Popular in Arts and Humanities

Arts and Humanities

Titus Quinctius Flamininus’ “Italian triumph”

McGill University Michael Fronda

Arts and Humanities

Lincoln and the Jews

Brandeis University Jonathan Sarna

Arts and Humanities

Amputations and Convalescence

University of Western Australia Emily Brink

Art

Drawing on the past: Palladio, his precursors and knowledge of ancient architecture

University of Birmingham David Hemsoll

Art

Language, Sound, and Image in Wallace Berman’s Aleph, 1956–1966

University of San Diego Chelsea Behle Fralick

Arts and Humanities

Early Modern Natural Law Theories

University of Copenhagen Knud Haakonssen

A Traitor to His Species

View more insights in Arts and Humanities - Books - History - History of North America and the United States

View more figures from University of Tennessee, Knoxville

View the page of Ernest Frithiof Freeberg

Read the Study

· Tools Cite Embed

Ernest Frithiof Freeberg tells the story of A Traitor to His Species, about a great guy who spoke for the voiceless and changed our relationship with animals.

Image courtesy of interviewee. January 31, 2024

Log-in or Sign-up to Faculti
Currently viewing this subject insight as a guest. You have insight(s) remaining for this month.

Workspace

<< >>

Video Summary
Similar Studies
AI Chat
Key Points
Key Quotes
Summary Translate
Full Transcript

Export as PDF

This video video discusses the life and impact of Henry Berg, the founder of the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA). Berg, a wealthy man who turned to animal welfare at the age of 53, was deeply influenced by his experiences in Russia during the Civil War, where he witnessed harsh treatment of horses. This video video led him to advocate for animal rights upon returning to the U.S. and learning from the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in the UK. Berg's efforts helped establish the first organized movement against animal cruelty in the U.S., and he actively campaigned for laws protecting various animals, expanding the definition of cruelty beyond just livestock to include all creatures. His work was controversial as he faced opposition from those who objected to his interventions in established practices. Berg's legacy is notable for its role in the evolution of societal attitudes towards animals, demonstrating a significant shift from viewing animals merely as economic assets to recognizing their welfare. His approach, which combined activism and legal authority for his organization, set important precedents for future animal rights movements. This video video also highlights the broader context of the animal welfare movement, including contributions from other figures and organizations, and underscores how societal views on animals have changed over time. It notes that while there have been advancements in animal protection, there remain unresolved ethical challenges related to animal welfare that persist into modern times.

Language:

Export as PDF

Export as PDF
Here are some similar articles that discuss the life of Henry Berg, the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), and the broader convideo of the animal welfare movement:

1. **"Henry Berg and the Birth of the ASPCA"** - This article explores the life of Henry Berg, detailing his motivations and the foundation of the ASPCA, as well as the challenges he faced in advocating for animal rights during his time.

2. **"The Evolution of Animal Rights: From Henry Berg to Modern Advocacy"** - This piece traces the history of animal rights advocacy in the United States, starting with Henry Berg’s foundational efforts and discussing how these initiatives laid the groundwork for contemporary animal welfare movements.

3. **"The Impact of Social Movements on Animal Welfare Legislation"** - This article examines how social movements, including the one started by Henry Berg, have influenced animal protection laws in the U.S. and how public perception of animals has evolved over the years.

4. **"Historical Perspectives on Animal Cruelty Laws"** - An exploration of the history and development of animal cruelty laws, highlighting the key figures and societal changes that contributed to the movement, including the role of Berg and the ASPCA.

5. **"Animal Welfare in America: A Historical Convideo"** - This comprehensive overview discusses the history of animal welfare in America, touching upon the founding of organizations like the ASPCA, significant legislation, and ongoing ethical challenges in animal treatment.

6. **"Advocacy and Progress: The Animal Rights Movement"** - This article looks at the milestones in the animal rights movement, including the contributions of Henry Berg, and analyzes how the movement has intersected with broader social justice issues.

7. **"Beyond Livestock: The Expanding Definition of Animal Cruelty"** - This article reviews how the definition of cruelty has broadened over the years due to advocacy by figures like Henry Berg, and what that means for animal welfare legislation today.

These articles can provide a deeper understanding of Henry Berg's impact on animal rights and the historical convideo of the animal welfare movement in the United States.

X-TIMESTAMP-MAP:LOCAL=00:00:00.000,MPEGTS=900000

00:00.000 --> 00:02.100
Partly, I was drawn by that central protagonist,

00:02.215 --> 00:04.805
Henry Berg, who's a fascinating character,

00:04.825 --> 00:08.325
who was the founder of the A-S-B-C-A, the American Society

00:08.385 --> 00:10.085
for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals,

00:10.085 --> 00:13.285
which was the first, in the United States, the,

00:13.285 --> 00:16.365
the First State organization, to try

00:16.365 --> 00:18.685
to a promote animal welfare and,

00:18.685 --> 00:20.725
and largely to fight animal cruelty.

00:21.225 --> 00:23.885
Uh, and Henry Berg is the central character,

00:23.885 --> 00:25.325
because he was the founder and,

00:25.385 --> 00:28.605
and really the, the, the leading, evangelist

00:28.625 --> 00:31.845
for this movement, for about 20 years,

00:32.205 --> 00:33.365
starting right after the Civil War.

00:34.425 --> 00:38.245
What's so fascinating about Berg is that he was,

00:38.855 --> 00:41.365
53 when he came to this work.

00:41.785 --> 00:46.285
He was up till that point, a wealthy, young man

00:46.285 --> 00:48.165
who had inherited money from his father

00:48.865 --> 00:51.765
and spent most of his time traveling the capitals of Europe

00:52.105 --> 00:53.885
and, writing very bad plays

00:54.025 --> 00:58.045
and very malin poetry, hoping to have a literary career.

00:58.825 --> 01:02.375
Uh, and when that obviously wasn't working out,

01:02.435 --> 01:05.895
he got assigned by Lincoln to the, to, the,

01:06.035 --> 01:09.095
the embassy in, in Russia, during the Civil War.

01:10.115 --> 01:12.415
It was at that point that he, he apparently, the,

01:12.415 --> 01:14.015
the Teamsters in St.

01:14.015 --> 01:17.055
Petersburg were even worse to their horses than

01:17.875 --> 01:19.815
the American drivers were.

01:19.875 --> 01:20.895
And he was on the streets,

01:20.955 --> 01:23.135
and he saw, a teamster beating a horse.

01:23.715 --> 01:26.935
Uh, and he, he demanded that this person stopped,

01:27.075 --> 01:30.575
and, the, the teamster did, dropped his whip,

01:30.575 --> 01:31.815
you know, and, and Berg said

01:31.815 --> 01:33.535
that was the greatest thing he'd ever done.

01:33.995 --> 01:35.815
You know, he suddenly felt like he had a calling.

01:36.635 --> 01:39.735
Uh, so he, he, left his position in Russia,

01:40.615 --> 01:43.905
stopped in in, England to learn about the Royal Society

01:43.925 --> 01:46.225
for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, which had started,

01:46.845 --> 01:48.465
about four decades earlier.

01:49.245 --> 01:52.065
Uh, and then brought that idea to the United States and,

01:52.445 --> 01:53.585
and incorporated it.

01:53.645 --> 01:58.105
So, so we have here, a a man who is, wealthy, who,

01:58.245 --> 02:00.465
never failed to be on the streets

02:00.465 --> 02:03.545
of New York without his top hat and his silver cane

02:03.545 --> 02:06.625
and his spats, doing battle against

02:07.245 --> 02:09.825
all those various people who were being cruel to animals,

02:09.825 --> 02:13.625
some of it very mundane, routine cruelty that was just part

02:13.625 --> 02:16.625
of the system, and some of it, much worse than that.

02:16.765 --> 02:18.385
And, and, and Berg went after them all.

02:19.165 --> 02:22.345
Uh, so I, so he's really, the, the person that drew me

02:22.345 --> 02:24.345
to this, to this topic was to sort

02:24.345 --> 02:26.305
of understand his motivations, and,

02:26.525 --> 02:27.745
and his wider impact.

02:28.445 --> 02:31.425
I'm kind to animals, in my daily life and,

02:31.605 --> 02:33.345
and very supportive of the movement.

02:33.485 --> 02:35.865
Uh, but it really was more from a historical

02:35.865 --> 02:37.225
perspective that I was interested.

02:37.485 --> 02:40.065
And I'm pretty, I was, you know, I was interested largely

02:40.065 --> 02:44.425
because I, I, a lot of my work has been about this period,

02:44.445 --> 02:47.865
the late 19th century, the early 20th century, as a,

02:48.405 --> 02:51.665
the period when many of our modern institutions

02:51.685 --> 02:53.385
and values, come into focus.

02:54.245 --> 02:55.705
And I think if you look at

02:56.175 --> 02:58.705
what the United States cities are like

02:58.845 --> 03:02.605
In the 1860s, you see an enormous number of animals

03:03.605 --> 03:05.725
interacting with human beings at, at, at every level.

03:05.785 --> 03:08.005
You know, big packs of stray dogs,

03:08.185 --> 03:10.685
and obviously horses providing much

03:10.685 --> 03:13.005
of the power stockyards in the center

03:13.005 --> 03:14.285
of cities and so forth.

03:14.545 --> 03:17.245
Uh, lots of people having this,

03:17.565 --> 03:20.365
a milk cow in the back alley of their, tenement.

03:20.905 --> 03:24.965
Uh, and by, by the early 20th century, that starts

03:24.985 --> 03:26.005
to change drastically.

03:26.185 --> 03:30.125
Uh, and now we consider, one,

03:31.085 --> 03:33.935
historian of this movement, put it very well, I thought,

03:34.445 --> 03:37.455
said that now we think of animals in the city as,

03:37.515 --> 03:40.215
as either pets or pests, you know, and,

03:40.315 --> 03:42.495
and so our, our engagement, our connection

03:42.495 --> 03:43.775
to animals is quite different.

03:43.875 --> 03:45.375
Uh, and I, I think the berg

03:45.555 --> 03:48.855
and this movement is an interesting way to get at sort

03:48.855 --> 03:51.935
of the, the, the evolution of that, of that, that change,

03:51.935 --> 03:54.535
both kinder to animals,

03:54.595 --> 03:57.175
but also they're, they're more invisible to, to at least

03:57.175 --> 03:59.495
to urban dwellers than they were in the,

03:59.495 --> 04:00.535
in the late 19th century.

04:01.015 --> 04:03.615
I spent a lot of time in, in Henry Berg's papers.

04:04.075 --> 04:06.735
Uh, he had terrible handwriting, which was unfortunate,

04:06.795 --> 04:09.575
but, the, it went through his letters, so,

04:09.575 --> 04:12.215
which were quite voluminous and, and, and,

04:12.235 --> 04:15.615
and coverage of, of, of his work was quite wide,

04:15.675 --> 04:17.015
and it was quite controversial.

04:17.715 --> 04:20.895
So it was interesting to see, the number of people,

04:21.205 --> 04:25.455
many, many people embraced Berg said, of course, we're,

04:25.455 --> 04:27.335
we're nobody's in favor of cruelty,

04:27.475 --> 04:29.135
but when it came to the kind of cruelty

04:29.135 --> 04:31.975
that they were practicing, they had objections.

04:32.435 --> 04:34.575
And so there was, there was always debates

04:34.575 --> 04:37.255
and controversy over Berg, showing up in the papers.

04:38.165 --> 04:40.375
Another important part of the research, though, was

04:40.375 --> 04:42.655
to realize that while Berg was the sort

04:42.655 --> 04:45.775
of the highest lightning rod of the movement,

04:45.775 --> 04:49.175
that he was just one part of a much wider, you know,

04:49.495 --> 04:51.495
thousands and thousands of, of men

04:51.495 --> 04:54.975
and women, in the United States joined organizations,

04:55.355 --> 04:58.335
smaller branches of the, of the SPCA movement,

04:58.995 --> 05:03.215
and particularly in Boston, George Angel founded,

05:03.835 --> 05:05.335
the Massachusetts Society

05:05.355 --> 05:06.935
for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.

05:06.955 --> 05:09.935
He still, fondly remembered

05:09.935 --> 05:13.095
and centrally remembered, in Massachusetts,

05:13.115 --> 05:15.695
and he was really a founder of what we think of now

05:15.695 --> 05:19.215
as humane education in the United States, sort

05:19.215 --> 05:22.135
of rather than punishing those who are ac cruel,

05:22.245 --> 05:25.215
instead cultivating a, a sense of generosity

05:25.215 --> 05:26.855
and empathy among younger people.

05:27.715 --> 05:30.255
Uh, and then, and then, the Quaker Ladies

05:30.315 --> 05:34.695
of Philadelphia, is particularly Carolyn Earl White,

05:35.205 --> 05:37.695
founded an organization in, in Philadelphia

05:37.765 --> 05:40.215
that was also very instrumental in developing some,

05:40.485 --> 05:42.095
some new ideas about animal welfare.

05:43.275 --> 05:45.895
So they were, I had spent some time in, in those archives

05:45.895 --> 05:48.175
as well, which were also quite deep and, and rich

05:48.175 --> 05:51.695
and interesting to try to capture this, that walberg is a,

05:51.695 --> 05:53.015
is a fascinating character,

05:53.035 --> 05:54.935
and really was provoked a lot of the,

05:55.605 --> 05:57.645
what I think most interesting controversies.

05:57.745 --> 05:59.605
Uh, they were also an important part of

05:59.605 --> 06:01.725
what actually we've inherited,

06:01.865 --> 06:04.885
in the United States in terms of anti cruelty, and,

06:04.945 --> 06:07.965
and contributing to what was really, as you're pointing out,

06:07.965 --> 06:11.125
that the R-S-P-C-A sort of an international movement.

06:11.565 --> 06:13.605
I think then the thing that distinguishes Berg from,

06:13.835 --> 06:17.085
from others, including the, the R-S-P-C-A, first

06:17.085 --> 06:18.485
of all, he passed the state law.

06:18.985 --> 06:22.005
Uh, again, nobody was against cruelty, so it wasn't

06:22.005 --> 06:24.765
that hard to get major players involved in,

06:24.765 --> 06:25.965
in a law against cruelty,

06:26.825 --> 06:28.605
but most of them expected that this would be,

06:28.855 --> 06:32.285
would be designed to protect, horses and,

06:32.425 --> 06:33.605
and maybe livestock.

06:34.305 --> 06:36.645
Uh, nobody thought that it would extend more,

06:36.645 --> 06:38.005
more broadly than, than that.

06:38.385 --> 06:42.045
And, Berg passed a law that said it was

06:43.115 --> 06:46.245
basically a protection, a against cruelty to all creatures.

06:47.145 --> 06:49.045
And so when he started to wage a campaign

06:49.045 --> 06:51.685
to defend the rights of, of sea turtles

06:51.685 --> 06:53.285
that were being shipped into,

06:53.515 --> 06:57.685
into the city flipped upside down, ropes put

06:57.685 --> 07:00.725
through their flippers, you know, as the standard way

07:00.725 --> 07:03.325
to ship them from up, from, from, the Caribbean,

07:04.905 --> 07:05.925
people were outraged.

07:05.945 --> 07:07.965
Why would you defend the rights of turtles?

07:08.265 --> 07:10.325
You know, why would you defend the rights of stray dogs?

07:10.785 --> 07:12.365
Why, why cats, you know,

07:12.475 --> 07:14.725
pigeons entering the, the pigeon shoots.

07:14.865 --> 07:18.485
Um, so he, he, he ex pushed this much further

07:19.355 --> 07:22.685
even than many of his supporters, would, would expect.

07:23.545 --> 07:26.565
The other very important contribution from Berg is that he

07:27.265 --> 07:30.805
put into the law a sort of quasi-legal authority for

07:31.465 --> 07:33.685
his organization, which was,

07:33.685 --> 07:36.325
which was a very important precedent for the movement,

07:36.835 --> 07:41.485
basically arguing this, the, the police are either not able

07:42.185 --> 07:43.805
to identify cruelty when they see it

07:43.805 --> 07:46.605
or not willing to punish the cruel, you know, the line

07:46.605 --> 07:50.285
between acceptable, exploitation of animals

07:50.425 --> 07:54.205
and cruel exploitation of animals was, was,

07:55.285 --> 07:56.315
still being worked out.

07:56.415 --> 07:59.195
It still is, for us, I think in many ways.

07:59.815 --> 08:03.755
Uh, so Berg said, let our agents, our,

08:03.755 --> 08:07.515
our appointed agents be in the field either to make sort

08:07.515 --> 08:09.795
of citizens arrests, quasi citizen arrests,

08:09.895 --> 08:12.635
or else to, to, to get the police involved and,

08:12.695 --> 08:14.715
and point them toward violations.

08:15.375 --> 08:17.315
So it was really, you know, there had been laws

08:17.315 --> 08:21.755
before that encouraged people to be, not to be cruel,

08:22.105 --> 08:24.475
largely to protect other people's cattle.

08:24.655 --> 08:26.075
You know, you can't, you can't

08:26.075 --> 08:27.635
bother somebody else's livestock.

08:28.095 --> 08:31.435
Uh, but this, this was far more expansive and, and,

08:31.455 --> 08:32.995
and had a lot of teeth in it that,

08:33.575 --> 08:37.075
so when Berg was not simply, you know, a preacher

08:37.295 --> 08:38.955
for animal rights,

08:39.255 --> 08:41.075
but instead was actually going out in the streets

08:41.075 --> 08:45.505
and arresting people, that inevitably drew lots

08:45.505 --> 08:50.255
of attention, which, you know, was berg often lost in court.

08:50.995 --> 08:53.655
Uh, but every time he was in court, he managed

08:53.655 --> 08:56.925
to make a speech and raise the profile of the movement,

08:57.065 --> 08:59.765
and, and, and push the point much further,

09:00.115 --> 09:01.525
than it would've been pushed otherwise.

09:02.035 --> 09:05.525
It's interesting to me that this movement began in, in,

09:05.745 --> 09:08.245
in urban environments, you know, and, and,

09:08.245 --> 09:10.485
and largely in areas where people increasingly

09:10.485 --> 09:11.805
didn't own their own animals.

09:12.665 --> 09:16.965
You know, it was much harder to, to push this idea into,

09:17.035 --> 09:18.845
into rural areas where people were

09:19.655 --> 09:23.325
using animals in all sorts of, domestic ways and hunting

09:23.385 --> 09:25.165
and fishing and that sort, that sort of thing.

09:25.585 --> 09:27.605
So in some, in some ways, I think the, you know,

09:27.605 --> 09:31.805
it was really a matter of, of an urban movement,

09:31.805 --> 09:33.165
and a changing sensibility.

09:33.545 --> 09:36.765
You were watching people be cruel to their horses.

09:36.905 --> 09:39.365
You were watching the suffering of stray dogs being,

09:39.695 --> 09:41.645
being rounded up and killed in the streets.

09:41.925 --> 09:44.765
I, I think you didn't have the same investment in being able

09:44.765 --> 09:46.605
to treat your own animals however you wanted to.

09:47.065 --> 09:49.765
Uh, so there was a sort of shared collective responsibility,

09:50.945 --> 09:54.885
and really it's part of a much wider, growth of empathy.

09:54.885 --> 09:57.525
And, and, and during what, you know, what evolved into what,

09:57.715 --> 09:59.505
what, you know, in,

09:59.505 --> 10:01.945
in American historians usually call the progressive

10:02.425 --> 10:06.985
movement, to sort of stamp out, I mean, that there's a,

10:06.985 --> 10:09.705
there's an obvious link between animal rights and,

10:09.965 --> 10:12.665
and concerns about, about, abuse of women

10:12.685 --> 10:13.865
and children, for example.

10:14.005 --> 10:16.585
And the two movements were, were very much in sync,

10:16.605 --> 10:17.745
and in some ways, the,

10:17.805 --> 10:20.025
the child welfare movement evolves out of

10:20.765 --> 10:22.105
the animal welfare movement.

10:22.925 --> 10:25.625
So there's a change in sensibility about cruelty that's,

10:25.625 --> 10:29.105
that is happening in this time period,

10:29.165 --> 10:31.545
in the United States as well as in, in Britain,

10:31.615 --> 10:35.385
that this reflects, he worked right, right to the end,

10:35.685 --> 10:37.425
as, as, as a leader of movement.

10:37.645 --> 10:41.745
And, you know, it was about 20 years, that,

10:41.765 --> 10:46.105
of his life, which, which, he was a, he was a,

10:46.245 --> 10:47.425
you know, became kind of a legend.

10:47.455 --> 10:50.545
Everybody, you know, in, in cities all across the country,

10:51.005 --> 10:53.305
if somebody stood up to defend animals, they'd say,

10:53.305 --> 10:54.985
here's another Henry Berg, you know, and,

10:55.205 --> 10:58.145
and the movement, was often called Bism.

10:58.645 --> 11:02.065
Uh, so he, he, he developed that, that that strong legacy,

11:02.685 --> 11:05.945
and, and never really failed to go

11:05.945 --> 11:08.025
after high profile cases.

11:08.465 --> 11:10.705
I mean, my favorite is his ongoing battles with,

11:10.705 --> 11:13.945
with PT Barnum, the, the circus entrepreneur,

11:14.775 --> 11:16.785
over mistreatment of circus animals.

11:17.085 --> 11:20.305
Uh, and, and the two came to learn, very much

11:20.305 --> 11:22.585
to enjoy each other's company in a lot of ways.

11:22.685 --> 11:23.905
And to each one

11:23.905 --> 11:26.745
of them benefited from the publicity when they had a face

11:26.765 --> 11:29.145
off over the mistreatment of an elephant or,

11:29.245 --> 11:30.305
or, or, or something.

11:31.125 --> 11:35.465
Uh, in fact, when, when Bird died, Barnum,

11:35.975 --> 11:38.465
donated money to create a, a, a fountain in his honor,

11:38.605 --> 11:41.705
in his hometown of Bridgeport, Connecticut, and,

11:41.725 --> 11:43.265
and was one of his pallbearers.

11:43.525 --> 11:47.985
So, many people, you know, throughout Berg's life,

11:47.985 --> 11:50.785
people said, he's crazy.

11:51.725 --> 11:53.885
You know, he is taking a good idea

11:53.945 --> 11:56.085
and taking it far, too far, too far.

11:56.465 --> 12:00.805
Uh, but very often they would say, well,

12:00.805 --> 12:02.085
but somebody needed to do that.

12:02.925 --> 12:05.885
Somebody needed to, to, to push the, the conversation.

12:06.625 --> 12:09.805
You know, we may not agree with everything he says,

12:10.585 --> 12:12.885
but somebody has to be saying these things in order

12:12.885 --> 12:14.285
to force us to be thinking about,

12:14.655 --> 12:16.125
about animals in a different way.

12:16.265 --> 12:19.405
So I think, you know, in many ways that's, that's probably,

12:19.825 --> 12:21.485
you know, what, how Berg was remembered.

12:22.005 --> 12:23.805
I hope it gets people to understand

12:23.905 --> 12:26.925
how central animals have been in, in human culture,

12:27.465 --> 12:28.725
and they remain.

12:28.865 --> 12:32.165
So I think one of the important observations I think I made

12:32.165 --> 12:34.525
in the book was that many of the moral questions that,

12:34.995 --> 12:39.205
that bergs so effectively raised are not really resolved.

12:39.205 --> 12:40.845
They're rather moved out of our site.

12:41.285 --> 12:42.525
I mean, I think the prime example

12:42.545 --> 12:45.965
of this is the euthanization of, of stray dogs and,

12:46.025 --> 12:47.725
and cats, right?

12:47.725 --> 12:51.165
Where that was done in a quite brutal fashion in, in,

12:51.345 --> 12:53.645
in the middle of the streets, you know, our,

12:53.665 --> 12:56.605
our dogs were rounded up and paid a bounty and,

12:56.945 --> 12:58.965
and dispatched in, in horrendous ways.

12:59.985 --> 13:01.085
The A-S-P-C-A

13:01.145 --> 13:03.845
and the SPCA movement more broadly figured out ways to,

13:04.585 --> 13:06.885
to euthanize thousands of animals.

13:07.065 --> 13:08.805
You know, oddly

13:08.805 --> 13:13.125
and paradoxically, this movement became the largest killer

13:13.425 --> 13:15.245
of these animals, right?

13:16.345 --> 13:17.765
But it's invisible for most of us.

13:17.865 --> 13:20.085
We don't have to think about it in quite the same way.

13:20.745 --> 13:23.085
Uh, same way with our, with livestock.

13:23.305 --> 13:26.005
You know, the mistreatment of livestock was quite visible

13:26.955 --> 13:30.255
to any urban dweller in 19th century America, when,

13:30.255 --> 13:32.295
when the animals were walking through the streets

13:32.315 --> 13:34.615
and were being butchered down the street

13:35.315 --> 13:37.455
or in a, you know, on the edge of the, of the city.

13:38.395 --> 13:39.455
Now it's a distant thing,

13:39.455 --> 13:42.385
and we only experience that, you know, the, the, those

13:42.385 --> 13:44.385
who are working for the animal welfare

13:44.645 --> 13:46.825
and animal rights at this point have to work very hard

13:46.845 --> 13:49.465
to have us see the implications

13:49.465 --> 13:50.785
of the way we're treating animals.

13:51.005 --> 13:55.025
Uh, so there's a sort of mixed legacy. I think, for us.

13:55.205 --> 13:58.305
We need to be, appreciative of the accomplishments,

13:58.315 --> 14:01.305
while at the same time recognizing the limitations,

14:01.305 --> 14:03.745
of the movement in the 19th and early 20th century.

Faculti AI can make mistakes