Popular in Law

Human Rights Law

Human Rights and Corruption: Problems and Potential of Individualising a Systemic Problem

Max Planck Institute Anne Peters

Law

A statistical approach to law school citation rankings

University of Virginia Joshua Fischman

Constitutional Law

What is constitutional ideology?

University of Oxford Nick Barber

Civil Procedure Law

Politics, Identity, and Class Certification on the U.S. Courts of Appeals

University of Pennsylvania Sean Farhang

Law

Diversity and Social Mobility in the UK legal profession

Law Society I. Stephanie Boyce

Internet Law

The Law of AI for Good

University of San Diego Orly Lobel

Human Rights Law

Transforming Restorative Justice for Transitional Settings

University of Nottingham Kerry Clamp

Protecting the Right to Social Participation of Older Persons in Long-Term Care

View more insights in Professional - Law - Human Rights Law

View more figures from Monash University

View the page of Rachel Morrison-Dayan

Read the Study

Next in Human Rights Law

The Discursive Evolution of Human Rights Law

Renana Keydar, Vera Shikhelman | Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Human Rights and Corruption: Problems and Potential of Individualising a Systemic Problem

Anne Peters | Max Planck Institute

Rachel Morrison-Dayan discusses how the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted social isolation and loneliness among older people in residential long-term care.

Image courtesy of interviewee. February 8, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the challenges of social isolation and loneliness faced by older adults in long-term care settings, emphasizing the need for better protection of their right to social participation under international human rights law. It defines long-term care as assistance with daily activities outside of the home and highlights the importance of social connections for mental and emotional well-being.

It points out that older women are particularly affected due to their higher representation in care facilities and longer life expectancy. This video video references Article 19 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which mandates that states support independent living and community inclusion, thus applying to older persons in aged care.

Various barriers to social participation are identified, including frailty, lack of access to technology, and insufficient staffing and training in care facilities. It notes the detrimental health effects of isolation, equating them to significant physical health conditions.

This video video advocates for individualized approaches in aged care that respect the autonomy and preferences of older individuals, suggesting practical measures such as homelike environments, community integration, better staffing, and use of assistive technologies for communication.

Lastly, it calls for comprehensive actions involving legislation, policy changes, community awareness, and interdisciplinary research to effectively combat loneliness and ensure meaningful social participation for older people in care settings. It emphasizes the need for a culture shift in the aged care sector to enhance the rights and quality of life for older adults.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.155 --> 00:03.485
Many older people living in long-term care settings

00:03.655 --> 00:06.125
experience social isolation and loneliness,

00:06.705 --> 00:09.525
and their right to continue accessing opportunities

00:09.705 --> 00:12.765
for social participation needs better protection

00:12.765 --> 00:14.885
through international human rights law.

00:15.505 --> 00:19.285
So by residential long-term care, I mean care

00:19.645 --> 00:22.965
provided outside of the home in activities of daily living,

00:23.235 --> 00:27.365
such as being helped in the shower, help with eating,

00:27.765 --> 00:29.725
mobility such as getting out of bed

00:29.825 --> 00:33.285
and accessing, the dining room or the garden.

00:33.705 --> 00:37.245
And by social participation, I mean, opportunities

00:37.385 --> 00:41.005
to engage in activities which provide, connection

00:41.155 --> 00:43.245
with others, interaction with others.

00:44.105 --> 00:45.685
And, the issue of social

00:46.245 --> 00:49.725
participation in long-term care is extremely,

00:49.845 --> 00:52.805
increasingly significant in an aging population,

00:52.985 --> 00:54.525
an aging global population.

00:56.205 --> 00:59.825
And this issue does in, does affect women disproportionately

01:00.325 --> 01:02.025
as they're overrepresented,

01:02.025 --> 01:05.385
overrepresented in long-term care due to their,

01:05.385 --> 01:07.345
for many reasons, including their, long,

01:07.345 --> 01:09.105
their longer life expectancy

01:09.285 --> 01:13.225
and the, less likelihood that their cared at home,

01:13.515 --> 01:15.225
cared for by a spouse at home.

