The Saga of Reginald McFadden

Key Question Being Explored in This Insight:

The Reginald McFadden commutation is a complex tale of mistakes, coincidences, and government officials courting fate. Regina Austin discusses.

View the page of: Regina Austin

Institution: University of Pennsylvania

Explore more insights in:

Law Professional

Media Literacy Toolkit

Faculti's Media Literacy Toolkit helps viewers critically engage with academic insights by analyzing the research context, identifying perspectives, and encouraging thoughtful evaluation.

Critical Questions to Consider ▼

What assumptions does the research make?
Are there alternative perspectives not explored?
What are the limitations of the research method?

Bias and Perspective Awareness ▼

This research comes from University of Pennsylvania . Reflect on how the institution's academic focus and research partnerships may shape the questions being explored.

Further Reading ▼

Read the Study

The Reginald McFadden commutation is a complex tale of mistakes, coincidences, and government officials courting fate. Regina Austin discusses.

Image courtesy of interviewee. March 15, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the impact of Pennsylvania's clemency process, particularly focusing on the case of Reginald McFadden, who was sentenced to life without parole (LWOP) but was later granted commutation. McFadden's release in 1994 led to a series of violent crimes, prompting concerns in the state about the commutation process, which saw a significant decline in approvals following his release.

The speaker compares McFadden's case to that of Willie Horton, whose crimes during a weekend furlough in Massachusetts affected political campaigning and public perception of parole. As a result of McFadden's actions, Pennsylvania politicians changed the clemency process, adding a victim advocate to the Board of Pardons and creating a requirement for unanimous votes for future commutations.

Despite these changes, the text points out that broader systemic issues remain in assessing candidates for commutation. McFadden's release illustrated flaws in evaluating inmate rehabilitation and character, leading to fear and skepticism about granting future commutations. Reflections on McFadden's behavior after his release reveal a lack of true rehabilitation, as he quickly reverted to criminal activity.

The speaker emphasizes the need for reform in the commutation process, including suggestions for legislative changes to allow for fairer evaluations, provisions for lifers to achieve parole, and a more transparent system. Additionally, there's a focus on the importance of acknowledging the victims of crime and the society's responsibility to those incarcerated. The discourse also highlights the ongoing struggle against racial stereotypes in the criminal justice system and the persistent challenge of ensuring fairness and equity in clemency proceedings.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.225 --> 00:03.045
Let me first set out, the, the context.

00:03.665 --> 00:05.245
Uh, in pen. In Pennsylvania,

00:05.485 --> 00:07.765
a life sentence means life without the

00:07.765 --> 00:08.885
possibility of parole.

00:09.395 --> 00:13.845
It's also known as LWOP and Death by Incarceration.

00:14.545 --> 00:18.165
Uh, a lifer who has demonstrated rehabilitation

00:18.385 --> 00:22.325
and has performed meritoriously, in service

00:22.465 --> 00:27.165
to the community may achieve release alive,

00:27.165 --> 00:28.925
through commutation of his sentence

00:29.035 --> 00:31.525
that requires an affirmative recommendation

00:31.525 --> 00:32.605
of the Board of Pardons.

00:32.865 --> 00:34.645
And a sign off by the governor.

00:34.995 --> 00:36.725
Between 1991

00:36.985 --> 00:41.925
and 1994, 285 lifers,

00:42.155 --> 00:45.085
including nine women were granted commutation.

00:45.675 --> 00:47.445
Between 1995

00:48.105 --> 00:52.485
and 2014, only six lifers were granted commutation.

00:53.395 --> 00:56.885
What happened? Well, one of the things that happened was

00:56.885 --> 01:00.285
that Reginald McFadden, who was serving an LWOP sentence,

01:00.345 --> 01:02.805
was commuted in 1994.

01:03.265 --> 01:06.725
Within 90 days of his release, he had killed

01:06.725 --> 01:08.725
and robbed a man, raped, murdered,

01:08.785 --> 01:12.085
and robbed an older woman, and raped, kidnapped,

01:12.185 --> 01:14.005
and robbed a second woman.

01:14.345 --> 01:17.885
And he was subsequently implicated in the murder of a third.

01:19.045 --> 01:22.645
Reginald McFadden is Pennsylvania's Willie Horton.

01:23.465 --> 01:25.205
Um, who is Willie Horton?

01:26.075 --> 01:29.805
William Willie Horton was the black

01:30.235 --> 01:33.485
Massachusetts man who was serving an LWOP sentence,

01:34.265 --> 01:37.605
who was given a weekend furlough from prison.

01:38.785 --> 01:40.045
He traveled to Maryland

01:40.855 --> 01:44.045
where he raped a white woman assaulted her partner

01:44.745 --> 01:46.445
and mad off with the man's car.

01:47.905 --> 01:52.125
His crimes sank the political fortunes of Democrat

01:52.645 --> 01:55.325
Governor Michael Dukakis, who was running

01:55.385 --> 01:57.885
for president in 1988.

01:59.635 --> 02:03.405
Dukakis political rivals, George HW Bush

02:03.705 --> 02:07.445
and Lee Atwater counted on the power

02:07.465 --> 02:09.325
of racial stereotyping

02:10.065 --> 02:14.005
and successfully used images of a

02:14.555 --> 02:19.125
wild looking Horton to link Dukakis with the threat

02:19.155 --> 02:22.725
that black criminals pose to law abiding white America,

02:24.725 --> 02:28.885
Dukakis one Bush, I'm sorry, Dukakis Lawson Bush won.

02:30.185 --> 02:31.325
Now in Pennsylvania,

02:32.685 --> 02:35.965
Reginald McFadden had a similar effect on the Governatorial

02:36.485 --> 02:40.965
campaign of Mark Single, who as Lieutenant Governor, served

02:41.345 --> 02:44.205
as chair of the pardoned board that voted

02:44.225 --> 02:48.885
to release McFadden Single lost the election to an opponent

02:48.945 --> 02:52.445
who ran on the slogan, life means Life.

02:53.455 --> 02:56.925
After that, he engineered the amendment

02:57.505 --> 03:02.045
to the Pennsylvania constitution, which added a victim

03:02.605 --> 03:04.405
advocate to the Board of Pardons,

03:04.615 --> 03:07.605
which already included the Lieutenant Governor,

03:08.185 --> 03:10.885
the Attorney General, and a corrections expert.

03:11.985 --> 03:16.845
And he engineered a, a unanimous vote requirement

03:16.985 --> 03:18.725
for future commutations.

03:19.665 --> 03:23.325
So politicians involved in the pardon process, mainly those

03:23.385 --> 03:26.685
who are interested in running for the highest offices

03:27.305 --> 03:28.965
in the State's executive branch,

03:29.755 --> 03:31.485
drew lessons from the impact

03:31.905 --> 03:35.765
of Mac Fadden on singles campaign, which

03:36.315 --> 03:39.765
also drew lessons from the impact

03:39.945 --> 03:42.445
of Willie Horton's saga.

03:43.265 --> 03:47.245
And as a result, Pennsylvania politicians

03:47.265 --> 03:49.965
who were involved in the Pardon process, chose not

03:49.965 --> 03:53.525
to risk their political fortunes on the potential law

03:53.525 --> 03:56.365
abiding behavior of communities.

03:57.515 --> 04:00.165
They refused to grant commutations

04:00.745 --> 04:02.805
and declared that they would not do so.

04:04.105 --> 04:05.845
Now, legal scholars would say

04:05.995 --> 04:08.565
that granting constitutions is part

04:08.565 --> 04:10.725
of the constitutional obligation.

04:12.895 --> 04:16.285
Executives occupying these positions in order

04:16.305 --> 04:19.045
to ensure fairness and equity in the

04:19.285 --> 04:20.325
criminal justice system.

04:22.105 --> 04:24.845
But that view has not prevailed.

04:25.705 --> 04:30.045
So be that as it may, Reginald McFadden hovers like

04:30.765 --> 04:33.565
a ghost over the commutation process.

04:35.595 --> 04:38.845
Because I had heard so much about Reginald McFadden,

04:39.405 --> 04:40.925
I wanted to know more about him.

04:41.525 --> 04:43.445
I wanted to know why he was having

04:44.115 --> 04:45.805
such an effect on the process.

04:46.825 --> 04:51.245
And what I discovered was a saga worthy of a serial

04:51.795 --> 04:53.725
True Crime podcast.

04:55.785 --> 04:59.565
Uh, New York Times article, which was written in 1995,

04:59.795 --> 05:03.405
concluded that McFadden's release was the result of

05:04.255 --> 05:07.285
fatal misjudgments, of McFadden's character

05:08.125 --> 05:09.725
bureaucratic errors

05:10.265 --> 05:13.805
and fundamental flaws in Pennsylvania's pardons process.

05:14.905 --> 05:16.325
And that about sums it up.

05:16.325 --> 05:20.645
According to the research that I did, I know

05:20.795 --> 05:25.205
what happened, but I do not know why it happened.

05:25.925 --> 05:29.565
I cannot offer an explanation

05:30.675 --> 05:32.885
from the perspective of the state actors.

05:34.105 --> 05:37.965
So I have not written the definitive story on the saga

05:37.985 --> 05:39.445
of Reginald McFadden.

05:40.325 --> 05:41.765
I could not obtain access

05:41.825 --> 05:43.805
to all the relevant official documents

05:43.805 --> 05:46.965
because of exemptions in the state's right to no law.

05:48.075 --> 05:50.445
Some files were missing,

05:50.665 --> 05:53.445
or lost, so I couldn't read those.

05:54.425 --> 05:57.605
So I turned to members of the lifer community

05:57.605 --> 06:02.005
with whom I had worked previously to get some idea of

06:02.105 --> 06:06.525
who McFadden was and some idea of the times

06:06.665 --> 06:10.765
and culture, in the state prison system at the time.

06:11.395 --> 06:14.845
However, my access to these valuable collaborators

06:14.945 --> 06:17.565
and the quality of the information

06:17.625 --> 06:22.365
and our interaction, was limited by their incarceration

06:22.425 --> 06:26.285
and the means that I had of communicating with them.

06:27.025 --> 06:29.965
But here are the highlights of what I learned.

06:30.975 --> 06:33.125
First, McFadden murdered

06:33.505 --> 06:34.845
or was involved in the murder

06:34.865 --> 06:37.285
of an elderly Philadelphia grandmother.

06:37.865 --> 06:40.085
Um, there were three others who were involved.

06:40.925 --> 06:45.445
McFadden was 16 at the time. He had two trials.

06:46.185 --> 06:48.125
Um, his co-defendants pled guilty

06:48.145 --> 06:51.885
and got off light by the time the courts were through

06:51.885 --> 06:53.005
with McFadden.

06:53.005 --> 06:55.125
However, he had an LWOP sentence.

06:56.145 --> 06:57.645
He thereafter and,

06:57.705 --> 07:01.165
and fairly rapidly filed for communication of,

07:01.345 --> 07:02.405
I'm sorry, commutation.

07:02.905 --> 07:06.965
He had eight petitions for commutation.

07:07.545 --> 07:11.285
He got a positive vote from the board four times.

07:12.385 --> 07:15.605
He was turned down by three governors,

07:16.385 --> 07:19.325
and then he was ultimately granted commutation.

07:20.985 --> 07:25.165
The governor who signed, his, commutation,

07:25.765 --> 07:29.205
documents was Bob Casey, soon senior.

07:30.505 --> 07:34.885
But Bob Casey Senior was delayed in acting on McFadden's

07:35.395 --> 07:40.165
application because in 1993, Casey

07:41.355 --> 07:42.525
basically was dying

07:43.185 --> 07:47.045
and needed a double organ transplant.

07:48.065 --> 07:53.005
And so after fewer than 24 hours on the transplant

07:53.415 --> 07:57.925
transplant waiting list, he got the organs that he needed.

07:59.385 --> 08:01.525
And there's a story behind that as well.

08:02.225 --> 08:05.645
Now, the pardon board, when they agreed to

08:07.345 --> 08:11.005
permit McFadden to be released through commutation,

08:11.745 --> 08:14.845
wanted him to spend two years in community corrections.

08:15.785 --> 08:20.325
And they specified a minimum term of years for him

08:20.515 --> 08:23.485
that took the residency in community

08:23.635 --> 08:25.165
corrections into account.

08:26.465 --> 08:31.165
But because of the delay in Casey's acting on

08:32.175 --> 08:33.205
McFadden's case,

08:34.085 --> 08:37.405
McFadden had already served out his minimum term.

08:38.635 --> 08:42.965
When he got the sign off from Casey, the relevant

08:43.965 --> 08:48.165
Pennsylvania authorities, unsure of what to do

08:48.545 --> 08:52.765
and not asking whether the,

08:52.775 --> 08:56.525
other actors had anything to say about it, decided

08:56.625 --> 09:01.325
to release McFadden without his having spent any time in

09:01.475 --> 09:02.845
community corrections.

09:03.885 --> 09:05.685
McFadden was shipped to New York

09:05.685 --> 09:09.245
because he had petitioned to serve out the rest

09:09.265 --> 09:13.365
of his mandatory life on parole in New York.

09:15.585 --> 09:20.045
Why New York? Well, he had worked,

09:20.145 --> 09:24.285
to create a cadre of supporters

09:25.095 --> 09:29.565
among a loose knit group of suburban Islamic adherence,

09:31.065 --> 09:35.405
and they had agreed that they would be available to support

09:35.425 --> 09:38.125
and supervise him on parole.

09:40.035 --> 09:43.445
Unfortunately, they were ill prepared for the task.

09:44.185 --> 09:46.845
Uh, one of them said that it was like dealing

09:46.845 --> 09:51.165
with a 16-year-old in a 41 year old's body.

09:52.225 --> 09:54.525
He also said that McFadden was a case

09:54.545 --> 09:56.205
of arrested development

09:57.065 --> 09:59.005
and that he acted like a stubborn

09:59.605 --> 10:02.285
teenager resisting parental control.

10:03.825 --> 10:06.485
The jobs they supplied the places to live,

10:06.625 --> 10:09.845
the automobile they gave him were inadequate,

10:11.185 --> 10:13.445
and McFadden made his own way,

10:13.865 --> 10:17.085
but he also resulted back to the old pattern

10:17.745 --> 10:19.205
of criminal behavior.

10:20.915 --> 10:24.205
Nothing was working, and so he went off

10:24.665 --> 10:26.045
and committed crimes,

10:27.105 --> 10:29.725
but he did find a job for himself.

10:30.905 --> 10:31.925
He got a job

10:32.145 --> 10:36.365
and he was about to, to take it when he was arrested.

10:36.865 --> 10:40.685
Um, his dream job as a counselor at a facility

10:40.905 --> 10:42.045
for troubled use.

10:44.025 --> 10:48.005
Now, McFadden was not a model candidate for commutation.

10:49.425 --> 10:51.405
Indeed, he had planned an escape

10:51.505 --> 10:54.845
and was talked out of it by a prison staff member.

10:55.905 --> 10:58.565
He did not participate in life

10:58.565 --> 11:00.805
or run organizations inside the prison.

11:01.705 --> 11:05.925
He expressed, expressed none of the regard for his peers

11:06.075 --> 11:07.445
that makes communes

11:07.625 --> 11:12.085
or other communities consider the impact of their behavior

11:12.515 --> 11:16.845
outside of the potent penitentiary on those who remain

11:17.185 --> 11:18.765
inside the penitentiary.

11:19.505 --> 11:21.085
Um, one of the bits

11:21.085 --> 11:23.725
of fallout from the Willie Horton effect.

11:25.225 --> 11:29.045
So why then did they give McFadden freedom?

11:29.995 --> 11:31.845
Well, I can't say definitively,

11:32.025 --> 11:33.765
but there are at least three reasons

11:34.475 --> 11:37.965
that I can see from the file and from my research.

11:38.985 --> 11:43.165
Number one, McFadden was a, a juvenile.

11:43.315 --> 11:47.165
When he committed the crime, he was

11:47.165 --> 11:48.885
what we call a juvie lifer.

11:50.065 --> 11:52.285
He had a tough upbringing and

11:52.785 --> 11:56.925
All the developmental limitations of juveniles,

11:57.905 --> 12:01.965
and that might have been the reason why he was commuted.

12:02.035 --> 12:04.165
That was probably the reason why he got

12:04.685 --> 12:05.965
positive votes early on,

12:07.185 --> 12:08.885
but I'm not sure it's an explanation

12:08.885 --> 12:11.925
for why he was given commutation at the age of 41.

12:13.225 --> 12:15.085
Beyond that, right?

12:15.465 --> 12:19.925
He had cooperated with prison authorities in connection with

12:20.815 --> 12:25.085
first an assault on correction officers early in his

12:25.195 --> 12:27.965
confinement in the P-A-D-O-C system.

12:28.705 --> 12:32.725
And later on he cooperated in an investigation into the

12:32.815 --> 12:36.845
activities of the fruit of Islam, the

12:37.995 --> 12:42.965
part of the nation of Islam, that was viewed as a

12:44.165 --> 12:46.405
military enforcement arm.

12:47.505 --> 12:50.045
Um, and that cooperation

12:50.585 --> 12:53.045
may have made him a sympathetic figure,

12:53.625 --> 12:56.725
at least within the P-A-D-O-C system.

12:57.625 --> 13:00.445
Of course, his fellow residents considered him a snitch.

13:01.225 --> 13:03.325
And as one of my collaborators told me,

13:03.675 --> 13:07.605
when you reward people to lie, they tell you

13:07.635 --> 13:08.885
what you want to hear.

13:09.915 --> 13:13.205
Finally, and this may be the best explanation,

13:13.865 --> 13:16.685
the board was likely convinced by his rhetoric

13:17.305 --> 13:21.685
and believed in the sincerity of his portrayal of himself

13:23.905 --> 13:28.165
as an individual pursuing his own path

13:28.165 --> 13:29.925
through self-improvement.

13:30.865 --> 13:35.765
And by being an exceptionally devout non-black,

13:35.765 --> 13:37.165
Muslim, Muslim.

13:38.705 --> 13:41.725
And one member of the Board of Pardons did vote against him

13:42.515 --> 13:45.845
when he came up this final time,

13:46.155 --> 13:47.565
that was the Attorney General,

13:49.065 --> 13:52.685
and he found McFadden's narrative glib,

13:53.355 --> 13:55.365
lacking in remorse, a bunch

13:55.365 --> 13:58.045
of words drunk together and patronizing.

13:58.425 --> 14:00.845
Um, that's an assessment with which I agree.

14:01.865 --> 14:04.045
Um, but whatever it was,

14:05.005 --> 14:08.685
McFadden worked his magic on the Board of Pardons

14:09.225 --> 14:11.165
and the governor's representatives

14:11.165 --> 14:13.325
and ultimately the governor, I suppose.

14:14.025 --> 14:16.045
Um, what's interesting, of course, is

14:16.045 --> 14:19.445
that the Attorney General, supported the changes

14:19.585 --> 14:23.525
to the commutation process, the the constitutional changes

14:23.665 --> 14:27.525
to the commutation process up

14:27.525 --> 14:30.885
until the time he was sent to federal prison for mail fraud

14:31.585 --> 14:35.645
and wound up, representing the lifers in litigation,

14:36.085 --> 14:37.925
challenging the constitutional amendments,

14:37.925 --> 14:42.325
and he is now an advocate, for incarcerated people.

14:44.185 --> 14:48.165
In any event, the constitutional amendments to the

14:48.355 --> 14:50.765
commutation process did not address

14:51.025 --> 14:54.845
The defects revealed by the commutation

14:55.105 --> 14:59.325
of Reginald McFadden, but subsequent legislative

14:59.345 --> 15:01.805
and administrative changes did.

15:02.625 --> 15:06.245
Um, the process is more rigorous in terms of assessments

15:06.505 --> 15:10.645
and face-to-face interviews at every level of the process.

15:11.825 --> 15:15.725
Uh, a stay in community corrections is now mandatory,

15:17.185 --> 15:18.885
and the path to commutation

15:19.545 --> 15:22.325
can be widened depending upon who's in charge.

15:23.105 --> 15:27.445
Um, it certainly was widened when John Federman,

15:27.505 --> 15:32.365
who is now the Senator, was the Lieutenant Governor

15:32.665 --> 15:35.445
and chair of the Board of Pardons.

15:37.025 --> 15:41.965
But the impact of the Constitutional amendments, the impact

15:41.965 --> 15:44.405
of Reginald McFadden, the impacts

15:45.345 --> 15:47.845
of Willie Horton is still there.

15:48.945 --> 15:51.685
The process is burdensome and slow,

15:52.385 --> 15:56.605
and the single vote of a public official can still sink

15:57.365 --> 16:00.645
a worthy applicant for commutation.

16:02.865 --> 16:06.885
Now, I never talk about

16:07.235 --> 16:09.765
commutation and talk about my work

16:09.955 --> 16:13.085
with lifers without expressing a sentiment

16:14.115 --> 16:18.405
with which they agree, which is to say that we have

16:18.405 --> 16:23.285
to remember the direct victims and the friends and families

16:23.305 --> 16:28.285
or co victims of those who are at paying the ult

16:28.285 --> 16:32.445
who pay the ultimate price for Reginald McFadden's,

16:32.455 --> 16:37.445
brief, tragic Willie Horton bungled commutation,

16:38.825 --> 16:42.285
which is to say to pay the price for

16:42.555 --> 16:46.765
what happened in terms of the bureaucracy

16:47.425 --> 16:50.525
of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, right?

16:51.065 --> 16:55.485
But beyond that, Pennsylvania's lifers were also harmed.

16:56.105 --> 16:59.285
Um, the present system impinges upon their hope

17:00.265 --> 17:03.045
of earning a merciful release from prison

17:03.595 --> 17:06.325
through rehabilitation and redemption.

17:07.345 --> 17:10.645
It holds them collectively responsible for the conduct

17:10.785 --> 17:11.845
of McFadden

17:12.465 --> 17:15.645
and any other future yet to be

17:16.365 --> 17:20.365
identified commune who might defy predictions

17:21.355 --> 17:25.845
even under the present, more stringent regime

17:26.265 --> 17:29.365
of the commutation process.

17:31.625 --> 17:36.405
Um, now there are some things that are being considered to

17:37.325 --> 17:40.885
underact in part the

17:41.665 --> 17:45.885
burden on lifers and on the system,

17:46.065 --> 17:48.005
and on the use of commutation

17:48.345 --> 17:52.325
to keep our criminal justice system fairer,

17:53.185 --> 17:54.605
and more equitable.

17:55.425 --> 17:59.365
Um, lifers in Pennsylvania,

17:59.835 --> 18:02.205
have sought the passage of a law

18:02.395 --> 18:06.205
that would convert all life sentences to life with parole.

18:07.225 --> 18:12.165
Uh, alternatively, there are proposals to attach

18:12.745 --> 18:17.085
to all life sentences, a fixed minimum of years,

18:17.895 --> 18:21.405
which once served would create eligibility

18:22.105 --> 18:27.045
for parole consideration, which is to say 25 to life,

18:27.145 --> 18:29.525
30 to life, 15 to life

18:30.755 --> 18:35.725
15, 20, 30 would trigger parole consideration,

18:36.505 --> 18:39.405
not release, but control, but, but,

18:39.505 --> 18:43.045
but control of the release decision by the board,

18:43.245 --> 18:45.085
a parole and probation.

18:46.385 --> 18:50.685
Um, that's not to say that there won't be pushback,

18:50.685 --> 18:54.645
there won't be political ramifications from wrong decisions,

18:54.785 --> 18:59.525
but the burden would not, fall on the executives

18:59.745 --> 19:02.125
and it would be lessened insofar

19:02.905 --> 19:05.685
as the lifers themselves are concerned.

19:06.655 --> 19:08.805
Other considerations,

19:08.855 --> 19:13.605
other alternative considerations include, legislative

19:14.365 --> 19:18.925
adoption of specific criteria for commutation,

19:18.955 --> 19:21.605
designation of a neutral arbiter

19:21.865 --> 19:26.285
or commutation council, to insulate politicians

19:26.345 --> 19:28.725
who vote in favor of commutation.

19:29.865 --> 19:32.565
So you, you pass, you pass the problem along

19:32.565 --> 19:34.325
and you get some insurance for that person.

19:34.505 --> 19:38.485
Mm-Hmm. Or the passage of another amendment to the state

19:39.005 --> 19:42.645
constitution to restore majority rule

19:43.305 --> 19:46.925
to the part of the process that is under the Board

19:46.925 --> 19:51.845
of Pardons, or to add members to the board of pardons

19:51.865 --> 19:56.845
who represent a broader spectrum of interest, maybe include,

19:57.505 --> 20:01.965
some folks who are involved in, criminal defense

20:02.665 --> 20:06.205
as opposed to, corrections,

20:06.345 --> 20:09.445
or in addition to a person from corrections.

20:10.385 --> 20:13.685
Um, I'm not confident

20:13.795 --> 20:18.125
that we can ensure that another politician

20:18.895 --> 20:22.925
won't be felt by the Willie Horton Effect in the

20:22.925 --> 20:25.485
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,

20:26.115 --> 20:29.365
because I am not confident that there

20:30.275 --> 20:34.805
will never be another Willie Horton or Reginald McFadden.

20:36.465 --> 20:40.245
But, but given the price on the other side

20:41.305 --> 20:43.645
and the impact that it has

20:44.825 --> 20:46.325
on lifers,

20:47.095 --> 20:50.645
Their families, their communities,

20:51.425 --> 20:54.965
and our desire for fairness, equity, and,

20:55.105 --> 20:59.005
and mercy, the risk may be worth taking.

21:00.065 --> 21:04.125
Um, I have to say that I'm not sure

21:04.315 --> 21:08.925
that racial stereotyping of people

21:08.985 --> 21:12.325
who are incarcerated, particularly black

21:12.345 --> 21:16.045
and brown people who are incarcerated is likely

21:16.065 --> 21:19.365
to be erased, anytime soon,

21:19.945 --> 21:21.285
though we're working on it.

21:22.145 --> 21:25.965
Um, so with

21:26.955 --> 21:30.005
work, I suspect that Willie Horton

21:30.005 --> 21:34.325
and Reginald McFadden will not be ghosts of the system,

21:35.065 --> 21:37.605
forever, but it requires work.

Quick Answers

Impact of Commutation Cases on Pennsylvania Politics

00:00:00 - Let me first set out, the, the context. in pen. In Pennsylvania, a life sentence means life without the possibility of parole. It's also known as LWOP and Death by Incarceration. a lifer who has demonstrated rehabilitation and has performed meritoriously, in service to the community may achieve release alive, through commutation of his sentence that requires an affirmative recommendation
00:00:32 - And a sign off by the governor. Between 1991 and 1994, 285 lifers, including nine women were granted commutation. Between 1995 and 2014, only six lifers were granted commutation. What happened? Well, one of the things that happened was that Reginald McFadden, who was serving an LWOP sentence, was commuted in 1994.
00:01:06 - and robbed a man, raped, murdered, and robbed an older woman, and raped, kidnapped, and robbed a second woman. And he was subsequently implicated in the murder of a third. Reginald McFadden is Pennsylvania's Willie Horton. who is Willie Horton? William Willie Horton was the black Massachusetts man who was serving an LWOP sentence,
00:01:38 - He traveled to Maryland where he raped a white woman assaulted her partner and mad off with the man's car. His crimes sank the political fortunes of Democrat Governor Michael Dukakis, who was running for president in 1988. Dukakis political rivals, George HW Bush and Lee Atwater counted on the power
00:02:10 - and successfully used images of a wild looking Horton to link Dukakis with the threat that black criminals pose to law abiding white America, Dukakis one Bush, I'm sorry, Dukakis Lawson Bush won. Now in Pennsylvania, Reginald McFadden had a similar effect on the Governatorial campaign of Mark Single, who as Lieutenant Governor, served
00:02:44 - to release McFadden Single lost the election to an opponent who ran on the slogan, life means Life. After that, he engineered the amendment to the Pennsylvania constitution, which added a victim advocate to the Board of Pardons, which already included the Lieutenant Governor, the Attorney General, and a corrections expert.

Political Risks and the Commutation Process

00:03:16 - for future commutations. So politicians involved in the pardon process, mainly those who are interested in running for the highest offices in the State's executive branch, drew lessons from the impact of Mac Fadden on singles campaign, which also drew lessons from the impact of Willie Horton's saga.
00:03:47 - who were involved in the Pardon process, chose not to risk their political fortunes on the potential law abiding behavior of communities. They refused to grant commutations and declared that they would not do so. Now, legal scholars would say that granting constitutions is part of the constitutional obligation. Executives occupying these positions in order
00:04:19 - criminal justice system. But that view has not prevailed. So be that as it may, Reginald McFadden hovers like a ghost over the commutation process. Because I had heard so much about Reginald McFadden, I wanted to know more about him. I wanted to know why he was having such an effect on the process.
00:04:51 - True Crime podcast. New York Times article, which was written in 1995, concluded that McFadden's release was the result of fatal misjudgments, of McFadden's character bureaucratic errors and fundamental flaws in Pennsylvania's pardons process. And that about sums it up. According to the research that I did, I know
00:05:25 - I cannot offer an explanation from the perspective of the state actors. So I have not written the definitive story on the saga of Reginald McFadden. I could not obtain access to all the relevant official documents because of exemptions in the state's right to no law. Some files were missing, or lost, so I couldn't read those.
00:05:57 - with whom I had worked previously to get some idea of who McFadden was and some idea of the times and culture, in the state prison system at the time. However, my access to these valuable collaborators and the quality of the information and our interaction, was limited by their incarceration and the means that I had of communicating with them.

Reginald McFadden's Controversial Commutation Case

00:06:30 - First, McFadden murdered or was involved in the murder of an elderly Philadelphia grandmother. there were three others who were involved. McFadden was 16 at the time. He had two trials. his co-defendants pled guilty and got off light by the time the courts were through with McFadden. However, he had an LWOP sentence. He thereafter and,
00:07:01 - I'm sorry, commutation. He had eight petitions for commutation. He got a positive vote from the board four times. He was turned down by three governors, and then he was ultimately granted commutation. The governor who signed, his, commutation, documents was Bob Casey, soon senior.
00:07:35 - application because in 1993, Casey basically was dying and needed a double organ transplant. And so after fewer than 24 hours on the transplant transplant waiting list, he got the organs that he needed. And there's a story behind that as well.
00:08:07 - permit McFadden to be released through commutation, wanted him to spend two years in community corrections. And they specified a minimum term of years for him that took the residency in community corrections into account. But because of the delay in Casey's acting on McFadden's case,
00:08:38 - When he got the sign off from Casey, the relevant Pennsylvania authorities, unsure of what to do and not asking whether the, other actors had anything to say about it, decided to release McFadden without his having spent any time in community corrections. McFadden was shipped to New York
00:09:09 - of his mandatory life on parole in New York. Why New York? Well, he had worked, to create a cadre of supporters among a loose knit group of suburban Islamic adherence, and they had agreed that they would be available to support and supervise him on parole.

Reginald McFadden: A Case of Arrested Development

00:09:44 - one of them said that it was like dealing with a 16-year-old in a 41 year old's body. He also said that McFadden was a case of arrested development and that he acted like a stubborn teenager resisting parental control. The jobs they supplied the places to live, the automobile they gave him were inadequate,
00:10:13 - but he also resulted back to the old pattern of criminal behavior. Nothing was working, and so he went off and committed crimes, but he did find a job for himself. He got a job and he was about to, to take it when he was arrested. his dream job as a counselor at a facility for troubled use.
00:10:49 - Indeed, he had planned an escape and was talked out of it by a prison staff member. He did not participate in life or run organizations inside the prison. He expressed, expressed none of the regard for his peers that makes communes or other communities consider the impact of their behavior outside of the potent penitentiary on those who remain
00:11:19 - one of the bits of fallout from the Willie Horton effect. So why then did they give McFadden freedom? Well, I can't say definitively, but there are at least three reasons that I can see from the file and from my research. Number one, McFadden was a, a juvenile. When he committed the crime, he was what we call a juvie lifer.
00:11:52 - All the developmental limitations of juveniles, and that might have been the reason why he was commuted. That was probably the reason why he got positive votes early on, but I'm not sure it's an explanation for why he was given commutation at the age of 41. Beyond that, right? He had cooperated with prison authorities in connection with
00:12:25 - confinement in the P-A-D-O-C system. And later on he cooperated in an investigation into the activities of the fruit of Islam, the part of the nation of Islam, that was viewed as a military enforcement arm. and that cooperation may have made him a sympathetic figure,

McFadden's Commotion: A Complex Redemption Debate

00:12:57 - Of course, his fellow residents considered him a snitch. And as one of my collaborators told me, when you reward people to lie, they tell you what you want to hear. Finally, and this may be the best explanation, the board was likely convinced by his rhetoric and believed in the sincerity of his portrayal of himself
00:13:28 - through self-improvement. And by being an exceptionally devout non-black, Muslim, Muslim. And one member of the Board of Pardons did vote against him when he came up this final time, that was the Attorney General, and he found McFadden's narrative glib, lacking in remorse, a bunch
00:13:58 - that's an assessment with which I agree. but whatever it was, McFadden worked his magic on the Board of Pardons and the governor's representatives and ultimately the governor, I suppose. what's interesting, of course, is that the Attorney General, supported the changes to the commutation process, the the constitutional changes to the commutation process up
00:14:31 - and wound up, representing the lifers in litigation, challenging the constitutional amendments, and he is now an advocate, for incarcerated people. In any event, the constitutional amendments to the commutation process did not address The defects revealed by the commutation of Reginald McFadden, but subsequent legislative
00:15:02 - the process is more rigorous in terms of assessments and face-to-face interviews at every level of the process. a stay in community corrections is now mandatory, and the path to commutation can be widened depending upon who's in charge. it certainly was widened when John Federman, who is now the Senator, was the Lieutenant Governor
00:15:37 - But the impact of the Constitutional amendments, the impact of Reginald McFadden, the impacts of Willie Horton is still there. The process is burdensome and slow, and the single vote of a public official can still sink a worthy applicant for commutation.

Challenges and Reforms in Pennsylvania's Commutation Process

00:16:07 - commutation and talk about my work with lifers without expressing a sentiment with which they agree, which is to say that we have to remember the direct victims and the friends and families or co victims of those who are at paying the ult who pay the ultimate price for Reginald McFadden's, brief, tragic Willie Horton bungled commutation,
00:16:42 - what happened in terms of the bureaucracy of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, right? But beyond that, Pennsylvania's lifers were also harmed. the present system impinges upon their hope of earning a merciful release from prison through rehabilitation and redemption. It holds them collectively responsible for the conduct
00:17:12 - and any other future yet to be identified commune who might defy predictions even under the present, more stringent regime of the commutation process. now there are some things that are being considered to underact in part the
00:17:46 - and on the use of commutation to keep our criminal justice system fairer, and more equitable. lifers in Pennsylvania, have sought the passage of a law that would convert all life sentences to life with parole. alternatively, there are proposals to attach
00:18:17 - which once served would create eligibility for parole consideration, which is to say 25 to life, 30 to life, 15 to life 15, 20, 30 would trigger parole consideration, not release, but control, but, but, but control of the release decision by the board,
00:18:46 - that's not to say that there won't be pushback, there won't be political ramifications from wrong decisions, but the burden would not, fall on the executives and it would be lessened insofar as the lifers themselves are concerned. Other considerations, other alternative considerations include, legislative

Rethinking Pennsylvania's Commutation Process

00:19:18 - designation of a neutral arbiter or commutation council, to insulate politicians who vote in favor of commutation. So you, you pass, you pass the problem along and you get some insurance for that person. Mm-Hmm. Or the passage of another amendment to the state constitution to restore majority rule to the part of the process that is under the Board
00:19:51 - who represent a broader spectrum of interest, maybe include, some folks who are involved in, criminal defense as opposed to, corrections, or in addition to a person from corrections. I'm not confident that we can ensure that another politician
00:20:22 - Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, because I am not confident that there will never be another Willie Horton or Reginald McFadden. But, but given the price on the other side and the impact that it has on lifers, Their families, their communities,
00:20:55 - and mercy, the risk may be worth taking. I have to say that I'm not sure that racial stereotyping of people who are incarcerated, particularly black and brown people who are incarcerated is likely to be erased, anytime soon, though we're working on it.
00:21:35 - work, I suspect that Willie Horton and Reginald McFadden will not be ghosts of the system, forever, but it requires work.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis

Data

Originals

Explainers

Podcasts