Popular in Art

Art

Amputations and Convalescence

University of Western Australia Emily Brink

Art

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

University of Birmingham David Hemsoll

Art

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

University of San Diego Chelsea Behle Fralick

Art

Maternity: Mothers and Children in the Arts of Africa

University of California Santa Barbara Herbert Cole

Art

Say it Again! Saxon!: The Erotic Intimate Space of Reading

American University Marianne Noble

Art

Snewíyalh tl’a Staḵw (Teachings of the Water)

University of British Columbia T. Patrick Carrabré

Art

Gawkers: Art and Audience in Late Nineteenth-Century France

Princeton University Bridget Alsdorf

First Lady of Laughs

View more insights in Books - Professional - Theatre Studies

View more figures from Columbia College Chicago

View the page of Grace Overbeke

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Grace Kessler Overbeke tells the story of Jean Carroll, the first Jewish woman to become a star in the field we now call stand-up comedy.

Image courtesy of interviewee. September 10, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

Faculti AI is thinking...

< >

Summary
Related Studies
Faculti AI
Key Points
Key Quotes
Translate
Transcript

Export as PDF

This video is a narrative about the life and legacy of Jean Carroll, a pioneering female comedian. The speaker reflects on their upbringing, influenced by comedy-loving parents who named them after the vaudeville comedian. This video background fostered a deep fascination with comedy, particularly the old vaudeville routines that characterized Carroll's time.

The speaker describes their thorough research into Carroll's life, which involved uncovering obscure connections through social media and diving into old newspapers and entertainment periodicals. Carroll, originally named Sadie Zeman, changed her name to pursue a successful career in comedy at a time when women faced significant resistance in the field, often met with skepticism from audiences.

Despite her glamorous persona, Carroll navigated personal struggles, including antisemitism, family issues, and the pressure of economic dependency. She aimed to break the cycle of dependency her mother faced, starting her career in talent shows and eventually evolving into a prominent performer who transformed stand-up comedy by emphasizing personal storytelling over traditional joke-telling.

Carroll’s impact on stand-up comedy and her efforts to redefine Jewish women's representation in media are highlighted, as she rejected stereotypical portrayals and presented a more sophisticated image. She is noted as a masterful storyteller, and the speaker hopes that recognition of her contributions serves as a reminder of the many overlooked stories of women and marginalized individuals in history, encouraging deeper exploration of historically neglected narratives.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
It seems like your message got cut off, and I can't see the video you're referring to. Could you please provide the video or clarify your request?

Export as PDF
It seems like the video you're referring to is not or is represented by quotation marks without content. If you could please provide the specific video or convideo, I'd be happy to help you identify key quotes or summarize it!

Export as PDF
Here are some articles that you might find similar to the narrative about Jean Carroll and her contributions to comedy, gender representation, and the exploration of overlooked narratives:

1. **"The Rise of Women in Comedy: Breaking Barriers"**
- This article explores the history of female comedians and their fight for recognition in a male-dominated industry. It highlights the pioneering figures who paved the way for future generations and emphasizes the importance of their stories.

2. **"Rediscovering Vaudeville: The Influence on Modern Comedy"**
- A discussion of how vaudeville acts influenced contemporary comedy styles, including stand-up. The article mentions various comedians who have drawn inspiration from vaudeville, reflecting on the cultural shifts and the role of women in this transition.

3. **"Beyond Stereotypes: Jewish Women in Comedy"**
- This piece examines Jewish women's representation in comedy, focusing on how comedians challenge and reshape cultural narratives. It discusses the struggles and triumphs of figures like Jean Carroll and others who have contributed to a more diverse portrayal.

4. **"The Power of Personal Storytelling in Stand-Up Comedy"**
- An analysis of how personal storytelling has become a dominant form of stand-up comedy. The article features interviews with various comedians who discuss how they incorporate their life experiences into their performances, resonating with the themes presented in Carroll's work.

5. **"Hidden Histories: A Look at Women in Entertainment"**
- This article delves into the often-ignored contributions of women in the entertainment industry, including pioneers like Jean Carroll. It emphasizes the importance of recognizing and telling these stories to inspire future artists.

6. **"Comedy as Resistance: The Role of Humor in Social Commentary"**
- This article examines how comedians, particularly women and people of marginalized backgrounds, use humor to address social issues and resist stereotypes. It connects to Carroll’s legacy of transforming narratives through comedy.

7. **"Celebrating the Unsung Heroes of Comedy"**
- A tribute to lesser-known comedians who have made significant contributions to the craft, the article emphasizes the need to recognize and honor the work of those like Jean Carroll who laid the groundwork for future performers.

Each of these articles shares themes of gender representation, the evolution of comedy, and the significance of storytelling in performance art, much like the narrative about Jean Carroll.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.105 --> 00:01.605
I'm gonna blame my parents for this one.

00:01.985 --> 00:04.445
Uh, my parents were huge comedy nerds

00:04.545 --> 00:06.565
and to the point that they named me

00:06.565 --> 00:10.365
after a comedian, Gracie Allen, who was in a comedy du

00:10.365 --> 00:12.525
with George Burns, and they were vaudeville comedians,

00:12.585 --> 00:14.245
and they made a radio program.

00:14.355 --> 00:16.205
They did the whole transition into tv

00:17.465 --> 00:19.965
and, they would play me these

00:20.105 --> 00:23.245
Old vaudeville Routines, like as bedtime stories,

00:23.425 --> 00:24.485
you know, on, on records

00:24.785 --> 00:28.165
and, cassette tapes at that point. And so I just

00:28.195 --> 00:29.765
Grew up with this,

00:30.115 --> 00:33.245
Obsession kind of with comedy from this period.

00:33.965 --> 00:36.445
Research was most Fun when I got to,

00:36.445 --> 00:38.205
Sort of follow a little detective

00:38.205 --> 00:40.445
Trail where there was a friend of a friend

00:40.545 --> 00:42.165
who knew someone on Facebook.

00:42.425 --> 00:46.005
And, you know, it led me to these very peculiar places.

00:46.485 --> 00:49.565
I met, a documentary filmmaker

00:49.625 --> 00:51.685
who had been making a movie about Gene Carroll.

00:52.145 --> 00:55.765
Uh, now the movie didn't actually get all the way made, but

00:55.765 --> 00:56.965
He had all this footage

00:57.305 --> 00:59.205
Of interviews with her

00:59.205 --> 01:01.765
that was just sitting in his, in his closet.

01:02.585 --> 01:04.645
And so he was incredibly generous,

01:04.825 --> 01:06.405
the wonderful Stephen Silverman.

01:06.985 --> 01:11.045
Um, I got to meet Jean Carroll's granddaughters, one

01:11.045 --> 01:14.405
of whom I got to meet in person, the other,

01:14.755 --> 01:17.205
Through Facebook. It was really

01:17.435 --> 01:20.485
Kind of a marvelous Detective

01:20.485 --> 01:23.005
Journey to track down these people who knew her

01:23.005 --> 01:24.365
and get to talk with them and,

01:24.385 --> 01:26.005
and get to know her through them.

01:26.145 --> 01:28.245
In addition to, talking to other people,

01:28.245 --> 01:29.325
which was my favorite part.

01:29.375 --> 01:31.245
There was also a tremendous amount of,

01:31.785 --> 01:32.805
just going through

01:34.025 --> 01:35.125
Old newspapers,

01:35.735 --> 01:37.565
Every kind of newspaper. You know, there were

01:37.745 --> 01:39.925
Old, Jewish newspapers,

01:39.925 --> 01:41.405
some of which were in Yiddish. There

01:41.405 --> 01:44.725
Were old, Uh, entertainment periodicals, you know,

01:44.725 --> 01:47.685
like Variety, which is written for showbiz insiders.

01:48.345 --> 01:50.765
Uh, and then there were, you know, standard New York Times,

01:51.185 --> 01:52.325
the Washington Post.

01:53.185 --> 01:57.845
Um, and just going through every time she was mentioned

01:58.785 --> 02:02.205
and really looking into how can I put together

02:03.125 --> 02:05.725
A story of her life From these little,

02:06.025 --> 02:08.445
Little bits of like what I call literary

02:08.445 --> 02:09.805
Detritus. Seeing Carol

02:10.025 --> 02:13.445
Was A figment of the imagination of,

02:13.785 --> 02:15.125
Sadie Zeman.

02:15.985 --> 02:20.085
Um, Sadie Zeman was her real name, and,

02:20.825 --> 02:22.045
or Celine Zeman.

02:22.095 --> 02:23.805
Sadie was her, her mother's nickname.

02:25.005 --> 02:27.905
And then when she went into show business, she was told, no,

02:27.905 --> 02:30.025
no, no, you cannot have a Jewish name.

02:30.495 --> 02:35.255
That is not going to work. And so she became Jean Carroll.

02:36.705 --> 02:39.445
And Jean Carroll was a lot of things

02:39.445 --> 02:40.965
that Sadie Zeman never was.