01:17.305 --> 01:19.725
So international human rights law,

01:20.275 --> 01:23.045
including the convention on the rights of Persons

01:23.045 --> 01:26.565
with disabilities, the Disabilities Convention,

01:26.665 --> 01:30.805
and in particular, article 19, living independently

01:30.805 --> 01:35.205
and in the community can be applied to the aged care context

01:35.545 --> 01:37.885
to better protect old person's right

01:38.025 --> 01:39.405
to social participation.

01:41.775 --> 01:45.035
In short, article 19 requires states

01:45.215 --> 01:47.235
to facilitate full inclusion

01:47.335 --> 01:49.155
and participation in the community.

01:49.945 --> 01:52.915
They need to ensure that the person can make individual

01:52.915 --> 01:54.595
choices about where

01:54.975 --> 01:58.675
and how they live, including their place of residence,

01:58.685 --> 02:02.355
daily routine, personal assistance, personal relationships,

02:03.305 --> 02:05.275
such that institutional living

02:05.615 --> 02:08.475
and rigid routines, which limit the choices

02:08.705 --> 02:11.555
that older people can make about their living arrangements

02:11.895 --> 02:12.995
are not acceptable.

02:14.505 --> 02:17.195
Article 19 also requires states

02:17.255 --> 02:21.795
to facilitate individualized assistance to support living

02:22.095 --> 02:24.555
and including and inclusion in the community

02:25.095 --> 02:29.035
and the availability of community services and facilities.

02:29.775 --> 02:33.715
For many people in residential aged care suffer from

02:33.805 --> 02:35.755
loneliness and depression,

02:36.615 --> 02:40.235
and women are overrepresented in aged care, as I said.

02:40.455 --> 02:42.115
And so both ageism

02:42.135 --> 02:44.795
and gender discrimination are relevant factors here.

02:46.325 --> 02:49.515
Older persons lack opportunities for social relationships

02:49.695 --> 02:52.755
for a number of reasons, including their frailty

02:53.095 --> 02:56.795
and the restrictive and closed nature of their environment

02:57.015 --> 02:58.875
or segregation from the community.

03:00.155 --> 03:02.685
They may also lack access to technology

03:02.715 --> 03:04.565
because they don't have that kind

03:04.565 --> 03:06.605
of technological know-how perhaps,

03:07.305 --> 03:11.725
or they lack staff assistance, for instance,

03:12.015 --> 03:14.285
Skype or internet chatting apps.

03:14.425 --> 03:17.125
Um, they may not have, the, the eyesight

03:17.225 --> 03:18.685
or the, hearing

03:18.905 --> 03:21.005
or other skills, to be able

03:21.005 --> 03:22.805
to make the best use of that technology.

03:23.545 --> 03:26.165
And furthermore, many older people

03:26.905 --> 03:30.445
are on psychotropic medicines such as antipsychotics

03:30.465 --> 03:33.085
or benzodiazepine medicines, for instance.

03:33.185 --> 03:36.805
And, and this along with perhaps other issues such

03:36.805 --> 03:39.125
as unmanaged pain or poor sleep

03:39.185 --> 03:42.965
or fear of falls, for example, may decrease their desire

03:43.185 --> 03:45.245
or ability to interact socially.

03:45.655 --> 03:49.045
Other factors, which adversely impact on opportunities

03:49.185 --> 03:53.245
for social participation include high staff turnover,

03:53.875 --> 03:55.125
poor staff training,

03:55.545 --> 03:57.685
and low staff to resident ratios,

03:57.815 --> 04:00.445
which do impact on the quality of care

04:00.985 --> 04:05.165
and the time that care workers have to, spend with,

04:05.715 --> 04:09.245
with, with people and to deliver person centered care

04:09.305 --> 04:11.125
and enhance social opportunities.

04:12.025 --> 04:15.245
We all remember the isolation endured by many people

04:15.245 --> 04:19.285
during the COVID-19 pandemic, brought a lot

04:19.285 --> 04:22.125
of public attention, to both the consequences

04:22.225 --> 04:26.125
of social isolation and the importance of social connection,

04:26.705 --> 04:28.445
and also the failings of long-term care.

04:29.185 --> 04:30.285
In the 13th session

04:30.945 --> 04:35.205
of the Open-ended working group on Aging in 2023,

04:35.905 --> 04:38.045
the United Nations Department of Economic

04:38.185 --> 04:41.645
and Social Affairs noted the continued segregation

04:41.865 --> 04:43.885
of older people from their communities.

04:44.665 --> 04:47.685
And reasons for this included the unpreparedness

04:47.685 --> 04:51.005
of institutions to facilitate social participation.

04:51.715 --> 04:55.725
This is really concerning as social isolation

04:55.725 --> 04:57.405
and loneliness, serious matters.

04:58.325 --> 04:59.325
Research has indicated

04:59.515 --> 05:03.165
that the health consequences can be similar in magnitude

05:03.225 --> 05:05.245
to conditions like diabetes and obesity.

05:06.715 --> 05:11.205
Some of the health effects are poorer, cardiovascular,

05:11.255 --> 05:14.525
brain and immune health, depression and anxiety

05:14.665 --> 05:16.205
and cognitive decline.

05:18.735 --> 05:21.275
So there isn't a specific right

05:21.455 --> 05:24.515
to social participation in human right treaties.

05:25.155 --> 05:28.035
Although social participation does broadly relate

05:28.035 --> 05:31.595
to other rights in core international treaties involving

05:32.105 --> 05:35.715
accessing education, employment, and healthcare.

05:37.425 --> 05:41.395
Some non-binding in international instruments dealing

05:41.795 --> 05:44.835
specifically with our older person's issues have

05:45.395 --> 05:49.315
recognized the continuing need for social participation

05:50.105 --> 05:52.835
such as the UN principles for older persons

05:52.835 --> 05:54.675
and the world Assemblies on Aging.

05:55.175 --> 05:58.025
But better protection is needed

05:59.615 --> 06:02.365
while treaty is relevant to protecting the right

06:02.365 --> 06:04.325
to social participation in aged care

06:04.955 --> 06:09.005
include the International Covenant on economic, cultural

06:09.005 --> 06:11.645
and social rights, especially the right to health

06:12.185 --> 06:14.085
or the elimination of all forms

06:14.145 --> 06:17.365
of discrimination against women with a higher number

06:17.365 --> 06:18.405
of women in aged care.

06:19.795 --> 06:22.935
The Disabilities Convention is particularly relevant

06:23.115 --> 06:25.175
to older people receiving aged care.

06:27.215 --> 06:30.675
But this convention is underappreciated in the aged care

06:30.675 --> 06:32.915
context as policy makers

06:33.095 --> 06:37.115
and service providers don't often define aged care services

06:37.215 --> 06:38.475
as disability services.

06:39.425 --> 06:42.595
However, the convention has considerable potential in

06:42.595 --> 06:45.395
raising awareness of social isolation

06:45.735 --> 06:49.235
and loneliness in aged care facilities as human right

06:49.775 --> 06:50.955
at human rights matters,

06:52.105 --> 06:54.605
and protecting the right to social participation

06:55.465 --> 06:56.965
if properly implemented.

06:59.305 --> 07:02.375
Human rights mechanisms should elaborate further

07:03.035 --> 07:06.135
on the relevance of the Disabilities Convention specifically

07:06.135 --> 07:09.015
to older persons in long care, long-term care.

07:09.515 --> 07:13.055
And especially as these, issues become more important

07:13.475 --> 07:15.255
as the population ages.

07:15.755 --> 07:19.415
So human rights mechanisms have explicitly confirmed the

07:19.415 --> 07:21.815
applicability of the Disabilities Convention

07:22.115 --> 07:23.295
to the Aged Care context.

07:24.035 --> 07:28.895
Um, in a 2019 Report on Aging a Disability Special

07:28.905 --> 07:31.575
Rapporteur on the Rights of Persons with disabilities,

07:31.815 --> 07:35.935
Catalina dus Aula elaborated on the applicability

07:36.235 --> 07:39.615
of the Disabilities Convention, including Article 19

07:40.315 --> 07:43.215
to older persons with age related disabilities.

07:43.955 --> 07:45.615
And both dus Aula

07:45.875 --> 07:49.335
and the current special Rapporteur Gerard Quinn have

07:49.855 --> 07:52.575
emphasized the need for transformation

07:53.235 --> 07:55.215
of institutional forms of care

07:55.315 --> 07:57.895
for older people within the dis within,

07:57.895 --> 08:01.535
with disabilities and for states to provide so services

08:01.675 --> 08:03.855
and support within the community.

08:04.155 --> 08:08.455
So in its general comment number five, adopted in 2017,

08:09.035 --> 08:11.815
the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

08:12.195 --> 08:13.255
and also the Office

08:13.355 --> 08:16.175
of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.

08:16.175 --> 08:19.575
In a 2014 thematic thematic study

08:20.095 --> 08:23.095
acknowledged the applicability of Article 19

08:23.095 --> 08:24.215
to older persons as well,

08:25.595 --> 08:27.015
and the European Network

08:27.155 --> 08:29.455
of National Human Rights Institutions

08:29.795 --> 08:32.975
and other scholars have also discussed the application

08:32.975 --> 08:36.095
of nine of Article 19 in the long-term care context.

08:36.405 --> 08:39.535
There's, there's been some useful proposals,

08:39.595 --> 08:42.415
in the work of the Open-ended working group on aging

08:42.535 --> 08:45.735
relating to draft state obligations on social

08:46.415 --> 08:49.135
participation in long-term care, reflecting the obligations

08:49.195 --> 08:52.615
of Article 19 of, of the Disabilities Convention,

08:53.275 --> 08:56.125
the World Alzheimer's Report 2020

08:56.805 --> 09:00.085
includes recommendations about dementia related design

09:00.425 --> 09:01.845
and the built environment.

09:02.545 --> 09:06.445
And this addresses weakness in human rights awareness within

09:06.505 --> 09:09.365
the architecture profession of the need

09:09.365 --> 09:10.805
to protect vulnerable groups

09:11.025 --> 09:15.045
and meaningfully involved, impacted parties in design,

09:15.415 --> 09:18.605
which can create an environment that is more conducive

09:18.705 --> 09:22.485
to social participation in respecting, protecting

09:22.665 --> 09:24.165
and fulfilling the rights.

09:24.165 --> 09:28.325
In Article 19 in aged Care states should ensure

09:28.325 --> 09:30.445
that these rights are reflected adequately

09:30.515 --> 09:35.485
through legislation policy, regularly re regulatory measures

09:35.625 --> 09:37.485
and monitoring of what's going on

09:37.585 --> 09:39.045
and the need for further changes.

09:40.345 --> 09:42.725
States must also ensure that

09:42.915 --> 09:46.845
that third party aged care providers uphold the standards in

09:46.845 --> 09:48.285
the disabilities convention

09:48.665 --> 09:52.325
and should focus on instigating deeper cultural changes

09:52.545 --> 09:55.685
within provider organizations to achieve this

09:56.065 --> 09:57.885
and the general community, as well

09:57.885 --> 10:00.605
as increasing opportunities for older people

10:00.665 --> 10:04.565
to participate meaningfully in decision making about their

10:04.565 --> 10:06.405
living arrangements, care and support.

10:07.665 --> 10:09.765
So what are some of the ways

10:09.835 --> 10:13.325
that Article 19 can be applied prac practically?

10:15.125 --> 10:17.735
Well, it's important that older,

10:18.165 --> 10:21.495
that older persons can choose to live in home-like settings

10:21.525 --> 10:24.135
with sufficient staffing, which allow them

10:24.135 --> 10:26.695
to maintain choice about their daily life

10:27.115 --> 10:28.615
and community connection,

10:29.235 --> 10:32.495
and are not forced into institutional living arrangements

10:32.685 --> 10:33.935
with rigid routines.

10:35.855 --> 10:39.345
Undertaking everyday activities in home-like environments

10:39.885 --> 10:43.185
can present social opportunities such as meal preparation

10:43.605 --> 10:46.385
or even just dusting or polishing ornaments

10:46.565 --> 10:50.435
and having a chat together in relation

10:50.435 --> 10:54.955
to environmental factors, natural light views to the

10:54.955 --> 10:58.675
outside, open plan kitchens as well

10:58.675 --> 10:59.995
as outdoor gardens

10:59.995 --> 11:04.235
and cafes can create welcoming environments for residents

11:04.235 --> 11:08.395
and visitors, and thereby facilitate social participation.

11:09.185 --> 11:12.195
Options, of course, vary between countries and settings.

11:13.925 --> 11:16.985
The provision of sufficient staff skills mix

11:17.005 --> 11:19.705
and training, including about the human rights

11:19.725 --> 11:23.465
of older persons is, is important in ensuring quality care

11:23.565 --> 11:26.985
and assisting older people to be socially involved.

11:28.995 --> 11:32.105
Staff assistance is important for personalized

11:32.205 --> 11:33.465
or group transport

11:33.685 --> 11:37.345
or activities with other people at the setting, such

11:37.345 --> 11:39.185
as intergenerational activities

11:39.325 --> 11:43.025
or volunteer programs where people of all ages can get

11:43.025 --> 11:45.865
to know each other, share their life experiences

11:46.085 --> 11:47.865
and discover common interests.

11:49.635 --> 11:53.525
Some cultural specific age care settings can foster a sense

11:53.525 --> 11:58.065
of community quite well, interaction

11:58.065 --> 12:01.425
with nature and pets, music, art, culture,

12:02.345 --> 12:05.465
reminiscence therapy, and physical activities such

12:05.465 --> 12:07.705
as hand massage, reflexology,

12:08.205 --> 12:11.825
or aroma therapy are also great ways to,

12:11.895 --> 12:13.465
inspire social participation.

12:15.455 --> 12:18.445
Assistance with communication is also

12:18.445 --> 12:20.285
important with the use.

12:20.465 --> 12:22.485
Um, such as with the use of technology

12:23.305 --> 12:26.325
and supporting communication may also include other

12:26.325 --> 12:30.165
measures, such as teaching of simple sign language to,

12:30.265 --> 12:32.965
to both staff and older people.

12:33.425 --> 12:38.165
Um, this could include words such as cup of tea, shower,

12:38.625 --> 12:42.205
happy or sad or bored.

12:42.385 --> 12:45.045
Um, that's just a few, words from,

12:45.255 --> 12:48.765
Australian sign language, called Auslan.

12:49.545 --> 12:53.485
Uh, so this could be very useful in aiding communication

12:53.495 --> 12:55.285
where older people suffer from.

12:55.345 --> 12:57.205
Uh, many, many people,

12:57.205 --> 12:59.325
who are old suffer from hearing loss,

12:59.325 --> 13:02.445
where understanding is even more difficult,

13:02.475 --> 13:06.245
when infection control masks such as with COVID-19,

13:06.245 --> 13:07.965
or other illnesses are worn,

13:08.225 --> 13:10.645
or where voices are are weak,

13:10.705 --> 13:12.565
or accents are difficult to understand.

13:14.545 --> 13:15.765
So all levels

13:15.865 --> 13:18.885
of government should be involved in making community

13:19.205 --> 13:21.565
services and facilities more accessible.

13:22.065 --> 13:24.805
And this could inc include, for example, better walking

13:25.365 --> 13:28.205
pathways between aged care settings and local parks

13:28.205 --> 13:30.725
and shops and accessible transport

13:31.305 --> 13:33.765
and the placement of community facilities

13:33.765 --> 13:35.045
near aged care settings.

13:35.215 --> 13:38.325
There are many challenges though in facilitating social

13:38.885 --> 13:40.645
participation, including the frailty

13:40.665 --> 13:42.525
of many persons living in age care

13:43.145 --> 13:45.365
and conditions like dementia.

13:46.585 --> 13:49.165
And there's also the need for specialized staff

13:49.305 --> 13:50.725
and environmental design

13:50.985 --> 13:53.325
and a range of practical considerations.

13:54.155 --> 13:57.405
There's also the need to balance different human rights,

13:57.835 --> 14:00.365
such as those involving autonomy and liberty

14:00.865 --> 14:02.805
and the need for protective measures.

14:04.165 --> 14:05.705
The challenges and dilemmas

14:05.845 --> 14:09.225
of applying the disabilities convention, including what

14:09.805 --> 14:12.785
deinstitutionalization should look like specifically in aged

14:12.785 --> 14:16.225
care and even matters like the extent of incorporation

14:16.225 --> 14:17.945
of technology such as robotics.

14:18.615 --> 14:21.945
They need further elaboration by human rights mechanisms

14:21.945 --> 14:24.305
and consultation with different stakeholders.

14:24.715 --> 14:28.185
There are many other articles of the disabilities convention

14:28.185 --> 14:32.065
that interact with, with Article 19, for example,

14:32.575 --> 14:35.185
article 26, which also relates

14:35.185 --> 14:38.585
to social re rehabilitation and relationship building

14:39.085 --> 14:42.345
and overcoming stereotypical views of people living

14:42.345 --> 14:44.025
with dementia and their capacity

14:44.025 --> 14:48.025
to engage in rehabilitative, re rehabilitative therapies

14:48.405 --> 14:51.525
and the recognition of older person's legal capacity under

14:51.555 --> 14:56.365
Article 12, including people, with dementia relating

14:56.365 --> 14:57.725
to support of decision making.

14:57.875 --> 15:00.805
Article five, equality

15:01.025 --> 15:03.565
and non-discrimination, which obliges states

15:03.625 --> 15:06.405
to prohibit discrimination on the basis of disability,

15:06.615 --> 15:10.045
where discrimination may take the form of segregation

15:10.225 --> 15:11.285
or social barriers

15:11.505 --> 15:14.205
or paternalistic, approaches

15:14.205 --> 15:17.165
to care which limit autonomy and erode identity.

15:18.425 --> 15:21.605
And there's also a need for greater community awareness

15:21.745 --> 15:25.645
of issues facing older people, under Article eight,

15:25.715 --> 15:29.605
through educational campaigns including dementia awareness.

15:29.865 --> 15:33.805
Um, and this can help our family members, particularly,

15:34.265 --> 15:37.725
when, when their family member may, acquire dementia

15:37.725 --> 15:40.845
and go into a f facility so that visits don't drop off.

15:40.945 --> 15:44.005
Um, if they can receive some education, on how

15:44.025 --> 15:48.005
to communicate, to make, visits, you know,

15:48.505 --> 15:51.925
be better for, for everyone the disabilities Convention

15:51.985 --> 15:55.805
and Article 19 in particular offers an important opportunity

15:55.985 --> 15:59.205
to protect the right of social participation in aged care.

15:59.825 --> 16:03.125
And this need is gaining importance in an aging population.

16:04.025 --> 16:07.685
In adopting human rights standards, state should ensure

16:07.685 --> 16:09.045
that older persons are

16:09.565 --> 16:12.245
provided with meaningful opportunities for social

16:12.805 --> 16:16.445
participation by facilitating choice in living arrangements

16:16.995 --> 16:19.725
such as smaller homelike settings with sufficient staff

16:20.185 --> 16:24.285
and individual assistance to support the pursuance

16:24.385 --> 16:27.365
of meaningful connections, as well as greater access

16:27.365 --> 16:29.805
to community services and facilities.

16:31.075 --> 16:34.885
This will require a range of measures including leisure,

16:35.275 --> 16:38.285
legislative policy, and regulatory, measures

16:38.285 --> 16:39.685
and adequate monitoring

16:39.945 --> 16:42.005
and working towards cultural change

16:42.395 --> 16:46.165
with the aged care sector, and also involving older persons

16:46.165 --> 16:49.565
and groups, which represent them in related decision making

16:49.815 --> 16:52.005
about living arrangements, care and support.

16:52.825 --> 16:54.565
And raising community awareness

16:54.705 --> 16:58.205
to encourage greater understanding of closer connections

16:58.345 --> 17:01.165
and the need for closer connections between older persons

17:01.165 --> 17:03.165
and younger generations is also crucial.

17:04.665 --> 17:07.605
And of course, more interdisciplinary research

17:07.705 --> 17:11.205
and dialogue is needed on the ways to tackle loneliness

17:11.205 --> 17:13.205
and social isolation in aged care,

17:13.545 --> 17:16.805
and how the disabilities convention can be implemented in

17:16.805 --> 17:20.485
this context to best protect the rights of older persons.

Social Participation Rights in Aged Care

00:00:00 - Many older people living in long-term care settings experience social isolation and loneliness, and their right to continue accessing opportunities for social participation needs better protection through international human rights law. So by residential long-term care, I mean care provided outside of the home in activities of daily living, such as being helped in the shower, help with eating, mobility such as getting out of bed and accessing, the dining room or the garden.
00:00:37 - to engage in activities which provide, connection with others, interaction with others. And, the issue of social participation in long-term care is extremely, increasingly significant in an aging population, an aging global population. And this issue does in, does affect women disproportionately as they're overrepresented, overrepresented in long-term care due to their,
00:01:07 - their longer life expectancy and the, less likelihood that their cared at home, cared for by a spouse at home. So international human rights law, including the convention on the rights of Persons with disabilities, the Disabilities Convention, and in particular, article 19, living independently and in the community can be applied to the aged care context
00:01:38 - to social participation. In short, article 19 requires states to facilitate full inclusion and participation in the community. They need to ensure that the person can make individual choices about where and how they live, including their place of residence, daily routine, personal assistance, personal relationships, such that institutional living
00:02:08 - that older people can make about their living arrangements are not acceptable. Article 19 also requires states to facilitate individualized assistance to support living and including and inclusion in the community and the availability of community services and facilities. For many people in residential aged care suffer from loneliness and depression,
00:02:40 - And so both ageism and gender discrimination are relevant factors here. Older persons lack opportunities for social relationships for a number of reasons, including their frailty and the restrictive and closed nature of their environment or segregation from the community. They may also lack access to technology because they don't have that kind of technological know-how perhaps,

Challenges of Social Participation for Older Adults

00:03:12 - Skype or internet chatting apps. they may not have, the, the eyesight or the, hearing or other skills, to be able to make the best use of that technology. And furthermore, many older people are on psychotropic medicines such as antipsychotics or benzodiazepine medicines, for instance. And, and this along with perhaps other issues such as unmanaged pain or poor sleep
00:03:43 - or ability to interact socially. Other factors, which adversely impact on opportunities for social participation include high staff turnover, poor staff training, and low staff to resident ratios, which do impact on the quality of care and the time that care workers have to, spend with, with, with people and to deliver person centered care
00:04:12 - We all remember the isolation endured by many people during the COVID-19 pandemic, brought a lot of public attention, to both the consequences of social isolation and the importance of social connection, and also the failings of long-term care. In the 13th session of the Open-ended working group on Aging in 2023, the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs noted the continued segregation
00:04:44 - And reasons for this included the unpreparedness of institutions to facilitate social participation. This is really concerning as social isolation and loneliness, serious matters. Research has indicated that the health consequences can be similar in magnitude to conditions like diabetes and obesity. Some of the health effects are poorer, cardiovascular, brain and immune health, depression and anxiety
00:05:18 - So there isn't a specific right to social participation in human right treaties. Although social participation does broadly relate to other rights in core international treaties involving accessing education, employment, and healthcare. Some non-binding in international instruments dealing specifically with our older person's issues have
00:05:50 - such as the UN principles for older persons and the world Assemblies on Aging. But better protection is needed while treaty is relevant to protecting the right to social participation in aged care include the International Covenant on economic, cultural and social rights, especially the right to health or the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women with a higher number

Enhancing Aged Care Rights through Disabilities Convention

00:06:19 - The Disabilities Convention is particularly relevant to older people receiving aged care. But this convention is underappreciated in the aged care context as policy makers and service providers don't often define aged care services as disability services. However, the convention has considerable potential in raising awareness of social isolation and loneliness in aged care facilities as human right
00:06:52 - and protecting the right to social participation if properly implemented. Human rights mechanisms should elaborate further on the relevance of the Disabilities Convention specifically to older persons in long care, long-term care. And especially as these, issues become more important as the population ages. So human rights mechanisms have explicitly confirmed the applicability of the Disabilities Convention
00:07:24 - in a 2019 Report on Aging a Disability Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Persons with disabilities, Catalina dus Aula elaborated on the applicability of the Disabilities Convention, including Article 19 to older persons with age related disabilities. And both dus Aula and the current special Rapporteur Gerard Quinn have emphasized the need for transformation
00:07:55 - for older people within the dis within, with disabilities and for states to provide so services and support within the community. So in its general comment number five, adopted in 2017, the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and also the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. In a 2014 thematic thematic study acknowledged the applicability of Article 19 to older persons as well,
00:08:27 - of National Human Rights Institutions and other scholars have also discussed the application of nine of Article 19 in the long-term care context. There's, there's been some useful proposals, in the work of the Open-ended working group on aging relating to draft state obligations on social participation in long-term care, reflecting the obligations of Article 19 of, of the Disabilities Convention, the World Alzheimer's Report 2020
00:09:00 - and the built environment. And this addresses weakness in human rights awareness within the architecture profession of the need to protect vulnerable groups and meaningfully involved, impacted parties in design, which can create an environment that is more conducive to social participation in respecting, protecting and fulfilling the rights. In Article 19 in aged Care states should ensure

Enhancing Social Participation for Older Adults

00:09:30 - through legislation policy, regularly re regulatory measures and monitoring of what's going on and the need for further changes. States must also ensure that that third party aged care providers uphold the standards in the disabilities convention and should focus on instigating deeper cultural changes within provider organizations to achieve this and the general community, as well as increasing opportunities for older people
00:10:04 - living arrangements, care and support. So what are some of the ways that Article 19 can be applied prac practically? Well, it's important that older, that older persons can choose to live in home-like settings with sufficient staffing, which allow them to maintain choice about their daily life and community connection, and are not forced into institutional living arrangements
00:10:35 - Undertaking everyday activities in home-like environments can present social opportunities such as meal preparation or even just dusting or polishing ornaments and having a chat together in relation to environmental factors, natural light views to the outside, open plan kitchens as well as outdoor gardens and cafes can create welcoming environments for residents
00:11:09 - Options, of course, vary between countries and settings. The provision of sufficient staff skills mix and training, including about the human rights of older persons is, is important in ensuring quality care and assisting older people to be socially involved. Staff assistance is important for personalized or group transport or activities with other people at the setting, such
00:11:39 - or volunteer programs where people of all ages can get to know each other, share their life experiences and discover common interests. Some cultural specific age care settings can foster a sense of community quite well, interaction with nature and pets, music, art, culture, reminiscence therapy, and physical activities such as hand massage, reflexology,
00:12:11 - inspire social participation. Assistance with communication is also important with the use. such as with the use of technology and supporting communication may also include other measures, such as teaching of simple sign language to, to both staff and older people. this could include words such as cup of tea, shower,

Enhancing Communication for Aging Populations

00:12:42 - that's just a few, words from, Australian sign language, called Auslan. so this could be very useful in aiding communication where older people suffer from. many, many people, who are old suffer from hearing loss, where understanding is even more difficult, when infection control masks such as with COVID-19, or other illnesses are worn, or where voices are are weak,
00:13:14 - So all levels of government should be involved in making community services and facilities more accessible. And this could inc include, for example, better walking pathways between aged care settings and local parks and shops and accessible transport and the placement of community facilities near aged care settings. There are many challenges though in facilitating social participation, including the frailty of many persons living in age care
00:13:46 - And there's also the need for specialized staff and environmental design and a range of practical considerations. There's also the need to balance different human rights, such as those involving autonomy and liberty and the need for protective measures. The challenges and dilemmas of applying the disabilities convention, including what deinstitutionalization should look like specifically in aged care and even matters like the extent of incorporation
00:14:18 - They need further elaboration by human rights mechanisms and consultation with different stakeholders. There are many other articles of the disabilities convention that interact with, with Article 19, for example, article 26, which also relates to social re rehabilitation and relationship building and overcoming stereotypical views of people living with dementia and their capacity to engage in rehabilitative, re rehabilitative therapies
00:14:51 - Article 12, including people, with dementia relating to support of decision making. Article five, equality and non-discrimination, which obliges states to prohibit discrimination on the basis of disability, where discrimination may take the form of segregation or social barriers or paternalistic, approaches to care which limit autonomy and erode identity.
00:15:21 - of issues facing older people, under Article eight, through educational campaigns including dementia awareness. and this can help our family members, particularly, when, when their family member may, acquire dementia and go into a f facility so that visits don't drop off. if they can receive some education, on how to communicate, to make, visits, you know,

Enhancing Social Participation for Older Adults

00:15:51 - and Article 19 in particular offers an important opportunity to protect the right of social participation in aged care. And this need is gaining importance in an aging population. In adopting human rights standards, state should ensure that older persons are provided with meaningful opportunities for social participation by facilitating choice in living arrangements such as smaller homelike settings with sufficient staff
00:16:24 - of meaningful connections, as well as greater access to community services and facilities. This will require a range of measures including leisure, legislative policy, and regulatory, measures and adequate monitoring and working towards cultural change with the aged care sector, and also involving older persons and groups, which represent them in related decision making about living arrangements, care and support.
00:17:16 - to encourage greater understanding of closer connections and the need for closer connections between older persons and younger generations is also crucial. And of course, more interdisciplinary research and dialogue is needed on the ways to tackle loneliness and social isolation in aged care, and how the disabilities convention can be implemented in this context to best protect the rights of older persons.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis