Popular in Professional

Culture and Society

The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place

New York University Harvey Moltoch

Education

The Role of Education in Reducing Racial Inequality

University of Southern California Pedro A. Noguera

Law

Diversity and Social Mobility in the UK legal profession

Law Society I. Stephanie Boyce

Internet Law

The Law of AI for Good

University of San Diego Orly Lobel

Pharmacy

Cytotoxic Activity and Anti-Migratory Effect of Berberine-Phytantriol Liquid Crystalline on Non-Small-Cell Lung Cancer

University of Technology Sydney Kamal Dua

Human Rights Law

Transforming Restorative Justice for Transitional Settings

University of Nottingham Kerry Clamp

Education

Where the Wild Things Were

View more insights in Books - Professional - Journalism and Media

View more figures from University of Southern California

View the page of Henry Jenkins

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Henry Jenkins discusses iconic works from The Cat in the Hat to The Twilight Zone to explain cultural trends in parenting and how we conceptualize childhood

Image courtesy of interviewee. September 18, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

Faculti AI is thinking...

< >

Summary
Related Studies
Faculti AI
Key Points
Key Quotes
Translate
Transcript

Export as PDF

This video is a reflective narrative discussing the author's experiences with parenting and his insights into the evolution of parenting philosophies, particularly focusing on permissive parenting. The author begins by sharing a childhood photo and how questions from his son about his own upbringing inspired him to explore parenting themes, especially in relation to Dr. Seuss and Dr. Benjamin Spock's influential works.

Permissive parenting ideals emerged post-World War II, fueled by the desire for more democratic family structures and a shift away from authoritarianism, which highlighted children's rights and self-expression. This video perspective coincided with the baby boom and a growing body of literature aimed at children and parents alike. The author emphasizes the importance of understanding the interconnectedness of these literary works and the contemporary parenting discourse, particularly through the lens of cultural icons like Fred Rogers and stories such as "Where the Wild Things Are."

The author also touches on the implications of cultural narratives around childhood and parenting, citing characters like Dennis the Menace and their depiction of the "good bad boy," who embodies curiosity and challenges traditional authority. He links these discussions to broader social movements and the concept of global brotherhood, referencing the changing dynamics in American culture during the mid-20th century.

Ultimately, the author highlights the ongoing struggles within parenting philosophies, situating current debates about children's rights, sexuality in literature, and family values as extensions of the permissive movement's legacy, while also noting the conservative backlash against these ideas in recent decades. He advocates for a nuanced understanding of these dynamics to respond effectively to contemporary political challenges related to family and parenting.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video:

1. **Personal Background and Influence of Dr. Seuss**: The speaker shares a personal anecdote about being asked by their son about childhood experiences, leading to the tradition of celebrating Dr. Seuss at MIT, which grew into a 20-year event. This tradition included showing Seuss's work and discussing the convideo of children's literature and parenting.

2. **Definition of Permissive Parenting**: Permissive parenting emerged after World War II, promoting a more democratic family structure, allowing children greater involvement in their lives. This movement reacted against authoritarian parenting styles, emphasizing the importance of children's curiosity and creativity.

3. **Influential Figures in Parenting Philosophy**: Key figures such as Dr. Benjamin Spock and anthropologist Margaret Mead are highlighted as central to the development of permissive parenting ideologies. Their work contributed to a more child-centered view of parenting, emphasizing the importance of understanding children's needs and perspectives.

4. **Cultural Reflections in Children's Media**: The video discusses the connections between children's literature, like "Where the Wild Things Are," and the evolving ideas around parenting. It suggests that children's stories reflected societal changes in attitudes towards discipline, authority, and children's rights, often portraying more egalitarian relationships between parents and children.

5. **Legacy of Permissive Parenting and Current Debates**: The speaker reflects on how current cultural and political discourses around parenting echo the debates from the permissive era. Asserting that ongoing discussions about family values, education, and children's rights are extensions of historical ideologies, the video emphasizes the need to understand the historical convideo to navigate contemporary parenting challenges effectively.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes from the video:

1. **On Parenting Traditions:**
- "I wanted to be able to tell him that... Dr. Seuss passed away... [which] became for 20 years an annual tradition."

2. **On Permissive Parenting:**
- "Permissive parenting is a set of ideals about what good parenting looks like, that start around World War II."
- "It was about shifting some of the authority that adults had had and allowing children a greater say in their own lives."

3. **Cultural Shifts:**
- "A celebration of children's curiosity, creativity, imagination... and their desire not to repress their sense of their body and their sexuality."

4. **Influences on Parenting:**
- "Dr. Benjamin Spock is very much a Freudian when he writes the Child and Baby Care book, which is the definitive childcare guide of this period of time."
- "I wanted to better understand the conversations the adult were having in the other room while I was watching Dennis the Menace."

5. **On Child Development Ideals:**
- "We have a sort of more child-centered view of what parenting might look like."
- "The push against authoritarian parenting in favor of democracy at home."

6. **Reflections on Childhood Literature:**
- "Maurice Sendak's book, which is about a boy who was bad in one sense, but is just being boyish in another."
- "What he discovers is... being a good parent... means knowing and respecting the rights of your subjects."

7. **Historical Convideo of Children’s Media:**
- "Johnny Quest... is not only an embodiment of America, but... also shown in strong friendship with a South Asian boy."

8. **On Current Debates:**
- "The kinds of debates about children's books... whether they should be sexually explicit or not also come out of this period."
- "We're seeing the struggle right now between ideals that were the legacy of the permissive era and ideals that are a legacy of the Reagan era come head to head."

9. **On Progressive and Conservative Parenting Ideals:**
- "We've accepted the idea that family values is a conservative discourse."
- "The more we understand the strengths and limitations of permissiveness, the better we can frame a response to reactionary politics of the family."

These quotes encapsulate the key themes surrounding the evolution of parenting ideologies, the role of children's literature, and the sociocultural shifts in understanding childhood and family dynamics over time.

Export as PDF
Here are some articles that share similar themes to the reflective narrative you about parenting, permissive parenting philosophies, cultural narratives, and the evolution of parenting over time:

1. **The Evolution of Parenting Styles and Their Impact on Child Development** - This article explores various parenting styles, including authoritative, authoritarian, and permissive approaches, discussing their long-term effects on children's behavior and personality.

2. **The Influence of Children's Literature on Parenting Philosophy** - This piece examines how classic children's literature, including works by authors like Dr. Seuss and Maurice Sendak, has shaped parental attitudes and ideologies through different historical convideos.

3. **The Shift to Permissive Parenting: A Historical Perspective** - An analytical look at the emergence of permissive parenting in the post-World War II era, emphasizing societal changes and literature's role in promoting children's rights.

4. **Cultural Icons and Their Role in Shaping Parenting Norms** - This article discusses figures like Mr. Rogers and their influence in advocating for empathetic parenting, highlighting how media representations have evolved to reflect changing values.

5. **"Good Bad Boys": Representation of Childhood in Media** - A deep dive into characters like Dennis the Menace and their impact on perceptions of childhood behavior, discussing the cultural implications of the "good bad boy" archetype in parenting discussions.

6. **Children's Rights and Parenting Philosophy: A Contemporary Debate** - An examination of current debates surrounding children's rights, sexuality in literature, and family structure, placing them in the convideo of historical permissive philosophy and modern conservative responses.

7. **Parenting in a Changing America: Balancing Rights and Values** - This article looks at the ongoing conflicts between progressive and conservative views on parenting and family values, reflecting on how these debates relate to the legacy of earlier parenting movements.

These articles can provide a broader understanding of the various aspects of parenting discussed in your video, exploring historical convideo, cultural representations, and the ongoing discourse surrounding parenting philosophies.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.025 --> 00:00.845
Yes, that is me.

00:00.875 --> 00:04.445
That is a picture of me from six years old

00:04.445 --> 00:06.165
or thereabouts that my mother took.

00:06.985 --> 00:08.545
So, so,

00:08.605 --> 00:12.025
and indeed this grows out of the chain of parenting, right?

00:12.305 --> 00:16.025
I, I most like most kids, my son always used to ask me

00:16.025 --> 00:19.625
what things were like when I was a little boy,

00:19.885 --> 00:23.425
and I wanted to be able to tell him that at the same time,

00:23.805 --> 00:25.905
around that same time, Dr.

00:26.115 --> 00:27.185
Seuss passed away

00:27.725 --> 00:31.865
and we decided to do a salute to him at MIT, which became

00:31.965 --> 00:33.985
for 20 years an annual tradition.

00:34.125 --> 00:38.385
So I would show 5,000 fingers of Dr TA film

00:38.385 --> 00:40.385
that he was centrally involved with.

00:40.965 --> 00:43.305
And I would read aloud, seuss's books

00:43.565 --> 00:46.625
to a mostly college mi, you know, audience

00:47.325 --> 00:50.505
and talk about what, what, what context they came out at,

00:50.605 --> 00:53.425
why were those stories written when they were written.

00:53.965 --> 00:55.145
So it starts with Dr.

00:55.395 --> 00:57.545
Seuss and a question from a little boy,

00:58.005 --> 01:02.705
and it's taken me almost 20 plus years to finish this book

01:03.245 --> 01:05.185
due to other professional interruptions.

01:05.245 --> 01:08.465
But I'm so happy that it's finally out and into the world.

01:09.125 --> 01:12.525
Now, the question about permissive parenting.

01:13.145 --> 01:16.995
Um, essentially permissive parenting is a set

01:16.995 --> 01:20.395
of ideals about what good parenting looks like, that start

01:20.495 --> 01:21.795
around World War ii.

01:22.265 --> 01:25.075
They're fed by, the idea

01:25.455 --> 01:28.075
of a more democratic family structure

01:28.255 --> 01:30.275
for America after the war.

01:30.795 --> 01:35.355
A sense that authoritarianism had been not serve the Germans

01:35.355 --> 01:36.435
or the Japanese well,

01:36.435 --> 01:38.795
and maybe wouldn't serve Americans well either.

01:39.375 --> 01:41.635
So it was about shifting some of the authority

01:41.635 --> 01:42.835
that adults had had

01:43.415 --> 01:46.395
and allowing children a greater say in their own lives.

01:47.015 --> 01:49.435
Now, the, some of these ideas were already taking shape

01:49.455 --> 01:51.315
as early as the progressive era,

01:51.615 --> 01:55.155
and there was just a sense of what, you know,

01:55.255 --> 01:59.035
giving children more say in their everyday development,

01:59.675 --> 02:03.235
a celebration of children's curiosity, creativity,

02:04.265 --> 02:07.315
imagination, their sense, you know, desire not

02:07.315 --> 02:10.555
to repress their sense of their body and their sexuality.

02:11.145 --> 02:13.875
This is the Freudian contribution to all of this.

02:14.055 --> 02:15.115
And Spock,

02:15.255 --> 02:18.435
Dr. Benjamin Spock is very much a Freudian when he writes

02:18.895 --> 02:20.395
the Child and Baby Care book,

02:20.395 --> 02:22.755
which is the definitive childcare guide

02:22.855 --> 02:24.595
of this period of time.

02:25.015 --> 02:26.355
So we put all that together

02:26.355 --> 02:30.755
and we have a, a sort of more child-centered view of

02:30.755 --> 02:32.835
what parenting might look like.

02:33.495 --> 02:35.115
Now, this comes out at the point

02:35.265 --> 02:38.155
that the baby boom is exploding a population

02:38.865 --> 02:43.675
explosion in America, and so is the rise of paperback books.

02:43.695 --> 02:45.675
So what we see are lots

02:45.675 --> 02:47.915
and lots of discourses about parenting

02:48.175 --> 02:51.715
and childhood, a large expansion in a number

02:51.715 --> 02:53.275
of books written for children

02:53.415 --> 02:55.075
or media produced for children,

02:55.735 --> 02:58.715
and a large expansion of the number of books written

02:59.025 --> 03:00.765
As advice literature for parents.

03:01.345 --> 03:03.965
So what I decided to do was read them side by side.

03:04.645 --> 03:06.365
'cause my mother raised me with Dr.

03:06.495 --> 03:09.245
Spock in one hand, and Dr. Seuss and the other.

03:09.425 --> 03:12.285
And I wanted to better understand the conversations the

03:12.285 --> 03:14.725
adult were having in the other room while I was

03:15.005 --> 03:16.045
watching Dennis the Menace.

