Popular in Professional

Business

The Allegory of the Favela: The Multifaceted Effects of Socioeconomic Mobility

University of Pennsylvania Leandro S. Pongeluppe

Architecture

Connecting Cities and Nature

University of Virginia Timothy Beatley

Human Rights Law

Human Rights and Corruption: Problems and Potential of Individualising a Systemic Problem

Max Planck Institute Anne Peters

Finance

Chinese Exchange Rate Policy: Lessons for Global Investors

University of California San Diego Michael Melvin

Law

A statistical approach to law school citation rankings

University of Virginia Joshua Fischman

Education

Firm Performance Pay as Insurance against Promotion Risk

Stockholm School of Economics Alvin Chen

Settling in outer space

View more insights in Professional - Law - Socio-legal Studies

View more figures from Cardiff University

View the page of PJ Blount

Read the Study

Next in Law

Wellbeing in the legal profession

Richard Collier | Newcastle University

Like Ships That Pass in the Night

Thomas Cotter | University of Minnesota

P.J Blount discusses the law and policy issues connected with potential human settlement in outer space.

Image courtesy of interviewee. November 27, 2023

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Comments are closed.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the evolving landscape of space law, focusing on the implications of long-term human habitation in outer space and the challenges posed by legal frameworks as humanity ventures beyond low Earth orbit. It highlights the historical context of space law, notably the Outer Space Treaty, which established key principles governing state interactions in space, including prohibitions on territorial claims and nuclear weapons deployment.

As humans contemplate settlements on celestial bodies like Mars, the text raises several critical questions, including the legal status and rights of individuals involved in such settlements, who may be considered either state astronauts or private employees. It argues for the importance of addressing legal responsibilities, emergency cooperation, and the potential for settlements to become self-sufficient and distanced from their Earth-based authorities.

The discussion emphasizes the need to rethink traditional territoriality in law and the potential for a paradigm shift in legal systems, particularly regarding sovereignty and self-governance for future space settlers. This video video concludes by inviting reflection on the fundamental principles of law and justice as they relate to the potential for human settlements in outer space.

Language:

Export as PDF

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.065 --> 00:01.165
In the volume that it's in.

00:01.165 --> 00:03.205
They're, they're trying to lay out, you know, what are,

00:03.205 --> 00:05.085
what are our future, what's our future agenda?

00:05.105 --> 00:08.365
If you're thinking about policy and law in outer space, and,

00:08.365 --> 00:10.445
and obviously the notion

00:10.625 --> 00:14.405
of long-term human habitation is one that we have had,

00:14.505 --> 00:16.245
in the space sector for, you know,

00:16.315 --> 00:18.125
well since the beginning, if not before.

00:18.445 --> 00:20.525
I mean, in the, the early 19 hundreds,

00:20.525 --> 00:23.245
people were already writing about what it would be like

00:23.265 --> 00:24.325
to live on the moon.

00:24.785 --> 00:27.125
Um, and so, you know, this, this notion

00:27.225 --> 00:30.525
of long-term settlement is one that we slowly creep closer

00:30.705 --> 00:32.045
and closer and closer to.

00:32.385 --> 00:34.845
And so sort of the context here is coming to grips with,

00:34.845 --> 00:36.885
well, what does that mean from a law

00:36.905 --> 00:40.245
and policy context, particularly projecting

00:40.245 --> 00:41.245
that well into the future?

00:41.865 --> 00:43.645
And one of the big questions that,

00:43.645 --> 00:46.205
that we have in space law is we, we recognize

00:46.205 --> 00:49.045
that space law was really established between

00:49.065 --> 00:51.485
and among states as they go up and, and, and,

00:51.785 --> 00:53.885
and engage in activities in space.

00:53.905 --> 00:56.485
And that's been very effective in low earth orbit.

00:56.825 --> 01:00.605
Um, where, you know, we have a lot of actors, as we sort

01:00.605 --> 01:02.885
of move away from low earth orbit,

01:02.885 --> 01:05.525
it gets a little bit more difficult to figure out, you know,

01:05.525 --> 01:07.085
what are the laws that are going to apply?

01:07.105 --> 01:08.805
And we've had lunar activities,

01:09.105 --> 01:11.245
but we haven't really had an establishment of

01:11.245 --> 01:12.325
how we coordinate these.

01:12.545 --> 01:14.205
And so, you know, a lot

01:14.205 --> 01:16.365
of my background comes from just thinking about

01:16.625 --> 01:19.485
how states are going to interact in space and, and,

01:19.585 --> 01:21.085
and what is going to play into that.

01:21.145 --> 01:22.445
So I work a lot with the,

01:22.445 --> 01:25.005
the literature on space traffic management,

01:25.095 --> 01:29.815
which is very much built on thinking about, you know, if,

01:29.835 --> 01:32.255
if we have two actors that wanna be in the same place at the

01:32.255 --> 01:35.015
same time, how do we come to a conclusion on that?

01:35.115 --> 01:37.535
And right now it's very, it's an ad hoc system.

01:37.995 --> 01:40.935
Um, but when you transpose that out into, you know,

01:40.935 --> 01:44.375
settlements on Mars, you have much deeper issues

01:44.375 --> 01:45.535
that you have to deal with.

01:45.635 --> 01:47.215
And so I would say that I, I,

01:47.275 --> 01:50.255
my work is very much based in sort of traditional space law.

01:50.315 --> 01:54.095
And then I, I, I use that to project forward into, well,

01:54.235 --> 01:57.935
how do we think about this as we move not just further away

01:57.935 --> 01:59.775
from, from, from the earth,

01:59.875 --> 02:02.015
but also move away from state paradigms.

02:02.435 --> 02:05.335
You know, in, in 1957, Sputnik gets launched

02:05.555 --> 02:08.015
and we kind of get these two different narratives.

02:08.115 --> 02:09.655
One is, will the Soviets beat the

02:09.655 --> 02:11.215
United States and the space race?

02:11.715 --> 02:14.375
Um, and, and that one is what we hear more often,

02:14.515 --> 02:15.775
but we often forget

02:15.805 --> 02:18.695
that there was ex an existential threat at the time.

02:19.155 --> 02:22.415
Um, the, the launch of Sputnik showed a capability

02:22.555 --> 02:24.855
to launch a nuclear weapon into space

02:24.875 --> 02:27.375
and drop it down, onto your adversary,

02:27.375 --> 02:31.455
which changed the dynamics of the potential for nuclear war.

02:31.765 --> 02:34.495
Luckily at the time, sort of the, the technology,

02:34.495 --> 02:36.975
there was a technology mismatch between these two states.

02:37.115 --> 02:39.735
And, they had the wherewithal to say, you know,

02:39.735 --> 02:41.695
maybe we should think about some rules for this.

02:41.695 --> 02:45.015
Maybe we should try to avoid conflict in outer space.

02:45.115 --> 02:46.975
And so, you know, just 10 years later

02:47.635 --> 02:49.255
we get the Outer Space Treaty,

02:49.255 --> 02:52.015
and the Outer Space Treaty sets out sort

02:52.015 --> 02:55.175
of these broad principles for how states are going

02:55.175 --> 02:57.495
to interact with each other in this space environment.

02:57.495 --> 02:59.845
And critical to that, our notions

02:59.845 --> 03:01.805
that you can't appropriate outer space,

03:01.865 --> 03:03.525
you can't make it part of your territory.

03:03.785 --> 03:05.685
And the goal behind that was to ensure

03:05.685 --> 03:06.965
that states didn't go off

03:06.965 --> 03:08.765
and have a fight over the moon as they,

03:08.765 --> 03:09.805
they sought territory.

03:10.145 --> 03:11.405
Um, there's also a rule

03:11.405 --> 03:13.365
that you can't station nuclear weapons

03:13.425 --> 03:14.965
or weapons of mass destruction in space.

03:14.965 --> 03:18.165
This, again, is linked to this idea that we want

03:18.165 --> 03:19.405
to increase security.

03:19.625 --> 03:21.445
So that's one big part of it.

03:21.465 --> 03:24.045
But the other part of the Outer Space Treaty is very much

03:24.075 --> 03:26.955
this idea that we should have cooperation

03:27.015 --> 03:28.475
and collaboration and space.

