Popular in Professional

Leading Figures

Induction of Social Contagion

Yale University Nicholas A. Christakis

Business

The Allegory of the Favela: The Multifaceted Effects of Socioeconomic Mobility

University of Pennsylvania Leandro S. Pongeluppe

Architecture

Connecting Cities and Nature

University of Virginia Timothy Beatley

Human Rights Law

Human Rights and Corruption: Problems and Potential of Individualising a Systemic Problem

Max Planck Institute Anne Peters

Finance

Chinese Exchange Rate Policy: Lessons for Global Investors

University of California San Diego Michael Melvin

Law

A statistical approach to law school citation rankings

University of Virginia Joshua Fischman

Education

Anatomy of an educational change

View more insights in Professional - Education - Rights, Equality & Justice in Education

View more figures from University College Dublin

View the page of Ciaran Sugrue

Read the Study

Next in Education

I do plan to do that in the future, just not the near future

Tim Fish | Monash University

Posthumanist new materialist pathways for reimagining music education research

Pamela Burnard | University of Cambridge

Ciaran Sugrue provides a critical analysis of a planned change, the Safe Learning Model (SLM), devised over time by Concern Worldwide, and implemented in 100 primary or elementary schools in a rural district of Sierra Leone.

Image courtesy of interviewee. November 29, 2023

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses a development initiative in Sierra Leone, one of the poorest countries in the world, focused on improving literacy and education through a multifaceted approach led by Concern Worldwide, a significant international NGO. The initiative aimed to address various issues such as agricultural production, gender-based violence, and literacy in the context of the country's post-civil war recovery.

Sierra Leone's education system faces challenges, including the prevalence of community schools that lack government recognition, where teachers often depend on community support rather than formal salaries. The government's declaration of free primary education has not fully reached these communities. Many teachers are unqualified and rely on community resources, impacting the quality of education.

A randomized control trial was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of an intervention designed to improve literacy in 100 rural schools. While there were modest improvements in literacy levels, significant challenges remained, such as the lack of difference in student performance regardless of teacher qualifications and the failure of the educational system to improve meaningfully.

Key findings highlight the limited effectiveness of the intervention and raise critical concerns about teacher capacity, sustainability, and the potential demoralization of the workforce if support is withdrawn. This video video suggests that ongoing reliance on NGOs for educational support may enable government inaction in addressing systemic issues within teacher education and the broader education system. Overall, it underscores the complexities of implementing successful educational reforms in challenging contexts like Sierra Leone.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.275 --> 00:02.895
The context, context on the one hand of Sierra Leone,

00:03.145 --> 00:07.095
which is one of the poorest countries on the planet

00:07.915 --> 00:11.575
in West Africa, for those who don't know their geography,

00:12.395 --> 00:15.905
it was funded

00:16.125 --> 00:20.265
by Concern Worldwide, which is known,

00:20.605 --> 00:23.905
internationally, a big INGO.

00:24.885 --> 00:27.105
Uh, they'd had,

00:27.125 --> 00:29.065
and their commitment is to work

00:29.065 --> 00:30.665
with the poorest of the poor.

00:32.305 --> 00:36.245
And, you know, there are other NGOs in the same category.

00:37.305 --> 00:39.725
Uh, so they were keen

00:40.225 --> 00:43.325
as most people are in the aid industry,

00:44.275 --> 00:48.485
even though they may not like that term, are keen

00:48.585 --> 00:50.925
to identify things that work.

00:51.705 --> 00:55.765
And for the likes of concern in particular,

00:56.315 --> 00:57.885
they would, you know, one

00:57.885 --> 01:01.765
of the great phrases in development work is scaling up.

01:02.505 --> 01:05.045
Uh, so finding something that works

01:05.385 --> 01:09.965
and given concerns, involvement in several other

01:10.645 --> 01:15.085
countries, they were keen to, essentially,

01:15.115 --> 01:17.325
they put a number of things together.

01:17.665 --> 01:22.525
They'd had various single initiatives like,

01:22.705 --> 01:25.365
trying to improve agricultural production,

01:25.825 --> 01:29.565
reduce gender-based violence, improve literacy levels.

01:30.305 --> 01:34.725
So the safe learning model became an effort

01:35.265 --> 01:37.365
to put all these elements together

01:38.105 --> 01:40.845
in a more multifaceted initiative.

01:41.865 --> 01:46.005
But of course, what became core

01:46.625 --> 01:49.765
in many respects, was,

01:50.225 --> 01:53.365
did the efforts over three, four years,

01:55.005 --> 01:56.605
literacy levels in schools.

01:57.345 --> 02:00.765
And of course, that would become an important kinda

02:01.405 --> 02:02.525
flagship element.

02:03.025 --> 02:06.365
So if this works in rural Sierra Leone,

02:06.795 --> 02:08.845
then we can transplant it elsewhere.

02:09.625 --> 02:13.245
You can't talk about Sierra Leone without mentioning,

02:13.305 --> 02:17.045
you know, a very bloody conflict of civil war that went on

02:17.065 --> 02:21.165
for 10 years with massive destruction of schools,

02:21.445 --> 02:22.765
villages, and so on.

02:23.265 --> 02:27.125
So after the war ended, there was this, you know,

02:27.305 --> 02:31.165
as often happens, the international donor community say,

02:31.695 --> 02:32.805
we're going to get in there

02:32.805 --> 02:36.165
and we're going to, you know, help you out, as it were.

02:36.985 --> 02:39.645
And, you know, elements of that happened.

02:40.345 --> 02:45.005
Uh, but again, the, the hundred schools that we worked with,

02:45.545 --> 02:50.125
which were for the most part rural schools, some in

02:50.635 --> 02:54.005
sort of, you know, reasonable sized towns of five,

02:54.065 --> 02:55.125
10,000 people,

02:55.905 --> 02:59.815
but you are talking about villages,

03:00.855 --> 03:05.395
with no electricity, no public transport.

03:06.135 --> 03:09.635
Uh, one meal a day continues to be the norm.

03:10.375 --> 03:12.595
Uh, so extreme poverty

03:13.735 --> 03:18.555
and the education system often,

03:19.645 --> 03:23.095
well, an important distinction is there are government

03:23.895 --> 03:27.965
recognized schools, but post the Civil War,

03:28.215 --> 03:31.525
there are many areas that still have

03:31.595 --> 03:33.645
what are called community schools.

03:34.355 --> 03:36.925
They're not recognized by the government.

03:37.065 --> 03:38.805
Now, here's where it gets complicated.

03:39.105 --> 03:43.165
You can have a government appointed principal

03:43.865 --> 03:46.285
in those schools who gets paid,

03:47.105 --> 03:49.925
but all of the other teachers are

03:49.955 --> 03:52.965
what are called community teachers who

03:53.685 --> 03:56.805
dependent on the community, who to

03:57.335 --> 04:02.205
often pay them in kind with rice, with accommodation,

04:02.345 --> 04:06.165
or with, you know, small amounts of Leone.

04:06.345 --> 04:09.125
So even though the government in Sierra Leone

04:09.705 --> 04:13.725
has since 2018, 19,

04:14.765 --> 04:18.365
recognized all primary education as free

04:19.345 --> 04:22.045
for many of these communities, that is not the case.

04:22.705 --> 04:24.885
So, you know, that's the reality.

04:25.065 --> 04:26.405
In fact, just

04:26.425 --> 04:30.285
before we began the conversation, I was thinking about one

04:30.285 --> 04:33.525
of our postdocs, who did field work

04:33.745 --> 04:37.285
as I did going into a school one day, was greeted

04:37.865 --> 04:41.605
by an entire class leaving the school precinct,

04:42.105 --> 04:45.805
and of course, inquired as to what was going on, only

04:45.865 --> 04:49.285
to be told that the teacher, a community teacher,

04:50.195 --> 04:54.525
sent them all home to come back with two cups of rice each

04:54.825 --> 04:56.285
and 2000 leone.

04:56.505 --> 05:01.405
We struggled to establish the profi precise figure of

05:02.875 --> 05:06.765
unqualified or community teachers in the hundred schools we

05:06.765 --> 05:10.525
worked in, but it certainly was close to 50%

05:11.645 --> 05:15.795
teenagers who have done, the equivalent

05:15.895 --> 05:20.195
of junior high school, you know, 15, 16 year olds

05:20.615 --> 05:23.835
who say, you know, I want to give back to the community.

05:24.585 --> 05:28.755
When you talk to them, often they don't,

05:29.715 --> 05:33.525
well, they don't either have had, had the academic results

05:33.865 --> 05:38.565
or the resources, to go to teacher education colleges.

05:39.305 --> 05:44.185
So, but they, there's still an incredible kind

05:44.185 --> 05:47.905
of spirit of community that,

05:48.085 --> 05:52.025
but also in a sense, tempered by, well,

05:52.025 --> 05:55.705
maybe if I do this, I will somehow get

05:55.705 --> 05:57.260
to become a qualified teacher.

05:58.125 --> 06:02.485
I suppose it's difficult to separate the initiative from

06:03.305 --> 06:04.565
the research design.

06:05.145 --> 06:09.525
So at the core of this is a randomized control trial

06:10.065 --> 06:12.285
around, literacy levels.

06:13.735 --> 06:18.715
Uh, and so the intervention was introduced.

06:19.135 --> 06:23.715
Uh, there were sort of coaches, mentors, in,

06:23.975 --> 06:27.995
in each school, well, you know, between all

06:27.995 --> 06:29.355
of the schools, all of the schools.

06:29.615 --> 06:33.635
But, in, in the context of the randomized control trial,

06:34.695 --> 06:38.435
we introduced or concern introduced

06:39.135 --> 06:40.555
at staged areas.

06:40.735 --> 06:44.395
So if you think of four 20 fives, so

06:44.905 --> 06:49.145
over the period of the study, 25

06:49.165 --> 06:51.225
of the schools got all of the treatment.

06:51.325 --> 06:55.385
And so you can see that back along so that we could see

06:55.975 --> 06:59.705
what the impact of the intervention actually was.

07:00.565 --> 07:05.525
But not us as a research group were,

07:05.945 --> 07:10.285
not entirely enamored with the randomized control only.

07:11.265 --> 07:14.125
So in each of four communities,

07:15.315 --> 07:17.655
we selected four families

07:18.785 --> 07:20.725
and did in-depth studies

07:20.955 --> 07:24.565
with the families in an intergenerational way,

07:24.725 --> 07:28.525
interviewing grandparents, parents, children.

07:29.345 --> 07:31.725
And of course, often, you know,

07:32.055 --> 07:36.605
while family in a western context has become, you know,

07:36.745 --> 07:41.525
a, a a sort of a, a mess of potage, so to speak,

07:42.105 --> 07:46.805
in, in, in a West African Sierra Leone context,

07:49.105 --> 07:51.685
you, you hear kids talking about siblings,

07:52.025 --> 07:53.485
but in fact their cousins

07:53.785 --> 07:56.045
or they've been taken in somewhere.

07:56.045 --> 07:57.325
And that's part of the culture

07:57.745 --> 08:00.005
and a commitment to community

08:00.115 --> 08:03.645
that arguably we don't see in the western world anymore.

08:04.135 --> 08:07.245
Older siblings trying to help out younger siblings.

08:08.305 --> 08:12.445
The the gender dimension was particularly strong

08:12.475 --> 08:17.005
because that's an area that NGOs,

08:17.425 --> 08:19.925
in a sense, talk a great deal about.

08:20.855 --> 08:22.515
Uh, so,

08:22.615 --> 08:27.035
and there were interventions in the community so

08:27.035 --> 08:30.395
that they spoke to the adults, at,

08:30.575 --> 08:33.275
at community meetings about respect

08:33.375 --> 08:35.275
and not beating up your wife

08:35.335 --> 08:39.195
and so on, in, in the expectation that somehow

08:39.825 --> 08:43.355
extending that into the community would have a positive

08:43.535 --> 08:44.555
impact in schools.

08:45.595 --> 08:49.875
Nonetheless, there was a lot of talk, especially from,

08:50.775 --> 08:53.515
well, it didn't matter whether the teachers were

08:53.515 --> 08:55.205
qualified or not, but also

08:55.545 --> 09:00.125
Elders That now that corporal punishment had been made

09:00.195 --> 09:01.845
Illegal by

09:01.865 --> 09:05.125
The government, which only happened, you know, in

09:05.125 --> 09:06.285
or around five,

09:06.385 --> 09:07.385
Six years ago. I've

09:07.385 --> 09:09.725
forgotten the actual Date. There

09:09.945 --> 09:12.525
Was, on the one hand, a kind of a fear of being

09:13.285 --> 09:14.725
reported and potentially

09:14.985 --> 09:17.045
Jailed For beating children.

09:18.075 --> 09:21.925
Nonetheless, when we spoke to the children,

09:22.445 --> 09:23.805
corporal punishment was

09:24.075 --> 09:27.405
Sort of widespread In school and in the community.

09:27.945 --> 09:29.085
And I suppose,

09:29.825 --> 09:32.725
You know, If you put on your Westerners hat,

09:33.305 --> 09:37.405
Uh, so to speak, Well, in an Irish context, we

09:37.405 --> 09:40.365
Abolished Corporal punishment in schools as recently

09:40.425 --> 09:41.765
as 1982.

09:42.345 --> 09:44.565
Uh, so It's not long since,

09:45.025 --> 09:47.365
You know, it was quite acceptable

09:47.625 --> 09:48.845
In Western context.

09:49.505 --> 09:50.645
But nonetheless,

09:51.425 --> 09:52.885
The Struggle then of

09:53.265 --> 09:55.245
The older Population saying the

09:55.245 --> 09:56.405
country has gone to hell,

09:56.895 --> 09:59.765
We've lost Children no longer respect

09:59.765 --> 10:01.405
Their elders, because

10:01.425 --> 10:03.725
You've taken away the fear. Now, arguably,

10:03.905 --> 10:07.685
We dealt with all of that 40, 40, 50 years ago.

10:08.345 --> 10:09.405
Uh, but so

10:09.405 --> 10:11.005
It becomes a kind of a shock

10:11.025 --> 10:13.325
to the system all over again when you

10:13.835 --> 10:18.205
Realize the struggles, Uh, and that the sky won't fall

10:18.515 --> 10:21.125
Because You no longer have a stick in the

10:21.125 --> 10:22.565
classroom, given that

10:23.005 --> 10:25.245
Literacy was at the heart of this,

10:25.475 --> 10:30.005
Then Arguably, well, what the data,

10:30.585 --> 10:33.565
say, is there were

10:34.145 --> 10:38.415
Modest improvements in literacy,

10:38.835 --> 10:41.555
But you have to factor In

10:42.795 --> 10:44.535
The issue that

10:45.615 --> 10:47.935
Language acquisition, you know, is

10:48.095 --> 10:50.735
A, a whole other Ball game,

10:51.445 --> 10:54.855
Complicated First language, second language.

10:55.235 --> 10:58.615
So there are four or five

10:59.775 --> 11:02.775
Prominent languages in Sierra Leone.

11:03.805 --> 11:07.835
Uh, Mother tongue,

11:09.205 --> 11:11.425
Saw Creole being the most

11:11.675 --> 11:14.865
Widespread Language, trying

11:14.885 --> 11:17.065
to teach English in a context

11:17.595 --> 11:21.705
Where, Creole Is the language of the

11:21.705 --> 11:23.025
School,

11:23.125 --> 11:25.385
And maybe not the language of the home,

11:25.485 --> 11:27.025
though it is for many.

11:27.525 --> 11:31.385
And trying to teach English on top of that with a bunch of,

11:31.605 --> 11:32.825
Uh, teachers.

11:33.365 --> 11:35.665
And here's one of the really telling

11:36.265 --> 11:39.345
findings, there was no

11:39.395 --> 11:42.955
Difference In terms of

11:43.545 --> 11:46.715
Student Or pupil performance, whether

11:47.395 --> 11:49.275
Teachers were qualified Or not.

11:50.765 --> 11:52.305
So despite the fact that

11:52.765 --> 11:57.125
The government teachers spent, in some instances,

11:57.345 --> 12:01.725
as many as three years in, a, a, a college

12:01.785 --> 12:04.325
of education or a teacher training college,

12:04.575 --> 12:08.495
there was no evidence in the classroom,

12:08.795 --> 12:11.335
of a, a difference in the quality

12:11.595 --> 12:13.135
of the teaching and the learning.

12:13.875 --> 12:18.255
And, that's probably it, it for me,

12:18.605 --> 12:23.315
that is not so much the issue of did literacy improve.

12:23.415 --> 12:28.235
If you, if you focus on literacy, as in part

12:28.385 --> 12:31.515
what was done by the coaches that worked

12:31.515 --> 12:36.355
with the teachers in the schools, then it's not unreasonable

12:36.495 --> 12:38.715
to expect some improvement.

12:39.335 --> 12:42.395
Uh, but given over a three year period

12:42.625 --> 12:44.475
that it was relatively modest,

12:46.025 --> 12:48.405
two questions arise for me.

12:49.535 --> 12:52.955
Uh, and you know, this is an anecdote,

12:53.055 --> 12:54.555
but an important one.

12:54.905 --> 12:58.235
When we spoke to the teachers, about

12:58.825 --> 13:02.115
what the benefits were of working with the coaches,

13:03.425 --> 13:07.555
they never actually said that, well, as a consequence,

13:08.255 --> 13:12.315
you know, I'm now doing more interactive pedagogy

13:12.535 --> 13:15.865
or whatever, repeatedly

13:17.395 --> 13:20.725
they said, I know, I now know how

13:20.725 --> 13:22.485
to mark the school register.

13:25.275 --> 13:29.465
So think about what that tells us

13:30.315 --> 13:35.185
about the capacity of teachers in those circumstances,

13:36.055 --> 13:40.985
that a, a sort of a plus in their learning was

13:40.985 --> 13:43.345
that they now knew how to mark the register.

13:43.815 --> 13:46.425
When we inquired about,

13:46.425 --> 13:49.175
because government actually

13:49.695 --> 13:54.215
provided proforma lesson plans for,

13:54.765 --> 13:56.255
English in particular.

13:56.915 --> 14:00.255
Uh, yet the teachers were obliged

14:00.435 --> 14:04.495
to provide lesson plans, submit them to the head teachers

14:04.955 --> 14:08.735
for approval, if you like, despite,

14:10.165 --> 14:12.385
you know, many weeks in the field.

14:13.125 --> 14:16.145
Uh, we never saw that actually happen.

14:17.255 --> 14:21.675
Uh, the same thing was to happen when,

14:22.095 --> 14:24.995
the coaches worked with me

14:25.095 --> 14:27.915
as a classroom teacher in the school.

14:28.655 --> 14:31.475
And when we spoke to the teachers

14:31.495 --> 14:35.155
and said, well, you know, what was the feedback?

14:35.375 --> 14:38.995
You know, what was the kind of the thing

14:38.995 --> 14:43.075
that was now going to add some quality to the teaching?

14:43.655 --> 14:47.595
Uh, the most frequent answer was,

14:47.975 --> 14:50.275
either he said everything was all right,

14:50.495 --> 14:54.165
or, I accepted all his suggestions,

14:54.465 --> 14:57.925
but you never really got to grips with

14:57.955 --> 15:00.085
what those suggestions were.

15:00.905 --> 15:05.685
So, well, you know, e even

15:05.755 --> 15:10.325
with the successes, there's still the question in my head.

15:11.025 --> 15:13.325
So after you've done this intervention,

15:14.845 --> 15:17.225
it now stops, right?

15:17.765 --> 15:20.665
So if you take away the coaching

15:21.495 --> 15:25.145
that brought about these modest successes

15:26.005 --> 15:30.545
or improvements, well, everything we know about,

15:31.205 --> 15:35.865
long-term reform is the extent

15:35.885 --> 15:40.585
to which there's a kind of an attrition of change over time.

15:41.285 --> 15:45.275
So there are two major things in my head.

15:45.375 --> 15:48.955
One is, what's the capacity that's there

15:50.205 --> 15:53.175
that you can build on in the first instance,

15:53.765 --> 15:58.415
once you take away the support, what are you building in

15:58.515 --> 16:00.295
by way of sustainability?

16:01.355 --> 16:05.805
Uh, when in fact, you know, the teachers are still saying,

16:06.745 --> 16:08.965
I'm not recognized by government.

16:09.345 --> 16:13.005
I'm not trained. What I really need is access

16:13.065 --> 16:14.445
to teacher education.

16:14.665 --> 16:18.525
So for me, at a more personal professional level,

16:19.265 --> 16:23.045
and this is in a way speaks back to the title of the paper

16:23.465 --> 16:26.925
and anatomy of an intervention, is that

16:28.465 --> 16:33.165
if we've been doing this repeatedly as, as

16:34.395 --> 16:39.325
NGOs have been doing over time, with

16:40.075 --> 16:41.525
very modest results,

16:41.785 --> 16:44.205
and then you take away the supports,

16:45.595 --> 16:49.135
are you actually demoralizing the workforce

16:49.885 --> 16:52.975
more than you are actually building

16:53.535 --> 16:54.975
capacity in the system?

16:55.475 --> 16:59.095
That's one question allied to it is, is

17:00.285 --> 17:04.345
in doing these interventions, not just in Sierra Leone,

17:04.405 --> 17:08.945
but you know, there are, there are similar efforts in lots

17:08.945 --> 17:12.385
of developing, Southern Hemisphere context.

17:14.575 --> 17:19.275
Are you in effect leaving governments

17:19.495 --> 17:23.315
off the hook by saying, well, we'll do this intervention,

17:23.455 --> 17:25.995
and that allows a government to say, okay, well we,

17:26.135 --> 17:29.515
we won't do anything while you are doing that, so to speak.

17:30.135 --> 17:33.195
Uh, and so 3, 4, 5 years later,

17:34.135 --> 17:37.635
you still have no reform of initial teacher education,

17:38.205 --> 17:40.675
which is really what's necessary and urgent.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis