Sometimes enough is enough: Nurses’ nonlinear levels of passion and the influence of politics

Key Question Being Explored in This Insight:

Examining nonlinear associations of work passion with job outcomes for nurses amidst work politics during a pandemic. Ilias Kapoutsis discusses the implications for nursing practice and scholarship.

View the page of: Ilias Kapoutsis

Institution: Athens University of Economics and Business

Explore more insights in:

Business Management Professional

Media Literacy Toolkit

Faculti's Media Literacy Toolkit helps viewers critically engage with academic insights by analyzing the research context, identifying perspectives, and encouraging thoughtful evaluation.

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

What assumptions does the research make?
Are there alternative perspectives not explored?
What are the limitations of the research method?

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

This research comes from Athens University of Economics and Business . Reflect on how the institution's academic focus and research partnerships may shape the questions being explored.

Further Reading ▼

Read the Study

Examining nonlinear associations of work passion with job outcomes for nurses amidst work politics during a pandemic. Ilias Kapoutsis discusses the implications for nursing practice and scholarship.

Image courtesy of interviewee. January 10, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the concept of work passion, particularly in healthcare settings like nursing, and challenges the common belief that high levels of passion always lead to enhanced performance and job satisfaction. It highlights that while work passion is generally viewed as a desirable trait that can increase engagement, commitment, and creativity—especially in high-stress fields like healthcare—it can also have negative effects when it becomes excessive or when the work environment is unsupportive.

The research identifies three core elements of work passion: affect (positive emotions associated with job activities), motivation (devotion of time to activities often at the expense of others), and identity (evaluation of work as meaningful and integral to one's self). It differentiates between harmonious passion, which is beneficial, and obsessive passion, which can lead to negative outcomes, especially in politically charged or ambiguous work environments.

The study conducted involved nurses and examined how different levels of passion influenced various work outcomes, including job satisfaction and performance. It revealed that moderate levels of passion were optimal for positive outcomes, while excessive passion could lead to increased workload without corresponding job satisfaction. Additionally, high organizational politics were found to require a balanced passion level for effective outcomes.

The findings suggest that organizations should not indiscriminately promote high passion among employees, but rather, foster environments where employees can effectively navigate political dynamics to harness their passion positively. In practice, developing skills such as political acumen can help employees manage their passion constructively, ensuring they do not experience negative consequences from excessive dedication or unclear expectations.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.245 --> 00:02.165
I would start by saying that most managers

00:02.725 --> 00:05.165
consider work passion an invaluable

00:05.225 --> 00:09.085
and hard to find, characteristic, frequently associated

00:09.235 --> 00:11.525
with, heightened performance.

00:12.105 --> 00:15.965
Uh, in healthcare organizations, for example, demands

00:16.065 --> 00:19.325
and, stress are often assumed, managers

00:19.465 --> 00:21.245
and patients and cards.

00:21.385 --> 00:24.445
And, I I could say that sometimes anticipate nurses

00:24.625 --> 00:26.685
to exhibit passion,

00:26.835 --> 00:29.925
however healthcare professional are, are at the forefront

00:30.545 --> 00:33.765
of, of illness, of, catastrophic, often death,

00:33.985 --> 00:38.525
as the recent pandemic crisis, crisis has on,

00:38.945 --> 00:40.565
in addition, they, they tend to work

00:40.745 --> 00:42.925
for more than 10, 10 to 12 hours.

00:43.065 --> 00:44.445
The job is often demanding

00:44.445 --> 00:47.525
and mistakes can be, really disastrous.

00:47.945 --> 00:51.165
Uh, however many people choose such professions

00:51.185 --> 00:53.525
and then work under, under extreme pressure

00:53.835 --> 00:57.285
because they need to exercise their passion for, for caring,

00:57.425 --> 00:59.485
for saving lives, or any other reason.

01:00.265 --> 01:03.845
Uh, however, in in our research, we challenge the assumption

01:03.995 --> 01:07.725
that the general form of passion is always desirable,

01:07.725 --> 01:10.325
suggesting that in passion, there is too much

01:10.325 --> 01:11.845
of a good thing effect.

01:12.665 --> 01:15.245
So, in, in broader terms, I would say

01:15.245 --> 01:16.885
that work passion is an emotional

01:17.465 --> 01:21.765
and rather, persistent state of desire toward,

01:21.965 --> 01:24.805
a specific job tasks or, activities.

01:25.265 --> 01:28.885
And, usually it includes three, three core elements.

01:29.025 --> 01:32.285
Uh, the first is, affect,

01:33.095 --> 01:34.565
let's imagine some positive

01:34.585 --> 01:37.325
and arousing emotions, attached with a,

01:37.485 --> 01:38.565
a task or an activity.

01:39.185 --> 01:43.125
Uh, it entails motivation, an inclination

01:43.345 --> 01:46.965
to devote time to the, to the activity, always a,

01:47.285 --> 01:49.885
although this often, may come at the expense

01:50.425 --> 01:53.085
of other activities because we sift focus, to,

01:53.085 --> 01:55.565
to the tasks that we are passionate, with.

01:56.025 --> 01:58.005
And, the third element is identity.

01:58.345 --> 02:02.445
Um, to evaluate the activity of passion as meaningful

02:02.865 --> 02:04.405
and, identity forming.

02:04.945 --> 02:08.565
Uh, so, a passionate employee would, probably say

02:08.565 --> 02:11.165
that this is not, just my job.

02:11.345 --> 02:12.925
It is, who, who I am.

02:13.625 --> 02:17.525
Um, so in general, we know that those who are more,

02:17.525 --> 02:20.485
passionate at work, tend to perform, tend

02:20.485 --> 02:22.925
to perform tasks and take initiatives

02:23.105 --> 02:25.765
to solve problems even when, rules

02:26.025 --> 02:29.125
and, expectations, are, are, are vague

02:29.345 --> 02:32.045
or, they operate in an uncertain environment.

02:32.585 --> 02:35.125
Uh, so the literature, suggests

02:35.125 --> 02:38.765
that passion relates in a, in a positive way with,

02:39.245 --> 02:43.685
numerous, work outcomes, such as, decreased,

02:43.875 --> 02:45.165
emotional exhaustion

02:45.265 --> 02:49.885
or burnout, an increased engagement,

02:50.505 --> 02:53.685
career commitment, and perhaps job creativity and others.

02:54.425 --> 02:57.205
Uh, but surprisingly, research

02:57.265 --> 02:59.605
and work passion, especially in,

02:59.835 --> 03:01.765
nursing is rather limited.

03:02.025 --> 03:04.365
We, we try to defend, we advocate that passion

03:04.985 --> 03:07.325
can be too much of a good thing,

03:07.635 --> 03:10.965
thus despite its merits, it's obvious merits,

03:10.965 --> 03:13.845
there might be instances, where work passion is,

03:14.145 --> 03:18.045
is not enough or it's harmful to employee health,

03:18.645 --> 03:21.165
satisfaction, satisfaction, behavior or, or,

03:21.165 --> 03:22.645
or even work, work performance.

03:23.185 --> 03:26.645
Um, for, for example, research suggests,

03:26.835 --> 03:30.885
potentially adverse effects, when passion is, is high,

03:31.145 --> 03:34.245
and, the, the context is, unsupportive

03:34.265 --> 03:38.365
or even, potentially threatening the work passion,

03:38.655 --> 03:42.045
tends to relate positively to, several work outcomes.

03:42.765 --> 03:45.285
Although research has indicated that there are two,

03:45.345 --> 03:47.885
two different forms, on the one hand,

03:48.065 --> 03:49.765
we are talking about harmonious passion.

03:50.265 --> 03:54.005
Uh, the passion that has all this, positive,

03:54.185 --> 03:56.565
it is the positive force, at work.

03:56.905 --> 03:59.325
But, if you have obsessive passion

03:59.865 --> 04:01.525
and you tend to, you know,

04:01.525 --> 04:03.725
narrow your focus on the specific tasks

04:03.785 --> 04:07.405
and you overdo it, then it may have deleterious,

04:07.555 --> 04:08.725
effects, at work.

04:09.105 --> 04:10.405
But in, in general,

04:10.515 --> 04:13.365
when you are talking about the general form of passion,

04:13.365 --> 04:16.325
for example, we ask how passionate, is your employee?

04:17.345 --> 04:20.165
We tend to, relate it rather positively.

04:20.225 --> 04:23.005
So we want employees that are, passionate.

04:23.425 --> 04:27.405
Uh, however, we believe that, passion in any form,

04:27.545 --> 04:28.845
cannot exist in a vacuum.

04:29.505 --> 04:33.125
Um, instead, it, its impact,

04:33.195 --> 04:37.445
depends on external work conditions, threats,

04:38.155 --> 04:42.245
rewards or punishment mechanisms, or leader attributes.

04:42.825 --> 04:47.525
And, while nurses, fight the battle to save lives,

04:47.575 --> 04:50.285
often they're left without the resources needed

04:50.545 --> 04:52.565
to provide appropriate care.

04:53.185 --> 04:55.445
Uh, for example, one nurse,

04:55.715 --> 04:58.685
that participate in the study reported that,

04:58.795 --> 05:01.085
they had better protection at, at the,

05:01.085 --> 05:05.125
at the local Starbucks, when she was,

05:05.185 --> 05:06.405
on her way to work.

05:06.945 --> 05:10.845
Uh, so in, in such demanding environments, the use

05:10.945 --> 05:15.805
of politics to secure resources is required,

05:16.105 --> 05:18.405
making politics an ideal construct

05:18.505 --> 05:20.885
to understand the impact of work passion.

05:24.155 --> 05:25.255
You've spoke there, Ilia.

05:25.255 --> 05:26.255
So my, forgive me on this

05:26.255 --> 05:29.735
because you've spoke there to the politics of, how,

05:29.875 --> 05:31.895
how politics is linked to passion in this study.

05:32.515 --> 05:35.415
Um, I haven't, got this wrong.

05:35.415 --> 05:37.495
Have I, I asked you about the related literature.

05:37.795 --> 05:39.735
Was that your answer to the related literature?

05:40.595 --> 05:45.495
Um, work passion relates positively to, to, to numbers,

05:45.565 --> 05:48.415
results, like, like performance

05:48.595 --> 05:50.255
and, citizenship behaviors

05:50.395 --> 05:52.975
and, increased job satisfaction,

05:52.985 --> 05:56.295
commitment decreased, exhaustion and burnout.

05:56.635 --> 05:59.725
But on the other hand, when, when,

06:00.025 --> 06:01.645
and this is what we suggest, that

06:01.815 --> 06:05.925
after a certain point when you have too much passion, then,

06:06.065 --> 06:10.245
we start to experience negative outcomes,

06:10.465 --> 06:12.845
in performance or even, satisfaction.

06:13.385 --> 06:18.165
And a, a, a key, construct, that depends,

06:18.345 --> 06:20.405
on whether we, we will experience

06:20.405 --> 06:21.605
that kind of negative effects.

06:21.665 --> 06:25.045
We believe that it is organizational politics, which is,

06:25.285 --> 06:29.125
a construct, that reflects, how the environment,

06:29.425 --> 06:30.445
works.

06:30.785 --> 06:32.445
So because I have, I have my passion,

06:32.505 --> 06:35.125
but the passion is, is,

06:35.585 --> 06:38.565
or let's say manifested in environments

06:38.835 --> 06:42.125
that may be uncertain or they may be mechanistic

06:42.185 --> 06:46.285
or they be maybe, fraught with politics

06:46.305 --> 06:47.925
and, other kind of situations.

06:47.945 --> 06:51.365
So we cannot isolate, isolate, work, passion

06:51.465 --> 06:53.365
and say that it's, it's always good.

06:53.625 --> 06:56.245
It might be good depending on the situation

06:56.275 --> 06:57.565
that, we are dealing with.

06:58.275 --> 07:01.325
When we discuss about, politics, at work,

07:01.675 --> 07:06.125
usually we, we, we, we speak to the perceptions

07:06.475 --> 07:10.685
that employees, have about, about others,

07:10.685 --> 07:15.005
whether others are engaging in, self-serving behaviors,

07:15.585 --> 07:18.285
often, at the expense of others

07:18.545 --> 07:21.445
or at the expense of organizational, goals.

07:21.945 --> 07:24.885
Um, so in, in our research, we argue

07:24.915 --> 07:29.445
that simply having a work passion is not always ideal,

07:29.665 --> 07:34.005
but rather, the activated level of passion matters for,

07:34.105 --> 07:35.405
for, nurse outcomes.

07:35.985 --> 07:40.005
Um, so, in, in this research,

07:40.385 --> 07:43.645
we expected that, work passion in general will,

07:43.885 --> 07:47.925
positively relate, to job satisfaction, to work effort,

07:48.425 --> 07:51.885
to citizenship, behaviors, pro-social,

07:52.255 --> 07:54.685
let's say behaviors, and then work performance.

07:55.185 --> 07:59.805
But after a point, the relationship, we expect it,

07:59.985 --> 08:01.085
we expect to be negative.

08:01.665 --> 08:06.285
Um, we know from, other studies, that,

08:06.585 --> 08:10.405
the manifestation of, of such activation levels, similar

08:10.465 --> 08:14.045
to work passion is cont contingent on situational factors.

08:14.545 --> 08:17.325
And we believe that organizational politics is a,

08:17.345 --> 08:20.525
is a very relevant contextual construct,

08:20.755 --> 08:22.805
that reflect a, a, a job demand.

08:23.505 --> 08:27.485
And while most, research views politics

08:27.745 --> 08:31.005
as an aversive, working condition,

08:31.035 --> 08:34.445
that has a negative impact on, work outcomes,

08:34.445 --> 08:38.325
sometimes politics can reflect, a process,

08:38.705 --> 08:39.925
through Wes.

08:39.945 --> 08:42.205
Uh, we can ensure power balance, we can

08:42.305 --> 08:43.965
and reads, discussions

08:44.145 --> 08:48.165
and decision making, processes, improve,

08:48.165 --> 08:51.805
organizational flexibility, perhaps overcome inertia,

08:52.265 --> 08:54.925
or adapt to environmental changes,

08:55.155 --> 08:56.885
fundamental attributes in, in,

08:56.905 --> 08:58.765
in the nursing profession, for example.

08:59.305 --> 09:03.005
So, when politics are lower, people know what

09:03.005 --> 09:07.445
to expect, rather than, immersing,

09:07.815 --> 09:11.885
let's say in the political arena at work, employees,

09:12.065 --> 09:15.005
do not have a common perception of what is expected

09:15.105 --> 09:19.005
and how contributions will lead to desired, outcomes.

09:19.505 --> 09:23.125
So, in our research, we studied work passion in,

09:23.125 --> 09:25.285
in these four, work outcomes.

09:25.425 --> 09:27.245
And, we, we advocated

09:27.245 --> 09:31.725
that this is con contingent on organizational politics,

09:31.825 --> 09:34.685
in, in terms of, methods, we,

09:34.785 --> 09:36.445
we focused on registered

09:36.545 --> 09:39.405
and licensed practical nurses,

09:39.405 --> 09:43.125
working at large hospital in the United States,

09:43.425 --> 09:45.525
amidst the, the, the, the pandemic.

09:46.265 --> 09:49.685
Um, they all worked for more than 30 hours per week.

09:49.755 --> 09:51.925
They had the permanent, work, work status.

09:52.545 --> 09:57.005
Um, we collected our data, twice, roughly,

09:57.025 --> 09:59.605
two months, apart between waves.

10:00.105 --> 10:03.925
And, for performance, we asked the nurses, supervisors.

10:03.945 --> 10:07.925
So we had, we collected data from, multiple sources,

10:08.585 --> 10:12.165
and we, we collected eventually,

10:12.875 --> 10:16.725
surveys from 330, nurses,

10:17.385 --> 10:20.925
and conducted some, sophisticated analysis

10:20.925 --> 10:22.965
to examine the, the, the relationship.

10:23.165 --> 10:27.005
I mentioned the study sold some interesting results,

10:27.235 --> 10:31.525
because initially we argued that, outcomes will be,

10:31.615 --> 10:35.685
would be most favorable when an optimal,

10:35.715 --> 10:40.285
that is a moderate, level of, work passion exists.

10:40.785 --> 10:45.765
Uh, interestingly, all the, the non-linear,

10:45.815 --> 10:47.645
let's say that, after,

10:47.645 --> 10:50.925
after a point that work passion, the effect

10:50.925 --> 10:55.045
of work passion, drops, were opposite to

10:55.075 --> 10:56.525
what we, theorized.

10:57.065 --> 10:59.125
Um, and, and that is

10:59.125 --> 11:01.005
before of course, we accounted for the,

11:01.185 --> 11:02.365
contextual effect.

11:02.465 --> 11:04.885
But, our data supported

11:05.045 --> 11:08.045
that nurses' behavioral outcomes were highest at

11:08.045 --> 11:09.085
high levels of passion.

11:09.985 --> 11:14.845
So, as passion, increases, performance,

11:15.025 --> 11:16.765
for example, increases,

11:16.905 --> 11:19.785
but job satisfaction, may not.

11:19.975 --> 11:23.545
Whereas positive work attitudes like job satisfaction

11:23.775 --> 11:26.745
promote a too much of a good thing effect,

11:27.125 --> 11:29.905
in the presence of exceedingly, high levels

11:30.005 --> 11:32.825
of work passion, these, positive,

11:32.975 --> 11:34.505
work behaviors do not.

11:35.005 --> 11:36.065
Um, thus,

11:36.465 --> 11:38.745
although, work passion may not

11:39.615 --> 11:43.465
guarantee consistently at least, high job satisfaction,

11:43.765 --> 11:47.705
it does provide the behavioral, ignition to,

11:47.765 --> 11:50.945
to repeatedly behave in ways to obtain,

11:50.945 --> 11:52.825
passion driven, goals.

11:53.905 --> 11:57.685
And yet, our general predictions for too much

11:57.685 --> 11:59.285
of a good thing effect in,

11:59.715 --> 12:03.685
work passion was supported when we added high politics

12:03.945 --> 12:05.085
in the, in the equation.

12:05.625 --> 12:10.245
And specifically, we, we found that, when perceptions

12:10.345 --> 12:14.205
of politics are high, work outcomes were higher

12:14.875 --> 12:16.885
when passion was at moderate levels.

12:17.505 --> 12:21.605
So, nurses need to be,

12:21.665 --> 12:23.445
at a moderate level to have,

12:23.445 --> 12:25.005
work passion at a moderate level,

12:25.225 --> 12:28.765
but at the same time work, in an environment,

12:29.075 --> 12:32.125
that has high, organizational politics,

12:32.125 --> 12:34.685
which might sound a bit, a bit strange.

12:35.265 --> 12:36.965
And,

12:37.275 --> 12:41.045
however, when perceptions of politics were low,

12:41.325 --> 12:43.325
a work passion did not impact,

12:43.355 --> 12:45.725
this prosocial behaviors and work performance.

12:46.065 --> 12:49.565
Um, although in such environments, job satisfaction

12:49.565 --> 12:52.445
and work careful dropped when passion was getting higher.

12:53.025 --> 12:57.245
Um, so such evidence confirm, let's say the idea

12:57.435 --> 13:02.085
that the work passion should not be examined in a silo,

13:02.145 --> 13:06.405
as its impact depends on numerous external work,

13:06.945 --> 13:09.925
contextual cues and,

13:10.185 --> 13:13.765
and taking all in our research so that high passion nurses

13:14.425 --> 13:16.645
are more satisfied with their job

13:17.185 --> 13:19.685
and, exhibit more significant,

13:19.795 --> 13:22.525
work careful work effort than proactive behavior

13:23.105 --> 13:25.805
and receive better performance appraisals.

13:26.235 --> 13:29.005
However, such benefits only hold

13:29.025 --> 13:31.165
to a certain threshold depending on the level

13:31.225 --> 13:33.805
of politics in the, in the, their context.

13:34.105 --> 13:37.485
In praxis, managers should be mindful

13:38.185 --> 13:42.645
of not an over encouraging, work, passionate,

13:42.985 --> 13:47.525
the organizations as such effects may not be, let's say,

13:47.645 --> 13:51.725
fruitful, as they can rather lead

13:51.785 --> 13:54.565
to wasted energy and, resources

13:55.185 --> 13:57.125
and perhaps employees themselves.

13:57.405 --> 13:58.885
Employees themselves must find ways

13:58.885 --> 14:01.245
to control, their passion.

14:01.755 --> 14:05.965
Otherwise, too much passion can damage rather than benefit,

14:06.465 --> 14:10.925
desired outcomes, especially when situations are,

14:11.025 --> 14:14.885
vague or they are, constantly evolving and

14:14.905 --> 14:16.125
or they are self-serving.

14:16.545 --> 14:21.305
So one way to control work passion,

14:21.525 --> 14:25.225
is to develop social skills like, political skill,

14:25.325 --> 14:27.305
for example,

14:27.525 --> 14:29.945
to navigate these political environments.

14:30.085 --> 14:33.145
So you may operate, in a, in a political environment,

14:33.145 --> 14:36.785
but if you know how to, navigate effectively, that means

14:36.785 --> 14:41.545
that you can, you can make the environment work,

14:42.145 --> 14:45.585
beneficially, towards your, your, your passion.

14:45.885 --> 14:50.025
And this finding suggests that healthcare organizations,

14:50.345 --> 14:53.605
specifically need to tolerate some political behavior,

14:54.105 --> 14:56.445
or I would say even encourage them,

14:56.535 --> 15:01.125
while developing the competence to, to navigate, such,

15:01.275 --> 15:04.045
such, ambiguous environments, effectively.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis

Data

Originals

Explainers

Podcasts

Faculti

New on Faculti

Idea Explorer

Definition

News Context

Critical Questions and Answers

Research Summaries

Sometimes enough is enough: Nurses’ nonlinear levels of passion and the influence of politics

Media Literacy Toolkit

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

Further Reading ▼