02:41.625 --> 02:43.965
Uh, she was Glamorous.

02:44.345 --> 02:48.495
She was deeply Assimilated American. She

02:49.075 --> 02:50.335
Was, Um,

02:51.375 --> 02:52.825
Well, she was college Educated.

02:52.915 --> 02:54.985
There were a number of times where she would talk about,

02:55.165 --> 02:56.945
you know, I didn't go to college for this.

02:58.005 --> 03:00.205
And the truth is, she didn't go to college at all.

03:01.105 --> 03:05.125
But it was like through this persona of Jean Carroll,

03:05.185 --> 03:08.525
she got to be the person that she dreamed of being.

03:10.135 --> 03:11.945
Also on a factual level,

03:12.055 --> 03:14.945
Jean Carroll was the first woman to do,

03:15.405 --> 03:17.865
the first Jewish woman somewhat argue, the first woman

03:17.965 --> 03:18.985
to do standup comedy.

03:19.265 --> 03:23.025
I mean, she talks about the audience would be very resistant

03:23.245 --> 03:26.025
to a, a woman doing standup.

03:26.245 --> 03:28.305
And you see it in so many different ways, right?

03:28.305 --> 03:31.465
Like you see the audience, she says,

03:32.045 --> 03:34.705
the men in the audience have their arms crossed,

03:34.765 --> 03:37.825
and they're looking at you with a sear as if to say,

03:37.925 --> 03:39.265
why should I listen to you?

03:40.125 --> 03:42.785
And then she said, sometimes the women in the audience would

03:42.785 --> 03:44.465
be even more angry,

03:44.495 --> 03:48.865
because, you know, she said that the women thought, well,

03:49.285 --> 03:50.665
why doesn't my husband listen to me?

03:50.665 --> 03:51.785
Like he's listening to her?

03:53.795 --> 03:57.175
And, there was also just logistical difficulties.

03:57.415 --> 04:01.655
I mean, trying to have a career in show business while also

04:02.585 --> 04:05.015
being a woman, whether you're on your own

04:05.035 --> 04:07.215
or whether you're taking care of a family, there's

04:08.015 --> 04:10.175
a tremendous amount of difficulty that comes with that.

04:11.115 --> 04:15.495
Um, and then there was the difficulty that she felt

04:16.085 --> 04:19.295
herself of, you know, what am I doing?

04:19.755 --> 04:22.815
How am I, like, should I really be doing this?

04:22.835 --> 04:24.215
Is this what I should devote myself to?

04:24.475 --> 04:27.255
She was born in Paris,

04:28.115 --> 04:31.135
and her, her parents were from Eastern Europe,

04:32.075 --> 04:34.015
but they wound up in Paris

04:34.325 --> 04:36.295
through her father's defection.

04:36.355 --> 04:39.895
He was drafted into the Russian army, but he defected.

04:40.435 --> 04:43.015
And so they, they left,

04:43.045 --> 04:44.175
they went, they went through Europe.

04:44.555 --> 04:46.935
At one point, he was put in prison for defecting.

04:47.755 --> 04:52.455
Um, and so she was born, in France,

04:52.965 --> 04:54.175
sort of on the way out.

04:54.835 --> 04:58.855
Her father then immigrated to the States, a couple years

04:58.855 --> 05:02.935
before her mother, so that he could put down roots,

05:03.435 --> 05:05.935
get some money, and then send money so that his wife

05:05.955 --> 05:08.295
and kids could, could join him in the States.

05:09.415 --> 05:11.715
So like a lot of immigrant families, they moved around.

05:12.055 --> 05:13.235
She finally arrived.

05:13.855 --> 05:15.435
Uh, she and her mother

05:15.855 --> 05:18.395
and their siblings arrived at Ellis Island

05:18.505 --> 05:19.635
when she was two years old.

05:19.635 --> 05:20.995
And they kind of moved around,

05:21.305 --> 05:23.195
generally throughout New England.

05:24.655 --> 05:29.395
But, she finally settled down when she was about eight.

05:30.495 --> 05:34.835
And one of the things that she learned upon settling down

05:35.895 --> 05:38.715
was that, there was a lot of antisemitism.

05:39.825 --> 05:43.285
People were not thrilled at the influx

05:43.745 --> 05:45.085
of, Jewish immigration.

05:46.065 --> 05:48.365
So there were kids on the playground

05:48.465 --> 05:50.925
who would call her names and slurs,

05:51.225 --> 05:54.805
and, some even tried to attack her.

05:56.595 --> 06:00.685
Um, so that was a, that was a harsh introduction

06:00.825 --> 06:02.485
to the world of antisemitism.

06:02.665 --> 06:05.885
So she was having a hard time, not only at school,

06:06.225 --> 06:08.565
but also at home because,

06:08.585 --> 06:10.805
her father struggled a great deal with alcoholism

06:11.145 --> 06:14.095
and, abusive tendencies.

06:14.515 --> 06:18.775
He would, he would abuse her mom.

06:19.475 --> 06:21.975
And she witnessed this happening,

06:22.235 --> 06:24.375
and it was really traumatizing for her.

06:25.115 --> 06:27.215
And so she made this pledge to herself,

06:27.835 --> 06:28.895
I'm never gonna let that happen.

06:29.865 --> 06:32.725
And she really connected it to economics.

06:32.825 --> 06:33.885
She felt like the reason

06:34.085 --> 06:36.445
that her mother couldn't escape from the situation is

06:36.445 --> 06:39.885
that her mother was financially dependent on her father.

06:41.205 --> 06:45.785
So she, which is such a, an intense realization for a child,

06:46.085 --> 06:49.505
but she said, okay, well, if I can make the money, then

06:50.225 --> 06:53.065
I will not be in the same situation that she is in.

06:53.645 --> 06:56.185
And if I can make more money than my father,

06:56.255 --> 06:59.065
then maybe I can support my mom and my siblings,

06:59.325 --> 07:01.185
and we can get out of his control.

07:02.265 --> 07:06.215
And she did. But there are very few jobs that,

07:06.355 --> 07:08.135
children can do.

07:09.115 --> 07:12.175
Uh, so she started making money by going to these,

07:12.815 --> 07:15.365
these amateur talent shows with prize money.

07:16.555 --> 07:19.575
It was sort of like a little, cottage industry.

07:19.815 --> 07:22.895
A lot of these shows were rigged so that,

07:23.315 --> 07:26.895
the kids were not so much local kids as paid child actors.

07:27.955 --> 07:32.485
And she had a role, which, it was called The Lemon Act.

07:32.955 --> 07:35.885
Basically, it's the person in the talent show who is so

07:36.605 --> 07:40.565
terrible that people just love to laugh at them.

07:42.175 --> 07:44.715
And so she had a little income from going

07:44.715 --> 07:48.315
to these talent shows and being so horribly bad that

07:49.035 --> 07:50.435
audiences would just crack up.

07:52.735 --> 07:54.555
And this turned into a career.

07:55.075 --> 07:58.795
I mean, she became a performer first

07:58.895 --> 08:00.435
by being laughably bad.

08:00.935 --> 08:03.235
And then, she got trained.

08:03.335 --> 08:05.955
She got trained as a dancer, she got trained as a singer.

08:06.415 --> 08:07.715
She went onto Vaudeville

08:07.775 --> 08:10.635
and started doing this musical comedy review.

08:11.495 --> 08:15.595
And eventually she went from being laughably bad

08:15.855 --> 08:17.235
to laughably.

08:17.875 --> 08:19.715
Excellent orthopedic style changed over time.

08:19.735 --> 08:23.035
But what the, what I think is really interesting is the way

08:23.035 --> 08:26.875
that she changed what we would now call standup comedy,

08:27.255 --> 08:29.075
to something really personal

08:29.495 --> 08:32.395
and quite intimate and confessional.

08:33.295 --> 08:35.555
You know, it used to be that a standup

08:35.715 --> 08:36.875
comedian would just tell jokes.

08:37.095 --> 08:38.435
It was like reciting a joke book.

08:39.995 --> 08:44.735
And for her, she made it far more about storytelling.

08:45.035 --> 08:48.535
She made it more about speaking about her observations,

08:48.995 --> 08:50.375
her specific point of view.

08:51.725 --> 08:54.545
And, you know, she wasn't the only person to do this,

08:54.605 --> 08:57.845
but it was a really big shift from, you know,

08:57.995 --> 08:59.085
joke book recitation.

09:00.065 --> 09:04.005
And this is the thing that at least in my view, is now

09:04.025 --> 09:06.765
so exciting about standup, is the,

09:06.905 --> 09:08.965
the personal storytelling.

09:09.195 --> 09:11.925
Some of the reviews said that it was a little bit jarring

09:11.955 --> 09:15.685
that, she was being so intimate.

09:16.865 --> 09:21.285
Um, some critics were very surprised to see

09:22.035 --> 09:25.645
such a glamorous woman talk with, what they called

09:26.245 --> 09:28.845
brooklynese, mannerisms.

09:29.635 --> 09:31.695
Um, I think she was really surprising.

09:32.375 --> 09:35.295
I mean, taken, if even setting aside the rather

09:35.575 --> 09:39.135
revolutionary fact that there was a woman doing this new

09:39.145 --> 09:43.725
genre of standup, which in and of itself was remarkable.

09:44.465 --> 09:47.245
Um, the ways that she was doing it was so remarkable the way

09:47.245 --> 09:51.325
that she was making it conversational and, and intimate.

09:51.645 --> 09:56.525
I think that this intimate style became sort of a template

09:56.545 --> 09:59.925
or certainly, a game changer so

09:59.925 --> 10:03.445
that when Joan Rivers took up the mantle not too much longer

10:03.495 --> 10:05.165
after Jean Carroll was performing,

10:05.385 --> 10:10.045
or when, to fields, I mean, there's, there are so many,

10:10.905 --> 10:12.765
comedians at this point

10:13.745 --> 10:18.485
who take up this conversational tone, this performance

10:18.485 --> 10:21.085
where you sort of treat the audience like they're your best

10:21.085 --> 10:23.245
friend and you're just chitchatting with them.

10:24.565 --> 10:27.505
And it influenced, I mean, women, men,

10:28.555 --> 10:31.265
non-binary comedians today, it's,

10:31.265 --> 10:33.385
this is the new norm for standup.

10:33.685 --> 10:38.505
She had a very clear idea of, of

10:38.535 --> 10:40.875
what she called dignity,

10:41.215 --> 10:44.485
and she felt that,

10:47.065 --> 10:50.605
it was undignified for women to,

10:50.995 --> 10:52.365
lose their femininity

10:52.545 --> 10:56.835
or to make a mockery

10:56.895 --> 10:58.795
of themselves, or to

11:00.315 --> 11:02.615
do too much broad physical humor.

11:04.745 --> 11:07.125
She was really insistent on reimagining

11:07.315 --> 11:09.005
what Jewish women were like.

11:09.265 --> 11:13.085
And specifically she was interested in changing the way that

11:13.745 --> 11:16.645
the media represented Jewish women.

11:18.025 --> 11:21.615
There were lots of wonderful Jewish women entertainers.

11:22.035 --> 11:23.935
Uh, Fannie Brice is incredible.

11:24.185 --> 11:25.535
Molly Berg, it was incredible.

11:26.795 --> 11:31.175
But a lot of the Jewish women prominent, comedians

11:32.445 --> 11:35.355
would sort of make their Jewishness into a punchline.

11:36.475 --> 11:40.255
It was, it was sort of like, minstrelsy, you know,

11:40.255 --> 11:42.815
they would lean really heavily into dialect

11:43.275 --> 11:46.215
and cartoonish kind of movements.

11:47.515 --> 11:50.055
And Jean Carroll refused to do that.

11:50.635 --> 11:55.365
She really made a case for Jewish women comedians

11:56.305 --> 12:00.535
as elegant, as sophisticated, as

12:01.755 --> 12:03.605
assimilated, first and foremost.

12:03.925 --> 12:08.085
I hope that they take away, a good story.

12:08.925 --> 12:13.865
I mean, Jim Carroll comedians are storytellers,

12:13.885 --> 12:16.945
and Jean Carroll in particular was just a masterful

12:17.625 --> 12:19.425
raconteur of a storyteller.

12:20.085 --> 12:23.425
And so I truly hope that,

12:23.575 --> 12:27.345
that readers get even a morsel from the book of

12:27.775 --> 12:31.585
what it was like to to hear Jean Carroll telling her story.

12:33.135 --> 12:36.305
Also, I'm hoping that the book could be a good example of,

12:37.085 --> 12:40.425
you know, what is lost when you only look at history

12:40.605 --> 12:42.705
as being stories from men.

12:43.635 --> 12:46.985
There are so many overlooked stories of women

12:47.725 --> 12:50.665
in every field of people of color, of people

12:50.725 --> 12:55.305
who have been marginalized, and it's such a great loss.

12:55.565 --> 12:59.705
So maybe this book can be a reminder for folks to, to

13:00.835 --> 13:02.705
check these nooks and crannies of history

13:02.725 --> 13:06.305
and find the stories that are just waiting to be unearthed

13:06.325 --> 13:06.785
and celebr.

Faculti AI can make mistakes