03:29.015 --> 03:30.475
And so it sets out

03:31.375 --> 03:34.215
a framework in which states can interact with each other.

03:34.635 --> 03:38.175
And key to that framework is the idea that states are going

03:38.175 --> 03:40.295
to be responsible for their non-state actors.

03:40.875 --> 03:44.095
Um, and so, you know, if, if I as a, a citizen

03:44.155 --> 03:45.495
of the United States wanna go

03:45.495 --> 03:48.535
and engage in a space activity, I have to go

03:48.535 --> 03:51.095
to the government and I have to get permission to do that.

03:51.435 --> 03:55.375
And part of that permission is ensuring that I abide

03:55.375 --> 03:56.815
by the international obligations

03:56.815 --> 03:59.575
of the United States when I engage in these activities.

03:59.675 --> 04:02.255
And so space law is very much built

04:02.275 --> 04:04.935
around this state framework, this idea

04:04.935 --> 04:06.455
that states are interacting up there.

04:06.555 --> 04:09.815
Now, states themselves have, domestic laws that,

04:09.815 --> 04:11.015
that govern space,

04:11.355 --> 04:13.655
but it's, it's, it's an integrated system.

04:13.795 --> 04:16.455
So those domestic laws do also need to comply

04:16.455 --> 04:17.615
with international laws.

04:17.675 --> 04:20.535
And so when I work through a domestic context

04:20.755 --> 04:22.215
to engage in a space activity,

04:22.795 --> 04:25.655
my state is looking out at the international system

04:25.835 --> 04:28.815
and thinking about how my activities impact their

04:28.815 --> 04:31.415
responsibility and their li liability within that system.

04:32.315 --> 04:35.935
But you can't appropriate space, by claim of sovereignty

04:35.995 --> 04:38.335
or by user occupation or by any other means.

04:38.835 --> 04:41.575
Um, and so no, you can't go up there

04:41.635 --> 04:43.615
and say, you know, this is my part of the moon

04:43.635 --> 04:44.855
and I own this part of the moon.

04:45.035 --> 04:47.135
You can't claim an orbit that this is my orbit

04:47.135 --> 04:49.695
and I own that orbit, but you can use it, right?

04:49.795 --> 04:53.215
So there is this idea that you can use these,

04:53.425 --> 04:55.655
these things and, and that's a, a,

04:55.675 --> 04:57.375
an important sort of dynamic there.

04:57.475 --> 05:00.215
So, so you can't own, but you can use.

05:00.355 --> 05:03.375
And so we have this division between sort of the,

05:03.375 --> 05:05.695
the real property notion of, of ownership

05:05.955 --> 05:07.255
and the movable property.

05:07.515 --> 05:10.535
Um, ocean notion of, of being able to like pick up a rock

05:10.635 --> 05:12.575
and use that rock,

05:12.795 --> 05:15.415
but the extension of law itself, while, while yes,

05:15.515 --> 05:18.855
law is often territorially based, the extension

05:18.855 --> 05:21.455
of law can follow the, the, the individual, right?

05:21.595 --> 05:23.655
So, if I go into space, there's still going

05:23.655 --> 05:25.335
to be personal jurisdiction over me,

05:25.395 --> 05:27.775
and I'm going to have to abide by those laws.

05:28.155 --> 05:31.335
Um, and most states that have authorization regimes

05:31.335 --> 05:33.935
for space have some sort of extension

05:33.935 --> 05:37.255
of jurisdiction over their nationals that go into space.

05:37.965 --> 05:41.055
This is one of the, the key problems that we have is that

05:41.795 --> 05:43.855
in article two, we have this idea that,

05:43.855 --> 05:46.015
that they can't appropriate by any other means.

05:46.235 --> 05:48.935
And if we think about property, right?

05:48.965 --> 05:52.415
When you own real property, that's something

05:52.415 --> 05:54.095
that you usually have to get permission

05:54.095 --> 05:55.255
to the state for, right?

05:55.385 --> 05:56.895
There is a, there's a deeded office,

05:57.105 --> 05:58.325
and those deeds are kept

05:58.345 --> 06:01.245
and there's a record of who owns this property.

06:01.705 --> 06:04.645
And so property law is often connected

06:04.645 --> 06:05.965
to this notion of territory.

06:06.465 --> 06:10.405
Now, we have had multiple attempts by people to sort

06:10.405 --> 06:13.205
of claim territory or claim property in space

06:13.205 --> 06:16.005
and say, well, the outer space treaty doesn't apply to me.

06:16.505 --> 06:19.685
But the problem becomes that you still need some state

06:19.905 --> 06:22.205
to give you a deeded or give you that license.

06:22.985 --> 06:26.805
Now, while this, how this connects over

06:26.805 --> 06:30.085
to this other problem is that at some point we're going

06:30.085 --> 06:32.525
to have a settlement that's going to say, Hey, no, you know,

06:32.525 --> 06:35.165
we've been here long enough, this is ours.

06:35.585 --> 06:37.765
And I, I do think that's a long-term problem.

06:38.265 --> 06:40.605
But, but so, so just to think about this in, in,

06:40.705 --> 06:42.885
in near mid and long-term, right?

06:42.885 --> 06:46.245
We have this near term problem of, of basically, I,

06:46.365 --> 06:48.525
I think the status of these individuals, right?

06:48.645 --> 06:49.845
I mean, and you've got two options.

06:50.075 --> 06:52.805
They could be state, that could be astronauts

06:53.025 --> 06:54.525
or they could be employees.

06:54.785 --> 06:56.245
And so if it's Elon Musk, right?

06:56.245 --> 06:57.365
Those are going to be employees.

06:57.365 --> 07:00.285
They're going to be subject to contract law,

07:00.625 --> 07:01.925
employment law.

07:02.425 --> 07:05.285
And so we have a lot of questions about what are the duties

07:05.285 --> 07:06.725
that are gonna be owed to those employees.

07:06.765 --> 07:09.245
I mean, can you imagine being on Mars,

07:09.245 --> 07:10.685
getting mad at Elon Musk

07:10.705 --> 07:12.605
and then getting fired while you're on Mars?

07:12.605 --> 07:15.525
Like, what are, what duties are owed to you?

07:16.185 --> 07:17.485
Um, and I think that that's a,

07:17.565 --> 07:19.805
a major question in the short term is just

07:19.805 --> 07:22.205
how do we treat these people that are going off

07:22.265 --> 07:23.805
to do this settlement activity?

07:23.985 --> 07:25.085
Now? And

07:25.145 --> 07:26.325
and when I say near term, right,

07:26.325 --> 07:27.925
I don't think it's super near term.

07:28.285 --> 07:30.845
I mean, there's, there's a reason nobody lives on the moons

07:30.965 --> 07:32.565
'cause it's not a pleasant thing to do.

07:33.185 --> 07:35.485
Um, but, but it is something that if we are going

07:35.485 --> 07:38.125
to pursue long-term habitation in the near term, we have

07:38.125 --> 07:40.445
to think about what are the rights of those individuals?

07:40.445 --> 07:43.045
What do we owe them moving into the midterm?

07:43.945 --> 07:46.845
If this is something that is slowly going to, to, you know,

07:46.845 --> 07:49.645
take hold and they're going to be others doing this.

07:50.145 --> 07:52.125
Um, in the midterm, we have to think about how

07:52.125 --> 07:53.405
to coordinate activities, right?

07:53.465 --> 07:55.325
If there are multiple,

07:55.475 --> 07:58.925
settlements on one celestial body, how do they interact?

07:59.265 --> 08:02.325
Um, what are the, the rights that are between them, right?

08:02.325 --> 08:04.365
Do they have to help each other in times of,

08:04.385 --> 08:05.685
of emergency and distress?

08:06.385 --> 08:08.245
How does that work? How do we make sure

08:08.245 --> 08:09.845
that they don't interfere with each other?

08:09.995 --> 08:12.565
Because it would be very bad for one settlement

08:12.625 --> 08:15.205
to inadvertently damage the other settlement

08:15.205 --> 08:17.445
and damage can cause problems, right?

08:17.445 --> 08:19.285
It, it's, it's a life or death situation

08:19.665 --> 08:20.845
in extreme environments.

08:20.945 --> 08:25.845
And then we have this sort of, this, this long-term idea

08:25.915 --> 08:28.125
that, that really gets back to this question

08:28.125 --> 08:29.285
of, well, can they own the land?

08:29.635 --> 08:31.605
Well, what happens when the settlement becomes

08:31.605 --> 08:35.805
self-sufficient and says, Hey, we don't like you government,

08:35.825 --> 08:39.085
or we don't like you corporation, and we now want to move on

08:39.105 --> 08:40.125
and be our own thing.

08:40.865 --> 08:43.925
And this is really sort of the fun question.

08:44.435 --> 08:46.205
It's one that we're, I would say

08:46.645 --> 08:48.045
hundreds of years away from.

08:48.185 --> 08:50.885
But, but how do we think about this notion of,

08:51.065 --> 08:54.565
of a human settlement breaking away from earth in the sense

08:54.565 --> 08:57.405
that we don't need you anymore and,

08:57.705 --> 09:00.845
and we don't owe you anything and you don't owe us anything.

09:01.145 --> 09:02.605
And, and, you know, again,

09:02.605 --> 09:04.325
think about this in the corporate sense, right?

09:04.715 --> 09:07.645
Elon Musk has invested a lot of money in his Mars city,

09:08.025 --> 09:10.125
and his Mars city suddenly says, we, we don't,

09:10.145 --> 09:11.685
we don't care for you, Elon.

09:12.225 --> 09:15.765
We can, we can grow our own food now and we don't need you.

09:16.315 --> 09:18.285
This is going to be a very problematic thing.

09:18.555 --> 09:21.485
This is this, this moment of a paradigm shift in the law.

09:21.905 --> 09:24.965
And it is a, it's a great opportunity to, to, you know, I,

09:25.205 --> 09:26.885
I, again, I don't think we're going

09:26.885 --> 09:28.165
to see this in our lifetime,

09:28.865 --> 09:31.365
but it's a great opportunity to reflect on

09:32.555 --> 09:33.965
what do we want out of the law?

09:34.035 --> 09:37.565
What is a legal system to us? What is just, and right?

09:37.865 --> 09:40.765
And, and that becomes, I think, a fundamental question

09:40.785 --> 09:41.965
to why we have law.

09:42.305 --> 09:45.245
And so I think that thinking about space settlement in this

09:45.245 --> 09:48.925
way gives us this sort of excellent thought experiment

09:49.425 --> 09:53.405
to think about, you know, well when is it proper for a, a,

09:53.765 --> 09:56.725
a group to break off and say we are our own thing

09:56.785 --> 09:58.445
and we want to do something different.

09:58.865 --> 10:02.085
Um, when is it right to keep them from doing that?

10:02.585 --> 10:05.485
How do we manage this division in legal systems?

10:06.025 --> 10:09.845
And, you know, we have so long thought about this in terms

10:09.905 --> 10:11.405
of territory, and,

10:11.405 --> 10:14.445
and in indeed in terms of sort of post-colonialism.

10:14.865 --> 10:18.085
But it's, it's interesting to think about it in terms

10:18.085 --> 10:19.085
of a paradigm shift.

10:19.805 --> 10:23.695
What do we think about it in terms of a settlement on, on,

10:23.875 --> 10:27.575
in, in foreign or not in foreign territory in interplanetary

10:27.735 --> 10:31.815
settlement that has depended on the earth for resupply for

10:31.835 --> 10:35.255
so long, suddenly saying, well, we're self-sufficient now

10:35.275 --> 10:36.655
and we don't need you anymore.

10:37.355 --> 10:39.455
And, and, and I just, I find that

10:39.455 --> 10:40.695
to be a really fascinating thing

10:40.695 --> 10:45.015
because it, it forces us to, to challenge the notion

10:45.015 --> 10:48.015
of territory territoriality, that's a big word to say.

10:48.175 --> 10:51.415
Suddenly it, it, it forces us to challenge that notion,

10:51.475 --> 10:52.775
and, and challenge the notion

10:52.775 --> 10:55.775
that law is explicitly linked to territoriality.

10:55.915 --> 10:57.215
And I, I find that fascinating.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis