Francis Scott Keybridge

18:08.065 --> 18:12.325
and Baltimore collapse, how that collapsed,

18:12.905 --> 18:16.125
why the whole bridge collapsed in the way,

18:16.235 --> 18:18.805
what was happening, on the ship,

18:19.225 --> 18:20.885
why they didn't have some precautions.

18:20.955 --> 18:23.005
There's this theory in crisis communication

18:23.005 --> 18:24.805
that talks about high reliability,

18:25.275 --> 18:28.045
that even if an accident is about to occur,

18:28.045 --> 18:29.205
there are backup systems

18:29.745 --> 18:32.685
and there should have been backup systems for power on this,

18:32.785 --> 18:34.165
cargo ship.

18:34.165 --> 18:38.305
In that, I look upon

18:39.295 --> 18:44.265
this article as a way of trying to make theory relevant

18:44.265 --> 18:47.065
and looking for theoretical perspectives

18:47.605 --> 18:50.625
to make crisis communication a solid field.

18:51.085 --> 18:54.665
Beside the three, the theories that I identify,

18:55.035 --> 18:57.505
there are theories like high reliability theory,

18:57.565 --> 18:59.945
normal accident theory, chaos theory.

19:00.365 --> 19:03.025
And so we've tried to take events and do that.

19:03.525 --> 19:06.825
The importance of this in the long run is that,

19:07.175 --> 19:09.905
most insurance companies are not paying off

19:10.605 --> 19:14.855
if a company hasn't done some work ahead of time.

19:15.315 --> 19:17.175
Uh, evacuation behavior.

19:17.555 --> 19:20.615
How many companies have ever seen an evacuation behavior?

19:21.195 --> 19:25.215
Uh, how, how do you organize your employees? What do you do?

19:25.365 --> 19:28.415
What if you have an active shooter, on the premises?

19:28.635 --> 19:29.695
How do you handle that?

19:30.075 --> 19:33.695
And so I think you have to expect a crisis.

19:34.275 --> 19:36.615
The belief that no company will have a crisis,

19:36.915 --> 19:37.975
is foolish.

19:38.595 --> 19:41.975
Uh, it would be nice if we never have a crisis,

19:42.275 --> 19:44.455
but there's not a hundred percent guarantee of that.

19:45.275 --> 19:47.935
If you never get outta bed, you're crisis free.

19:48.235 --> 19:50.535
But once you get outta bed in the morning,

19:50.535 --> 19:52.335
you're gonna face a level of risk.

19:52.635 --> 19:53.695
Bad things do happen.

19:54.245 --> 19:56.655
Organizations have to prepare for a crisis,

19:57.115 --> 20:00.495
and I think insurance providers are saying,

20:00.875 --> 20:03.575
we are not gonna pay off if you have a bombing,

20:03.755 --> 20:06.775
if you have a, if you have a fire,

20:07.035 --> 20:10.255
unless we've seen that you've hired an emergency manager.

20:10.935 --> 20:13.295
I know at our school, we now have somebody who's a

20:13.295 --> 20:14.535
crisis communication manager.

20:15.175 --> 20:17.535
A lot of things we're falling between the cracks.

20:17.875 --> 20:22.775
We now have everybody's cell phone number is there.

20:22.875 --> 20:25.015
So if we have an active shooter on campus,

20:25.475 --> 20:28.295
if we have flooding on lower campus, we're able to do that.

20:28.635 --> 20:31.655
We have the digital technology to be able to reach people.

20:32.115 --> 20:36.435
And I hope that this theoretical piece

20:37.055 --> 20:38.835
can be used to build more theory

20:39.055 --> 20:42.195
and then to alert people that this is an important area.

20:42.615 --> 20:46.715
For a long time, we were the stepchild of public relations.

20:47.115 --> 20:50.165
Emergency management is an important area by itself,

20:50.505 --> 20:53.005
and every company should make preparation.

20:53.305 --> 20:57.365
People don't intuitively do this unless they practice, and

20:57.365 --> 20:59.125
unless you devote some resources

20:59.225 --> 21:03.605
to hiring an emergency manager, providing time so

21:03.605 --> 21:05.805
that employees will know what to do.

21:05.955 --> 21:08.045
Otherwise, people are scared

21:08.305 --> 21:11.565
and anxious during a crisis, which leads to more deaths

21:11.565 --> 21:12.525
and more destruction.

"Understanding Crisis Communication: The Value Jet Flight 92 Incident"

00:00:00 - Value Jett Flight 92 took off in 1996. What was interesting about Value Jett is that it was a discount airline. the FAA wanted to promote this whole new segment of air communica airline communication. And so Value Jet happened to be one of the poster children for this new line of airlines. Southwest was probably the most prominent one that has survived in that, unfortunately, having taken off in Miami and heading toward Atlanta, it had an electrical disturbance right away,
00:00:47 - The fire was so strong that you didn't have seats, you didn't have metal, you had virtually nothing on the Everglades. And looking for the black box was hard. And so the question became, how did this crisis occur? Who was responsible for it? And how do we explain it in this context? And so I used the Value Jet Airline crash as a vehicle for bringing together several theories and several elements of crisis communication. That was the context in which it occurred.
00:01:25 - of everyday language. And so newspapers love to talk about, crisis, and that we had a more specific notion of what a crisis is. in order to have a crisis, you have to meet three criteria. One criteria is something occurs sudden. So a lot of problems occur because they're simmering, they simmer for a long time, and then they finally blow over. And that, for crisis to occur, something happens to have occur sudden, much like with the challenger disaster, where we had so many, shuttles that flew,
00:02:06 - So it has to be something that number one is sudden. Number two, it has to be a threat to important value. So you're on your way to work today, you have a flat tire, you pull off to the side. Is that a crisis? Well, it may be to you a traumatic event, but actually you pull out your phone, you call aaa or you call one of the, services. And that, it's just a distraction or a nuisance. A threat to important values has to really hit important values. I'll give you an example of a threat to important values. The University of Minnesota, had a basketball team
00:02:51 - for the NCA tournament on the eve of their playing in the game, it was revealed that somebody had written papers for 15 basketball players on the team. Well, is this a crisis? there's nothing more important than academic life than academic integrity. And in fact, the team was pulled from the tournament. the basketball coach was eventually fired. The athletic director for women was fired, the athletic director for men and the vice president for, student affairs. And so, a crisis has to be a threat to important values.
00:03:32 - there's a short response time. You don't have forever. With an airline crash, you usually have to get a message to the public, and it could be a standby message within four hours. And the message may say something like this, we haven't recovered the black box. We're not sure what happened, but we're looking for the black box. And as soon as we have any information, we'll relay it to you. And the reason you do this in the airline industry is that 20% of the public is scared of flying anyways. You've got another 30% that have anxieties. And so you have to calm a public that this was an atypical

"Understanding Crisis: Key Elements and Theoretical Frameworks for Effective Response"

00:04:12 - but you don't wanna let a lot of time go by an academic life. When somebody attacks an article you've written, the response may be six months or a year later, that doesn't happen in a crisis situation. The response has to be immediate. So for a crisis to occur, we have three elements, surprise, threat to important value and a short response time. And those three constitute what we think of as a crisis. And there are crisis situations which have to be responded to for a long time. I used to go to a, we had crisis conferences. And the crisis conferences started after the Exxon Bel Ds, where you had academics.
00:04:57 - you had people from corporations. And we tell war stories. And the war stories would often be interesting. They often involve lots of people in that, but you didn't get a sense of how you could proceed. And so the academics started getting together, and we started talking about how do we explain these things? We could have 2000 war stories, but you haven't developed any principles. Eventually, out of these conferences, we developed several approaches to how to study a crisis. One approach, we'll call a stage, theory and stage theory.
00:05:35 - The one I like best is Stephen Fink. stage theory is really a natural history, evolution of a crisis. And natural history means something has a beginning, middle, and end. In the case of Stephen Fink, he's really got four stages that each crisis goes through. The first stage is something called the prodromal, or it's a Greek word, meaning running ahead. And he says that there are warning signs that run ahead of a crisis. In the case of the Challenger disaster, the o-rings had not sealed 19 times before. So there were warning signs and astute manager would've noticed there's a problem
00:06:18 - before it actually took off. The second stage fin is the acute stage. And the acute stage is where something happens. In the case of value, jet flight 5 92, the acute stage was the explosion over the Florida Everglades. The acute stage is often the shortest part of a crisis. In the case of values that it lasted about 10 days as they went on a scavenger hunt, looking for the bodies, looking for the black box. The third stage is the a chronic stage. And the chronic stage is where you investigate what happened. You make changes along the way. You implement reforms.
00:07:00 - and this is the longest of the four stages. And then the crisis resolution. And the definition of a crisis resolution for f is that the company has made whole again. And so the company has made whole, and you start looking for new prodromes along the way. So the four stages for Fink were, the prodromal, the acute, the chronic, and the crisis resolution. That's a natural history. There were other stage theorists. The stage theory is a really useful way of thinking about a crisis. A second approach, a very different orientation, is strategy theory.
00:07:42 - And strategy, theory is centered on reputation and image. much like economics is designed, to talk about profit maximizing activity. In communication, we're concerned with reputation maximizing activity. And so either an individual or an organization has a reputation that they wanna protect. And Benoit says that a crisis occurs when there's an attack on your reputation. Somebody has said something offensive and that it hits you directly. And for him, there are five strategies in which you can

"Strategies of Crisis Management: Denial, Responsibility, and Public Response"

00:08:28 - the attack, one of the strategies is called just denial. whatever you said is not true. it's false. I didn't do it. And so, a variation of denial is, scapegoating. Yeah, it was done, but was done by somebody else. it wasn't me. And so denial is one strategy. Second strategy is reducing the offensiveness where you try to reduce the offensiveness of it. and here you can use minimization. You can use displacement. There are various things that you can use in order to, reduce the offensiveness of it.
00:09:09 - where you try to show that you had a good intentions or an accident occurred, or his most interesting, variation is the feasibility. Things just got out of control. and the Exxon Ved, the weather was calm for three days and then the weather was bad, and you couldn't bring in an easy rescue crew. And so, that became part of re evasion of responsibility. the nice fourth category is a corrective action. And here's where people make cor corrections or reforms.
00:09:53 - And his stiff category is apologies or mortification. Here you express regret. You express, problems along the way. the problem with expressing regret though, is that as other people point it out, there's a trade off. if I say I'm sorry, I really didn't mean to do it, it opens me up to legal liability. And so a lot of companies use what's called the equivocal apology. I'm really sorry. The problem occurred, but you never say I caused the problem. You always have something that
00:10:33 - So that was the third, a fourth of, benoy strategies. his last strategy is, ification. So you've got five strategies that he has as part of how to handle a crisis. And the last major orientation I look at at, especially in this article, is focusing event. A focusing event is a sudden event that captures public attention. And that event sort of crystallizes lots of issues along the way. probably the best example
00:11:14 - We had had school shootings before Columbine. Often they occurred in urban areas, drive-by shootings or in rural areas. What was so devastating about Columbine, it occurred in an upper middle class town, Littleton, Colorado. it occurred in an area where people moved to, to get away from the ills of urban society. And so it became an event that crystallized public opinion. There were five cover stories on Time Magazine, about school shootings, about, what happens.
00:11:58 - Berkland, who's the chief theorist of focusing event, says that a focusing event will lead to a legislative enactment. People will pass legislation to prevent this from happening again. My approach is that a focus event often leads to a rhetorical symbol. So Columbine did not have a legislative enactment. television people argue that, and computer people argued that, the First Amendment stopped the government from issuing a new regulations gun. People said the Second Amendment stopped

"Crisis Analysis: The Lessons from Value Jet and the Columbine Tragedy"

00:12:35 - And so there was never any major legislation. But Columbine has become a symbol. And anytime we've had a school shooting, and since Columbine in 1990, nine, we have had several school shootings along the way. And everybody brings up Columbine as the template for here's what happens. So a focusing events is a way of looking at how the public actually focuses on something. It's an agenda setting part of the media, how the agenda is set by the media in order for public opinion to crystallize on one topic.
00:13:18 - that I look at in this article, stage theory, strategy, theory and focusing event. And all three have it. My argument is that the best way to understand the crisis is to take elements from all three approaches to actually get a more comprehensive view of what a crisis is Like. Why is value jet lasting? It's 25 years since I wrote the article. What was special about value jet value jet was a discount airline. The FAA was put into a dual role. On the one hand, it wanted to promote this discount segment of the airline industry.
00:13:59 - They offered easy access to people. The seaport Small, they have no frills, no extra food in that. But part of the FAA wanted to promote this as a way of people moving. On the other hand, the fa a's mandate is to provide for public safety. And so, you had conflicting goals we wanna both promote as well as measure public safety. So there was something special about the value jet case. You had a federal agency that was caught in with dual purposes and acted Badly Because they should have monitored value jet ahead of time.
00:14:39 - that they had monitored 5,000 value jet flights ahead of time. So What happened? Well, there had been warning signs that value jet was a problematic airline value. Jet often bought planes from other companies and then reconditioned them. But these planes were predisposed to have accidents and value. Jet had a higher rate of accident than what was normal in the airline industry. And the FAA sort of let it slide. So in the prodromal where you could've actually intervened,
00:15:22 - it was a terrible tragedy. You could not find any remnants of the bodies at all. people combed the Flora Everglades, they were able to find, the black box eventually, but it was a difficult thing. What turns out is the Arrow values that Flight 5 92 was carrying some oxygen tanks. And those oxygen tanks exploded and the way that didn't leave any remnants of the plane at all. And so there was a question, do you allow these airplanes to actually carry these oxygen tanks in this kind
00:16:01 - And so the acute raised some questions. The chronic is people started investigating a value jet, and value jet had cut corners, had not done the kind of maintenance it needed. It was able to postpone maintenance in order to keep the prices down. And so, what was interesting about its pricing structure is that it achieved those economies, but only by neglecting the kinds of things that should have been done. And so there was a question about whether values Jett would be able to exist. And indeed, values Jet had to change its name.

"Value Jet: Lessons in Crisis Management and Communication"

00:16:42 - Now, there were other discount airlines. Many of them went by the wayside. we had something called People's Express in the nineties that came out of Newark. Southwest Airline was the best of the discount, but, value Jet could not survive in its current way. You saw value jet fighting back using many of OID strategies that, it was a good airline, that it bolstered it record of how it served people and that, so it followed a pattern in that. But this became a focusing a bit. And the reason it did is
00:17:26 - that was designed to supervise this, company. And that just defaulted on what its responsibility is. And so value Jet becomes the poster child for this is bad government and bad industry. What I did in the work, and actually I was trying to find a good vehicle for looking at theory. if you're gonna work in a field like crisis communication, war stories aren't enough. I have a database with had, which has 2000 crisis events.
00:18:04 - the other day, the Francis Scott Keybridge and Baltimore collapse, how that collapsed, why the whole bridge collapsed in the way, what was happening, on the ship, why they didn't have some precautions. There's this theory in crisis communication that talks about high reliability, that even if an accident is about to occur, there are backup systems and there should have been backup systems for power on this, cargo ship. In that, I look upon this article as a way of trying to make theory relevant
00:18:47 - to make crisis communication a solid field. Beside the three, the theories that I identify, there are theories like high reliability theory, normal accident theory, chaos theory. And so we've tried to take events and do that. The importance of this in the long run is that, most insurance companies are not paying off if a company hasn't done some work ahead of time. evacuation behavior. How many companies have ever seen an evacuation behavior? how, how do you organize your employees? What do you do?
00:19:28 - How do you handle that? And so I think you have to expect a crisis. The belief that no company will have a crisis, is foolish. it would be nice if we never have a crisis, but there's not a hundred percent guarantee of that. If you never get outta bed, you're crisis free. But once you get outta bed in the morning, you're gonna face a level of risk. Bad things do happen. Organizations have to prepare for a crisis, and I think insurance providers are saying, we are not gonna pay off if you have a bombing, if you have a, if you have a fire,
00:20:10 - I know at our school, we now have somebody who's a crisis communication manager. A lot of things we're falling between the cracks. We now have everybody's cell phone number is there. So if we have an active shooter on campus, if we have flooding on lower campus, we're able to do that. We have the digital technology to be able to reach people. And I hope that this theoretical piece can be used to build more theory and then to alert people that this is an important area. For a long time, we were the stepchild of public relations.

"Proactive Crisis Preparedness: The Importance of Training and Resources"

00:21:11 - and every company should make preparation. People don't intuitively do this unless they practice, and unless you devote some resources to hiring an emergency manager, providing time so that employees will know what to do. Otherwise, people are scared and anxious during a crisis, which leads to more deaths and more destruction.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis

Data

Originals

Explainers

Podcasts

Faculti

New on Faculti

Idea Explorer

Definition

News Context

Critical Questions and Answers

Research Summaries

ValuJet Flight 592: Crisis communication theory blended and extended

Media Literacy Toolkit

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

Further Reading ▼