03:16.185 --> 03:21.005
One was the permissive era idea about a more about,

03:21.765 --> 03:24.325
families and gender dynamics in the home.

03:24.505 --> 03:28.605
The second was the push against authoritarian parenting in

03:28.605 --> 03:30.085
favor of democracy at home.

03:30.505 --> 03:33.645
The third is the rise in popularization of Freudianism

03:33.665 --> 03:34.845
by Benjamin Spot.

03:35.545 --> 03:36.885
So we put those together

03:37.145 --> 03:40.205
and I would say the key architects are Margaret Mead,

03:40.205 --> 03:42.965
the anthropologist and her circle around her,

03:43.025 --> 03:45.365
and Benjamin Spock, the pediatrician,

03:45.585 --> 03:46.885
and the circle around him.

03:48.005 --> 03:50.365
Interestingly, Spock was Mead's pediatrician,

03:50.665 --> 03:52.045
so those worlds collide.

03:53.155 --> 03:56.345
Spock also was part of a center research center

03:56.375 --> 04:00.425
that included Eric Erickson and, Fred Rogers.

04:00.845 --> 04:02.385
So we can already start

04:02.385 --> 04:05.505
to see the ways something like Mr. Rogers neighborhood,

04:05.505 --> 04:09.875
which is much beloved now, comes out of this discourse about

04:09.875 --> 04:11.835
what child could, which should be.

04:12.015 --> 04:15.355
And Fred Rogers trained minister also trained

04:15.495 --> 04:16.515
in child study.

04:17.015 --> 04:19.435
So he was able to really observe parents

04:19.495 --> 04:21.235
and children interacting directly

04:21.735 --> 04:25.995
and tried to translate that into the philosophy of the show.

04:26.455 --> 04:29.275
And so what we do, what when we do across the book is try

04:29.275 --> 04:31.275
to find where those connections occur.

04:31.975 --> 04:34.835
And many, many cases they do directly in terms

04:34.835 --> 04:37.555
of the biographies of these key figures,

04:37.655 --> 04:40.555
but also they just occur in terms of the ideals,

04:40.655 --> 04:43.595
the philosophies, the images of childhood

04:43.905 --> 04:47.155
that are taking shape during that period of time.

04:47.895 --> 04:49.395
So there was a congruence

04:49.395 --> 04:51.715
between the books my mother would've been reading

04:51.775 --> 04:53.115
and the books I would've been,

04:53.255 --> 04:54.515
she would've been reading to me.

04:55.295 --> 04:57.715
And I think that congruence is

04:58.025 --> 04:59.715
what I'm mapping across this book.

05:00.125 --> 05:02.355
Let's think about where the wild things are.

05:02.655 --> 05:07.115
The Maurice Sinek book, which is about a boy who was

05:08.775 --> 05:10.315
bad in one sense,

05:10.455 --> 05:13.075
but is just being boyish in another, right?

05:13.215 --> 05:15.235
And how does his mother deal with him?

05:15.335 --> 05:17.515
She sends him to bed without any supper,

05:17.755 --> 05:20.915
although later she relents and brings supper up to him.

05:20.975 --> 05:23.635
So it wasn't really a punishment, it was a timeout.

05:24.405 --> 05:27.785
And he goes to an island where he meets monsters

05:27.925 --> 05:31.465
and has to figure out how to manage them and parent them.

05:31.565 --> 05:36.105
And what he discovers is, you know, that being,

05:36.445 --> 05:38.345
you know, a good parent as and

05:38.485 --> 05:40.385
or being a good king means knowing

05:40.525 --> 05:43.945
and respecting the rights of your subjects.

05:44.565 --> 05:48.825
And so he, he earns their respect. He doesn't demand it.

05:49.285 --> 05:53.745
And so I think if we look at that, Sendak is the illustrator

05:54.045 --> 05:57.885
for, several other earlier children's book writers,

05:57.885 --> 06:00.685
including the one who wrote a hole is to Dig,

06:00.865 --> 06:04.245
and the one who wrote Harold and the Purple Crayon.

06:04.305 --> 06:06.125
So there's a set of connections there.

06:06.905 --> 06:10.285
Uh, both of them were into progressive politics,

06:10.285 --> 06:14.125
reading anthropology, including the works of Margaret Mead.

06:14.125 --> 06:17.805
So it's not hard to make both thematic connections.

06:18.185 --> 06:20.205
Wow is parenting being depicted

06:20.785 --> 06:23.605
and, you know, what does it mean to be a good, bad boy,

06:23.605 --> 06:26.125
which is in some ways the ideal of that period.

06:26.785 --> 06:29.845
And it's also connected by the intellectual circles.

06:29.905 --> 06:33.685
The ri travel in kind of central figure in the book is

06:33.685 --> 06:35.685
what I call the Boy in the Stripe shirt.

06:35.905 --> 06:38.405
And hence my picture on the cover of the book.

06:38.425 --> 06:39.525
I'm wearing a striped shirt.

06:39.625 --> 06:42.365
I'm surrounded by the toys of that era,

06:42.865 --> 06:45.405
but the boy in the Stripe shirt is everywhere in

06:45.405 --> 06:46.445
fifties and sixties.

06:46.555 --> 06:50.485
Culture, even Charlie Brown has a rather anxiously jagged

06:50.545 --> 06:53.645
stripe shirt, but is still a boy in the striped shirt.

06:54.385 --> 06:57.005
Now what that fig, the striped shirt is red

06:57.145 --> 06:59.325
and white, typically with blue jeans.

06:59.425 --> 07:00.845
So we have red, white, and blue.

07:01.065 --> 07:04.485
The All American handful Dennis de Menace is

07:04.555 --> 07:06.005
described by his author.

07:06.745 --> 07:11.565
Uh, and so the sense of Americanness as being a little bold,

07:12.475 --> 07:16.855
but also democratic, you know, a natural leader.

07:17.285 --> 07:21.615
There's a kind of national image at stake in those figures.

07:22.485 --> 07:25.785
So if we look at Dennis the Menace, we see one set

07:25.785 --> 07:27.705
of ideals, which is the good bad boy.

07:27.845 --> 07:31.785
The boy who's badness is not mischief

07:31.805 --> 07:33.265
as it would've been saying the Cats

07:33.265 --> 07:36.705
and Jamer kids in the twenties and thirties.

07:37.365 --> 07:41.625
It is curiosity, it is a willingness to treat adults

07:42.165 --> 07:45.265
as equals not to see them as superior to him.

07:45.685 --> 07:49.105
And as a result, he does things that cause problems,

07:49.285 --> 07:51.425
but they're not really malicious problems.

07:52.465 --> 07:53.885
Uh, Hank Ketchum

07:53.885 --> 07:56.885
who created Dennis de Menace was a bit on the conservative

07:56.885 --> 07:58.685
end of the permissive side.

07:58.785 --> 08:02.725
So he often shows the parents' frustrations with these kids,

08:03.345 --> 08:06.365
but he is also speaking to the humor of a situation

08:06.695 --> 08:08.205
where parents who were raised

08:08.275 --> 08:10.885
with strict discipline were trying to raise their children

08:10.995 --> 08:12.205
with more permissiveness.

08:13.415 --> 08:16.115
In terms of Johnny Quest. We take that one step further.

08:16.455 --> 08:19.515
He is, he is not only an embodiment of America,

08:19.895 --> 08:23.515
but he is also shown in strong friendship

08:23.665 --> 08:26.705
with a South Asian boy, right,

08:26.955 --> 08:28.625
who's been adopted into the family.

08:28.765 --> 08:31.265
Now, this is a period of time when Americans

08:31.265 --> 08:35.225
after the war adopting large numbers of kids from Asia,

08:35.465 --> 08:39.385
although few from India than from China or Japan.

08:39.885 --> 08:44.025
But India during this period under Nru was standing in

08:44.385 --> 08:45.985
standing as a kind of mediator

08:45.985 --> 08:47.705
between the east and the West.

08:48.085 --> 08:50.945
So there's enormous interest in the US foreign policy

08:51.565 --> 08:54.905
to reach out and embrace India and pull

08:54.905 --> 08:58.225
It over to our side in the Cold War politics.

08:58.245 --> 09:01.945
So there's no accident that Haji is an Indian kid.

09:02.375 --> 09:05.065
There's some, there's a similar white kid,

09:05.165 --> 09:08.945
Indian kid Friendship in Maya, another show of the period

09:08.945 --> 09:11.745
where Jay North plays the American boy.

09:12.365 --> 09:13.705
So we put all that together

09:13.845 --> 09:17.465
and it really embodies this notion of brotherhood,

09:17.525 --> 09:21.065
global brotherhood, which Margaret Mead writes a lot about.

09:21.415 --> 09:23.465
This is a period of time in the Boy Scouts

09:23.605 --> 09:27.385
as the citizenship in the world merit badge when the Model

09:27.685 --> 09:29.985
UN is coming into being, where it's a small,

09:29.985 --> 09:34.425
small world is created by Disney first for the world's fair

09:34.445 --> 09:36.265
and later for its theme parks.

09:36.605 --> 09:39.905
So there's a lot in the air about global brotherhood,

09:40.185 --> 09:41.265
gro global friendship.

09:41.765 --> 09:45.025
And in that way, I think Johnny Quest,

09:45.205 --> 09:47.105
it totally embodies that spirit,

09:48.185 --> 09:51.035
even if at the same time it has a healthy dose, dose

09:51.175 --> 09:53.715
of yellow peril, discourse running through it too.

09:53.815 --> 09:56.795
You know, a lot of the culture war debates that we're seeing

09:56.935 --> 10:00.515
around children's books around teaching boil down

10:00.535 --> 10:04.075
to the same debates that emerged during this period, right?

10:04.875 --> 10:08.075
I, I'm certain that the writers of the period wouldn't know

10:08.075 --> 10:10.995
what to do with the trans kid if it bit, if it bit them,

10:11.495 --> 10:15.275
but the sense that a child's body should be not sha should

10:15.275 --> 10:18.035
be respected and they should have pride in it.

10:18.035 --> 10:19.395
They shouldn't be ashamed of it,

10:19.395 --> 10:22.275
that they sh they know what's important for their own lives.

10:22.655 --> 10:25.075
All of that is there. You know, the, the kinds

10:25.075 --> 10:27.755
of debates about children's books,

10:27.875 --> 10:30.595
whether they should be sexually explicit

10:30.815 --> 10:33.195
or not also come out of this period.

10:33.735 --> 10:36.995
So at the end of the period, I'm writing about 68, 69,

10:37.055 --> 10:38.995
we start to see conservative backlash

10:39.425 --> 10:40.715
against permissiveness.

10:40.775 --> 10:41.835
And some of the kinds

10:41.835 --> 10:45.315
of cultural discourse we're seeing today from the right,

10:46.095 --> 10:50.315
say from Florida, those were very much the dominant beliefs

10:50.655 --> 10:55.315
in the seventies as people like Charles Dobson stepped in

10:55.455 --> 10:57.675
and became much more conservative figures.

10:58.095 --> 11:00.955
So we're seeing the struggle right now between ideals

11:00.955 --> 11:04.875
that were the legacy of the permissive era

11:05.375 --> 11:08.715
and ideals that are a legacy of the Reagan era come head

11:08.715 --> 11:10.315
to head where it comes to

11:10.315 --> 11:12.075
how we think about parenting today.

11:12.615 --> 11:15.075
And so I think it's important for us to understand

11:15.665 --> 11:17.435
that more progressive discourse.

11:17.525 --> 11:18.835
We've accepted the idea

11:18.835 --> 11:21.395
that family values is a conservative discourse,

11:21.945 --> 11:24.835
that parenting is celebrated by JD Vance.

11:25.055 --> 11:26.435
Not necessarily,

11:26.575 --> 11:30.355
but even though we see what a spectacular parent, you know,

11:30.715 --> 11:32.995
governor Wal, coach Waltz is right?

11:33.455 --> 11:37.755
So, so those debates today really boil down to an extension

11:38.055 --> 11:40.595
of the debates that have their legacy back in this period.

11:41.095 --> 11:45.335
And the more we understand the, the ti that strengths

11:45.335 --> 11:48.415
and limitations of permissiveness, the better we can frame

11:48.975 --> 11:51.855
a response to reactionary politics of the family.

Faculti AI can make mistakes