Popular in History

Arts and Humanities

Freedom’s Dominion

Vanderbilt University Jefferson Cowie

Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

McGill University Michael Fronda

Arts and Humanities

Lincoln and the Jews

Brandeis University Jonathan Sarna

Arts and Humanities

Early Modern Natural Law Theories

University of Copenhagen Knud Haakonssen

Arts and Humanities

Phoenicians Among Others: Why Migrants Mattered in the Ancient Mediterranean

University of California San Diego Denise Demetriou

Arts and Humanities

The loneliness of leadership

University of Liverpool Elaine Chalus

Arts and Humanities

The Mughal Royal Court Progress and the Conquest Landscape

View more insights in Arts and Humanities - History - Asian History

View more figures from Rice University

View the page of Lisa Balabanlilar

Read the Study

Next in Arts and Humanities

Election Integrity in a One-Party Dictatorship

David Brandenberger | University of Richmond

The Poverty of Disaster: Debt and Insecurity in Eighteenth-Century Britain

Tawny Paul | University of California Los Angeles

How did the Mughal rulers’ initial disdain for the landscapes of South Asia transform into a deep appreciation, and what role did their peripatetic royal court play in fostering this intimate connection with the lands they governed?

Image courtesy of interviewee. October 24, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video is a detailed discussion about the author's journey in studying Timurid history, particularly focusing on the Mughal Empire and its connections to Central Asian nomadic traditions. The author, initially interested in Ottoman history, became captivated by Timurid studies under the guidance of Steven Dale, leading to a comprehensive exploration of the Mughal dynasty's heritage, ruling practices, and socio-political structures.

The narrative highlights the Mughal Empire's semi-nomadic characteristics, where mobility was integral to governance and military organization. The author emphasizes that the early Mughal rulers, descended from Timur and Genghis Khan, maintained this lifestyle, using it as a means to assert power and legitimacy over their vast territories, particularly in Northern India.

Key themes include:

1. **Mughal Mobility**: The rulers frequently traveled with massive entourages to reinforce their authority and respond to the needs of their subjects, creating a visible presence across their domains.

2. **Cultural and Political Synthesis**: The Mughals adopted and integrated local customs and urban centers into their administration while maintaining ties to their Central Asian origins.

3. **Role of Women**: Women in the Mughal court played significant roles as political actors, engaged in trade, and participated in architectural projects, thus contributing to the imperial narrative.

4. **Environmental Considerations**: The author reflects on the ecological implications of this semi-nomadic lifestyle, suggesting that their mobility allowed landscapes to recover from heavy usage.

5. **Comparative Analysis**: The author contrasts Mughal court practices with those of contemporaneous empires, particularly emphasizing that unlike Western trends toward sedentary governance, the Mughals kept their nomadic roots and utilized them for political mobilization and legitimacy.

The discussion concludes by recognizing how the Mughal Empire's blend of mobile and urban governance created unique socio-political dynamics that shaped their imperial identity and interaction with the local populations.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video:

1. **Personal Academic Journey**: The narrator, initially focused on Ottoman history, shifted their academic focus to the Timurid Mughal dynasty after being influenced by a prominent scholar, Steven Dale. This shift highlights the importance of personal intellectual influences in shaping academic pursuits.

2. **Mughal Empire and Mobility**: The Mughal rulers, direct descendants of Timur, maintained a semi-nomadic lifestyle. This mobility was integral to their rule, allowing them to project power across their territories and reinforcing their legitimacy as conquerors. They would travel with large armies, establishing their presence and often performing through spectacle, which became a key aspect of their kingship.

3. **Integration of Local Nobility**: The Mughals strategically integrated local South Asian nobility, including Rajputs, into their royal court through intermarriage and political alliances. This approach helped legitimize their rule and foster relationships with the diverse religious communities within their empire, showcasing a blend of Islamic and local governance.

4. **Role of Women in the Mughal Empire**: Women in the Mughal dynasty held significant power and influence, participating in trade, owning property, and serving as diplomats. Their involvement extended beyond traditional roles, with royal women actively contributing to the political and economic landscape of the empire, exemplified by figures like Jahanara Begum.

5. **Environmental Implications of Semi-Nomadism**: The semi-nomadic lifestyle of the Mughals, while potentially damaging in certain convideos (like during large hunting drives), allowed for sustainable interaction with the fragile Central Asian landscapes. Their mobility enabled recovery of resources and minimized local resource depletion, contrasting with the sedentary lifestyles of other empires which often led to significant ecological strain.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes from the video, which highlight important themes and ideas:

1. **On Influence and Shift in Academic Focus**:
"I changed fields, changed research languages... there's this, the sense of a human connection there that is incredibly compelling."

2. **Historical Convideo of the Timurids**:
"They are direct descendants of Timor... who built this massive West Asian empire in the wake of Mongol collapse."

3. **Social and Political Dynamics**:
"So when a new band of Mongol invaders comes in, they would rather fight each other than unify and fight off these Mongols."

4. **Mughal Identity and Heritage**:
"As rulers of India, they're still thinking as Turks and Mongols in many ways."

5. **Peripatetic Court and Kingship**:
"The movement of armies... is a reenactment of that, making a reference point to that historical kingship of Central Asia."

6. **Political Theater and Power Claims**:
"They’re claiming their conquest territories through this constant march. It's theater. It's an awe inspiring spectacle."

7. **Urban Centers and Cultural Synthesis**:
"They recognize the value of urban centers... they are not to be, dismissed, right? They’re claiming their conquest territories."

8. **Role of Women in Mughal Society**:
"Women are really involved in supporting trade and... political actors... they cannot be kings, but their bloodlines can be identified as royal."

9. **Environmental Considerations**:
"Mobility is actually logical... allows the landscape to recover essentially."

10. **Mobility vs. Sedentism**:
"While we are traveling, we are accessible. We become available to the needs of our subject people."

11. **Justice and Relationship Building**:
"It becomes something of a positive, to some degree... as a relationship building exercise."

These quotes capture the historical, social, and political complexities discussed in the video about the Mughal Empire, its rulers' identities, the nomadic lifestyle, the role of women, and the interaction with the environment.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP=LOCAL:00:00:00.000,MPEGTS:90000

1
00:00:00.185 --> 00:00:01.765
My background is American.

2
00:00:02.245 --> 00:00:04.245
I lived in Turkey for years though,

3
00:00:04.265 --> 00:00:06.645
and when I went to graduate school, it was my intent

4
00:00:06.645 --> 00:00:07.965
to study Ottoman history.

5
00:00:08.745 --> 00:00:10.005
So I went to the Ohio State,

6
00:00:10.005 --> 00:00:12.525
which had a really good Ottoman history program,

7
00:00:12.705 --> 00:00:15.085
and there I fell under the influence of a scholar

8
00:00:15.105 --> 00:00:19.205
of the Timor Moogle dynasty, Steven Dale,

9
00:00:19.655 --> 00:00:22.325
who's written the most significant work on the founder

10
00:00:22.325 --> 00:00:25.725
of the dynasty, Bob Boza Bo,

11
00:00:26.455 --> 00:00:28.365
completely carried me away.

12
00:00:28.685 --> 00:00:32.965
I changed fields, changed research languages,

13
00:00:33.185 --> 00:00:35.685
was enamored, and I've never stopped being enamored.

14
00:00:35.795 --> 00:00:40.005
There's something about the access they have given us

15
00:00:40.185 --> 00:00:43.445
to their thinking through their use of memoirs, which

16
00:00:43.465 --> 00:00:45.325
of course we read very cautiously.

17
00:00:45.865 --> 00:00:49.805
Um, but there's this, the sense of a human connection there

18
00:00:49.805 --> 00:00:51.645
that is incredibly compelling.

19
00:00:52.145 --> 00:00:55.685
Um, yes, these are public documents that are intended to

20
00:00:56.475 --> 00:00:58.365
present an argument in their favor,

21
00:00:59.105 --> 00:01:03.405
but reading it that way, we still can get a sense

22
00:01:03.405 --> 00:01:05.805
of these kings who are trying

23
00:01:05.805 --> 00:01:07.765
to justify their place in the world.

24
00:01:08.185 --> 00:01:12.165
So who are they? Uh, they are direct descendants of Timor,

25
00:01:13.535 --> 00:01:18.515
who will have built this massive West Asian empire

26
00:01:18.815 --> 00:01:21.915
in the wake of Mongol Iil collapse.

27
00:01:22.725 --> 00:01:24.355
He'll die in 1405.

28
00:01:24.575 --> 00:01:27.195
His descendants remain in an area

29
00:01:27.265 --> 00:01:29.555
that we can call it Uzbekistan.

30
00:01:29.555 --> 00:01:30.875
It wasn't Uzbekistan then,

31
00:01:30.875 --> 00:01:34.915
but it will become that their capital city of Sam, Marco K.

32
00:01:35.015 --> 00:01:39.555
But their unity is, broken up really early

33
00:01:39.775 --> 00:01:43.715
as they form a lot of rival princely kingdoms in the region.

34
00:01:44.575 --> 00:01:46.435
Um, they hate each other.

35
00:01:46.815 --> 00:01:51.475
So when a new band of Mongol invaders comes in,

36
00:01:52.095 --> 00:01:55.635
at the very beginning of the 16th century,

37
00:01:56.145 --> 00:01:58.315
they would rather fight each other than fight off,

38
00:01:58.315 --> 00:02:00.155
than unify and fight off these Mongols.

39
00:02:00.215 --> 00:02:03.715
So, these Uzbeks come in,

40
00:02:03.965 --> 00:02:07.355
break up the Timor at Heartland, send them all into,

41
00:02:08.215 --> 00:02:09.235
exile.

42
00:02:09.655 --> 00:02:13.755
And the last independent Prince is a Hiin Babu,

43
00:02:13.895 --> 00:02:18.435
and he has a, a vision of himself as a future to more.

44
00:02:19.025 --> 00:02:23.715
He's not always, really capable.

45
00:02:24.735 --> 00:02:26.995
He loses Semicon three times,

46
00:02:27.935 --> 00:02:29.835
but eventually he's able

47
00:02:29.955 --> 00:02:34.735
to form a permanent kingdom in Kabul, call to him all

48
00:02:34.735 --> 00:02:36.935
of the refugee timid elites,

49
00:02:37.635 --> 00:02:41.495
and then push downward into Northern India as a way

50
00:02:41.635 --> 00:02:45.215
of sustaining this large population of,

51
00:02:45.605 --> 00:02:47.375
refugee elites.

52
00:02:47.375 --> 00:02:50.935
Right? So he'll conquer in northern India,

53
00:02:51.045 --> 00:02:55.695
against the local, rulers who are Muslim Turks.

54
00:02:56.235 --> 00:02:58.095
Uh, the Lodi dynasty.

55
00:02:58.545 --> 00:03:02.165
He'll defeat them at the battle upon pot in 1526,

56
00:03:02.275 --> 00:03:04.645
from which point he will begin

57
00:03:04.645 --> 00:03:06.965
to conquer the entirety of the north.

58
00:03:07.295 --> 00:03:10.405
He'll spend the next four years putting down rebellion,

59
00:03:10.405 --> 00:03:14.445
seizing territory, and then dies in 1530.

60
00:03:15.225 --> 00:03:17.365
Um, and it's his descendants then

61
00:03:17.565 --> 00:03:22.125
that will formulate this mogul empire for no known reason.

62
00:03:22.425 --> 00:03:25.485
I'm, I'm really drawn to the mobility issue,

63
00:03:25.605 --> 00:03:28.285
a semi nomadism, probably one

64
00:03:28.285 --> 00:03:30.605
of the reasons I was less happy with ottoman studies

65
00:03:30.745 --> 00:03:32.845
and more happy with Timor moguls

66
00:03:32.845 --> 00:03:37.765
because this, traditional lifestyle is sustained,

67
00:03:38.265 --> 00:03:42.485
as for as long as they can afford to keep it up.

68
00:03:43.025 --> 00:03:47.925
Um, so this more traditional semi nomadic lifestyle drew

69
00:03:47.925 --> 00:03:52.765
me in, and nobody else seemed to be working on it.

70
00:03:52.765 --> 00:03:55.365
People identified a peripatetic royal court court.

71
00:03:56.025 --> 00:03:59.565
But I started reading about court progresses in Europe,

72
00:03:59.625 --> 00:04:02.485
in Western Europe, and the comparisons were just

73
00:04:02.485 --> 00:04:05.805
so compelling and interesting to me, that

74
00:04:06.395 --> 00:04:08.125
it's drawn me further and further in.

75
00:04:08.305 --> 00:04:11.325
And another part of this is the really well studied side

76
00:04:11.325 --> 00:04:14.485
of Moogle history, which is their,

77
00:04:15.125 --> 00:04:19.605
interest in the natural world, through experimentation,

78
00:04:19.825 --> 00:04:21.565
you know, scientific experimentation

79
00:04:21.565 --> 00:04:23.765
through painting and the arts.

80
00:04:24.385 --> 00:04:27.405
Uh, and then this constant movement feeds into that

81
00:04:28.815 --> 00:04:31.295
pleasure, that this real pleasure that they take

82
00:04:31.835 --> 00:04:33.015
in being in nature.

83
00:04:33.595 --> 00:04:36.615
One of the primary re sources

84
00:04:36.875 --> 00:04:38.775
for their ruling legitimacy, right?

85
00:04:38.775 --> 00:04:41.935
Their direct descendants from Genis Khan and Timor.

86
00:04:42.795 --> 00:04:47.295
So that central Asian kind of performance of kingship,

87
00:04:47.415 --> 00:04:52.255
ideology of kingship continues to inform their, their,

88
00:04:52.475 --> 00:04:57.455
actions and their values when they move into South Asia.

89
00:04:57.755 --> 00:05:00.295
So, as rulers of India, they're still thinking as Turks

90
00:05:00.295 --> 00:05:01.655
and Mongols in many ways.

91
00:05:02.755 --> 00:05:04.935
Um, so of course,

92
00:05:04.935 --> 00:05:09.335
the semi nomadic heritage is an important, aspect,

93
00:05:09.415 --> 00:05:10.615
sorry, of their rule.

94
00:05:11.475 --> 00:05:16.215
Um, and in some ways this is a reenactment of

95
00:05:16.245 --> 00:05:19.615
that, making a reference point to

96
00:05:19.885 --> 00:05:22.695
that historical kingship of Central Asia.

97
00:05:22.995 --> 00:05:26.415
But it has really practical purposes too,

98
00:05:26.445 --> 00:05:28.575
like their ancestors, they're leading army.

99
00:05:28.875 --> 00:05:32.855
So they, the first two of the great mogul kings, bu

100
00:05:32.855 --> 00:05:37.655
and ion are essentially, conquerors

101
00:05:38.165 --> 00:05:40.055
through their entire lifetimes.

102
00:05:40.085 --> 00:05:43.535
They, they don't have an opportunity for sedentary lifestyle

103
00:05:43.595 --> 00:05:48.245
to develop or, you know, the,

104
00:05:48.345 --> 00:05:50.525
the development of a kind of capital city

105
00:05:50.625 --> 00:05:55.615
and sedentary court culture, their descendants will continue

106
00:05:55.615 --> 00:05:57.095
to expand the empire.

107
00:05:58.065 --> 00:06:00.925
Uh, so much of this is the movement of armies,

108
00:06:00.945 --> 00:06:02.765
but with the, in the case of the Moogle,

109
00:06:02.765 --> 00:06:06.005
there's this really interesting overlap that happens

110
00:06:06.625 --> 00:06:07.765
in which they're traveling

111
00:06:07.765 --> 00:06:11.165
with these enormous armies while at the same time

112
00:06:12.375 --> 00:06:16.965
performing this, this very idiosyncratic,

113
00:06:17.625 --> 00:06:21.965
sustained progress through their conquest territories.

114
00:06:22.625 --> 00:06:24.805
Um, one of the things I look at is

115
00:06:24.805 --> 00:06:25.885
how they get away with this.

116
00:06:26.425 --> 00:06:28.045
How does the nobility,

117
00:06:28.065 --> 00:06:30.685
how do the subject population feel about kings

118
00:06:30.685 --> 00:06:33.995
that don't really anchor themselves?

119
00:06:35.255 --> 00:06:39.045
And, of course, for their Turkish Persian

120
00:06:39.605 --> 00:06:43.645
Mongol nobility, there's this reference to the past that's,

121
00:06:43.875 --> 00:06:46.605
that justifies that can be seen to justify them.

122
00:06:47.105 --> 00:06:50.605
But even for the South Asian nobility

123
00:06:50.745 --> 00:06:53.565
who they pull right into their royal court,

124
00:06:54.155 --> 00:06:58.605
they'll intermarry with local Raj put, families

125
00:06:59.975 --> 00:07:01.595
for those noblemen.

126
00:07:02.025 --> 00:07:04.835
This is part of a kind of, performance

127
00:07:04.835 --> 00:07:08.155
of a chakra art tin, a wheel turning ruler.

128
00:07:08.175 --> 00:07:12.035
And there are vedic injunctions that a king needs

129
00:07:12.175 --> 00:07:14.755
to move across the four quarters of his empire,

130
00:07:15.045 --> 00:07:17.475
constantly reestablishing his boundaries.

131
00:07:18.175 --> 00:07:20.195
So there's no pushback here at all.

132
00:07:20.665 --> 00:07:22.035
Well, they're empire builders.

133
00:07:22.055 --> 00:07:24.915
So a part of this is the need to conquer,

134
00:07:25.335 --> 00:07:27.675
but it's another side of that that comes up a lot,

135
00:07:27.675 --> 00:07:31.035
is the need to continually reinforce the power

136
00:07:31.295 --> 00:07:32.675
of the Moul army.

137
00:07:33.055 --> 00:07:37.115
So they will move throughout their provinces continually

138
00:07:37.615 --> 00:07:42.275
as a, as a definitive statement that they are not to be,

139
00:07:42.775 --> 00:07:43.955
dismissed, right?

140
00:07:43.955 --> 00:07:46.555
They, they're claiming their conquest territories

141
00:07:46.745 --> 00:07:48.795
through this constant march.

142
00:07:49.345 --> 00:07:52.955
It's theater. It's an awe inspiring spectacle.

143
00:07:53.255 --> 00:07:56.555
We have some great European eyewitness,

144
00:07:57.715 --> 00:08:02.555
descriptions in this period, who, expressed

145
00:08:03.285 --> 00:08:07.035
shock over the sheer size of this movement.

146
00:08:07.095 --> 00:08:11.755
It could be a hundred thousand, 200,000 individuals moving.

147
00:08:12.445 --> 00:08:14.155
It'll take 12 hours to pass,

148
00:08:14.585 --> 00:08:16.555
says one Englishman who watches it.

149
00:08:17.255 --> 00:08:20.315
So it's an awesome theater of rulership

150
00:08:20.335 --> 00:08:22.155
and power for that reason.

151
00:08:22.215 --> 00:08:23.515
It serves a political purpose.

152
00:08:24.105 --> 00:08:25.915
This is so interesting with them

153
00:08:25.945 --> 00:08:29.835
because they recognize the value of urban centers,

154
00:08:30.135 --> 00:08:33.555
and they use them, they will

155
00:08:34.205 --> 00:08:37.155
adopt local important cities

156
00:08:37.495 --> 00:08:39.195
and then build some of their own.

157
00:08:39.895 --> 00:08:43.395
Um, so Delhi, Agra Lahore, these are the great cities

158
00:08:43.455 --> 00:08:44.635
of the Moogle world.

159
00:08:45.225 --> 00:08:47.035
They'll build a few capitals.

160
00:08:47.185 --> 00:08:50.315
Homa in the second, ruler will attempt

161
00:08:50.335 --> 00:08:53.155
to build a capital outside of Delhi called Din Pana.

162
00:08:53.735 --> 00:08:54.795
Uh, which doesn't

163
00:08:54.795 --> 00:08:56.525
Take, for various reasons.

164
00:08:57.145 --> 00:09:01.525
Uh, Akbar will build Fatur sire outside of Agra next

165
00:09:01.525 --> 00:09:02.645
to a Sufi shrine.

166
00:09:02.745 --> 00:09:04.845
So he's really developing a dialogue

167
00:09:05.115 --> 00:09:09.805
with very popular local, religious, communities

168
00:09:10.115 --> 00:09:13.125
that most importantly draw not just from the Muslim

169
00:09:13.295 --> 00:09:15.245
population, but are also popular

170
00:09:15.435 --> 00:09:18.445
with other religious communities in the region.

171
00:09:18.625 --> 00:09:22.205
So it goes far beyond simply appealing to,

172
00:09:22.875 --> 00:09:25.445
Islamic royal culture, right?

173
00:09:26.145 --> 00:09:28.725
Um, but none of those, none of that really takes,

174
00:09:29.235 --> 00:09:32.325
they continue to return to Delhi, Agra Lahore.

175
00:09:33.025 --> 00:09:37.365
Um, and then, Shahan,

176
00:09:38.105 --> 00:09:41.805
the, fourth mogul emperor, I'm counting in my head,

177
00:09:42.905 --> 00:09:46.125
will build Shahan BHA in a suburb of Delhi.

178
00:09:46.385 --> 00:09:50.525
And he seems to have a vision of a real sedentary capital,

179
00:09:50.865 --> 00:09:53.285
but even in this case, his son

180
00:09:53.465 --> 00:09:55.765
and successor Arong Zeb

181
00:09:56.515 --> 00:09:58.685
will within 20 years leave

182
00:09:59.875 --> 00:10:02.295
and move the entire royal court to the Decken,

183
00:10:03.035 --> 00:10:05.505
which he's focused on conquering.

184
00:10:06.205 --> 00:10:10.035
So even Shahan is not, a,

185
00:10:10.235 --> 00:10:12.235
a permanent center until

186
00:10:12.725 --> 00:10:14.555
after the death of Arong zab,

187
00:10:14.975 --> 00:10:17.755
the moguls immediately go into a state of decline.

188
00:10:17.755 --> 00:10:22.555
Their income drops, their power drops, then they become kind

189
00:10:22.555 --> 00:10:27.315
of locked into a sedentary royal court at Shahan Budd.

190
00:10:27.335 --> 00:10:30.995
So it's a reluctant permanence, right?

191
00:10:31.655 --> 00:10:34.195
So, so architecture's really important to them

192
00:10:34.215 --> 00:10:38.475
as a demonstration of power and of aesthetic prowess, right?

193
00:10:38.735 --> 00:10:41.555
So they're gonna build gorgeous structures

194
00:10:41.555 --> 00:10:42.595
across their empire.

195
00:10:42.655 --> 00:10:45.635
And of course, they're most famous for their tombs,

196
00:10:45.925 --> 00:10:49.195
which are set in the all important imperial formal

197
00:10:49.295 --> 00:10:50.595
garden landscape.

198
00:10:51.175 --> 00:10:55.755
Um, that is an affirmation, unequivocal affirmation

199
00:10:55.755 --> 00:11:00.555
of sovereignty, that, that direct landscape,

200
00:11:01.095 --> 00:11:05.975
and they'll, enhance the kind of trade

201
00:11:06.275 --> 00:11:10.615
of their empire by building centers of trade,

202
00:11:11.415 --> 00:11:13.655
caravans for the movement of merchants

203
00:11:13.655 --> 00:11:17.655
and their goods, better roads, canals,

204
00:11:18.555 --> 00:11:20.455
and this includes women as well

205
00:11:20.455 --> 00:11:21.855
as men within the royal family.

206
00:11:22.715 --> 00:11:25.055
Uh, the women are very involved in trade.

207
00:11:25.055 --> 00:11:27.175
They themselves benefit, many

208
00:11:27.175 --> 00:11:29.695
of them own trade trading ships

209
00:11:29.795 --> 00:11:32.615
and caravans working through proxies.

210
00:11:32.995 --> 00:11:36.775
So they're really happy to continue to support this.

211
00:11:37.385 --> 00:11:40.615
Women are such a cool part of this whole Moogle narrative

212
00:11:40.685 --> 00:11:45.495
because they, I, I consider that they've inherited a,

213
00:11:45.615 --> 00:11:48.895
a, a degree of political charisma from their Turo,

214
00:11:48.975 --> 00:11:53.885
Mongol past royal women carry, some sovereignty,

215
00:11:54.065 --> 00:11:55.485
so they cannot be kings,

216
00:11:55.945 --> 00:12:00.645
but their bloodlines can be s can be,

217
00:12:01.285 --> 00:12:03.685
identified as, as, as matic

218
00:12:03.825 --> 00:12:07.115
and royal, in the Moog context.

219
00:12:07.815 --> 00:12:11.195
Um, women will serve as diplomats, their

220
00:12:12.175 --> 00:12:15.515
openly advising on politics, mostly with regards

221
00:12:15.515 --> 00:12:16.915
to family relationships.

222
00:12:17.615 --> 00:12:20.235
But they're, they're a part of this imperial project.

223
00:12:20.905 --> 00:12:23.315
They're, they're fascinating individuals.

224
00:12:23.695 --> 00:12:27.235
So they're all paid salaries, and they own property,

225
00:12:27.415 --> 00:12:29.835
and they may own ships

226
00:12:30.335 --> 00:12:34.555
and, income producing businesses.

227
00:12:35.255 --> 00:12:39.515
So with that money, their emphasis is very much on

228
00:12:40.515 --> 00:12:45.315
reinforcing this imperial, pose

229
00:12:45.745 --> 00:12:49.675
that comes with the establishment of important

230
00:12:50.515 --> 00:12:51.515
monumental architecture.

231
00:12:51.735 --> 00:12:54.555
So we have Sha Jahan building, SHA Jahan Abba,

232
00:12:54.555 --> 00:12:57.715
but it's his daughter, Johan Nara,

233
00:12:58.135 --> 00:13:01.675
who will build the great marketplace of Delhi, the Chocho.

234
00:13:02.295 --> 00:13:06.995
Um, she'll also build a major caravan sai, nearby

235
00:13:07.095 --> 00:13:09.435
so that all of the caravans,

236
00:13:09.575 --> 00:13:12.475
the merchant caravans can easily move in

237
00:13:12.475 --> 00:13:15.755
and out of the new capital city, nor Johan.

238
00:13:16.575 --> 00:13:21.035
Um, her, SHA Johan's father's wife, Johan gear,

239
00:13:21.415 --> 00:13:25.515
nor Johan builds the largest caravan ry in India

240
00:13:26.185 --> 00:13:29.675
that can house thousands of merchants and their animals.

241
00:13:30.375 --> 00:13:33.315
Um, so women are really involved in

242
00:13:34.905 --> 00:13:39.215
supporting trade and, and, activities of that kind,

243
00:13:39.275 --> 00:13:42.895
but it's because they are accepted

244
00:13:42.915 --> 00:13:47.775
as full partners in this whole, establishment

245
00:13:47.775 --> 00:13:52.055
of imperial power development of the royal of royal family,

246
00:13:52.755 --> 00:13:56.735
reinforcement of Moogle dynastic strength.

247
00:13:57.285 --> 00:14:00.295
They're not, they're not playing a role as girls, right?

248
00:14:00.295 --> 00:14:03.375
They're, they're power players. They're political actors.

249
00:14:03.965 --> 00:14:06.735
There's a, a memoir written by one of them.

250
00:14:06.835 --> 00:14:10.055
In fact, it's Ba War's daughter, UL Baan Beum,

251
00:14:10.545 --> 00:14:13.695
who's born in Kabul before the conquest of India.

252
00:14:14.155 --> 00:14:16.695
And she'll write a memoir at the request

253
00:14:16.715 --> 00:14:20.615
of her nephew Akbar, the great, mogul ruler Akbar.

254
00:14:21.575 --> 00:14:24.555
And I think historians have often found her memoir

255
00:14:24.555 --> 00:14:25.955
to be a little frustrating

256
00:14:26.265 --> 00:14:30.795
because they want it to be, a voice from the harem,

257
00:14:31.595 --> 00:14:35.125
whereas, in fact, what Goba ham is interested in

258
00:14:35.125 --> 00:14:36.165
and what she writes about,

259
00:14:36.165 --> 00:14:38.325
and the whole reason for her writing, is

260
00:14:38.345 --> 00:14:41.005
to establish the power of her dynasty.

261
00:14:41.455 --> 00:14:42.885
She's a political actor.

262
00:14:43.665 --> 00:14:48.605
So of course, when you have this, para community

263
00:14:48.785 --> 00:14:51.605
of a hundred, 200,000 people,

264
00:14:51.665 --> 00:14:56.205
sir Thomas Rowe estimates 600,000 souls, people

265
00:14:56.345 --> 00:14:59.845
and animals moving, the obvious question is,

266
00:15:00.275 --> 00:15:03.325
what dire impact does this have on the environment?

267
00:15:03.865 --> 00:15:08.045
So it's really hard to tease out, a lot of detail there.

268
00:15:08.745 --> 00:15:09.965
Uh, a turn to,

269
00:15:09.965 --> 00:15:13.245
to some military historians who've done some research on the

270
00:15:13.405 --> 00:15:17.525
movement of the troops, which is the same issue, right?

271
00:15:17.985 --> 00:15:22.645
Um, so looking at the ways that they move, the path

272
00:15:22.645 --> 00:15:25.325
that they choose to take, always near bodies, bodies

273
00:15:25.345 --> 00:15:30.045
of water, how the, the road systems are developed,

274
00:15:30.345 --> 00:15:31.725
how shade trees are planted,

275
00:15:32.265 --> 00:15:34.605
how water cleanliness is protected,

276
00:15:35.025 --> 00:15:37.085
how we dispose of refuse.

277
00:15:37.625 --> 00:15:40.725
Uh, this is all really problematic, and it's hard to get at,

278
00:15:40.745 --> 00:15:42.365
but it's very significant.

279
00:15:42.995 --> 00:15:44.925
What I think is most interesting though,

280
00:15:45.145 --> 00:15:49.325
it about this whole question is that,

281
00:15:49.945 --> 00:15:54.405
you know, semi nomadism is the logical kind of,

282
00:15:54.785 --> 00:15:58.485
e economy to develop in environments

283
00:15:58.485 --> 00:16:00.715
that are fragile, right?

284
00:16:00.735 --> 00:16:02.635
So we have the vulnerability of the,

285
00:16:02.815 --> 00:16:04.435
of the central Asian step,

286
00:16:05.695 --> 00:16:08.195
and there's no real opportunity there

287
00:16:08.255 --> 00:16:13.155
for a sedentary population to grow, permanently

288
00:16:13.265 --> 00:16:15.515
because there's little access to water.

289
00:16:15.625 --> 00:16:17.875
There's, little a access

290
00:16:17.975 --> 00:16:20.275
to sustainable arc, agriculture.

291
00:16:21.625 --> 00:16:24.005
So as a response to vulnerable

292
00:16:24.025 --> 00:16:25.725
and fragile landscapes,

293
00:16:26.885 --> 00:16:30.045
mobility is actually, logical.

294
00:16:31.495 --> 00:16:32.955
So, because, yeah,

295
00:16:32.955 --> 00:16:35.875
because the of their temporary status,

296
00:16:36.865 --> 00:16:40.195
this mobility allows the landscape to recover essentially,

297
00:16:40.655 --> 00:16:43.195
though, even though, for example, they'll run

298
00:16:43.785 --> 00:16:48.595
massive hunting drives, which is maybe responsible

299
00:16:48.595 --> 00:16:51.275
for the deaths of thousands of animals in each case,

300
00:16:51.735 --> 00:16:55.035
and the movement of a hundred thousand hunters,

301
00:16:56.855 --> 00:16:59.445
they will pops,

302
00:16:59.805 --> 00:17:04.165
probably commit terrible ecological damage and then leave,

303
00:17:04.585 --> 00:17:06.165
and the landscape recovers.

304
00:17:06.785 --> 00:17:11.285
Uh, so we don't really see, the,

305
00:17:11.385 --> 00:17:13.645
the kind of, environmental disaster

306
00:17:14.115 --> 00:17:16.685
that we would have from a sedentary royal court.

307
00:17:17.235 --> 00:17:18.565
Well, semi nomadism

308
00:17:18.625 --> 00:17:21.845
or a, a royal court progress is really common in the

309
00:17:21.845 --> 00:17:23.525
medieval period all over the world.

310
00:17:24.345 --> 00:17:29.335
Um, there are a lot of different responses to it,

311
00:17:29.475 --> 00:17:34.175
but by the 17th century, most western nations,

312
00:17:34.275 --> 00:17:37.665
and you could say most generally,

313
00:17:38.605 --> 00:17:42.505
sea semi nomadism is something kind of retrograde,

314
00:17:42.655 --> 00:17:44.385
traditional, not modern.

315
00:17:45.045 --> 00:17:49.565
So an effort to ent arise populations, which

316
00:17:49.565 --> 00:17:51.125
of course makes them a lot easier to control

317
00:17:51.225 --> 00:17:53.565
and to tax, which is the primary motive

318
00:17:53.585 --> 00:17:55.285
of government at all times.

319
00:17:56.105 --> 00:17:58.765
Um, this is part of it,

320
00:17:58.765 --> 00:18:01.165
but that also means that the actual royal courts

321
00:18:01.165 --> 00:18:02.285
begin to set to rise.

322
00:18:02.465 --> 00:18:06.165
So, in England, in France, in Spain,

323
00:18:06.165 --> 00:18:09.525
there's been some great work done recently on,

324
00:18:09.585 --> 00:18:12.805
the peripatetic Royal Court of Spain,

325
00:18:13.425 --> 00:18:17.405
and Elizabeth in England, whose movement is much,

326
00:18:17.405 --> 00:18:19.365
much smaller than that of the moguls.

327
00:18:19.745 --> 00:18:23.045
She may have had a court progress of maybe 750 people

328
00:18:23.505 --> 00:18:25.565
as opposed to 200,000,

329
00:18:26.985 --> 00:18:31.445
but she's moving, as an effort to impose her will

330
00:18:32.105 --> 00:18:35.605
on recalcitrant nobility, right?

331
00:18:35.605 --> 00:18:39.085
Those who are not adopting, the religious rights,

332
00:18:39.135 --> 00:18:42.085
she's trying to oppose who are secret Catholics, she'll go

333
00:18:42.145 --> 00:18:44.885
and settle herself on them,

334
00:18:45.425 --> 00:18:48.365
and they have to support her, her revenue,

335
00:18:48.985 --> 00:18:51.925
and it can deliberately bankrupt them, right?

336
00:18:52.905 --> 00:18:53.965
In the mogul case.

337
00:18:54.625 --> 00:18:58.045
Um, not only are they unwilling

338
00:18:58.045 --> 00:19:02.885
to give up this mobility for some, some kind

339
00:19:02.885 --> 00:19:05.725
of sense of, of modernity,

340
00:19:06.625 --> 00:19:08.925
but they are self-sustaining as they're mobile.

341
00:19:09.025 --> 00:19:10.645
And that's another part of this project

342
00:19:10.865 --> 00:19:13.525
of looking at the environmental demands

343
00:19:13.525 --> 00:19:14.525
of the court progress.

344
00:19:14.995 --> 00:19:19.725
They have entire tribal communities who will bring food

345
00:19:20.185 --> 00:19:24.925
to the mobile court, grain carrying,

346
00:19:25.865 --> 00:19:29.685
RAs, who will meet the court in it, in their,

347
00:19:30.075 --> 00:19:32.005
campgrounds and supply them with food.

348
00:19:32.095 --> 00:19:34.845
There are markets set up within the,

349
00:19:36.035 --> 00:19:38.645
camp encampment so that people can purchase food.

350
00:19:39.115 --> 00:19:41.125
They don't strain the resources

351
00:19:41.125 --> 00:19:45.535
of the actual place they are, camped on,

352
00:19:46.155 --> 00:19:48.095
nor do they strain the resources

353
00:19:48.275 --> 00:19:49.735
of the elites of that region.

354
00:19:49.995 --> 00:19:52.615
So those elites are required to come and pay ob,

355
00:19:52.915 --> 00:19:55.815
and there's a gift exchange, and it's very ritualized

356
00:19:55.815 --> 00:20:00.215
and important, but the actual, support

357
00:20:01.075 --> 00:20:04.575
of this massive population is not local.

358
00:20:05.235 --> 00:20:06.815
Uh, it's not locally driven.

359
00:20:07.475 --> 00:20:12.255
Um, and so this allows them to make this more,

360
00:20:12.415 --> 00:20:16.295
relationship building patronage, establishing

361
00:20:17.595 --> 00:20:21.295
fey reinforcing, connection locally.

362
00:20:21.915 --> 00:20:23.255
But it's not a punishment.

363
00:20:24.045 --> 00:20:26.535
It's not a way of forcing anyone to their will.

364
00:20:27.435 --> 00:20:28.815
And, and at the same time,

365
00:20:28.815 --> 00:20:31.615
the mogul kings themselves will say, you know,

366
00:20:31.615 --> 00:20:33.615
while we are traveling, we are accessible.

367
00:20:34.475 --> 00:20:38.495
We become available to the needs of our subject people.

368
00:20:38.715 --> 00:20:42.495
So we'll make, we'll make ourselves, public.

369
00:20:43.395 --> 00:20:47.885
We will respond to requests for justice or support.

370
00:20:48.665 --> 00:20:53.125
Um, will, will heighten the closeness of the relationships

371
00:20:53.155 --> 00:20:54.965
with local notables.

372
00:20:55.625 --> 00:20:59.765
So it becomes something of a, a positive,

373
00:21:00.365 --> 00:21:03.555
I mean, to some degree, I mean, there's still

374
00:21:04.805 --> 00:21:07.765
marching along with armies and elephants and horses

375
00:21:08.025 --> 00:21:10.485
and weapons, and scaring the daylights out

376
00:21:10.485 --> 00:21:11.605
of everybody, I'm sure.

377
00:21:12.265 --> 00:21:16.085
But it's interesting how they negotiate that, not

378
00:21:16.085 --> 00:21:18.845
as a punishment, but as a relationship building exercise.

379
00:21:19.475 --> 00:21:21.685
They all, they will make themselves available to

380
00:21:22.475 --> 00:21:25.725
even the most mundane subject people

381
00:21:27.355 --> 00:21:31.215
in certain circumstances in order to offer justice, right?

382
00:21:31.215 --> 00:21:35.215
So Junge will write about sitting on a riverbank,

383
00:21:35.355 --> 00:21:37.535
in Gujarat on one of his travels,

384
00:21:37.955 --> 00:21:39.855
and he's complaining bitterly, I'm tired,

385
00:21:40.035 --> 00:21:41.255
I'm sick, I'm miserable.

386
00:21:41.255 --> 00:21:44.295
It's hot here, but I am compelled to be here

387
00:21:44.295 --> 00:21:46.695
so I can offer justice the people to the people

388
00:21:46.755 --> 00:21:49.495
who wanna come and have contact with me.

389
00:21:50.555 --> 00:21:53.055
So their progress is

390
00:21:53.855 --> 00:21:55.575
imagined in a very different way than that.

391
00:21:55.575 --> 00:21:58.375
Those of other nations in the period,

392
00:21:58.375 --> 00:21:59.375
certainly Western Europe.

393
00:22:00.095 --> 00:22:02.655
I mean, we can look at the Qing in China, for example.

394
00:22:03.395 --> 00:22:07.615
How for many generations, in the late medieval period,

395
00:22:08.005 --> 00:22:10.335
they stop having a court progress

396
00:22:10.605 --> 00:22:14.295
because they're, concerned

397
00:22:14.295 --> 00:22:16.655
that it may reinforce their connection to their

398
00:22:17.315 --> 00:22:18.935
Manchu forebearers, right?

399
00:22:18.935 --> 00:22:21.215
They, they don't wanna be identified as one

400
00:22:21.375 --> 00:22:23.135
of those semi pneumatic tribal peoples.

401
00:22:23.515 --> 00:22:26.855
And later under the cho long emperor, when they're more

402
00:22:27.605 --> 00:22:31.415
confident of their right to rule, they will return

403
00:22:31.475 --> 00:22:34.575
to at least a ritualized progress, to visit shrines

404
00:22:34.575 --> 00:22:38.895
and things, to reclaim a part of

405
00:22:39.645 --> 00:22:43.175
that, legitimizing performance of kingship.

Journey into the Timurid Legacy

00:00:00 - My background is American. I lived in Turkey for years though, and when I went to graduate school, it was my intent to study Ottoman history. So I went to the Ohio State, which had a really good Ottoman history program, and there I fell under the influence of a scholar of the Timor Moogle dynasty, Steven Dale, who's written the most significant work on the founder of the dynasty, Bob Boza Bo, completely carried me away. I changed fields, changed research languages,

00:00:35 - There's something about the access they have given us to their thinking through their use of memoirs, which of course we read very cautiously. but there's this, the sense of a human connection there that is incredibly compelling. yes, these are public documents that are intended to present an argument in their favor, but reading it that way, we still can get a sense

00:01:05 - to justify their place in the world. So who are they? they are direct descendants of Timor, who will have built this massive West Asian empire in the wake of Mongol Iil collapse. He'll die in 1405. His descendants remain in an area that we can call it Uzbekistan. It wasn't Uzbekistan then, but it will become that their capital city of Sam, Marco K.

Princely Rivalries and the Rise of the Mughal Empire

00:01:39 - as they form a lot of rival princely kingdoms in the region. they hate each other. So when a new band of Mongol invaders comes in, at the very beginning of the 16th century, they would rather fight each other than fight off, than unify and fight off these Mongols. So, these Uzbeks come in, break up the Timor at Heartland, send them all into,

00:02:09 - And the last independent Prince is a Hiin Babu, and he has a, a vision of himself as a future to more. He's not always, really capable. He loses Semicon three times, but eventually he's able to form a permanent kingdom in Kabul, call to him all of the refugee timid elites, and then push downward into Northern India as a way

00:02:45 - refugee elites. Right? So he'll conquer in northern India, against the local, rulers who are Muslim Turks. the Lodi dynasty. He'll defeat them at the battle upon pot in 1526, from which point he will begin to conquer the entirety of the north. He'll spend the next four years putting down rebellion, seizing territory, and then dies in 1530.

Mobility and Kingship in Mughal Culture

00:03:17 - that will formulate this mogul empire for no known reason. I'm, I'm really drawn to the mobility issue, a semi nomadism, probably one of the reasons I was less happy with ottoman studies and more happy with Timor moguls because this, traditional lifestyle is sustained, as for as long as they can afford to keep it up. so this more traditional semi nomadic lifestyle drew

00:03:52 - People identified a peripatetic royal court court. But I started reading about court progresses in Europe, in Western Europe, and the comparisons were just so compelling and interesting to me, that it's drawn me further and further in. And another part of this is the really well studied side of Moogle history, which is their, interest in the natural world, through experimentation,

00:04:21 - through painting and the arts. and then this constant movement feeds into that pleasure, that this real pleasure that they take in being in nature. One of the primary re sources for their ruling legitimacy, right? Their direct descendants from Genis Khan and Timor. So that central Asian kind of performance of kingship, ideology of kingship continues to inform their, their,

Legacy of Semi-Nomadic Rulership in Mughal India

00:04:57 - So, as rulers of India, they're still thinking as Turks and Mongols in many ways. so of course, the semi nomadic heritage is an important, aspect, sorry, of their rule. and in some ways this is a reenactment of that, making a reference point to that historical kingship of Central Asia.

00:05:26 - like their ancestors, they're leading army. So they, the first two of the great mogul kings, bu and ion are essentially, conquerors through their entire lifetimes. They, they don't have an opportunity for sedentary lifestyle to develop or, you know, the, the development of a kind of capital city and sedentary court culture, their descendants will continue

00:05:58 - so much of this is the movement of armies, but with the, in the case of the Moogle, there's this really interesting overlap that happens in which they're traveling with these enormous armies while at the same time performing this, this very idiosyncratic, sustained progress through their conquest territories. one of the things I look at is how they get away with this.

Imperial Mobility and the Performance of Kingship

00:06:28 - how do the subject population feel about kings that don't really anchor themselves? And, of course, for their Turkish Persian Mongol nobility, there's this reference to the past that's, that justifies that can be seen to justify them. But even for the South Asian nobility who they pull right into their royal court, they'll intermarry with local Raj put, families

00:07:02 - This is part of a kind of, performance of a chakra art tin, a wheel turning ruler. And there are vedic injunctions that a king needs to move across the four quarters of his empire, constantly reestablishing his boundaries. So there's no pushback here at all. Well, they're empire builders. So a part of this is the need to conquer, but it's another side of that that comes up a lot, is the need to continually reinforce the power

00:07:33 - So they will move throughout their provinces continually as a, as a definitive statement that they are not to be, dismissed, right? They, they're claiming their conquest territories through this constant march. It's theater. It's an awe inspiring spectacle. We have some great European eyewitness, descriptions in this period, who, expressed

The Majesty of Mogul Movements and Urban Foundations

00:08:07 - It could be a hundred thousand, 200,000 individuals moving. It'll take 12 hours to pass, says one Englishman who watches it. So it's an awesome theater of rulership and power for that reason. It serves a political purpose. This is so interesting with them because they recognize the value of urban centers, and they use them, they will

00:08:37 - and then build some of their own. so Delhi, Agra Lahore, these are the great cities of the Moogle world. They'll build a few capitals. Homa in the second, ruler will attempt to build a capital outside of Delhi called Din Pana. which doesn't Take, for various reasons. Akbar will build Fatur sire outside of Agra next to a Sufi shrine. So he's really developing a dialogue

00:09:10 - that most importantly draw not just from the Muslim population, but are also popular with other religious communities in the region. So it goes far beyond simply appealing to, Islamic royal culture, right? but none of those, none of that really takes, they continue to return to Delhi, Agra Lahore. and then, Shahan,

The Evolution of Mughal Capital and Architecture

00:09:42 - will build Shahan BHA in a suburb of Delhi. And he seems to have a vision of a real sedentary capital, but even in this case, his son and successor Arong Zeb will within 20 years leave and move the entire royal court to the Decken, which he's focused on conquering. So even Shahan is not, a,

00:10:12 - after the death of Arong zab, the moguls immediately go into a state of decline. Their income drops, their power drops, then they become kind of locked into a sedentary royal court at Shahan Budd. So it's a reluctant permanence, right? So, so architecture's really important to them as a demonstration of power and of aesthetic prowess, right? So they're gonna build gorgeous structures

00:10:42 - And of course, they're most famous for their tombs, which are set in the all important imperial formal garden landscape. that is an affirmation, unequivocal affirmation of sovereignty, that, that direct landscape, and they'll, enhance the kind of trade of their empire by building centers of trade, caravans for the movement of merchants

Empowered Women in the Mughal Empire

00:11:18 - and this includes women as well as men within the royal family. the women are very involved in trade. They themselves benefit, many of them own trade trading ships and caravans working through proxies. So they're really happy to continue to support this. Women are such a cool part of this whole Moogle narrative because they, I, I consider that they've inherited a,

00:11:48 - Mongol past royal women carry, some sovereignty, so they cannot be kings, but their bloodlines can be s can be, identified as, as, as matic and royal, in the Moog context. women will serve as diplomats, their openly advising on politics, mostly with regards to family relationships.

00:12:20 - They're, they're fascinating individuals. So they're all paid salaries, and they own property, and they may own ships and, income producing businesses. So with that money, their emphasis is very much on reinforcing this imperial, pose that comes with the establishment of important

Empowered Women in Mughal Trade and Politics

00:12:51 - So we have Sha Jahan building, SHA Jahan Abba, but it's his daughter, Johan Nara, who will build the great marketplace of Delhi, the Chocho. she'll also build a major caravan sai, nearby so that all of the caravans, the merchant caravans can easily move in and out of the new capital city, nor Johan. her, SHA Johan's father's wife, Johan gear,

00:13:26 - that can house thousands of merchants and their animals. so women are really involved in supporting trade and, and, activities of that kind, but it's because they are accepted as full partners in this whole, establishment of imperial power development of the royal of royal family,

00:13:57 - They're not, they're not playing a role as girls, right? They're, they're power players. They're political actors. There's a, a memoir written by one of them. In fact, it's Ba War's daughter, UL Baan Beum, who's born in Kabul before the conquest of India. And she'll write a memoir at the request of her nephew Akbar, the great, mogul ruler Akbar. And I think historians have often found her memoir

Voices of Power: The Political Role of Women in Mogul History

00:14:26 - because they want it to be, a voice from the harem, whereas, in fact, what Goba ham is interested in and what she writes about, and the whole reason for her writing, is to establish the power of her dynasty. She's a political actor. So of course, when you have this, para community of a hundred, 200,000 people, sir Thomas Rowe estimates 600,000 souls, people

00:15:00 - what dire impact does this have on the environment? So it's really hard to tease out, a lot of detail there. a turn to, to some military historians who've done some research on the movement of the troops, which is the same issue, right? so looking at the ways that they move, the path that they choose to take, always near bodies, bodies of water, how the, the road systems are developed,

00:15:32 - how water cleanliness is protected, how we dispose of refuse. this is all really problematic, and it's hard to get at, but it's very significant. What I think is most interesting though, it about this whole question is that, you know, semi nomadism is the logical kind of, e economy to develop in environments that are fragile, right?

Mobility and Environmental Impact in Central Asian Nomadism

00:16:02 - of the central Asian step, and there's no real opportunity there for a sedentary population to grow, permanently because there's little access to water. There's, little a access to sustainable arc, agriculture. So as a response to vulnerable and fragile landscapes, mobility is actually, logical.

00:16:32 - because the of their temporary status, this mobility allows the landscape to recover essentially, though, even though, for example, they'll run massive hunting drives, which is maybe responsible for the deaths of thousands of animals in each case, and the movement of a hundred thousand hunters, they will pops, probably commit terrible ecological damage and then leave,

00:17:06 - so we don't really see, the, the kind of, environmental disaster that we would have from a sedentary royal court. Well, semi nomadism or a, a royal court progress is really common in the medieval period all over the world. there are a lot of different responses to it, but by the 17th century, most western nations, and you could say most generally,

Mobility and Control in Monarchical Governance

00:17:42 - traditional, not modern. So an effort to ent arise populations, which of course makes them a lot easier to control and to tax, which is the primary motive of government at all times. this is part of it, but that also means that the actual royal courts begin to set to rise. So, in England, in France, in Spain, there's been some great work done recently on,

00:18:13 - and Elizabeth in England, whose movement is much, much smaller than that of the moguls. She may have had a court progress of maybe 750 people as opposed to 200,000, but she's moving, as an effort to impose her will on recalcitrant nobility, right? Those who are not adopting, the religious rights, she's trying to oppose who are secret Catholics, she'll go

00:18:45 - and they have to support her, her revenue, and it can deliberately bankrupt them, right? In the mogul case. not only are they unwilling to give up this mobility for some, some kind of sense of, of modernity, but they are self-sustaining as they're mobile. And that's another part of this project of looking at the environmental demands

Mobile Courts and Community Dynamics: The Mogul System

00:19:14 - They have entire tribal communities who will bring food to the mobile court, grain carrying, RAs, who will meet the court in it, in their, campgrounds and supply them with food. There are markets set up within the, camp encampment so that people can purchase food. They don't strain the resources of the actual place they are, camped on,

00:19:48 - of the elites of that region. So those elites are required to come and pay ob, and there's a gift exchange, and it's very ritualized and important, but the actual, support of this massive population is not local. it's not locally driven. and so this allows them to make this more, relationship building patronage, establishing

00:20:21 - But it's not a punishment. It's not a way of forcing anyone to their will. And, and at the same time, the mogul kings themselves will say, you know, while we are traveling, we are accessible. We become available to the needs of our subject people. So we'll make, we'll make ourselves, public. We will respond to requests for justice or support.

Negotiating Power: Justice and Relationships in Mogul Rule

00:20:53 - with local notables. So it becomes something of a, a positive, I mean, to some degree, I mean, there's still marching along with armies and elephants and horses and weapons, and scaring the daylights out of everybody, I'm sure. But it's interesting how they negotiate that, not as a punishment, but as a relationship building exercise.

00:21:22 - even the most mundane subject people in certain circumstances in order to offer justice, right? So Junge will write about sitting on a riverbank, in Gujarat on one of his travels, and he's complaining bitterly, I'm tired, I'm sick, I'm miserable. It's hot here, but I am compelled to be here so I can offer justice the people to the people who wanna come and have contact with me.

00:21:53 - imagined in a very different way than that. Those of other nations in the period, certainly Western Europe. I mean, we can look at the Qing in China, for example. How for many generations, in the late medieval period, they stop having a court progress because they're, concerned that it may reinforce their connection to their Manchu forebearers, right? They, they don't wanna be identified as one

Ritualized Kingship: The Return of Imperial Progress

00:22:39 - And later under the cho long emperor, when they're more confident of their right to rule, they will return to at least a ritualized progress, to visit shrines and things, to reclaim a part of that, legitimizing performance of kingship.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis