Popular in Arts and Humanities

Arts and Humanities

Freedom’s Dominion

Vanderbilt University Jefferson Cowie

Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

McGill University Michael Fronda

Arts and Humanities

Lincoln and the Jews

Brandeis University Jonathan Sarna

Arts and Humanities

Amputations and Convalescence

University of Western Australia Emily Brink

Art

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

University of Birmingham David Hemsoll

Art

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

University of San Diego Chelsea Behle Fralick

Elite Families and Settler Society, Nineteenth-Century Ontario

View more insights in Arts and Humanities - History - History of North America and the United States

View more figures from University of Toronto

View the page of Cecilia Morgan

Read the Study

Next in Arts and Humanities

Freedom’s Dominion

Jefferson Cowie | Vanderbilt University

Forgetting Fathers: Untold Stories from an Orphaned Past

David Marshall | University of California Santa Barbara

Cecilia Morgan discusses the history of two middle-class settler families in 19th-century Ontario, a project which explores themes of gender, social and cultural identity, middle-class formation, and settler and imperial relationships.

Image courtesy of interviewee. September 13, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month. Login to view 8000+ figures on the platform.

Generating Workspace...

Export as PDF

This video appears to be a detailed exploration of gender, class formation, and settler colonialism in 19th century Ontario, primarily through the experiences of two families: the Hamiltons and the Harrises. Both families built significant homes—Willowbank and Elden House—in the 1830s, reflecting their socio-economic aspirations and the desire for community leadership.

The speaker discusses their initial interest in the interplay of gender and middle-class formation, which led them to study these families and their extensive correspondence. Gender relations are highlighted, particularly focusing on the challenges faced by the widowed heads of the families, Hannah Hamilton and Amelia Harris, as they navigated socio-economic pressures following the loss of their husbands.

Attention is given to the role of material culture and domestic spaces in establishing their social status and how their correspondence reveals a complex blend of aspirations, anxieties, and emotional expressions. Notably, the quest for permanence and stability amidst colonial expansion illustrates the settlers' attempts to replicate societal norms from their homelands in Britain and to affirm their identities as respectable members of a developing society.

The analysis also touches on the performance of social rituals, where both families sought to reinforce their status through invitations and gatherings, reflecting their evolving social dynamics. The letters of both families reveal deep emotional connections, nostalgia, and the pressures of maintaining status and economic stability amid ongoing challenges.

Ultimately, the text conveys that the narratives of success in settler colonialism were not guaranteed, but rather required continuous effort, maintaining social networks, and often confronting the vulnerabilities of family life in a colonial context.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are five key points from the video:

1. **Interest in Gender and Class Formation**: The speaker expresses a longstanding interest in the relationships between gender and middle-class formation in 19th-century Ontario. This includes exploring how these relationships interacted with the wider colonial and imperial convideos.

2. **Study of Historical Families**: The speaker examines the Hamilton and Harris families in Ontario, including their socio-economic backgrounds, family structures, and experiences of loss, particularly of breadwinners. The parallels and differences between these families provide insights into middle-class aspirations and gender relations during that time.

3. **Material Culture and Social Status**: The video discusses how material possessions played a significant role in establishing and demonstrating social status for both families. This includes the accumulation of goods and hosting of social events as methods to display cultural refinement and secure a position within their communities.

4. **Anxiety and Family Dynamics**: The letters and diaries of the families reveal much about the emotional experiences of their members, including anxieties regarding finances, social status, and familial obligations. The families faced challenges in maintaining their status, further complicated by external pressures such as illness and economic fluctuations.

5. **Settler Colonialism and Continuity**: The narrative emphasizes the non-preordained and contingent nature of settler colonialism in Canada. While these families contributed to the social and institutional construction of a settler society, their experiences illustrate that stability and success were not guaranteed and required continuous effort and adaptability.

Export as PDF
Here are some key quotes from the video that capture the main themes and ideas:

1. "I've long had an interest in, uh, the relationships between gender and middle class formation in 19th century Ontario."

2. "Both women who were heads of these families... were widowed very young... had to contend with the loss of the family breadwinner."

3. "The homes... reflected their ambitions and their aspirations."

4. "One of the key elements of understanding settler colonialism is the desire to achieve permanence and stability."

5. "The fact that they used Willow Bank... as a way of entertaining... reflects that desire to show to the community that... they were leaders in the community."

6. "Without those families, for one thing, you wouldn't have the reproduction of the next generation."

7. "It's a kind of metaphorical statement about their prominence, their stability, their desire to be leaders in their community."

8. "These were colonies meant to persist and last for generations."

9. "You see similar aspirations at work... it's not just about bricks and mortar."

10. "There is a story about her and her mother... closing off rooms so that when there's... social betters came to visit, they wouldn't see how poor these women were."

11. "The letters expose that other side of settler colonialism that runs alongside or underneath all the stories of settler success."

12. "This was a kind of an ongoing process of maintenance, um, and hope and aspiration."

13. "So you see this sort of desire to accumulate and this desire to display... enhancing their own status."

14. "I found... nostalgia played a quite a central part in many colonies... hoping to replicate what they had had in the mother country."

15. "The letters also tell me quite a bit about how... their own hopes for things like, um, sons getting good positions, family investments going well."

These quotes reflect the exploration of gender roles, family dynamics, societal aspirations, and the complexities of settler colonialism in 19th century Ontario.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.115 --> 00:03.165
I've long had an interest in, the relationships

00:03.165 --> 00:04.325
between gender

00:04.625 --> 00:08.005
and middle class formation in 19th century Ontario.

00:08.665 --> 00:12.085
Uh, the, the, the province has different names depending

00:12.085 --> 00:14.165
upon, you know, who was in charge, upper Canada,

00:14.345 --> 00:16.245
Canada West, and then the province of Ontario

00:16.295 --> 00:18.805
after Confederation in 1867.

00:19.385 --> 00:22.405
As so, I've long had an interest in those particular

00:22.405 --> 00:25.565
relationships, and also in the, the relationship

00:25.705 --> 00:29.325
of this particular territory, to a wider colonial,

00:29.685 --> 00:31.565
imperial and transnational world.

00:32.185 --> 00:36.165
And, I, I had, it's, it's a, it's a kind of a funny,

00:36.305 --> 00:39.685
almost sort of con, story about contingencies,

00:39.685 --> 00:42.245
because in my previous work, I've looked at the history

00:42.245 --> 00:45.725
of commemoration and public memory and heritage in Canada,

00:46.465 --> 00:50.605
and I was asked to give, a talk at a site Willowbank,

00:50.895 --> 00:52.645
which is now a national historic site

00:53.265 --> 00:54.515
in Queensland, Ontario.

00:55.455 --> 00:58.595
And, the people there found, found out that I had,

00:58.615 --> 01:00.915
you know, this interest in ge in gender history

01:00.975 --> 01:02.235
and particularly women's history.

01:02.615 --> 01:04.395
And they, to alerted me to the presence

01:04.415 --> 01:06.475
of this very large collection of letters

01:06.585 --> 01:07.755
that the Hamilton family

01:08.135 --> 01:10.595
who had built Willow Bank in the 1830s had left.

01:11.295 --> 01:13.235
So I thought, well, this, you know, this sounds fascinating.

01:13.275 --> 01:15.755
I went and had a look at, at the letters,

01:15.895 --> 01:18.795
and thought this would be great if I could also pair it

01:18.795 --> 01:20.755
with another family with similar,

01:20.935 --> 01:23.635
but perhaps some different, aspects to their lives.

01:24.095 --> 01:27.515
So I found the Harris Family Collection in which sits in

01:27.515 --> 01:29.155
the, west in Western University's

01:29.155 --> 01:30.235
archives in London, Ontario.

01:30.855 --> 01:33.715
The Harrises were very similar to similar in many ways

01:33.815 --> 01:34.835
to the Hamiltons.

01:35.175 --> 01:38.435
Uh, they built a large house, Elden house in the 1830s.

01:38.975 --> 01:40.995
Um, their backgrounds in many ways were similar.

01:41.425 --> 01:43.795
They had very large numbers of children,

01:44.055 --> 01:46.875
10 living in the Hamilton, in the Harris family,

01:47.095 --> 01:49.555
and 11 living in the, in the,

01:49.555 --> 01:50.755
ha in the Hamilton family.

01:51.455 --> 01:53.475
Um, they, they had, you know, sort

01:53.475 --> 01:55.555
of similar socioeconomic aspirations.

01:56.215 --> 01:59.235
And they also were, I think really interesting in

01:59.235 --> 02:03.155
that both, both women who were heads of these families,

02:03.295 --> 02:04.915
Amelia Harris in London,

02:05.495 --> 02:08.755
and Hannah Hamilton in Queenstown, Ontario,

02:08.755 --> 02:10.315
were widowed in, in some,

02:10.415 --> 02:13.115
and in particularly in Ham, Hannah Hamilton's case,

02:13.145 --> 02:16.475
very young, or very early in their, in, in their lives.

02:16.855 --> 02:18.595
So they also had to contend with the loss

02:18.595 --> 02:20.835
of the family breadwinner, John, John Harris

02:21.015 --> 02:22.355
and Alexander Hamilton.

02:22.735 --> 02:23.955
And so I thought, well, there's lots

02:23.955 --> 02:25.715
of similarities here, but also some differences.

02:25.715 --> 02:28.475
And it would be really interesting to look at these

02:29.035 --> 02:30.395
families, and tell

02:30.415 --> 02:32.435
and see what they could tell me about questions

02:32.435 --> 02:34.675
of middle class formation, gender relations,

02:34.975 --> 02:36.395
and also settler colonialism

02:36.395 --> 02:37.795
because they were certainly settlers.

02:37.825 --> 02:41.475
They came from backgrounds that encompassed Scotland,

02:41.545 --> 02:45.355
England, the fur trade in, Southern Upper Canada.

02:45.935 --> 02:48.595
And, and also the loyalist migration

02:48.655 --> 02:50.515
of the 1780s to the colony.

02:50.535 --> 02:53.235
Uh, the homes, I think very much reflected,

02:53.325 --> 02:55.795
their am their ambitions and their aspirations.

02:56.415 --> 02:58.955
Uh, the, in the case of Alexander Hamilton

02:59.025 --> 03:02.325
And, and his wife Hannah, they built Willowbank,

03:02.565 --> 03:06.365
I think based in Alexander's mind, around the, kind

03:06.365 --> 03:10.525
of the notions of, of, you know, middle class,

03:10.545 --> 03:12.685
middle class, even in his case, upper class,

03:12.685 --> 03:15.245
upper middle class stability, as a way

03:15.245 --> 03:17.445
of marking their presence on the landscape.

03:17.865 --> 03:20.005
Uh, in some ways, I think it was a reaction

03:20.025 --> 03:22.685
to the home in which he had grown up in, in Queenstown.

03:22.865 --> 03:26.525
His father, Robert Hamilton, was a very important,

03:26.845 --> 03:29.005
merchant and, land speculator

03:29.065 --> 03:31.565
and also a member of the fur trade networks

03:31.565 --> 03:33.605
that linked the colony to Montreal.

03:34.385 --> 03:36.605
And so I think that in many ways, their desire

03:36.665 --> 03:39.405
to build this very large, very large home,

03:39.475 --> 03:42.325
sitting on a hill overlooking the mouth of Niagara River,

03:42.615 --> 03:45.805
where the, where some of the trade was coming in, ref,

03:45.865 --> 03:48.685
you know, reflected that, that desire to show

03:48.685 --> 03:50.085
to the community that, you know,

03:50.085 --> 03:53.445
that they were leaders in the community, that they had,

03:53.895 --> 03:56.005
links to political networks that extended

03:56.025 --> 03:58.005
beyond the colony in some, in some cases.

03:58.585 --> 04:01.525
And, and also to the sort of socio socioeconomic

04:01.665 --> 04:04.045
and cultural aspirations to be genteel.

04:04.365 --> 04:05.565
I mean, I can talk a little bit about

04:05.565 --> 04:07.925
how those aspirations sometimes didn't always work out

04:07.925 --> 04:10.165
for them, but I think that's very much the case.

04:10.705 --> 04:12.685
Uh, and I think it's not just about bricks

04:12.685 --> 04:15.205
and mortar, the fact that they used Willow Bank

04:15.225 --> 04:16.605
and certainly the Harris family

04:16.665 --> 04:20.725
and Elden House also did this, as a way of entertaining,

04:20.945 --> 04:24.365
of bringing important people both within the, their own,

04:24.365 --> 04:25.685
immediate social network,

04:26.185 --> 04:28.925
but also people who were part of the colonial government,

04:29.425 --> 04:32.605
members of the Garrison in particularly in the Harris

04:32.605 --> 04:33.765
family case in London,

04:34.225 --> 04:37.205
and also British, British VI visitors who came to the colony

04:37.205 --> 04:39.045
as well, that had been part

04:39.045 --> 04:41.645
of Alexander Hamilton's upbringing with his, his father.

04:42.065 --> 04:44.325
And I think these were things that he very much wanted

04:44.325 --> 04:46.045
to replicate for himself and his wife.

04:46.425 --> 04:49.485
And you see similar aspirations at, at work, too,

04:49.485 --> 04:50.845
in the case of the Harris family.

04:51.315 --> 04:54.565
It's, it's not just the actual physical space of the homes

04:54.565 --> 04:56.525
that I, and certainly I think those were important,

04:56.865 --> 04:58.165
but it's also, I think a kind

04:58.165 --> 05:00.965
of a metaphorical statement about their, you know,

05:01.095 --> 05:03.965
their prominence, their stability, their desire

05:03.965 --> 05:05.165
to be leaders in their community.

05:05.925 --> 05:09.245
I think the homes also may, you know, also,

05:09.515 --> 05:10.925
reflect that as, as well.

05:11.105 --> 05:12.725
One of the, one of the key elements

05:12.725 --> 05:15.445
of understanding settler colonialism is the desire

05:15.465 --> 05:16.605
to achieve permanence

05:16.605 --> 05:20.445
and stability to set up societies that in so many ways,

05:20.795 --> 05:22.885
both replicated what people had left behind,

05:22.885 --> 05:23.885
whether it was in the 13

05:23.885 --> 05:25.205
colonies or whether it was in Britain.

05:25.865 --> 05:28.565
Uh, but, you know, so to establish things like churches,

05:28.795 --> 05:33.245
voluntary institutions, political institutions,

05:33.375 --> 05:36.885
bring in British law and justice and, and its,

05:36.885 --> 05:39.605
and its, penal system, and, you know,

05:39.605 --> 05:42.205
and to education, all those kinds of institutions

05:42.205 --> 05:44.925
that were meant to signal that the, these were societies

05:44.925 --> 05:47.565
that were going to last, they were gonna be permanent,

05:47.585 --> 05:50.005
and, you know, and people were going to cont, you know,

05:50.005 --> 05:52.725
contribute to them in political, economic

05:52.825 --> 05:54.245
and sociocultural ways.

05:54.745 --> 05:55.885
So I think that's, you know,

05:55.885 --> 05:57.765
that's a really key part of all of this.

05:57.825 --> 05:59.845
And I think at the heart of all of this, the family,

06:00.385 --> 06:03.765
the sort of heterosexual, patriarchal family,

06:03.945 --> 06:06.605
was very much the foundation of all

06:06.605 --> 06:07.845
of these kinds of institutions.

06:07.845 --> 06:09.805
Without those families, for one thing,

06:09.805 --> 06:11.725
you wouldn't have the reproduction of the next generation.

06:11.905 --> 06:13.445
And that's certainly something that the Hamiltons

06:13.445 --> 06:15.245
and Harrises did in spades.

06:15.405 --> 06:18.165
I mean, they, large numbers of children who then went on

06:18.185 --> 06:21.605
to have many children themselves, who you know,

06:21.605 --> 06:24.165
and whose presence sort of marked both the landscape

06:24.165 --> 06:25.525
of Upper Canada and Ontario,

06:25.585 --> 06:27.365
but also around the British empire as well.

06:27.905 --> 06:29.405
Uh, so I think the, the, you know, the,

06:29.405 --> 06:32.485
these families are sort of key to settler stability,

06:32.505 --> 06:34.525
and there's certainly, there's something that the British

06:34.525 --> 06:36.445
government and the colonial governments want,

06:36.445 --> 06:37.725
wanted to see established.

06:38.055 --> 06:40.805
Upper Canada, in many ways, was a success story in that, in

06:40.805 --> 06:42.605
that aspect, partly because of the influx

06:42.605 --> 06:43.885
of influx of loyalists.

06:44.425 --> 06:46.285
Um, but these families were meant to be white.

06:46.285 --> 06:48.965
They were meant to be British, if not in direct descent,

06:48.965 --> 06:50.205
at least in their affiliations.

06:50.625 --> 06:52.045
And they were also meant to be Christian.

06:52.145 --> 06:54.285
And so these are, you know, things that the Harris

06:54.305 --> 06:56.565
and Hamilton families, really, you know,

06:56.565 --> 06:57.965
really fulfilled that kind of promise.

06:58.505 --> 07:01.245
And, and again, you know, coming back to the, you know, sort

07:01.245 --> 07:03.965
of the overall arching theme of settler society,

07:04.425 --> 07:06.245
unlike other colonies such as India

07:06.245 --> 07:07.765
or Jamaica, these were meant

07:07.765 --> 07:09.125
to be places where people stayed.

07:09.155 --> 07:13.805
They didn't come just to extract resources, you know,

07:13.905 --> 07:16.405
and, and, and build wealth and then take it, it

07:16.425 --> 07:17.565
and themselves back to Britain.

07:18.015 --> 07:20.245
These were colonies meant to persist

07:20.305 --> 07:22.245
and last for, you know, generations.

07:22.905 --> 07:25.525
Uh, and, and again, the notion of building better Britains,

07:25.565 --> 07:27.565
I think, which is something else I've looked at in my other

07:27.565 --> 07:30.245
work, I think is very much key to all of us, even,

07:30.275 --> 07:33.285
even though they were modifications and transformations

07:33.285 --> 07:35.405
and adaptations, but still, I think that's,

07:35.405 --> 07:36.925
that's their driving mentality.

07:37.745 --> 07:40.245
Um, and so the fact too, that the Harrises

07:40.245 --> 07:43.685
and Hamiltons both were members of, to,

07:43.685 --> 07:47.365
to varying degrees, members of the political elite,

07:47.365 --> 07:50.205
they were able to make considerable amounts

07:50.205 --> 07:53.245
of money at certain times, particularly for the Harrises out

07:53.245 --> 07:54.365
of local economies.

07:54.745 --> 07:58.285
Uh, and again, their, their ability to really,

07:58.285 --> 07:59.885
establish themselves,

08:00.145 --> 08:02.525
as social social leaders in their communities, again,

08:02.525 --> 08:05.685
something that they hoped for, at any rate, was a key part

08:05.685 --> 08:07.005
of settler colonialism.

08:07.195 --> 08:08.805
This is sort of so interesting

08:08.805 --> 08:11.205
because in the case of the Hamiltons,

08:11.205 --> 08:13.445
because of the economic circumstances that

08:13.675 --> 08:16.605
that shaped their, their family history,

08:16.915 --> 08:20.885
what you see is a desire to, to have the kinds of markers

08:20.885 --> 08:24.445
of, you know, gen genteel or even gentry, family life.

08:25.025 --> 08:28.125
But what you see actually in their letters is the fact

08:28.125 --> 08:29.765
that they had to really struggle to do that.

08:30.025 --> 08:31.525
Um, they couldn't afford

08:31.525 --> 08:33.765
to pl employ large numbers of servants.

08:34.105 --> 08:37.365
Um, Willow Bank was both this very, you know, very large,

08:37.625 --> 08:40.285
IM impressive home,

08:40.305 --> 08:42.085
but it also was a working farm as well.

08:42.665 --> 08:44.805
And so what you find in some of the diaries

08:44.825 --> 08:47.405
and letters is the, you know, the need for these people,

08:47.515 --> 08:49.885
both men and women, to contribute to that farm

08:49.985 --> 08:51.965
to actually be involved in labor.

08:52.065 --> 08:54.165
And I think for the women in particular, it's interesting

08:54.165 --> 08:56.925
because the mark of being a, you know, a genial woman

08:56.945 --> 08:58.765
or a middle class woman was not

08:58.765 --> 09:00.605
to be engaged in much manual labor.

09:00.625 --> 09:04.405
It was to direct the work of servants in, in, in reality,

09:04.545 --> 09:07.445
for the Hamilton women, they act actually ended up having

09:07.445 --> 09:08.765
to do a lot of that work themselves.

09:09.385 --> 09:11.165
You see some of that in the Harris family

09:11.265 --> 09:12.485
correspondence as well.

09:12.625 --> 09:15.845
But because they were, you know, they were better off,

09:15.995 --> 09:18.645
that family eventually ended up through one

09:18.645 --> 09:20.965
of their daughters-in-law, inheriting a large amount

09:20.965 --> 09:22.685
of money that came from England,

09:23.225 --> 09:25.325
but originally was made,

09:25.425 --> 09:27.765
in land speculation in Southern Upper Canada.

09:28.265 --> 09:31.245
So the Harrises were able to actually employ servants to,

09:31.465 --> 09:35.125
and to participate in a kind of a world of domestic and

09:35.265 --> 09:39.165
and culture, that was always kind of harder

09:39.225 --> 09:40.805
for the Hamiltons to have,

09:40.805 --> 09:42.085
certainly lots of aspirations.

09:42.145 --> 09:45.285
So, for example, you see the Hamiltons sending their sons

09:45.285 --> 09:48.845
to Upper Canada College, which was one of the elite,

09:48.865 --> 09:50.405
in educational institutions.

09:51.145 --> 09:55.685
Um, but that, that didn't necessarily result in the kind of

09:56.245 --> 09:58.325
elevated professions that their, that, that they hoped

09:58.325 --> 10:00.685
for their, their sons, to occupy, certainly

10:00.685 --> 10:02.645
that the sons are hope to occupy as well.

10:02.885 --> 10:04.165
I mean, and these di these letters

10:04.165 --> 10:05.805
and diaries are full of emotions.

10:05.885 --> 10:08.525
I mean, and I, I, I was, I think,

10:08.565 --> 10:11.205
a little surprised actually to see just how,

10:11.705 --> 10:13.485
how emotion pervades their writings,

10:13.485 --> 10:15.405
because sometimes letters and diaries, you know,

10:15.405 --> 10:18.485
you will get, straightforward accounts of, you know,

10:18.725 --> 10:21.685
I let the cows out, or, you know, the weather was like this,

10:21.945 --> 10:24.005
or, you know, we went to town and we bought this.

10:24.305 --> 10:26.925
But in fact, I was pleasantly surprised actually,

10:26.925 --> 10:29.125
to see just how many emotions are expressed.

10:29.125 --> 10:32.845
So you get pleasure, you get joy, you get, a sense

10:32.845 --> 10:34.885
of fun at times, and pleasure

10:34.885 --> 10:37.525
and joy, particularly coming from things like falling in

10:37.525 --> 10:40.685
love, marriage, the safe birth of a child, but,

10:40.745 --> 10:43.165
but also things like irritation, anger,

10:43.545 --> 10:44.845
and lots of anxiety.

10:45.505 --> 10:48.605
Um, but when it comes to things like nostalgia, I,

10:48.845 --> 10:51.085
I had known from my other readings that,

10:51.085 --> 10:54.445
nostalgia played a quite a central part in many colonies.

10:54.545 --> 10:56.325
Um, people hoping to replicate

10:56.325 --> 10:57.805
what they had had in the mother country,

10:58.385 --> 11:01.005
not always being able to do that, hoping to get home.

11:01.665 --> 11:04.605
Um, and so what I found in the, in both of these,

11:05.075 --> 11:07.565
collections, because so many of the children traveled

11:07.565 --> 11:09.405
around a lot sometimes and,

11:09.405 --> 11:11.005
and sometimes had to leave home for work

11:11.005 --> 11:13.205
or for marriage, is a sense of nostalgia.

11:13.365 --> 11:16.125
A hope that they will be able to return to either Willowbank

11:16.125 --> 11:17.685
or Elden house,

11:17.825 --> 11:19.925
and to, you know, re-experience the kind

11:19.925 --> 11:21.565
of the pleasures that they had had as children.

11:22.115 --> 11:23.645
Sometimes that's expressed

11:23.685 --> 11:25.445
for the actual spaces of the homes.

11:25.585 --> 11:27.725
You know, I remember being on the lawn,

11:27.825 --> 11:29.645
or I remember, you know,

11:29.705 --> 11:32.285
how happy we were playing in our bedrooms upstairs.

11:32.755 --> 11:36.045
Sometimes it's about the food that they cons consumed,

11:36.045 --> 11:38.285
particularly with Willowbank having its orchards.

11:38.345 --> 11:41.725
Um, you know, I, I long for the apples that we, that we used

11:41.725 --> 11:43.645
to eat, you know, please send me the apples

11:43.645 --> 11:45.165
or the cherries or what have you.

11:45.705 --> 11:47.925
And some, and sometimes though, it's, it's for the people,

11:48.155 --> 11:49.445
it's a nostalgia for the people,

11:49.505 --> 11:51.525
and particularly the mothers,

11:51.525 --> 11:54.365
because so many of these children spent time away from,

11:54.365 --> 11:56.205
from their mothers and, you know,

11:56.205 --> 12:00.325
and had all kinds of, you know, hopes for reunion,

12:00.325 --> 12:01.805
with, with their mothers and along,

12:01.805 --> 12:03.485
and being able to spend more time with them.

12:03.905 --> 12:06.165
Um, you see, and you see that for both sons and daughters.

12:06.205 --> 12:08.405
I think what was really interesting, for me with,

12:08.635 --> 12:10.125
with things like nostalgia

12:10.125 --> 12:13.685
and homesickness was the fact that both, daughters

12:13.705 --> 12:15.445
and sons express these feelings.

12:15.585 --> 12:17.205
Um, and sometimes even nieces

12:17.205 --> 12:20.405
and nephews who had spent parts of their childhood, at,

12:20.545 --> 12:22.725
at both either Willowbank or, or Alden house.

12:23.345 --> 12:25.045
Um, and then sometimes, you know, they were,

12:25.045 --> 12:26.685
there were moments when particularly

12:26.685 --> 12:29.965
after their mothers had died, these adult children,

12:30.085 --> 12:31.685
would enjoin the other siblings

12:31.785 --> 12:34.085
who might still be living in the homes to, you know,

12:34.085 --> 12:35.965
and say, come, come and live with us now.

12:36.185 --> 12:37.365
Um, mother is gone.

12:37.745 --> 12:39.805
The house really means nothing without her.

12:40.035 --> 12:42.165
It's more of a burden, sell it and come

12:42.165 --> 12:43.685
and live with us, whether that's in Toronto

12:43.825 --> 12:46.085
or whether it's in London, for example, England,

12:46.265 --> 12:48.365
we know from other historians that,

12:48.865 --> 12:50.365
ma material culture played

12:50.965 --> 12:54.125
a very central role in helping middle class people.

12:54.385 --> 12:56.925
Um, and even the, you know, upper middle class, the gentry

12:56.925 --> 12:59.365
and the aristocracy establish their sense of

12:59.365 --> 13:01.605
who they were in the 19th century,

13:01.625 --> 13:03.045
but particularly for middle class people.

13:03.425 --> 13:05.085
And I think there's a couple of elements here

13:05.085 --> 13:06.765
that are important and that relate to the,

13:06.765 --> 13:08.125
the families I'm looking at.

13:08.585 --> 13:11.965
Uh, for, you know, for one thing, it allowed them to,

13:12.785 --> 13:15.085
kind of embrace their own desire to,

13:15.105 --> 13:18.725
to have lovely things, to add to the, the,

13:18.725 --> 13:20.645
well the number of items that they could have

13:20.645 --> 13:23.245
to enhance their own daily lives and make them easier.

13:23.585 --> 13:26.765
But it also spoke, to their, own kind

13:26.765 --> 13:30.485
of performative aspects as well, of, of being, of,

13:30.545 --> 13:32.005
of trying to become middle class.

13:32.545 --> 13:34.085
Uh, they could have, you know, it signaled

13:34.085 --> 13:36.285
that they could afford these kinds of goods for one thing.

13:36.585 --> 13:38.565
And also that they had, servants

13:38.635 --> 13:40.365
that they could hire servants,

13:40.365 --> 13:42.285
and that they could direct servants to take care

13:42.285 --> 13:43.965
of all this material,

13:44.185 --> 13:47.365
and in ways that, you know, would, again, allow them to,

13:47.865 --> 13:49.405
enhance their own status.

13:49.555 --> 13:51.605
When people came over for dinner, there was a lot

13:51.605 --> 13:54.005
of material, about entertaining,

13:54.225 --> 13:57.245
and that the, their desire to entertain members

13:57.245 --> 13:58.285
of their own social circle,

13:58.425 --> 13:59.725
or even impress people

13:59.725 --> 14:01.725
who were a little bit more elevated than they, they were,

14:02.425 --> 14:04.805
and what I found really interesting was that

14:05.125 --> 14:07.405
although all of them lived in places where they could,

14:07.465 --> 14:10.685
by the middle of the 19th century obtain a certain degree

14:10.685 --> 14:13.085
of material culture, so they could go to, you know,

14:13.365 --> 14:14.365
shopping in London, Ontario,

14:14.885 --> 14:17.445
shopping in the Niagara area, the city of St.

14:17.445 --> 14:19.445
Catherine's. So there's lots of other places they could go.

14:20.185 --> 14:21.925
But what I found interesting was the fact

14:21.925 --> 14:24.325
that when they could, when they had the opportunity

14:24.345 --> 14:26.645
and the money, they would go to Toronto to buy things.

14:26.645 --> 14:29.405
They would go to New York sometimes to buy things

14:29.625 --> 14:30.845
or they, or overseas.

14:30.945 --> 14:33.805
So they would ask for better China, better plates,

14:34.145 --> 14:36.565
or better plate, you know, better glassware,

14:36.975 --> 14:40.925
nicer fabric for their clothing, drapes, carpets and so on.

14:41.065 --> 14:44.085
And sometimes get people who were also, you know, living in,

14:44.265 --> 14:46.605
in those places, particularly in, in England,

14:46.755 --> 14:49.245
they would ask them to send things, to them

14:49.345 --> 14:51.165
or bring things when they came home to visit.

14:51.625 --> 14:54.645
So I, you know, so you see this sort of desire to accumulate

14:54.665 --> 14:57.725
and this desire to, to, to display.

14:58.065 --> 14:59.685
Um, you know, very much so.

15:00.115 --> 15:02.725
It's unfortunate that Willowbank has actually very little

15:02.865 --> 15:06.245
of the, interior material culture that's, that the, that

15:06.245 --> 15:07.285
that family amassed.

15:07.745 --> 15:09.885
Um, possibly, I think

15:09.885 --> 15:11.485
because the house went through a number of owners

15:11.615 --> 15:12.845
after the har,

15:12.845 --> 15:15.245
the Hamilton's left it in the early 20th century.

15:15.865 --> 15:17.205
The Harris Family House though,

15:17.205 --> 15:20.485
and it's, it's a city of London Museum is full.

15:20.645 --> 15:23.445
I mean, it's chalk block with all kinds

15:23.505 --> 15:25.005
of items and artifacts.

15:25.065 --> 15:26.445
And some of them, some of them are things

15:26.445 --> 15:27.645
that they purchased locally,

15:28.065 --> 15:29.365
but a lot of them are things

15:29.365 --> 15:31.765
that were brought back from either, you know,

15:31.765 --> 15:34.525
things being purchased in, in Britain, or

15:34.525 --> 15:36.885
because a number of those family members traveled

15:36.915 --> 15:38.285
extensively around the world.

15:38.745 --> 15:39.925
Things that they,

15:40.115 --> 15:42.405
also brought back from, you know, from those travels.

15:42.405 --> 15:45.005
And I think one of those thing, you know, there's one thing

15:45.005 --> 15:46.405
that that, that,

15:46.835 --> 15:48.925
that particular form of acquisition did.

15:48.945 --> 15:52.285
It, it allowed them to, remind themselves, they kind,

15:52.285 --> 15:54.405
you, they're souvenirs, they remind themselves

15:54.465 --> 15:57.005
of the places they've been, but it also displayed both

15:57.005 --> 15:58.885
to themselves and to any visitors

15:59.235 --> 16:03.045
that they were not parochial, that they were, I hesitate

16:03.045 --> 16:05.285
to use the word cosmopolitan, it's not quite right,

16:05.465 --> 16:07.885
but it, it is, you know, that they were imperial subjects

16:07.885 --> 16:10.325
who could amass things in the same way

16:10.325 --> 16:11.805
that other people could.

16:11.905 --> 16:15.125
And again, enhancing their own status, in their own eyes

16:15.125 --> 16:18.445
and in the eyes of any, any visitors, makes them more,

16:18.445 --> 16:19.525
you know, makes them more interesting,

16:19.525 --> 16:22.205
makes them appear more cultured and refined.

16:22.345 --> 16:25.325
And so I think that's one of the central key things

16:25.325 --> 16:26.845
that material culture did for them.

16:27.025 --> 16:30.005
You know, that ritual and performance became very, you know,

16:30.005 --> 16:31.525
very important to anybody trying

16:31.525 --> 16:33.045
to establish a new form of status.

16:33.185 --> 16:35.205
And, and early in the upper Canada's history,

16:35.205 --> 16:39.125
you see all kinds of jockeying, between, you know,

16:39.125 --> 16:42.565
groups of, groups of middle class, upper middle class women,

16:43.065 --> 16:47.125
loyalist women versus the more recent arrivals,

16:47.145 --> 16:49.485
of women who would come with their British colonial,

16:49.845 --> 16:51.805
official husbands jockeying for position

16:51.825 --> 16:53.365
and things like who would pay calls

16:53.465 --> 16:57.245
and who would, who would lead the ball at the, at the,

16:57.245 --> 16:59.205
Lieutenant Governor's home, for example.

16:59.905 --> 17:02.845
And I think, you know, the, these kinds of rituals

17:02.845 --> 17:06.565
and performances were perhaps not quite as rigid

17:06.865 --> 17:09.565
or as fully fleshed out as they were in, in Britain

17:09.565 --> 17:12.365
during this period, or even in, in, the,

17:12.745 --> 17:13.845
the 13 colonies.

17:14.105 --> 17:15.765
But at the same time, I do see

17:16.385 --> 17:18.725
ritual playing an important part in them, trying

17:18.725 --> 17:21.525
to figure out who they were and establish who they were.

17:21.625 --> 17:24.725
So, for example, being out in public, there's a lot

17:24.725 --> 17:28.005
of references in the letters to acknowledging,

17:28.145 --> 17:29.405
the, the greetings of someone.

17:29.945 --> 17:32.005
So you would, you know, you would acknowledge,

17:32.005 --> 17:33.405
you would bow, you would curtsy,

17:33.425 --> 17:35.085
you would shake someone's hand.

17:35.705 --> 17:38.205
Um, you would acknowledge that this person was part

17:38.205 --> 17:39.485
of your social circle, or

17:39.485 --> 17:41.405
that they might even be your social social better.

17:41.755 --> 17:44.725
Whereas if someone had had behaved badly, you would,

17:44.745 --> 17:47.045
you would snub them or, you know, or ignore them.

17:47.385 --> 17:49.765
And of course, for people who were laboring

17:49.765 --> 17:50.765
or working class, you would

17:50.765 --> 17:51.805
just not acknowledge them at all.

17:51.825 --> 17:53.965
And I, I see this kind of references to, in,

17:53.965 --> 17:56.605
in the letters at all, quite a bit,

17:56.605 --> 17:59.205
giving parties other forms of entertainment, such

17:59.205 --> 18:01.485
as going on sleigh rides or picnics

18:01.665 --> 18:03.885
or, having, you know, tea, tea parties

18:03.985 --> 18:05.285
or cro croquet parties.

18:05.545 --> 18:08.325
The, the harrises in particular were very, very fond

18:08.325 --> 18:10.085
of playing croquet.

18:10.265 --> 18:12.925
So there was a kind of performative aspect to that,

18:13.025 --> 18:15.725
as well, because it depended upon who you would invite to,

18:15.785 --> 18:18.725
to be part of, that particular form of leisure.

18:19.225 --> 18:20.245
Um, you know, and,

18:20.245 --> 18:21.765
and I've seen discussions of, well, well, we'll,

18:21.765 --> 18:25.165
so we'll invite Soso, with the implicit understanding

18:25.165 --> 18:28.085
that they are social equal, but we won't invite Soandso

18:28.085 --> 18:30.245
because they have behaved badly in, in the past.

18:30.305 --> 18:32.365
And that some of that might seem, you know, somewhat,

18:32.425 --> 18:33.725
you know, to be taken for granted.

18:34.105 --> 18:36.485
But at the same time, I think they put enormous stock on

18:36.785 --> 18:38.605
who is, who is in and who is out.

18:38.985 --> 18:40.645
And particularly because some of these forms

18:40.665 --> 18:45.125
of entertainment, again, they're not as heavily codified

18:45.225 --> 18:47.925
as, as some, as some forms of social practice,

18:48.185 --> 18:50.165
but at the same time, they were happening in people's homes,

18:50.265 --> 18:52.045
in their intimate and domestic spaces.

18:52.265 --> 18:54.765
So, you know, you only want people in your home

18:54.945 --> 18:56.445
who you pre perceive to be

18:56.745 --> 18:58.605
of a certain kind of class or quality.

18:59.105 --> 19:02.685
And there's a lot of, mentions of the,

19:02.685 --> 19:05.445
or use of the word civil in, in a lot of their writing.

19:06.145 --> 19:08.125
So andSo was not civil to me, so

19:08.125 --> 19:09.365
therefore I'm going

19:09.365 --> 19:11.445
to cut them the next time I see them versus,

19:11.745 --> 19:14.965
so andSo is very civil, so we will welcome them into our

19:14.965 --> 19:17.085
so social circle, and,

19:17.225 --> 19:19.245
and, you know, consider them to be one of us,

19:19.985 --> 19:21.405
balls as well.

19:21.785 --> 19:23.965
Um, there's, you know, there's quite a lot

19:23.965 --> 19:25.645
of writing about people going to balls,

19:25.905 --> 19:28.165
and again, they're not as, exclusive

19:28.185 --> 19:30.325
and I think probably not as hierarchical

19:30.385 --> 19:31.885
as the ones that happened in Britain.

19:32.505 --> 19:36.125
Um, but at the, by the same token, there's a certain,

19:36.125 --> 19:37.765
level of decorum that's expected.

19:38.065 --> 19:40.565
You know, you, you, there would be a bit

19:40.565 --> 19:42.925
of a scandal if people didn't behave properly at a ball,

19:42.945 --> 19:44.885
if somebody drank too much,

19:45.065 --> 19:46.765
if they didn't know the right dances,

19:46.825 --> 19:48.205
if they dressed inappropriately.

19:48.705 --> 19:52.365
So you can see them sort of set setting, social,

19:52.365 --> 19:53.885
setting out social categories

19:53.885 --> 19:55.685
and establishing social hierarchies

19:55.685 --> 19:57.285
through something like a ball,

19:57.285 --> 19:59.605
even though there's also a lot of writing about the balls

19:59.905 --> 20:02.565
as simply being, a, you know, a form

20:02.565 --> 20:05.085
of very pleasant entertainment, and leisure,

20:05.505 --> 20:06.765
and even even balls.

20:06.825 --> 20:08.765
Um, you know, you have, you had to have a certain amount

20:08.765 --> 20:10.165
of money to attend them in the first place.

20:10.425 --> 20:13.005
Um, for, you know, for one, you, you couldn't, you know,

20:13.005 --> 20:15.845
you had to sometimes buy a ticket to them,

20:15.845 --> 20:18.005
and you certainly had to dress in a certain way.

20:18.105 --> 20:21.165
Um, so I see references in the Hamilton letters to,

20:21.225 --> 20:22.805
you know, I can't go to this particular

20:22.805 --> 20:24.005
ball, I just can't afford it.

20:24.005 --> 20:25.525
And there's been too many,

20:25.525 --> 20:27.925
and then looking down their noses at certain kinds of balls.

20:27.925 --> 20:29.845
So there's, you know, the, the, there's a ball

20:29.845 --> 20:31.365
that the servants are having in the town.

20:31.865 --> 20:34.405
Um, and yes, that's, you know, isn't that nice for them,

20:34.425 --> 20:37.445
but certainly we would never dream of, of attending that.

20:37.985 --> 20:40.405
Um, you know, even though they're in very close proximity

20:40.505 --> 20:42.485
to a number of these people, these are not very,

20:42.485 --> 20:43.725
these are not big societies.

20:43.945 --> 20:46.845
Um, you know, it's not a city like London or,

20:46.845 --> 20:49.565
or, Edinburgh or, you know, somewhere like that.

20:49.895 --> 20:51.805
These are very small societies in which,

20:51.825 --> 20:53.525
and I think that's why the jockeying for place

20:53.625 --> 20:55.165
and setting out,

20:55.775 --> 20:57.725
those social hierarchies was so important.

20:57.915 --> 21:00.365
That is, for me, a very, very important question.

21:00.585 --> 21:02.045
Um, there's, you know, there's a lot

21:02.045 --> 21:03.805
of work being done in Canadian history right now,

21:04.165 --> 21:07.845
a about Canada as a settler colony or as a settler nation.

21:08.465 --> 21:09.485
Um, and,

21:09.625 --> 21:12.405
and so much of that important work is being done,

21:12.965 --> 21:15.045
vis-a-vis indigenous people, you know,

21:15.045 --> 21:17.605
under understanding their dispossession,

21:17.865 --> 21:20.485
and their, you know, their, you know, their marginalization

21:20.485 --> 21:21.845
through settler colonialism.

21:22.505 --> 21:24.365
Um, and so what I, you know,

21:24.365 --> 21:26.285
so I went into this project thinking, well,

21:26.285 --> 21:27.325
we are talking about power.

21:27.425 --> 21:29.885
We are talking about, you know, relations of power

21:30.305 --> 21:31.605
and that these people certainly

21:31.885 --> 21:33.565
occupied, occupied positions of power.

21:34.145 --> 21:37.565
Um, but I think looking at families and individuals

21:37.565 --> 21:40.565
and family networks, it lets us see that things are,

21:40.875 --> 21:42.245
were not preordained

21:42.265 --> 21:46.125
and not quite always as, settled as we might think.

21:46.225 --> 21:49.925
And I, here I go back to the example of Alexandra Alexander

21:50.105 --> 21:51.565
and Hannah, Hannah Hamilton.

21:52.065 --> 21:54.085
Um, so they, you know,

21:54.515 --> 21:56.645
they both come from prominent families.

21:56.915 --> 22:00.405
Hers, hers loyalist, his Scottish merchant infer trading.

22:00.915 --> 22:03.885
They, they, they built Willow Bank in the 1830s.

22:04.505 --> 22:06.845
Um, they incurred a considerable amount

22:06.845 --> 22:08.285
of debt to, to build it.

22:08.705 --> 22:11.645
And then just as they were finishing it, he died,

22:11.785 --> 22:15.605
and left her, with a, a, the last baby on the way.

22:15.905 --> 22:19.285
Um, so her, their last child was, was posthumous,

22:19.445 --> 22:22.285
a considerable number of, of other children to look

22:22.285 --> 22:25.085
after a large amount of debt and very little money.

22:25.705 --> 22:29.245
And she would've lost the home if in fact, his,

22:29.245 --> 22:31.085
other family members and friends

22:31.685 --> 22:33.925
hadn't taken over the debt since she did not get full title

22:33.925 --> 22:35.685
back to the house until 1858.

22:35.745 --> 22:36.765
So there was an interval

22:36.765 --> 22:40.485
of about 20 years when her status was completely dependent

22:40.485 --> 22:43.445
upon others, pay, you know, paying down that debt.

22:43.825 --> 22:46.605
Uh, and in fact, her sister-in-law ended up just forgiving

22:46.605 --> 22:47.885
the debt in 1858.

22:47.885 --> 22:49.045
And so she got the house back.

22:49.225 --> 22:52.285
But even after that, I see letters from her sons telling

22:52.345 --> 22:54.885
her, often you might con, you know,

22:54.885 --> 22:56.325
you should consider selling this home.

22:56.585 --> 22:58.165
You don't have the money to keep it up.

22:58.595 --> 23:00.445
It's, it's very difficult for you to,

23:00.465 --> 23:01.645
you know, to look after it.

23:01.945 --> 23:04.405
And there is a story, I think it might be a bit apocryphal,

23:04.405 --> 23:06.005
and I'm still trying to track it down,

23:06.065 --> 23:07.485
but there is a story about her

23:07.485 --> 23:10.845
and her mother, Hannah Jarvis selling off furniture in the

23:10.845 --> 23:14.245
home, and then closing off rooms so that when there's,

23:14.265 --> 23:16.125
you know, there's social betters

23:16.125 --> 23:18.485
and equals came to, to visit, they wouldn't see

23:18.485 --> 23:19.525
how poor these women were.

23:19.525 --> 23:20.765
They were taking in sewing.

23:20.765 --> 23:22.045
At one point, one

23:22.045 --> 23:23.725
of their daughters ended up teaching school

23:24.025 --> 23:28.085
and, teaching, giving music lessons as a,

23:28.085 --> 23:29.805
as a way of trying to, you know, support the family.

23:30.185 --> 23:31.765
And the sons all had to leave home.

23:32.075 --> 23:35.765
They, they weren't able to stay, on the family homestead

23:36.185 --> 23:37.325
or at, at Willow Bank

23:37.625 --> 23:39.165
for any cons, everything length of time.

23:39.165 --> 23:40.365
They kept coming back and forth.

23:40.505 --> 23:43.445
But, they traveled across the colony, going

23:43.465 --> 23:45.045
to other parts, other parts of,

23:45.060 --> 23:46.805
of Upper Canada and to Toronto.

23:47.385 --> 23:49.965
And in a couple of cases, actually going across the border

23:50.105 --> 23:53.805
to Wisconsin, to Chicago, and to upstate New York to work

23:53.805 --> 23:57.485
because they, they couldn't find work that I, I mean,

23:57.485 --> 23:59.885
I think it's, it's hard to tell whether it was also their

23:59.915 --> 24:01.125
aspirations,

24:01.125 --> 24:02.245
but they couldn't find work

24:02.245 --> 24:04.165
that they felt would support them,

24:04.225 --> 24:06.325
and then also allow them to send money home to their mother,

24:06.325 --> 24:07.685
which they were constantly doing.

24:07.785 --> 24:10.805
So that's kind of a reminder to me that, you know,

24:10.915 --> 24:15.045
that things weren't always quite, quite so settled,

24:15.385 --> 24:17.805
you know, quite, you know, quite, quite so neat.

24:18.265 --> 24:19.885
And that the letters also, I think, tell,

24:19.995 --> 24:22.805
tell me quite a bit about how, their own, you know,

24:22.805 --> 24:24.965
their own hopes for things like,

24:25.955 --> 24:28.965
sons getting good positions, family investments going well.

24:29.025 --> 24:31.485
And then when I talk about anxiety, there's a lot

24:31.485 --> 24:34.645
of anxiety about money, on, in, in both sets

24:34.645 --> 24:36.925
of family letters, getting money, keeping money,

24:36.925 --> 24:38.845
increasing money, you know,

24:38.845 --> 24:41.045
making sure you could educate your children properly.

24:41.785 --> 24:44.125
Um, so, you know, they, so they had

24:44.125 --> 24:45.525
to worry about, about that.

24:45.525 --> 24:48.205
They had to worry about, you know, sons getting decent,

24:48.205 --> 24:49.205
professional positions.

24:49.205 --> 24:51.645
And so maintaining their status, like not going out to work

24:51.645 --> 24:53.125
as a laborer, but,

24:53.185 --> 24:54.645
but actually maintaining their status

24:54.645 --> 24:57.045
through occupations such as the law.

24:57.345 --> 25:02.125
Um, surveying a number of the, the Hamilton, sons were,

25:02.125 --> 25:05.205
were surveyors, daughters marry a lot

25:05.205 --> 25:06.925
of anxiety about daughters marrying.

25:07.105 --> 25:08.405
Um, I see that quite a lot.

25:09.105 --> 25:12.965
Um, and heads of families being struck in being struck down

25:13.065 --> 25:15.005
by illness, or accident.

25:15.225 --> 25:16.245
So, you know, a lot of, and,

25:16.245 --> 25:18.045
and again, going back to anxiety, a lot

25:18.045 --> 25:20.685
of anxiety about illnesses, that I see.

25:20.685 --> 25:22.565
So even though these people had resources

25:22.945 --> 25:25.965
and they, you know, they had land, they had social position

25:26.225 --> 25:30.645
and a degree of, of, of wealth, there's still a lot

25:30.645 --> 25:32.645
of anxiety, around the fact that all

25:32.645 --> 25:34.885
of this could be taken away from you if you didn't

25:34.885 --> 25:36.205
constantly work at it.

25:36.305 --> 25:38.885
So I see a lot of, you know, both for the physical work,

25:38.885 --> 25:40.525
but also emotional work and,

25:40.865 --> 25:42.605
and social work and maintaining that.

25:43.105 --> 25:45.925
So I think for me, the letters really expose that other side

25:45.925 --> 25:49.125
of settler colonialism that runs along, you know, alongside

25:49.185 --> 25:52.485
or underneath, all the stories of settler success,

25:52.545 --> 25:56.405
you know, inheriting land, building these large homes

25:56.545 --> 25:58.885
and helping create or shape certain kinds

25:58.885 --> 26:00.205
of settler institutions.

26:00.785 --> 26:03.925
Um, upper Canada, in many ways was a success story as far

26:03.925 --> 26:05.965
as, the British Empire was concerned.

26:06.425 --> 26:09.045
Um, but at the same time, I think the letters show us that

26:09.045 --> 26:10.245
that could never be taken for granted

26:10.905 --> 26:12.445
and that nothing was preordained.

26:12.705 --> 26:15.245
Um, that, that, that this was a kind of an ongoing process

26:15.385 --> 26:18.445
of maintenance, and hope and aspiration.

26:18.465 --> 26:20.645
And some of that was not always, always realized

26:20.665 --> 26:21.125
for these people.

"Exploring Gender, Class Formation, and Settler Colonialism in 19th Century Ontario: The Hamilton and Harris Families"

00:00:00 - I've long had an interest in, the relationships between gender and middle class formation in 19th century Ontario. the, the, the province has different names depending upon, you know, who was in charge, upper Canada, Canada West, and then the province of Ontario after Confederation in 1867. As so, I've long had an interest in those particular relationships, and also in the, the relationship of this particular territory, to a wider colonial, imperial and transnational world. And, I, I had, it's, it's a, it's a kind of a funny, almost sort of con, story about contingencies, because in my previous work, I've looked at the history
00:00:46 - and I was asked to give, a talk at a site Willowbank, which is now a national historic site in Queensland, Ontario. And, the people there found, found out that I had, you know, this interest in ge in gender history and particularly women's history. And they, to alerted me to the presence of this very large collection of letters that the Hamilton family who had built Willow Bank in the 1830s had left. So I thought, well, this, you know, this sounds fascinating. I went and had a look at, at the letters, and thought this would be great if I could also pair it with another family with similar, but perhaps some different, aspects to their lives.
00:01:27 - the, west in Western University's archives in London, Ontario. The Harrises were very similar to similar in many ways to the Hamiltons. they built a large house, Elden house in the 1830s. their backgrounds in many ways were similar. They had very large numbers of children, 10 living in the Hamilton, in the Harris family, and 11 living in the, in the, ha in the Hamilton family. they, they had, you know, sort of similar socioeconomic aspirations. And they also were, I think really interesting in that both, both women who were heads of these families, Amelia Harris in London,
00:02:08 - were widowed in, in some, and in particularly in Ham, Hannah Hamilton's case, very young, or very early in their, in, in their lives. So they also had to contend with the loss of the family breadwinner, John, John Harris and Alexander Hamilton. And so I thought, well, there's lots of similarities here, but also some differences. And it would be really interesting to look at these families, and tell and see what they could tell me about questions of middle class formation, gender relations, and also settler colonialism because they were certainly settlers. They came from backgrounds that encompassed Scotland, England, the fur trade in, Southern Upper Canada.
00:02:48 - of the 1780s to the colony. the homes, I think very much reflected, their am their ambitions and their aspirations. the, in the case of Alexander Hamilton And, and his wife Hannah, they built Willowbank, I think based in Alexander's mind, around the, kind of the notions of, of, you know, middle class, middle class, even in his case, upper class, upper middle class stability, as a way of marking their presence on the landscape. in some ways, I think it was a reaction to the home in which he had grown up in, in Queenstown. His father, Robert Hamilton, was a very important,
00:03:29 - and also a member of the fur trade networks that linked the colony to Montreal. And so I think that in many ways, their desire to build this very large, very large home, sitting on a hill overlooking the mouth of Niagara River, where the, where some of the trade was coming in, ref, you know, reflected that, that desire to show to the community that, you know, that they were leaders in the community, that they had, links to political networks that extended beyond the colony in some, in some cases. And, and also to the sort of socio socioeconomic and cultural aspirations to be genteel. I mean, I can talk a little bit about how those aspirations sometimes didn't always work out

"Constructing Stability: The Role of Homes in Settler Colonial Aspirations and Community Leadership in 19th Century Ontario"

00:04:10 - and I think it's not just about bricks and mortar, the fact that they used Willow Bank and certainly the Harris family and Elden House also did this, as a way of entertaining, of bringing important people both within the, their own, immediate social network, but also people who were part of the colonial government, members of the Garrison in particularly in the Harris family case in London, and also British, British VI visitors who came to the colony as well, that had been part of Alexander Hamilton's upbringing with his, his father. And I think these were things that he very much wanted to replicate for himself and his wife. And you see similar aspirations at, at work, too,
00:04:51 - It's, it's not just the actual physical space of the homes that I, and certainly I think those were important, but it's also, I think a kind of a metaphorical statement about their, you know, their prominence, their stability, their desire to be leaders in their community. I think the homes also may, you know, also, reflect that as, as well. One of the, one of the key elements of understanding settler colonialism is the desire to achieve permanence and stability to set up societies that in so many ways, both replicated what people had left behind, whether it was in the 13 colonies or whether it was in Britain. but, you know, so to establish things like churches, voluntary institutions, political institutions,
00:05:36 - and its, penal system, and, you know, and to education, all those kinds of institutions that were meant to signal that the, these were societies that were going to last, they were gonna be permanent, and, you know, and people were going to cont, you know, contribute to them in political, economic and sociocultural ways. So I think that's, you know, that's a really key part of all of this. And I think at the heart of all of this, the family, the sort of heterosexual, patriarchal family, was very much the foundation of all of these kinds of institutions. Without those families, for one thing, you wouldn't have the reproduction of the next generation. And that's certainly something that the Hamiltons
00:06:15 - I mean, they, large numbers of children who then went on to have many children themselves, who you know, and whose presence sort of marked both the landscape of Upper Canada and Ontario, but also around the British empire as well. so I think the, the, you know, the, these families are sort of key to settler stability, and there's certainly, there's something that the British government and the colonial governments want, wanted to see established. Upper Canada, in many ways, was a success story in that, in that aspect, partly because of the influx of influx of loyalists. but these families were meant to be white. They were meant to be British, if not in direct descent, at least in their affiliations. And they were also meant to be Christian. And so these are, you know, things that the Harris
00:06:56 - really fulfilled that kind of promise. And, and again, you know, coming back to the, you know, sort of the overall arching theme of settler society, unlike other colonies such as India or Jamaica, these were meant to be places where people stayed. They didn't come just to extract resources, you know, and, and, and build wealth and then take it, it and themselves back to Britain. These were colonies meant to persist and last for, you know, generations. and, and again, the notion of building better Britains, I think, which is something else I've looked at in my other work, I think is very much key to all of us, even, even though they were modifications and transformations and adaptations, but still, I think that's,
00:07:37 - and so the fact too, that the Harrises and Hamiltons both were members of, to, to varying degrees, members of the political elite, they were able to make considerable amounts of money at certain times, particularly for the Harrises out of local economies. and again, their, their ability to really, establish themselves, as social social leaders in their communities, again, something that they hoped for, at any rate, was a key part of settler colonialism. This is sort of so interesting because in the case of the Hamiltons, because of the economic circumstances that that shaped their, their family history,

"Struggles of Genteel Life: Labor, Nostalgia, and Emotional Echoes in the Letters of Ontario's 19th Century Families"

00:08:20 - of, you know, gen genteel or even gentry, family life. But what you see actually in their letters is the fact that they had to really struggle to do that. they couldn't afford to pl employ large numbers of servants. Willow Bank was both this very, you know, very large, IM impressive home, but it also was a working farm as well. And so what you find in some of the diaries and letters is the, you know, the need for these people, both men and women, to contribute to that farm to actually be involved in labor. And I think for the women in particular, it's interesting because the mark of being a, you know, a genial woman
00:08:58 - to be engaged in much manual labor. It was to direct the work of servants in, in, in reality, for the Hamilton women, they act actually ended up having to do a lot of that work themselves. You see some of that in the Harris family correspondence as well. But because they were, you know, they were better off, that family eventually ended up through one of their daughters-in-law, inheriting a large amount of money that came from England, but originally was made, in land speculation in Southern Upper Canada. So the Harrises were able to actually employ servants to, and to participate in a kind of a world of domestic and and culture, that was always kind of harder
00:09:40 - certainly lots of aspirations. So, for example, you see the Hamiltons sending their sons to Upper Canada College, which was one of the elite, in educational institutions. but that, that didn't necessarily result in the kind of elevated professions that their, that, that they hoped for their, their sons, to occupy, certainly that the sons are hope to occupy as well. I mean, and these di these letters and diaries are full of emotions. I mean, and I, I, I was, I think, a little surprised actually to see just how, how emotion pervades their writings, because sometimes letters and diaries, you know, you will get, straightforward accounts of, you know, I let the cows out, or, you know, the weather was like this,
00:10:24 - But in fact, I was pleasantly surprised actually, to see just how many emotions are expressed. So you get pleasure, you get joy, you get, a sense of fun at times, and pleasure and joy, particularly coming from things like falling in love, marriage, the safe birth of a child, but, but also things like irritation, anger, and lots of anxiety. but when it comes to things like nostalgia, I, I had known from my other readings that, nostalgia played a quite a central part in many colonies. people hoping to replicate what they had had in the mother country, not always being able to do that, hoping to get home. and so what I found in the, in both of these,
00:11:07 - around a lot sometimes and, and sometimes had to leave home for work or for marriage, is a sense of nostalgia. A hope that they will be able to return to either Willowbank or Elden house, and to, you know, re-experience the kind of the pleasures that they had had as children. Sometimes that's expressed for the actual spaces of the homes. You know, I remember being on the lawn, or I remember, you know, how happy we were playing in our bedrooms upstairs. Sometimes it's about the food that they cons consumed, particularly with Willowbank having its orchards. you know, I, I long for the apples that we, that we used to eat, you know, please send me the apples or the cherries or what have you.
00:11:48 - it's a nostalgia for the people, and particularly the mothers, because so many of these children spent time away from, from their mothers and, you know, and had all kinds of, you know, hopes for reunion, with, with their mothers and along, and being able to spend more time with them. you see, and you see that for both sons and daughters. I think what was really interesting, for me with, with things like nostalgia and homesickness was the fact that both, daughters and sons express these feelings. and sometimes even nieces and nephews who had spent parts of their childhood, at, at both either Willowbank or, or Alden house. and then sometimes, you know, they were, there were moments when particularly

"Material Culture and Social Status in 19th Century Settler Society"

00:12:30 - would enjoin the other siblings who might still be living in the homes to, you know, and say, come, come and live with us now. mother is gone. The house really means nothing without her. It's more of a burden, sell it and come and live with us, whether that's in Toronto or whether it's in London, for example, England, we know from other historians that, ma material culture played a very central role in helping middle class people. and even the, you know, upper middle class, the gentry and the aristocracy establish their sense of who they were in the 19th century, but particularly for middle class people. And I think there's a couple of elements here that are important and that relate to the,
00:13:08 - for, you know, for one thing, it allowed them to, kind of embrace their own desire to, to have lovely things, to add to the, the, well the number of items that they could have to enhance their own daily lives and make them easier. But it also spoke, to their, own kind of performative aspects as well, of, of being, of, of trying to become middle class. they could have, you know, it signaled that they could afford these kinds of goods for one thing. And also that they had, servants that they could hire servants, and that they could direct servants to take care of all this material, and in ways that, you know, would, again, allow them to,
00:13:49 - When people came over for dinner, there was a lot of material, about entertaining, and that the, their desire to entertain members of their own social circle, or even impress people who were a little bit more elevated than they, they were, and what I found really interesting was that although all of them lived in places where they could, by the middle of the 19th century obtain a certain degree of material culture, so they could go to, you know, shopping in London, Ontario, shopping in the Niagara area, the city of St. Catherine's. So there's lots of other places they could go. But what I found interesting was the fact that when they could, when they had the opportunity and the money, they would go to Toronto to buy things. They would go to New York sometimes to buy things
00:14:30 - So they would ask for better China, better plates, or better plate, you know, better glassware, nicer fabric for their clothing, drapes, carpets and so on. And sometimes get people who were also, you know, living in, in those places, particularly in, in England, they would ask them to send things, to them or bring things when they came home to visit. So I, you know, so you see this sort of desire to accumulate and this desire to, to, to display. you know, very much so. It's unfortunate that Willowbank has actually very little of the, interior material culture that's, that the, that that family amassed. possibly, I think
00:15:11 - after the har, the Hamilton's left it in the early 20th century. The Harris Family House though, and it's, it's a city of London Museum is full. I mean, it's chalk block with all kinds of items and artifacts. And some of them, some of them are things that they purchased locally, but a lot of them are things that were brought back from either, you know, things being purchased in, in Britain, or because a number of those family members traveled extensively around the world. Things that they, also brought back from, you know, from those travels. And I think one of those thing, you know, there's one thing that that, that, that particular form of acquisition did. It, it allowed them to, remind themselves, they kind,
00:15:54 - of the places they've been, but it also displayed both to themselves and to any visitors that they were not parochial, that they were, I hesitate to use the word cosmopolitan, it's not quite right, but it, it is, you know, that they were imperial subjects who could amass things in the same way that other people could. And again, enhancing their own status, in their own eyes and in the eyes of any, any visitors, makes them more, you know, makes them more interesting, makes them appear more cultured and refined. And so I think that's one of the central key things that material culture did for them. You know, that ritual and performance became very, you know, very important to anybody trying to establish a new form of status.

"Social Dynamics and Class Performance Among Women in 19th Century Ontario"

00:16:35 - you see all kinds of jockeying, between, you know, groups of, groups of middle class, upper middle class women, loyalist women versus the more recent arrivals, of women who would come with their British colonial, official husbands jockeying for position and things like who would pay calls and who would, who would lead the ball at the, at the, Lieutenant Governor's home, for example. And I think, you know, the, these kinds of rituals and performances were perhaps not quite as rigid or as fully fleshed out as they were in, in Britain during this period, or even in, in, the, the 13 colonies.
00:17:16 - ritual playing an important part in them, trying to figure out who they were and establish who they were. So, for example, being out in public, there's a lot of references in the letters to acknowledging, the, the greetings of someone. So you would, you know, you would acknowledge, you would bow, you would curtsy, you would shake someone's hand. you would acknowledge that this person was part of your social circle, or that they might even be your social social better. Whereas if someone had had behaved badly, you would, you would snub them or, you know, or ignore them. And of course, for people who were laboring or working class, you would just not acknowledge them at all. And I, I see this kind of references to, in, in the letters at all, quite a bit,
00:17:59 - as going on sleigh rides or picnics or, having, you know, tea, tea parties or cro croquet parties. The, the harrises in particular were very, very fond of playing croquet. So there was a kind of performative aspect to that, as well, because it depended upon who you would invite to, to be part of, that particular form of leisure. you know, and, and I've seen discussions of, well, well, we'll, so we'll invite Soso, with the implicit understanding that they are social equal, but we won't invite Soandso because they have behaved badly in, in the past. And that some of that might seem, you know, somewhat, you know, to be taken for granted. But at the same time, I think they put enormous stock on
00:18:38 - And particularly because some of these forms of entertainment, again, they're not as heavily codified as, as some, as some forms of social practice, but at the same time, they were happening in people's homes, in their intimate and domestic spaces. So, you know, you only want people in your home who you pre perceive to be of a certain kind of class or quality. And there's a lot of, mentions of the, or use of the word civil in, in a lot of their writing. So andSo was not civil to me, so therefore I'm going to cut them the next time I see them versus, so andSo is very civil, so we will welcome them into our so social circle, and,
00:19:19 - balls as well. there's, you know, there's quite a lot of writing about people going to balls, and again, they're not as, exclusive and I think probably not as hierarchical as the ones that happened in Britain. but at the, by the same token, there's a certain, level of decorum that's expected. You know, you, you, there would be a bit of a scandal if people didn't behave properly at a ball, if somebody drank too much, if they didn't know the right dances, if they dressed inappropriately. So you can see them sort of set setting, social, setting out social categories and establishing social hierarchies through something like a ball,
00:19:59 - as simply being, a, you know, a form of very pleasant entertainment, and leisure, and even even balls. you know, you have, you had to have a certain amount of money to attend them in the first place. for, you know, for one, you, you couldn't, you know, you had to sometimes buy a ticket to them, and you certainly had to dress in a certain way. so I see references in the Hamilton letters to, you know, I can't go to this particular ball, I just can't afford it. And there's been too many, and then looking down their noses at certain kinds of balls. So there's, you know, the, the, there's a ball that the servants are having in the town. and yes, that's, you know, isn't that nice for them, but certainly we would never dream of, of attending that.

"Navigating Social Hierarchies and Financial Struggles in 19th Century Settler Canada"

00:20:40 - to a number of these people, these are not very, these are not big societies. you know, it's not a city like London or, or, Edinburgh or, you know, somewhere like that. These are very small societies in which, and I think that's why the jockeying for place and setting out, those social hierarchies was so important. That is, for me, a very, very important question. there's, you know, there's a lot of work being done in Canadian history right now, a about Canada as a settler colony or as a settler nation. and, and so much of that important work is being done, vis-a-vis indigenous people, you know, under understanding their dispossession, and their, you know, their, you know, their marginalization
00:21:22 - and so what I, you know, so I went into this project thinking, well, we are talking about power. We are talking about, you know, relations of power and that these people certainly occupied, occupied positions of power. but I think looking at families and individuals and family networks, it lets us see that things are, were not preordained and not quite always as, settled as we might think. And I, here I go back to the example of Alexandra Alexander and Hannah, Hannah Hamilton. so they, you know, they both come from prominent families. Hers, hers loyalist, his Scottish merchant infer trading.
00:22:04 - they incurred a considerable amount of debt to, to build it. And then just as they were finishing it, he died, and left her, with a, a, the last baby on the way. so her, their last child was, was posthumous, a considerable number of, of other children to look after a large amount of debt and very little money. And she would've lost the home if in fact, his, other family members and friends hadn't taken over the debt since she did not get full title back to the house until 1858. So there was an interval of about 20 years when her status was completely dependent upon others, pay, you know, paying down that debt.
00:22:46 - the debt in 1858. And so she got the house back. But even after that, I see letters from her sons telling her, often you might con, you know, you should consider selling this home. You don't have the money to keep it up. It's, it's very difficult for you to, you know, to look after it. And there is a story, I think it might be a bit apocryphal, and I'm still trying to track it down, but there is a story about her and her mother, Hannah Jarvis selling off furniture in the home, and then closing off rooms so that when there's, you know, there's social betters and equals came to, to visit, they wouldn't see how poor these women were. They were taking in sewing. At one point, one of their daughters ended up teaching school
00:23:28 - as a way of trying to, you know, support the family. And the sons all had to leave home. They, they weren't able to stay, on the family homestead or at, at Willow Bank for any cons, everything length of time. They kept coming back and forth. But, they traveled across the colony, going to other parts, other parts of, of Upper Canada and to Toronto. And in a couple of cases, actually going across the border to Wisconsin, to Chicago, and to upstate New York to work because they, they couldn't find work that I, I mean, I think it's, it's hard to tell whether it was also their aspirations, but they couldn't find work that they felt would support them,
00:24:06 - which they were constantly doing. So that's kind of a reminder to me that, you know, that things weren't always quite, quite so settled, you know, quite, you know, quite, quite so neat. And that the letters also, I think, tell, tell me quite a bit about how, their own, you know, their own hopes for things like, sons getting good positions, family investments going well. And then when I talk about anxiety, there's a lot of anxiety about money, on, in, in both sets of family letters, getting money, keeping money, increasing money, you know, making sure you could educate your children properly. so, you know, they, so they had to worry about, about that.

Title: "The Fragile Facade of Settler Success: Anxiety, Maintenance, and Social Status in 19th Century Upper Canada"

00:24:48 - professional positions. And so maintaining their status, like not going out to work as a laborer, but, but actually maintaining their status through occupations such as the law. surveying a number of the, the Hamilton, sons were, were surveyors, daughters marry a lot of anxiety about daughters marrying. I see that quite a lot. and heads of families being struck in being struck down by illness, or accident. So, you know, a lot of, and, and again, going back to anxiety, a lot of anxiety about illnesses, that I see. So even though these people had resources and they, you know, they had land, they had social position
00:25:30 - of anxiety, around the fact that all of this could be taken away from you if you didn't constantly work at it. So I see a lot of, you know, both for the physical work, but also emotional work and, and social work and maintaining that. So I think for me, the letters really expose that other side of settler colonialism that runs along, you know, alongside or underneath, all the stories of settler success, you know, inheriting land, building these large homes and helping create or shape certain kinds of settler institutions. upper Canada, in many ways was a success story as far as, the British Empire was concerned.
00:26:20 - that could never be taken for granted and that nothing was preordained. that, that, that this was a kind of an ongoing process of maintenance, and hope and aspiration. And some of that was not always, always realized for these people.

Faculti AI can make mistakes

Research

Policy

Analysis